7 ms·
Thoughts as a tech manager: - People's attempts to hide their remote lifestyle are mostly laughable. You don't need sophisticated tooling to know that someone
by paxys 4y ago
Thoughts as a tech manager:
- People's attempts to hide their remote lifestyle are mostly laughable. You don't need sophisticated tooling to know that someone isn't where they say. I see you every day. I can recognize patterns. I can see the changes in work hours, response times and just general behavior. I can tell when you have just rolled out of bed with a coffee or come back from the club.
- Most managers I know don't give a shit. In fact we'd rather not know at all. It's really HR you have to worry about (and I'm not going to tell them unless you give me a reason to).
- HR itself only cares because of the tax implications. Inter-state taxes are bad enough, figuring out international ones are basically impossible. The company can get into major trouble if they are not following local employment laws, and "I didn't know my employee lived there" isn't a good enough defense.
- For those saying "IRS will come after you", these remote employees are paying full federal, state (mostly CA), payroll and various local taxes while using none of the benefits. The government is probably ecstatic that such people exist.
- The government on the other side is the one you really have to worry about. Locals in Mexico City, all over South America, Bali, Thailand, Vietnam and really all over the world are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) who work on tourist visas and upend the local economy while paying no taxes. It's only a matter of time before they all start cracking down.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoCan't you then say the same thing about tourists? I don't get why digital nomads are worse than tourists for the country in any way.
- jejeyyy77 4y agoAs a tech employee turned contractor: I write software for pay. That's it. I don't see my employer as a boss - they are a customer. If they aren't happy with the product, they can find someone else and I can respond to the other 50 LinkedIn requests...
- knorker 4y agoAs a contractor you are free to incorporate wherever you want. I wouldn't work from e.g. Iran, or you could get sued to death when your customer is indicted for violating US sanctions, but yeah why would your employer care? Oh, because maybe they have various insurance and partner contracts that speak about your physical location. If your contract doesn't say where you are, then work from anywhere, and follow whatever laws. If your contract does say where you are, then violate the contract an your own risk.
- knorker 4y ago> The government on the other side is the one you really have to worry about. Locals in Mexico City, all over South America, Bali, Thailand, Vietnam and really all over the world are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) who upend the local economy and pay no taxes. It's only a matter of time before they all start cracking down. Also your employer needs to worry about this. And therefore you need to worry about your employer suing you. If you think that's far fetched, do you think your employer will NOT throw you under the bus when France sues your German employer for turning a blind eye to where their employee is? Frankly as a tech manager YOU are adding legal risk to yourself personally by protecting the employee from the company. Arguably YOU personally are complicit in tax fraud.
- aiisahik 4y agoThis is trash. I hire engineers all over LATAM. I could not care less if they pay their taxes. I do not pay any taxes in LATAM. My company does no business in LATAM. What are they going to do? Sue my company? LOL. P.S. I used to be a lawyer and I can weigh the risks. Completely negligible compared to all the other risks I have as a founder.
- knorker 4y agoIt's very much not trash. As you say this is risk. You can make any tradeoff you want, and you are probably right. You can hire someone you think may be working from Iran. You're pretty sure you won't get caught violating sanctions for it. > I could not care less if they pay their taxes I don't know LATAM employer side taxes, but if their tax offices do decide to target you then what you "could not care less" about will not matter much. But shrug, yeah you probably won't get caught. My favorite lawyer quote: "Legal didn't say we can't do it. Legal says if we do it then we may all go to jail. It's not the same thing". And indeed it's not. But it's not trash.
- aiisahik 4y agoHow do the tax offices of other countries "target me" exactly? What legal options do they have against a US based company with no business/customer in that country? They can go after my contractors but then my contractors would just move to another country like Uruguay (which btw is very tax friendly towards remote workers and hardly charges any taxes). Some of my contractors have done exactly that.
- Tangurena2 4y agoIn my state, counties also assess income tax. The largest city has lower tax levels for people who work in the city but live elsewhere. Our payroll app needs to know what days you are working from home. This way, if you work in one county and live in another, the county you live in will get their share of the income tax. I think this is going to be a huge problem in a year or 2 when cities & counties see a large drop in income and try to figure out how to "fix" it.
- bheadmaster 4y ago> Locals [...] are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) who upend the local economy and pay no taxes Wait, aren't digital nomads literally bringing money in from another country? They pay taxes on everything they consume, yet they don't take the money from inside the country, they bring it in from the outside. Why exactly would they be pissed?
- BossingAround 4y agoBecause nomads owe them more than they already pay
- slim 4y agoyou are right with regards to developing countries. if you bring foreign currency you are welcome
- LanceH 4y agoRight up until there are enough of you that the price of a house goes up, and the restaurants go upscale.
- knorker 4y agoCitizens working without paying into pension, healthcare, or following local employment laws (best example: France, that really cares what employees in their borders do). You can't simply unilaterally declare that sales tax compensates for everything you do, and think laws don't apply.
- maerF0x0 4y agoThey also do not qualify to receive from most of those services. So are they really a burden?
- vkou 4y agoThe same can be said about illegal immigrants and temporary visa holders in the United States. An H1B worker pays taxes, pays into social security, etc, but isn't going to get a penny back out of it. And yet, for some reason, a lot of people really dislike[1] H1Bs... [1] Last election cycle, I've received a beautiful election pamphlet from a frothing-at-the-mouth state politician-want-to-be who spent most of his 250 words assuring me that H1Bs are robbing the country by mooching all of its services while not paying any taxes. He, uh, got 40% of the vote.
- tifik 4y ago> upend the local economy and pay no taxes I understand that taxes are important to maintain local infrastructure, but up to a certain point, isn't it beneficial having a few people literally bringing in foreign money to pay for the same products and services other locals pay for? There are places that officially encourage that behavior. I understand how that might eventually upend the local economy - it's called gentrification and while digital nomads certainly contribute to it, it surely can't be fully blamed on them. Places where people want to live at will eventually get gentrified in some shape or form. The logic behind labeling digital nomads as illegal immigrants completely eludes me. I genuinely don't understand why you would make that assumption.
- paxys 4y ago> The logic behind labeling digital nomads as illegal immigrants completely eludes me. I genuinely don't understand why you would make that assumption. Close to 100% of them are on tourist visas and are explicitly not allowed to work in the country. What else do you think an illegal immigrant is?
- panzagl 4y agoUsually it means work in the country you're visiting- I can't go to Mexico for a week and wait tables, but if I vacation there I still get paid by my employer.
- UncleMeat 4y agoVacation sure. But if you want to work from these countries then you can't be on a tourist visa.
- tifik 4y agoIt comes down to how you define 'working from a country'. Doesn't it mean 'being employed by a local company and paying income taxes' there? If I go on a vacation and respond to a few work-related emails, am I breaking any laws because I'm working on a tourist visa? Yes, that is ad absurdum, but I'm trying to point out that it's not as clear cut. There is a line that international treaties define, and staying someplace (sometimes even up to 6 months) and working there doesn't necessarily have any income tax implications for you or your employer.
- jcrawfordor 4y agoMexico is starting to get a lot stricter on FMMs and IMF agents are getting reticent to issue them for maximum term like they used to. I'm told this is a result of IMF getting really frustrated by the number of people who are repeatedly taking out 180 day FMMs with only token returns to the US to avoid getting permanent residence - which is not very difficult but means the tax collector knows you're there!
- lgleason 4y agoCosta Rica is staring to do this as well.
- pain2022 4y agoWhat these abbreviations mean? IMF is not even googleable. This is so annoying
- kelnos 4y agoI'm not sure either, but I'm guessing IMF is their immigration authority, and FMM is a type of (tourist?) visa.
- jcrawfordor 4y agoSorry, FMM is the forma migratoria multiplé, it's the usual paperwork for entering Mexico for any short-term reason, if you're an American (and I think some other nearby countries). It's not really a visa as those aren't required for Americans, just a form they use to track guests and mostly to collect a fee/fax for stays longer than 7 days. IMF is my own fault, I meant instituto migración federal, but that's not actually what it's called - it's the INM, instituto nacional de migración. I think I was mixing up like three different names in my head. Mexico is really very lax about what you are allowed to do while in Mexico on an FMM and the fee for one isn't very much at all. But what you can't do is stay past the departure date on the FMM which cannot be more than 180 days from when it was issued. INM agents used to be very willing to just put the full 180 days on every FMM but lately are asking questions about your return plans and only giving you shorter time periods. Apparently there were a lot of people who were living in Mexico and basically going to San Diego at the end of their FMM, staying a few days, and then reentering on a 180 day FMM to return to where they live. This has always been against the rules but I don't think INM really cared that much until recently, because the number of people doing it increased greatly.
- aiisahik 4y agoYou don't need to worry about the government on the other side either unless your company actually does business in that jurisdiction in such a way that they can sanction you. Local governments are usually trying to attract digital nomads with remote working visas. One gov can crack down - the nomad would just move to a friendlier jurisdiction.
- lgleason 4y agoI'm not sure you are correct about the countries the digital nomads are flocking to being pissed about them. Maybe a few locals, but, the government of Costa Rica is encouraging digital nomads because it brings money into the country because these nomads are dining at local restaurants, shopping at local stores, hiring people to clean their house, paying rent etc.. When the average salary in 10k a year in these countries a digital nomad is easily spending enough to create at least one, if not multiple jobs for a local.
- abigail95 4y agoI don't violate foreign laws if I buy a goods online from another country. I don't need to know anything about laws governing manufacturing to purchase a screwdriver made in California. I only need to know my own laws. Is it legal to import screwdrives in my jurisdiction? Yes. Can I do this transaction without violating my own sanction laws? Yes That's it. Whether the California entity is allowed to sell to me is their problem, not mine. The same applies for labor. I want to buy foreign labor? I negotiate the price, I get the work, I pay the invoice. Which laws do I consult? Every potential country-to-country mix in the world? No, I consult my own laws. Is it legal to purchase foreign labor/services. Yes. Can I do this transaction without violating my own sanction laws? Yes Whether I buy a website or a screwdriver - I do not need to know anything about who I'm buying it from beyond the necessary information to avoid international sanctions.
- Melchori 4y agoYou clearly never heard of import laws or ignore it to make an argument which is flawed.
- outworlder 4y agoAbout your last point. Interestingly, some governments have been trying to entice people to work remotely in their countries. Iceland is the latest example. I'm guessing that, while they don't directly collect the tax revenue, there's some incentive to the local economy as that's where a lot of the consumption would happen.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y ago> upend the local economy Are the governments really that upset with illegal immigrants that (typically) don't commit crimes (aside from immigration/taxes) and spend (by local standards) crazy amounts of money in the local economy?
- steele 4y agoDon't commit crimes aside from crimes
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoImmigration and tax evasion generally don't directly hurt someone who'd be pissed off that the government let the crime happen, unlike e.g. theft, robbery, rape, or even just loitering around drunk in public.
- steele 4y agoWhite-collar crime is crime. Tax evasion while relying on tax-funded infrastructure is theft.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoI'm not talking about philosophy, I'm talking about what gets people angry at the government. Imagine that you're running a pub. There's a regular that dresses funny, runs a small show, drinks like a hole, and at the end of the day, always runs out without paying his bill. He's stealing from you. However, there are many people who go to the pub just to watch his antics. The food and drinks he steals are nothing compared to the extra money you make from that. You have every right to kick him out, and you might do it out of spite because you will not tolerate thieves... but the pragmatic thing to do is to look the other way, so it's not surprising when that's what happens.
- steele 4y agoYour hypothetical is hollow sophistry while taxation is both law and social contract. Miss me with that "I'm not talking about philosophy, now imagine you're a cowboy riding a dinosaur" bollocks.
- rupi 4y agoThis is 100% correct. The biggest risk is the remote country coming after the employee and/or employer. If you are the employer, and you are 100% sure you are never going to do business in the country, you MAY be ok. However, there are tax treaties at play as well and that can complicate things. If the remote country goes after the employee, it may get ugly especially if the employee is still there. That indirectly also impacts the employer. So if you or your employees are going to work from a different country, read their regulations and be very careful about staying longer than the time period that they consider you a resident for tax purposes. This is quite an interesting space for some future startup.
- Negitivefrags 4y agoI’m quite suprised you are willing to hire people who you know are lying to you. To me, someone like that has demonstrated that they can’t be trusted and I would remove them from the business ASAP. You can fix a lot of things with an employee/employer relationship, but those things require trust. You just don’t ever know where you stand with someone who lies.
- jackblemming 4y agoWould you rather hire obvious liars or good liars? Everyone lies occasionally, or omits information. To believe otherwise is naive.
- Nathanba 4y agoThat's kind of an important thing to lie about (money and work related), I'd rather have someone not lying about anything at the very least on that subject. Actually, I'm editing the comment. Even lying about anything is bad because you'll eventually start lying about something work related too. That's just how it is, whether it's a time table, some interaction you had with a customer where you don't quite paint the truth or anything else. Eventually it always impacts the real world. That's the thing about the word "lying", it's not so precise. You practically mixed "omitting information" and "lying" together even though they can be extremely different in quality, depending on intent, situation and much more.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> I’m quite suprised you are willing to hire people who you know are lying to you. From what I understand, that's most job interviews. If someone has very little practical coding skills, but is a LeetCode ninja, then you get what you ask for, I guess. I don't lie, but it also seems to make me unpopular. Fortunately, I don't need the work.
- whatatita 4y ago> People's attempts to hide their remote lifestyle are mostly laughable That can depend on how/where they're staying. If they're at "home" abroad, with a similar time zone, then there's often no way to tell except technically. I have a team mate who often spends time across the border for weeks at a time. We wouldn't know if she didn't mention it. We are in the EU though, so working from other EU countries is fine, within limits.
- bombcar 4y agoTimezone is the most noticeable one, but that can be solved by going north or south. If you go too far of course, then your workmates might notice that it's winter when it should be summer. And anyone with the login details can see where your login pings are from.
- 0x457 4y agoTimezone is noticeable, but really depends on how different and how many "Webcam On" meetings you have. My home office has blackout curtains, so it's always the same light condition regardless of time of the day. Now, it's hard to attend some meetings when time difference is very dramatic, like it's 1am in your local, but 10am at work HQ. > If you go too far of course, then your workmates might notice that it's winter when it should be summer. Doubt. Most of my co-workers use virtual backgrounds. I wear the same home clothes the entire year. > And anyone with the login details can see where your login pings are from. Good luck, I have a WireGuard box at my parent's house that I route my work traffic through when needed. Maybe I should start a business of hosting "residential" VPN exit nodes...
- coredog64 4y ago2FA apps record physical location. Now you need to spoof time & location on your phone to log in.
- 0x457 4y agoExcept I use YubiKey for my 2FA, so where my phone is irrelevant. Moreover, I've never ever granted 2FA app location permissions. Don't even remember any of them asking it. It's generally GeoIP and time is well...the same everywhere?
- ev1 4y ago> - The government on the other side is the one you really have to worry about. Locals in Mexico City, all over South America, Bali, Thailand, Vietnam and really all over the world are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) who work on tourist visas and upend the local economy while paying no taxes. It's only a matter of time before they all start cracking down. Thailand explicitly gives out digital nomad visas for this?
- marcosdumay 4y ago> Locals in ... all over South America... are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) Brazilian here. At least on the part of South America that I know that well (a little more than my country), nobody gives a shit.
- cfcosta 4y agoSame from my experience, keep bringing them dollars
- asdadsdad 4y agowait until your rent and other prices drive up by influx of abnormal salaries for the local economy and everything becomes ultra-expensive for you. Barcelona, Mexico City, ...
- marcosdumay 4y agoAre those people planning to all stay on the same place? South America is quite big. Anyway, I'm not sure rent is high on those place (or rater specifically Mexico City) because of immigration. I can't imagine deciding to move to Mexico and picking specifically Mexico City instead of somewhere else (it would be like deciding to go to Brazil and insisting on living in São Paulo - people have many reasons for living there, remote working immigrants have almost none). At the same time, there are plenty of reasons to have expensive rents there that don't depend on immigrants.
- huevosabio 4y ago>Locals in Mexico City, all over South America, Bali, Thailand, Vietnam and really all over the world are pissed with these "digital nomads" (read: illegal immigrants) While it may be the case in other countries, Mexico has fairly straightforward laws that allow you to work remotely for up to 4 years without paying local income taxes. Basically, as long as you have a stable job outside the country, you are fine. The mood among some Mexicans may be negative, but for the most part Mexicans understand (thanks to a long experience with tourism) that foreigners bring in the big bucks. And this is good for us.
- ulfw 4y agoBali is ENCOURAGING Digital nomads [1] Thailand also has special visas and wants more digital nomads [2] etc etc [1] https://www.indonesiaevisas.com/news/digital-nomad-visa https://www.indonesiaevisas.com/news/digital-nomad-visa [2] https://nomadgirl.co/thailand-digital-nomad-visa-what-is-there-and-what-is-coming/ https://nomadgirl.co/thailand-digital-nomad-visa-what-is-the...
- brailsafe 4y agoAs a remote contractor turned employee with adhd, I've stopped guilting myself about this and stopped really trying to hide it. I focus relentlessly on doing whatever it takes to get the shit I've agreed to do done in the time and way I can best do it. But I'm not moving to another country either.