5 ms·
BliKVM PCIe puts a computer in your computer
- LinuxBender 4y agoThis looks like a nice alternative to the proprietary ilo/drac especially for home or remote site use. Is this running a bog standard Rasberry Pi OS and an open source firmware? Can the owner run a command to drop to a root shell, configure firewall rules, etc? Asking because Dell made it much harder to get a root shell on the dracs and the enterprise cards have hard coded creds this is not documented. Is the KVM interface using HTML5?
- jaywalk 4y agoThe card itself isn't running anything. You just add a bog-standard rPi CM4 running PiKVM (https://pikvm.org/ https://pikvm.org/). You can accomplish the same thing with a regular rPi running PiKVM externally.
- LinuxBender 4y agoPerfect, thankyou for the clarification. That makes sense now given its an add-on board. It's been ages since I looked into network KVM. The DIY/consumer options seem to have evolved quite a bit.
- jaywalk 4y agoThere are some nice options out there. I use a DIY TinyPilot build, and have been pretty happy with it.
- geerlingguy 4y agoYeah, PiKVM is quite nice these days. It also defaults to booting in a minimal readonly filesystem, so running it off a microSD card isn't an issue either.
- znpy 4y agounironically i've been thinking that something like this should have been done years before. i would have done it myself, but i don't have the skills. the ideal would be to have two (three?) network ports however. the idea would be to have one port to the wan, another to the network port of the host computer, and maybe a third one for the ilo/idrac/ipmi port. it would be great in my opinion.
- jaywalk 4y agoI don't understand the use for additional Ethernet ports. What functionality do you envision for them?
- jewel 4y agoThe concept has been around for a while: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SunPCi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SunPCi
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Maursault 4y agoAlso notable[1][2], but for entirely different and wider purposes, and considerably closer in generational performance to the host machines. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibility_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibility_card [2] https://lowendmac.com/1991/radius-rocket-and-stage-ii-rocket/ https://lowendmac.com/1991/radius-rocket-and-stage-ii-rocket...
- jeffbee 4y agoIn case you wanted your PC to draw 2W even when it's off. This card by itself would violate the energy star standards for small servers when off.
- geerlingguy 4y agoMost IPMI/iDRAC/ILO chips burn 3-6W when the server's powered off, if you have them running on a network. If you need the remote management even when the server's powered down, that power consumption's a tradeoff you have to make. ASRock Rack's PAUL card says it uses 7-8W, so this board is a good bit under that.
- chrisan 4y agoCouldn't you just use WOL for the pi?
- geerlingguy 4y agoUnfortunately the Raspberry Pi doesn't support WoL :(
- formerly_proven 4y agoPCIe actually includes stand-by power, so this card using usb-c PD and PoE instead would suggest idle power consumption is significant. > It uses about 2-3 Watts at idle, and 4-6 watts when you're remoted in controlling the screen. I think ATX only requires around 5 W minimum for 5 Vsb so yeah… It’s kinda hard to measure the power use of Ilom, something like an AST2500, for a number of reasons. They do get slightly warm, so the chip itself probably burns around 1 W. But system power use when on is of course also increased due to the various links (PCIe, NIC links etc.). Plus around .5-1 W for the always-on Ethernet link - EEE and a quiet management network would help here.
- geerlingguy 4y agoIn my testing for the video, the card uses 2-3W at idle, and 4-6W when streaming video to a remote browser session. I haven't looked at the idle power spec lately, but I believe the biggest problem would be when the computer is fully shut down, I don't think you can get enough power to run a card like this?
- lathiat 4y agoPCIe provides standby power on 3.3v only. I can't find a specific number for "standby" but even not in standby it seems to be 1100mA @ 3.3v =~ 3.63W - so may be enough. You'd need a step-up to 5V for the CM4 though. Seems like it may be borderline enough for the video part not being active but maybe similar to USB it might be "not quite enough".
- snoopy_telex 4y agoI would love to see it have an option to expose the USB HID and HDMI over the pci link rather than having to loop cables between the card and the host.
- geerlingguy 4y agoAnd a serial bus connection, could be useful in a number of scenarios. The devs behind this board (blicube) have been willing to listen to customer requests[1]... it's not outside the realm of possibility—though would increase the complexity of the board a bit. [1] https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board/issues https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board/issues
- fennecfoxen 4y agoIt puts a computer in my computer? So I can compute while I compute?
- phendrenad2 4y agoI wonder how many fewer of these they would sell if the PCIe card edge were blank rather than covered in useless pins.
- consp 4y agoWouldn't that potentially put unwanted scrapings (non conductive) on the pcie pins? This looks like the best option to me.
- phendrenad2 4y agoI don't think so - there have been many examples of plastic or FR4 cards which sit in PCI slots.
- Melatonic 4y agoDoesnt it take power from the slot?
- phendrenad2 4y agoIt does not...
- zamadatix 4y agoI really love PiKVM! I use it for my personal colo'd boxes and it's a real treat over normal remote management solutions. That said I'm not sure what BliKVM really provides me beyond more limitations on where I can put it and one less PCIe slot available on the motherboard. I was expecting something more smart NIC like where the PCIe bus is actually used to communicate with the host too - or maybe the better description was wishing for :).
- drewzero1 4y agoI agree, I got excited when I saw the PCIe card and less excited when I found out it didn't do anything with the slot. I'd love to see on that used the slot for communication, maybe even video and power.
- goombacloud 4y agoIs the "USB-PC" port to forward the server's serial console or doesn't it have a port for that? PiKVM seems to support IPMI SoL.
- geerlingguy 4y agoThat's just an external port for USB input (from a USB port on the PC), not for serial bus. This card doesn't have any serial bus input, though I think there are pins exposed for UART somewhere, but not populated.
- mtlynch 4y agoI'm the founder of TinyPilot, a project that operates in the same space. I haven't really been following BliKVM, but some alarm bells are going off as I follow the links here: 1. BliKVM advertises themselves as open hardware, but the hardware repo[0] contains no sources / schematics that would allow anyone to reproduce the hardware. 2. When I looked for the hardware sources, I realized that BliKVM is redistributing TinyPilot code in violation of TinyPilot's license. [1], [2] We're licensed under MIT, so BliKVM is allowed to redistribute and modify freely, but they have to preserve our license and copyright notice. If BliKVM actually is open hardware, that would be wonderful, and I'd be interested in collaborating with them, but it doesn't seem like honest advertising at this point. [0] https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board [1] https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board/blob/master/src/blikvm.sh https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/pikvm-board/blob/master/src... vs. TinyPilot's code: https://github.com/tiny-pilot/tinypilot/blob/609b36faf2352cb0922111b2fc9f13bd73824855/quick-install https://github.com/tiny-pilot/tinypilot/blob/609b36faf2352cb... [2] https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/blikvm/blob/master/package/kvmd-hid/enable-gadget.sh https://github.com/ThomasVon2021/blikvm/blob/master/package/... vs. TinyPilot's code: https://github.com/tiny-pilot/ansible-role-tinypilot/blob/master/files/init-usb-gadget https://github.com/tiny-pilot/ansible-role-tinypilot/blob/ma...
- ddalex 4y agoThank you for putting TinyPilot together - it saved my ass a couple of times; but the big problem is that the USB port of the host computer doesn't provide enough current to reliably power the Pi through the USB-C, so an out-of-box Pi is not really reliable.
- mtlynch 4y agoGlad to hear it! Regarding power, you can get a USB-C splitter[0], which will allow you to give your Pi the full 3 Amps. The TinyPilot Voyager 2 has this built-in, and the PoE one makes it so you don't need AC power at all. [0] https://tinypilotkvm.com/blog/build-a-kvm-over-ip-under-100#the-power-problem https://tinypilotkvm.com/blog/build-a-kvm-over-ip-under-100#...
- pixelmonkey 4y agoMy "cheap trick" to do this with my own home server is to use a Raspberry Pi which stays always on and is wired into same LAN as my homelab server. Then, I have a small shell script that uses the etherwake Linux CLI tool to send a Wake-on-LAN magic packet to wake my server when it's sleeping. For full server reboots, I have the server on a remote-accessible power switch that can be cycled from the same Raspberry Pi. I network all the devices together using ZeroTier. I have to admit, though, that the idea of the computer being inside the server box (similar to a Dell iDRAC in a colo environment) is appealing, and also opens up the opportunity for things like "direct KVM" keyboard/display access. That said, for my homelab use cases, the ability to reboot the server, suspend/unsuspend, and bastion SSH through the Raspberry Pi has been good enough.
- gibspaulding 4y agoIt would be pretty easy to model and 3d print an adapter to fit a Pi into a 3.5HDD bay. You'd have to run the power and Ethernet connection out the back of the PC through a water cooler grommet or PCI slot, but it would give the pi a safe home with good air flow! I considered doing this once for a file server I was hosting on a pi (since it would provide a home for a storage drive as well), but ended up going a different route.
- drewzero1 4y agoEven better in a floppy/media card/5.25 bay so there could be an OLED IP/info readout on the front of the PC. I love this idea, really getting my gears turning.
- toast0 4y ago> . Then, I have a small shell script that uses the etherwake Linux CLI tool to send a Wake-on-LAN magic packet to wake my server when it's sleeping. For full server reboots, I have the server on a remote-accessible power switch that can be cycled from the same Raspberry Pi. A long time ago, Facebook wired wake-on-lan to do a system reset. (With selected ethernet cards that could customize the wake-on-lan packet). They abandoned that in favor of OpenBMC, but it's an interesting idea for low spec control.
- hackcasual 4y agoI bought a Raritan KX IV-101 at the start of the pandemic, and it was single handedly the best home office purchase I've made. They're going for about $300 more than what I got it for, but it simply out-performs the PiKVM for an actual KVM replacement, where I'm able to use my personal desktop setup for working on my work PCs. Being able to do 1920x1200 at 60fps is so much more fluid and useable. 24fps is distracting to me even for simple things like text editing.
- mmastrac 4y agoWith the exception of Raspberry Pis, the KXII is pretty much golden for this as well. There's the small downside of needing to use a Java app for remote access but the interactivity is amazing.
- amelius 4y agoWhy put a computer inside every server if you can have a computer control a whole rack of servers? The KVM part is only useful when setting up the server. A solution that allows easy unplugging seems preferable.
- Melatonic 4y agoFor remote access? KVM has saved my ass many times
- ThinkBeat 4y agoI was hoping it would be a full PC that went inside my PC. CPU,RAM,STORAGE,VIDEO and I would like it as an x64 variant. I am sure ARM would sell well. and mix and match. With a simple way to add even more PCs inside a PC. For one thing, it would let you run "rack of PI" experiments in parallel computing. Make cross compiling easier, offload tasks,
- nikau 4y agoThings like that were popular in the Amiga era with bridgeboards to run x86 code on a 68000 machine, but not much of a market now with modern CPU speed and hypervisor support.