10 ms·
TGV unveils high-speed trains of the future
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoI would settle for building the high-speed trains of the present.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoAww man, I wish we had these in Austria. Don't get me wrong, the trains here are nice, but they are sooo slow that most of the times it's quicker and cheaper to get to your destination by car on the Autobahn, especially if you just buy the ticket a few days before the journey without any discounts and pay full price.
- Freak_NL 4y agoÖBB is leading the pack on the sleeper train front though. Wien, Graz, Innsbruck, all linked up to the rest of Europe on a neat network of NightJet trains. The next generation of rolling stock for the sleeper cars looks amazing too.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoSure, but Graz - Vienna train route is still slow as shit and that's Austria's second city. The train travels at like ~100km/h average or something, which is pathetic compared to high speed trains in Germany or France. I get that this could be a limitation of the Austrian landscape making fast train infra challenging, but even a Flixbus traveling on the slow lane on the Autobahn gets you there ~30 min faster and at half the price of OBB. The trains are nice and the service is great, but the speeds are a joke for the price of the non-discounted tickets as even traveling on the autobahn by bus can be faster on most routes.
- baud147258 4y agowell, if the SNCF could also pour some of that money in secondary/regional lines too, it'd be swell
- hadrien01 4y agoThat's on regional administrations, not the SNCF
- thrillgore 4y agoI thought the SNCF *was* all the regional authorities and also the owners of the rail lines.
- saryant 4y agoSome regions operate TER trains themselves.
- hadrien01 4y agoThe SNCF is currently the only operator of regional train lines in France, but it's the regions that decide what lines are run and on what budget. They also own or lease the trains. The rails are indeed owned by SNCF Réseau.
- julienchastang 4y agoThere is also "Chemins de fer de Provence"[0] separate from the SNCF. I took it once in the 80s when I was kid traveling from Nice to somewhere in the Maritime Alps for a day. I remember a rickety old train that did not travel fast, but nevertheless had its charms. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemins_de_fer_de_Provence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemins_de_fer_de_Provence Edit: The French Wikipedia page is quite a bit more interesting: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemins_de_fer_de_Provence https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemins_de_fer_de_Provence
- thrillgore 4y agoWhen I first saw the AGV2 trains years ago, I thought the nose looked tacky as hell but it looks a lot better with this prototype livery. Good job Alstom/SNCF. It'll never be as nice as the Atlantique EMUs but not bad. Can you also fix the byzantine booking system while you're at it?
- londons_explore 4y agoPlane designers figured out long ago that for the best aerodynamics you don't actually want a pointy nose - a big hemisphere like the bottom of a raindrop performs best. So why does this have a pointier nose? Just for PR?
- thrillgore 4y agoI think pointier noses and air flow matter more for tunnel travel due to the piston effect, so it does matter here.
- Someone 4y ago¿Maybe a desire to create some downforce to keep the train on its track? There also is a difference in velocity and in expected air pressure, airplanes don’t have to bother about not creating pressure waves for planes passing them at a few meters distance while flying in the reverse direction and airplanes are relatively much longer than air planes compared to their width. That means that a much larger fraction of the air resistance comes from the sides of the train.
- agumonkey 4y agoare you sure planes aerodynamics weren't tailored to 3d movements while a train isn't ?
- carabiner 4y agoNo, commercial jets have a blunt nose for structural reasons and pilot visibility while landing. SR-71, F-16 and so on all have pointy noses.
- londons_explore 4y agoPointy noses in military craft are to reduce the radar cross section - it actually performs worse. A round nose has a flat bit at the front which reflects radar direct back towards the enemy that you're flying towards. Military planes generally have no surfaces facing directly forwards for that reason - even surfaces made of plastics reflect some radar when they get wet.
- londons_explore 4y agoSo how many Wh/mile can it do?
- speedgoose 4y agoThe old one did around 20kWh/km and they claim 32% less CO2 per passenger. Perhaps including the construction too, but that shouldn’t change a lot. So let’s say 14kWh/km (or about 8 times the recommended food energy per day for an average person, per mile).
- londons_explore 4y agoThat actually seems like an awful lot... A tesla model 3 is 250 wh/mile. so 56 cars energy = 1 trains energy. The train has steel wheels (far lower rolling resistance) and a far more aerodynamic shape... But also has the downside of far more weight, probably less efficient motors and power electronics, limited regen ability, and faster speed (air losses are the third power of speed)
- speedgoose 4y agoThe train also has 740 passengers. 56 Tesla model 3 could fit 280 people (a bit tight in the middle back seat). And yes, the model 3 cannot average 300km/h. Still it shows that trains could be better.
- seszett 4y ago> 56 cars energy = 1 trains energy. These trains accommodate around 500 passengers though, while a car is generally max 5 passengers. So the trains are about ten times more efficient, and two to three times as far.
- makapuf 4y agoAnd an average tesla does not have 5 ppl in it, from what I can see its more like 1.5, whereas you typical train seems to be 60% full (personal experience).
- esel2k 4y agoSitting on the TGV Lyria while writing this. I have to say it is a great feeling to travel across the country in a few hours. However I think it is the experience around it that make it difficult: Waiting lines at Gare the Lyon never knowing where your train comes and having huge qeues or just the idea that travelling with bags or family squeeze in the metro, still makes me think about flying or driving for certain use-cases. I think it is mostly a business train to get from A to B (bug cities).
- danw1979 4y agoYup, I’d definitely travel from London to the south of France by train more often if it didn’t mean the Gare du nord - gare de lyon change…
- lostlogin 4y agoI’ve only done that trip a once by rail. I was blown away by the rail option, it was great. Despite Gare du Nord being disorganised and gross, it was the best international travel I’ve ever done by a huge margin. One is likely to need a connection at both ends and connecting from a rail hub is a lot simpler than from an airport (and less subject to rip off airport pricing). I loved the space, the comfort, the views and the display showing the speed.
- jacobriis 4y agoYou can connect in Lille, France for TGV service to Montpellier and Marseilles.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThere used to be a TGV direct from London to Marseille, at least during the summer season, iirc. But, IMHO, it's much more convenient and faster to fly from Heathrow to Marseille.
- makapuf 4y agoBut much more emitting of CO2
- woodruffw 4y agoI was about to gripe about trains in the US, but it looks like Amtrak is buying models that look pretty similar to these ones for the next generation of Acela trains[1]. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avelia_Liberty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avelia_Liberty
- gumby 4y agoBetween NY and Boston I've never seen the speeds claimed on that Wikipedia page -- not even close. I only once rode NY->DC and it felt a bit faster, but not hugely so. I didn't conduct any formal measurements, but I use to be a frequent TGV, ICE, and Shinkansen rider and you can tell you're moving fast by just looking out the window.
- masklinn 4y agoYes the US priorities on rail (freight) means Acela is… not very good. IIRC the current train set has a maximum speed of 240km/h, and because so little of the way is dedicated the average speed end to end is around 110 I think. Kph. On the fastest section between NYC and DC it’s 130, or 80 mph. That’s a car’s speed. Boston to DC is 735km which Acela covers in 6h45 minutes. By comparison Paris to Marseilles is 862km which the TGV covers in 3h. In fact, the “Mistral” which preceded the TGV and ran from 1950 to 1981 covered the distance in 6h40. That’s how bad Acela service is: it compares disfavorably to best-of-class trains from the 60s.
- bombcar 4y agoStandard "heavy rail" Amtrak (think: Pacific Surfliner, two stories tall with thundering diesel, https://www.pacificsurfliner.com/plan-your-trip/ https://www.pacificsurfliner.com/plan-your-trip/ ) can run at 120 MPH if the track has positive track control. By some definitions that makes it "high speed rail" heh. Which the Surfliner didn't in my day (and I think it still doesn't) - but it would hit 90 MPH through Camp Pendleton and I swear my GPS clocked it at 100 once. Still would beat a car LA station to San Diego station during rush hour traffic.
- 4y ago
- perihelions 4y ago- "In 2022, we don't want to go faster" Yes we do! - "the goal instead is high speed trains that accommodate more people" No; we want legroom. - "...while consuming less energy" We don't want that either. Isn't your electricity nuclear power anyway? What's the problem with consuming too much clean energy? You're in direct competition with airline travel, so every bit of increased consumer attractiveness is a *net social benefit* with regards to climate change. What exactly is the hangup? Smells like cost-cutting MBA's shoving through unpopular changes, with a sugarcoating of social responsibility. This future sucks. I want my atomic flying cars back.
- progval 4y ago> Isn't your electricity nuclear power anyway? What's the problem with consuming too much clean energy? According to a 2019 poll, 69% of French people believe that nuclear "contributes to producing CO2 and climate change". (34% answered "a lot", 35% "a little", 13% "not really", 17% "no") Source: https://www.bva-group.com/sondages/francais-nucleaire-sondage-bva-orano/ https://www.bva-group.com/sondages/francais-nucleaire-sondag...
- pasabagi 4y agoWell, it does. Nuclear plants have very high embodied carbon, as they're made out of large amounts of steel and concrete. That's obviously not as bad as a coal plant or even a gas plant. But 'a lot' is still probably correct.
- tremon 4y agoBy that reasoning, a wind park isn't carbon-free electricity either. I wish you good luck on your campaign to convince the public, after that you can come back here and we'll talk again.
- cinntaile 4y agoIf we just look at how much CO2 something produces when it's ready-built we potentially ignore a huge part of the pollution. You usually do a life cycle analysis (LCA) and come up with a g CO2-equivalents/kWh. No energy source has 0g/kWh.
- j-pb 4y agoTo think that we could have maglev trains in europe for 40 years now...
- 88840-8855 4y agoIt was a political decision back than. German stopped being great long time ago and the Transrapid cancellation was just the beginning of German downturn. The energy crisis will be the last episode of Germany's long depression.
- tremon 4y agothe last episode of Germany's long depression Last or latest? Calling it the last makes it sound hopeful, but your post doesn't exactly read like that.
- DuskStar 4y agoSometimes the last bad thing means that good things are coming. Other times, it means that nothing more is coming.
- mqus 4y agoSo you would rather have built completely new tracks, stations and other infrastrusture, which can only be used with in-system trainsets and will most likely be completely incompatible with anything running on other european rails for decades? No possibility of dual-use with older sleeper trains, regional trains or freight trains? I would argue the decision was not as bad as you make it out to be.
- j-pb 4y agoThat argument is the root cause why we stopped investing in innovation and infrastructure. The same could have been said about airports, highways, trains, electricity, the internet. Current train travel is a joke in germany, the infrastructure is failing, the prices and shedules are an international meme. One of the main reason it sucks so much is having shared cargo and passenger rail. The successfull high speed trains are using their tracks exclusively. If we had started investing 40 years ago we would all be cruising silently at 460kmh with tickets half the price, because of the maintenance free solid state tech. Transrapid is also more wheelchair accessible because it is level with the platform and the cabin is much wider. Also remember that stupid solar roadways idea? Guess where that actually works, in between the transrapid rails. By covering the center of the pylons in solar a route from bremen to hamburg would produce enough energy to replace 1 1/2 coal power plants.
- inglor_cz 4y ago" the first test phase will start in the Czech Republic at the end of 2022." Interestingly, while we have 0 km of passenger high-speed rail in CZ, we have a testing facility that half of Europe uses when testing their high-speed trains. [0]. Hey, at least something. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velim_railway_test_circuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velim_railway_test_circuit
- knerz 4y agoAre there any high-speed rail lines in planning in Czechia? I am desperate for a high speed Berlin-Prague-Vienna link.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThere are, but, as we say in Czech: "the paper can tolerate anything". I will certainly be opening a bottle of Malbec the day when the works actually start. HSRs would be very useful, as the contemporary railway network is badly overloaded and at the edge of its capacity. Every irregularity, including planned repairs, unleashes a hurricane of delays all over the main corridors.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y ago"Papier ist geduldig" (Paper is patient) would be the german equivalent. Cheers :-)
- jonp888 4y agoYes, a new high speed line will be built between Dresden and Prague, mostly in tunnel to replace the current slow and restricted line which had to stay in the river gorge.
- nwellnhof 4y agoMunich-Prague is even worse. 5 1/2 hours by train for a 300 km trip.
- simonebrunozzi 4y ago
- julienchastang 4y agoI recently took the TGV from Avignon to Paris. It was fast, clean (a notable improvement from the past), efficient and on time. I was left with my usual feeling: why can't we have this in the US? It will never happen. A confluence of NIMBY, onerous regulation, a judicial system that ensures private contractors have the upper hand in legal disputes, just to name a few reasons will always mean this kind of infrastructure will remain out of reach for most Americans especially those living outside the northeast corridor.
- pkulak 4y agoWell, California is working on it, but taking a constant stream of abuse for going over budget. Not sure who else is ever going to sign on for this process. I can't remember the last time and entire nation cared this much about an over-budget freeway program; and there have been plenty.
- vondur 4y agoNot easy here. You see the results of the California high speed rail project. Billions spent with basically nothing to show for it. Buying the land up near the cities they would service is super expensive. I was hoping they could at least connect the Central Valley cities. It may allow people to live where it’s cheaper and commute to the LA area.
- rr888 4y agoTwo big differences. The distance between US cities is much further than Europe (aside from the NE USA which does have high speed rail). Also European cities have nice downtowns and good public transport so people do want to go from one city center to another. As opposed to the USA where no one wants to go from say downtown Houston to downtown Denver.
- antongribok 4y agoNorth-East USA does not have high speed rail. Amtrak Acela is not high speed rail.
- yakshaving_jgt 4y ago