10 ms·
Google loses challenge against EU antitrust decision, wins 5% fine cut
- belter 4y agoGoogle and Alphabet v Commission (Google Android) Case T-604/18: https://curia.europa.eu/juris/fiche.jsf;jsessionid=93085C8069F448B3CE9381B51E3B95C2?id=T%3B604%3B18%3BRD%3B1%3BP%3B1%3BT2018%2F0604%2FP&nat=or&mat=or&pcs=Oor&jur=C%2CT%2CF&num=T-604%252F18&for=&jge=&dates=&language=en&pro=&cit=none%252CC%252CCJ%252CR%252C2008E%252C%252C%252C%252C%252C%252C%252C%252C%252C%252Ctrue%252Cfalse%252Cfalse&oqp=&td=%3BALL&avg=&lgrec=en&lg=&cid=124616 https://curia.europa.eu/juris/fiche.jsf;jsessionid=93085C806... And... "Google faces fines of up to $25.4b in UK and EU ad tech case" - https://www.theregister.com/2022/09/14/google_cat_eu_case/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/09/14/google_cat_eu_case/
- aargh_aargh 4y agoJust got me thinking - how does such an amount get actually transferred from company to state (EU) coffers? Do they wire it in parts from their presumably multiple accounts in various banks? Which entity do they send it to? Does the fine allow paying it in installments? How does it pass AML clearance? And what happens should they theoretically fail to pay? Does law enforcement show up at their door? Does a collection agency handle it?
- amelius 4y agoI assume the paying party will be creative about it. The fine is probably paid in Play Store vouchers.
- pieter_mj 4y agoMore abandoned projects. Keep an eye on Google Graveyard : https://killedbygoogle.com/ https://killedbygoogle.com/
- aurora72 4y agoBetter question: Is it paid at all?
- amelius 4y agoGoogle probably knows exactly which public servant is responsible for keeping track of the money ...
- the_cramer 4y agoAnother question: what is done with this money?
- mtmail 4y agoI assume it's similar to the Microsoft case https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Commission "The fines will not be distributed to the companies that lost income due to Microsoft practices. The money paid in fines to the European Court goes back into the EU budget" 2019 EU's budget was 148m EUR. Budget overall is used for a mix of growth (e.g. building bridges or other infracstructure), security (border patrol), regional help (e.g. after wildfires). They do a lot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#Expenditure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#E...
- formerkrogemp 4y ago> And what happens should they theoretically fail to pay? They pay more or lose access to billions in sales. It's both as complicated and as simple as that.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoI'd ship it in pennies if it were up to me. And lobby the US government for a special issue penny that carries a 99% tax when used. The EU can suck it.
- illuminati1911 4y agoLol. They have probably defined how to money is to be sent to them. Even if they had not it's probably better to stfu and comply. More your try to fuck with the regulators, more they will punish you.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoIf you really took that comment seriously, you have bigger problems to worry about. Speculating that this did seriously play out and you "fuck with the regulators, they punish you", is that really the accepted cultural take in Europe? I mean, sure, there is a common sense level of decency in dealing with regulators and not making them madder than need be, but take a look at the United States. A regulator may try asserting more power than they possess and the courts offer a system to at least challenge it and have these excesses checked. I suppose the point of my comical take was the idea of challenging an unjust ruling by entities with a noted history of hostility toward US tech firms. Trump went aggressive on the EU and threatened to sanction the fuck out of the union if they hit the tech firms or Boeing with fines. There's always a bigger fish in the pond. The regulators themselves can play this game given Europes historical economic position, but when tech companies deemed important to US national security and honestly scientific progress around the world are put at threat by the squabbling in Brussels, you can bet a stern response from the US will be taken seriously.
- IanCal 4y ago> Speculating that this did seriously play out and you "fuck with the regulators, they punish you", is that really the accepted cultural take in Europe? Yes? Regulators are there to stop companies abusing their powers. > A regulator may try asserting more power than they possess and the courts offer a system to at least challenge it and have these excesses checked. Legally challenging a regulator within the system is not "fucking with the regulators". We're already talking about an appeal, and there may be another level of appeals to this. It's not a regulator running wild. > I suppose the point of my comical take was the idea of challenging an unjust ruling by entities with a noted history of hostility toward US tech firms. Trump went aggressive on the EU and threatened to sanction the fuck out of the union if they hit the tech firms or Boeing with fines. It feels weird that you think an appropriate response to a company fined for breaking the rules and being anti-competitive is political threats and sanctions. > scientific progress around the world are put at threat by the squabbling in Brussels I'm not really sure that google forcibly stopping manufacturers from making phones with non-google-approved android installed is key scientific progress.
- throw_a_grenade 4y agoSimple wire transfer. Some time later they (or their lawyers) will get a letter with IBAN number (idk about curia.eu, but in Poland the account would be in central bank). Also a wire title which they need to add to wire order so the transfers can be identified. It doesn't need to be a single transfer, but all of them need to arrive before stated date. Again idk about this particular court, but also in Poland (and I expect most EU countries) they're also allowed to pay at the counter with a "legal tender" (cash and some limited legal papers like promissiory note), that is, they're free to dump truckload of coins at the main entrance, should they procure such an amount. Over here people do it sometimes to vent themselves if they loose a case. Typically police will get called, but it's the cashier's job description to count the money, and they can't require extra payment for that, so in extreme cases the office gets locked for a whole day.
- kwhitefoot 4y ago> they're free to dump truckload of coins at the main entrance, Probably not. I suspect that most countries allow creditors to refuse payment in large quantities of coins or notes. Certainly the UK does.
- PeterisP 4y ago> And what happens should they theoretically fail to pay? Does law enforcement show up at their door? Does a collection agency handle it? Court-assigned fines to the government generally get collected by the internal revenue service, not a collection agency; but the standard means if they do not comply does not involve law enforcement showing up at their door but the starting point is letters to all the banks to seize any current and incoming funds, if that is not sufficient, followed by seizure and auction of any real assets (e.g. buildings) - but since the described amount is roughly what Google earns from EU in a single month, simply seizing that sales revenue would be enough.
- sph 4y agoIt's sad that with corporate PR and NDAs we have no idea how this would affect Google, so it often comes, makes a headline, and passes. How much are Google executives freaking out because of these antitrust lawsuits?
- izacus 4y ago"The Court agreed with the Commission's assessment that iPhone maker Apple (AAPL.O) was not in the same market and therefore could not be a competitive constraint against Android." This tells a lot about how much our EU lawmakers understand modern technology. While there's nothing wrong with this fine, claiming that Apple isn't in the same market as Android is utter ridiculousness.
- IanCal 4y agoApple isn't in the same market. It helps to look at the actual overview because it explains what they mean by markets and why apple isn't in the same market: https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2022-09/cp220147en.pdf https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/202... What's key in this is that it's about google taking their dominant position in one market and using it to exert undue influence in another market.
- ethbr0 4y ago> In the present case, the General Court notes at the outset that the Commission identified, first of all, four types of relevant market: (i) the worldwide market (excluding China) for the licensing of smart mobile device operating systems; (ii) the worldwide market (excluding China) for Android app stores; (iii) the various national markets, within the EEA, for the provision of general search services; and (iv) the worldwide market for non OS-specific mobile web browsers. The Commission went on to find that Google held a dominant position on the first three of those markets.
- IanCal 4y agoYes, if my wording of "one market" is confusing hopefully this makes it clear: You don't really get in trouble for just growing your business within a market. You get in trouble for abusing your dominant position in one market to influence another. You can see this in the restrictions identified > those contained in ‘distribution agreements’, requiring manufacturers of mobile devices to pre-install the general search (Google Search) and (Chrome) browser apps in order to be able to obtain a licence from Google to use its app store (Play Store); They used their position of having a huge influence with Play Store to force manufacturers to include google search and chrome, which are unrelated. > those contained in ‘anti-fragmentation agreements’, under which the operating licences necessary for the pre-installation of the Google Search and Play Store apps could be obtained by mobile device manufacturers only if they undertook not to sell devices running versions of the Android operating system not approved by Google; They used their position with Android to force manufacturers to push google search and the play store by not letting them even build other devices without approval. > those contained in ‘revenue share agreements’, under which the grant of a share of Google’s advertising revenue to the manufacturers of mobile devices and the mobile network operators concerned was subject to their undertaking not to pre-install a competing general search service on a predefined portfolio of devices. They used their advertising business to force out competitors in search. You can argue this is one market if you want but it's clear this isn't competing on the merits of google search.
- DisjointedHunt 4y ago
- nicoburns 4y agoAs a European, Chinese companies having my data is much less of a concern than US companies having it. The Chinese government isn't likely to use that data to meddle in my personal affairs, prosecute me, or request my extradition (and if they did, my government is unlikely to stand for that). The US government on the other hand might well do just that for something as minor as copyright violation.
- Iolaum 4y agoDon't bet on it. US and China are both empires, they will do what they can.
- lizardactivist 4y agoBut one of them has militarized the whole planet and has begun many, many wars to get what it wants and make the world more conducive to its corporations and their reach. There is no way you can even begin to compare China to the US on the great scale of evil.
- pessimizer 4y agoMaybe we won't take your word on it.
- unity1001 4y ago'Empire' does not mean 'great polity'. It is a specific political construct. And the US is closer to an actual empire than China ever is.
- nicoburns 4y agoTo the extent that they're both empires, I would suggest that Europe is in the US empire and not the Chinese empire.
- 4y ago
- AlexanderTheGr8 4y agoThis seems to be a very big fine ($4.12B), much bigger than any "cost of business" I can think of. What are the chances that google will actually have to pay it? They could re-appeal [0] or play some other judicial trick. Or maybe they say "enough is enough" and don't pay it. They have been appealing the €2.42 billion fine from July 2017 even now[1]. So I don't think that they have any intention to pay this much larger fine any time soon. Google's stock is already doing bad this year and this will likely make it worse (although the early trading today hasn't shown any indication of a change.) [0] "The company can still appeal the ruling in the EU’s highest court." - https://www.cnbc.com/2022/09/14/eu-court-backs-antitrust-ruling-against-google-but-reduces-fine.html https://www.cnbc.com/2022/09/14/eu-court-backs-antitrust-rul... [1] https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2022-09/cp220147en.pdf https://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/202...
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoThe State Department and White House will likely intervene when the EU wants to start using fines as a revenue stream. Google has been historically targeted by individuals in high ranking roles at the EU who have gone on record calling it their personal mission to harm US tech firms. There is a limit.
- ls15 4y agoVolkswagen paid much more for Dieselgate in the US
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoSo . . deliberately concealing poisonous gas emissions on a scale so massive, it affected every living thing in the United States is a little different to a highly subjective interpretation of a dominant market position and an even more suspect ruling on abuse of said monopoly.
- ls15 4y ago
- carlmr 4y agoI find it interesting how many Americans are pissed off ITT about the EU fining a US company for malicious practices. I didn't see the same reaction from Americans when the US was suing VW, Toyota, or other foreign companies for theirs.
- from 4y agoThere is this idea of “dual criminality” that makes those examples more fair from the American perspective. For instance emissions tampering is illegal in Europe too, the same of which can not be said for their set of increasingly arcane antitrust rules that are almost overwhelmingly used against American companies.
- thunkshift1 4y agoWell, its about time America stepped up with its own anti-trust laws as well. EU has ‘increasingly arcane’ antitrust anti tech monopoly laws because its a pioneer here and US is doing exactly jack to rein in the big tech. I mean why should they, right? Their companies going out in the world conquering new markets and raking in revenues like never before while uncle sam has to kick back his feet and wait for his to cut roll in. Not to mention all that sweet sweet consumer data and spying benefits. EU is not at fault here.
- from 4y ago> because its a pioneer here In what? Bureaucracy? > EU is not at fault here. They could try promoting innovation and producing tech companies of their own instead of devoting substantial amounts of energy to squeezing their more successful foreign counterparts. A cursory glance at the largest market cap companies in America reveals they are on average about 40-50 years old vs like 100 for Europe.
- f1refly 4y ago> they could try innovation and producing consumer hostile stalking conglomarates of their own yes, they could do that. The core business is illegal though, so I imagine it to be rather hard.
- ApolloFortyNine 4y agoIt's absolutely insane to me that the OS that actually allows users to install third party app stores and third party apps had an antitrust decision against it before Apple, who locks down there entire OS to users, did. It just seems like the EU here was more worried about businesses than users here. If users were the priority, they would have went after the ios app market. You can release an Android phone if you so desire right now, the problem seemed to stem from Google not letting you pick and choose which of the Google apps a manufacture could install. This seems clearly up to interpretation, if any manufacture could release an Android phone, then how is the OS what's abusing the Monopoly status here? It seems clear the real culprit is actually the App store, which Google required if a manufacturer included also needed to include a number of Google apps. If Google got punished so heavily for this, ios's total undeniable 100% monopoly on ios Apps should be a $50 billion fine. They've done all the same moves as Google, but even more locked down.
- jmoak3 4y agoAs a longtime iOS user, I entirely agree! This is a whacko bananas thing to press without any hint of something similar for Apple yet. Dinging Google for making manufacturers carry Google Maps (or whatever) if they install the Google Play App store is like when we dinged Microsoft for bundling a browser, all while Apple still won't allow you to have another browser. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Cor.... https://9to5mac.com/2022/03/01/web-developers-challenge-apple-to-allow-other-browser-engines-on-ios/ https://9to5mac.com/2022/03/01/web-developers-challenge-appl... I tell family and friends about the webkit issue and every single one pulls out their browser of choice and says "nuh-uh, see here's the chrome app. what do you mean it's still the same?" Imagine if Microsoft in the 90s started banning competitor software cause they may be "insecure" or "not private enough". Good grief, the only thing Google did wrong here was letting others manufacture Android phones. The lesson to take away from the EU here is to never show weakness or willingness to compromise, or let anyone else into your playpen. No way Apple gives even an inch after this. In my ideal world Google is dinged for this, and Apple gets the fattest fine known to man.
- 4y ago
- georgiecasey 4y agoso Apple and Samsung get most of the profits, and Google has to pay a huge fine for doing the open source thing and letting 3rd parties build handsets. If Google just built their own handset, kept Android closed-source and charged €800 a phone, the EU would have no problem with that but we'd all be worse off.
- aembleton 4y agoMaybe that's what Google should do in the EU. Refuse to licence the play store. If they did, then I'm sure Samsung would develop an app store to compete.
- PeterStuer 4y agoSamsung already has an appstore