11 ms·
They created a company that people willingly buy over $1 billion of product from every year. Why shouldn’t creating that much value in the world result in the o
by sokoloff 4y ago
They created a company that people willingly buy over $1 billion of product from every year. Why shouldn’t creating that much value in the world result in the owners collectively benefiting? If that happens to be a million different people each having a $1000 stake or 1 family having a $1B stake, I don’t have a problem thinking that either is a valid outcome.
IMO, we should look at the value created and celebrate that rather than jealously fret over the concentration of the number of people who own it.
To be clear: I think what they did is admirable on both the building and the recent transaction. I respect them greatly for both parts.
- criddell 4y ago> a million different people each having a $1000 stake or 1 family having a $1B stake Money is power. Do you see no difference in a million people have a little power vs one family having enormous power?
- marcusverus 4y agoIf you want to reduce the influence of money on politics, you're not going to achieve that by punishing billionaires, or by destroying the incentive structure that allows them to exist. If you want to reduce the influence of money in politics, you'll have to understand the specific mechanisms that create said influence, and address them by law. Wealth is good. People acquire wealth by adding value. We want to incentivize people to add value. Of course, the "billionaires shouldn't exist" crowd understand little and less, and would happily have us destroy this system of incentives without even achieving their stated goals, because they, much like the "defund police" crowd, are more interested in appearing virtuous than in actually solving problems.
- kasey_junk 4y ago> Wealth is good. People acquire wealth by adding value. Those are axioms presented without evidence. It’s trivial to find counter examples. I’m no radical redistributionist but the idea that wealth in and of itself shows added value is clearly wrong.
- prottog 4y agoI suppose it depends on how you define wealth, but I can't think of many people who became really fabulously wealthy without creating value for other people, except when government was involved in a monopolistic or rent-seeking way. It's trivial to steal somebody's lunch money. It's much harder to become a multi-billionaire without making something that a lot of other people wanted to spend money on. (If those other people were forced to spend money on it by the power of the government, it's a different matter.)
- hackerlight 4y agoRegulatory capture is just the beginning. Just because two people agreed to trade doesn't mean value was created. First there's externalities. Global warming caused by oil companies. Stochastic terrorism and fragmentation of our polity caused by social media and news companies. Healthcare crisis caused by fast food companies. Second the notion of voluntary trade is a fairy tail that's ignorant of the underlying neuro and psychological processes that go into decision making. The dopamine system is stupidly easy to game. It's like if we got a bunch of moths to kill themselves by flying into a bright light somewhere and we call that voluntary, as if we weren't merely hacking ancient circuitry. That's what's happening now with opioids, fast food, social media and more.
- Levitz 4y ago>Just because two people agreed to trade doesn't mean value was created. Reminds me of that adage: "Economics is the idea that if I pay you a dollar to step on shit and you in turn pay me the same dollar to step on shit, that makes for a better world"
- orwin 4y agoMoney is just an arbitrary mean of distributing production. In a capitalist society (and at a lesser extent in a mercantile one too), having a lot of "things", in this case money and capital: we can call wealth, is power (this has implication for anarchist beliefs). Democracy and in a limited way, socialism (pensions for the elderly, healthcare, subsidized public transportation, i know this is not the original meaning, but for this its good enough) counterbalance the power gap between wealthy people and non-wealthy people, but clearly in the western world (at least in my country), the counterbalance is weaker and weaker. I don't think a random millionaire like Eric Finman should have more power than a random citizen, and yet he have. I don't think the "billionaire shouldn't exist" crowd actually exist. But i'm part of the "billionaires shouldn't have this much power" crowd, since it feels like in my country, they own the press, the executive and 40% of the legislative power. The judiciary power is the only one that might be a bit free from influence, but i'm not certain.
- sokoloff 4y agoThere are commenters on this very page who count themselves among the “billionaires should not exist” crowd.
- orwin 4y agoLet me rephrase this: i don't think people saying 'billionaires shouldn't exist' are against their existence, but against the disproportionate amount of power they have.
- int_19h 4y agoBillionaires existing is ipso facto evidence of extreme inequality in allocation of generated wealth - so extreme that there is no feasible justification for it. Therefore, billionaires should not exist. A more verbose way to say the same thing is that society should be structured in ways that make it impossible to collect so much wealth produced by other people as economic rent.
- orwin 4y ago
- hackerlight 4y ago"People acquire wealth by adding value" This incorrect view comes from objectivist thought. Namely, the trader theory of value. But it's false ideology. Some wealth implies value add. SpaceX. Other wealth was partly figuratively stolen due to incomplete laws that prevent market failure. Purdue Pharma, slave trader, hitman, oil company (global warming), sex trafficker, social media company (societal fragmentation), fast food company (costs on public healthcare), landowners (regulatory capture), porn company (victims of revenge porn), car company (health effects of tire dust). I'd say it's more the norm nowadays that wealth is partly stolen, figuratively speaking. The distortions and market failures have become so large.
- marcusverus 4y agoYou seem to be suggesting that the mere existence of externalities somehow negates the fact that value was added, which is silly. The existence of externalities doesn't negate the adding of value. Would we be better off without oil companies? Obviously not (just ask a European!) Hence it's impossible to say that they're not adding value, or that the people who create them aren't adding value.
- nine_k 4y agoOTOH concentration of capital makes companies like Tesla and SpaceX possible. It also makes large, self-sustaining charities possible.
- therealdrag0 4y agoIt’s a convenience for rich people to find their own ventures, but it’s not the only way for ventures to be funded. If the wealth was distributed among thousands more then those folks would still be looking to invest it, many in EV or space tech, and some might just pool their money into venture capital coops that perform the same function as individual rich folks etc. (allowing individual entities to be pitched to instead of each of thousands of investors.)
- sokoloff 4y agoOf course I see a difference between those two; I just don’t think it’s a problem. Over many decades, many millions of people transferred some of their power to Patagonia as a result of their belief that they’d rather have the Patagonia product than the amount of power that money represented. Millions were made better off, by their own value function.
- rland 4y agoThis is actually a great way of looking at it. Patagonia here is the exception, that's why we're all here talking about it! I didn't want to give my bit of power to my health insurer, but guess what, I have to have healthcare to live and there's effectively one local hospital I can choose. I didn't want to give my ~~~bit~~~ hefty chunk of power to the company that gatekeeps the patent on insulin, but I really didn't have much choice on that one. I didn't want to give my bit of power to the telecom conglomerate, but did I have a choice? I need to be online to participate in today's society. I didn't want to give my bit of power to Google, but... uhh actually I didn't give it to them, they stole it by spying on me. The reality is that concentrations of power that are inherent to our system of free exchange inevitably congeal into something that looks a lot less free. All of these examples (and there are so many, most of our economy is like this!) don't really represent individual value functions, because when power gets concentrated enough, it becomes possible to take choice away.
- prottog 4y agoHealth insurance and medical care are all highly regulated industries with exceptionally high cost of entry; one could call it a broken market. It's not competitive at all. I always marvel at how much better the whole experience is when I take my dog to the vet than when I myself go see a doctor, and can't help but wonder if there wasn't so much state intervention (or even just wiser intervention) in medicine, my experience would be different. Forms of insulin for which the patent has expired are affordable. The stuff under patent is expensive but objectively better at its job. One could argue that the forms in between (patent recently expired but not widely available as generics in the market) are again due to the result of onerous regulations keeping competition out of that market. Telecommunications, at least the hardwired kind, is a natural monopoly and I wish some smarter incentive-structuring would take place in that market; maybe public ownership of the infrastructure with competitive private service providers operating on top of it. Wireless is generally more competitive and you can actually be online for less money than you think. I'm not sure what your point was about Google? You certainly don't have to use their services.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> Why shouldn’t creating that much value in the world result in the owners collectively benefiting? One can benefit without being a billionaire.
- smaddox 4y agoShould we cap the benefit at some particular monetary value? Wouldn't that disincentivize building companies past a certain point of success? Is that really what we want?
- layer8 4y agoLooking at many of the big companies, that doesn’t seem like a particularly bad idea.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoI think we should scale income tax based on wealth personally
- layer8 4y agoThat will just lead people to outsource their wealth by whatever means, so that it doesn’t formally count as their wealth anymore, but they effectively still control it.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThen I hope we can couple it with a well funded IRS. In theory this would be difficult to do unlike the games that occur now because you don't merely need to suggest that you're not earning the income. You can't give it to a family member or it gets it with a hefty gift tax. You can't stuff it into a shell corp because you still own the shell corp. You could donate it to a charity which you control which is a thing that happens now.
- layer8 4y ago
- jacknews 4y agoBut one person did not create all the value. And it's not even all the employees of this single company who created it. The entire structure of society, technology, law and order, transport infrastructure, etc, etc, enabled such a concentration of wealth. It's good to see when beneficiaries realise it's not really 'their' money at all.
- smileysteve 4y agoAnd in the context Created a billion dollar company that people buy from to enjoy the outdoors (at least some of the time for a large portion of the customers)(or at least signal)
- nine_k 4y agoYou speak as if almost all these societal benefits are not paid for by willful trading, and by taxes. Did this particular billionaire evade taxes? used tons of governmental subsidies, or government-granted monopolies? Does this company look like it did not pay its fair share back?
- jacknews 4y agoIsn't that the point? The current rules allow, even encourage such individual wealth. That is the policy failure.
- sokoloff 4y agoAre you representing that conclusion as based on your set of axioms (which is fine and I can’t argue against) or suggesting that those axioms are universal?
- jacknews 4y agoI don't think there's much to assume here. Governments around the world have rules about companies, salaries, taxes and so on. There exist a large number of billionaires. Therefore, assuming most of them follow the rules, the rules allow such a concentration of individual wealth. I'm not against innovators getting relatively rich, that's often the incentive to innovate, or at least to push through the 'perspiration' part of that activity, but there should be balance.
- alistairSH 4y agoThe problem is concentration of wealth to the point there are negative impacts elsewhere in society. Bezos didn’t get rich in a vacuum. He did it by pushing warehouse workers to the brink of sanity and physical collapse. By making drivers per in bottles instead of taking bathroom breaks. Etc. And then there’s Zuck. Does FB/Meta really provide value to society that warrants his wealth? Sire, within the confines of the rules we have in place it does. But that doesn’t mean we can’t question those rules.
- wnolens 4y ago> Does FB/Meta really provide value to society that warrants his wealth? Do basketball players deserve to make 10x the salary of CEOs? (Average, from top Google result). A market where by individuals have the freedom to allocate their dollars towards things they need and/or want (among plenty of options) has determined so. No one gets rich in a vacuum. Slave labor is illegal. Hundreds of thousands of people are paid along the way - inside Amazon, outside, the government.
- int_19h 4y agoThere is a power imbalance between employers and employees, which is particularly severe in case of large corporations. Slavery is not the only way to economically exploit people, just the most direct one.
- banannaise 4y ago> Do basketball players deserve to make 10x the salary of CEOs? (Average, from top Google result). The short answer: no, they don't, basketball has its own wealth distribution problem, but that's a problem within basketball rather than for society at large. (Non-superstar players are severely undercompensated, particularly when it comes to development leagues, college, and even high school.) The shorter answer: we're not talking about CEOs, we're talking about owners and shareholders, so why even bring up CEOs?
- kevinwang 4y ago> Why shouldn’t creating that much value in the world result in the owners collectively benefiting? It's an inefficient allocation of resources, since wealth brings marginally decreasing utility.
- notch656a 4y ago>wealth brings marginally decreasing utility. If it is consumed, then sure. If it is invested by a wise rich person who can manage and grow businesses, then his employees/customers/investors/partners (and perhaps even their own trade partners) may well reach much more utility from the fruits of that wealth than the utility realized if the wealth ended up in less productive hands.
- Tiktaalik 4y agoThe failure is that we think Chouinard wholly created this value and deserves this extreme concentration of the wealth created by the Patagonia company instead of the many, many, many people that gave their lifetimes and labour toward furthering the goals of the Patagonia company.
- eternalban 4y agoSo this boils down to us lacking a fair and effective valuation methodology for leadership, which includes psychological aspects that possibly can't be objectively quantified. p.s. Possibly a feedback mechanism where each contributor votes a fraction back to the person/team in charge and valuation (compensation) emerges that way.
- FredPret 4y agoWe have a system for this already. You vote using money.
- cloutchaser 4y ago> many, many, many people that gave their lifetimes and labour toward furthering the goals of the Patagonia company And they could leave at any point, they are paid for their work within 30 days. They take 0 risk. As an entrepreneur for 20 years, I used to believe employees believe in companies and missions, but they don't, 99% of the time. They get paid for 30 days work, on time, and if they get a better offer they leave. I'm sorry but that is 0 risk compared to what an entrepreneur does. People like yourself clearly have no idea how much responsibility and risk, and emotional strain an entrepreneur takes on, while employing people and paying them monthly. There is no comparison. Don't expect people who take 0 risk to become millionaires. It's a ridiculous proposition. If that were the case "everyone" would be a millionaire, or a professional sports person, or an influencers, or whatever. Taking risk, and building things yourself is much much harder. People who have never done it don't understand.
- gabrielgio 4y agoI can't comment on how much harder it is for a person to be a bussiness owner as problably we don't live in the same country and we don't live under the same laws/regulation, otherwise I'd challenge that. > They take 0 risk. For wealthy worker problably, but for labor worker is not risky free. > building things yourself is much much harder Unless you work alone you don't build things yourself. > People like yourself clearly have no idea how much responsibility and risk, and emotional strain an entrepreneur takes on It seems like you don't have idea how hard it is to be in the bottom layer of the wealth distribution. > Don't expect people who take 0 risk to become millionaires. I don't think no one in this thread meant that. They are just advocating for better wealth distribution.
- spyckie2 4y agoThe economic system that creates billionares is the problem, not the billionaires themselves. But because the issue is that wealth suppresses wages, the easiest visualization and embodiment of wealth is billionaires. > Why shouldn’t creating that much value in the world result in the owners collectively benefiting? Billionaires make money from both value creation and value capture, but it can be argued pretty convincingly that value capture is how billionaires make their money rather than value creation. In fact, there's plenty of examples where value is created but not captured (open source being one of them) that lead you to realize that massive value creation isn't possible with just one person, but massive value capture is. Even superstar value creators like Einstein or Beethoven were ultimately just contributors to a larger scientific or musical community. When considering economic policy, you have to think of it as value capture, value creation, and value distribution. And while it's nice to think of value capture as "the capture of the value you create", the reality is that value capture can be any systemic transfer of wealth. Gambling is a prime example of a transfer of value without any creation of it. Billionaires are actually not the problem; the problem is that wealth captures too much value compared to wages, which then produces economic conditions of slavery.