29 ms·
Anti-royal protesters are being arrested in the U.K. as 'Not My King' tag grows
- Kukumber 4y ago
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoFor all its faults, I love the US. I can go downtown with a sign that says "Not my president", and I may get some cheers, may get some boos. What I won't get is arrested. This is true no matter who is president. Now, if I were saying this about President Harris, say, when she came to visit Biden's body while it was lying in state, that would be deplorable taste. It would be worse if my sign criticized Biden while his family came to pay their respects. That's pretty extreme levels of being a tasteless jerk. It's not grounds for arrest, though... in the US.
- codefreeordie 4y agoYou would probably not get arrested, but depending on what city you did this in, and under what circumstances, you might get dead.
- soupbowl 4y agoAny examples of that happening?
- potta_coffee 4y agoWell, you may be killed but that's incidental to whatever speech you're practicing; you'll just be killed for your wallet.
- troutwine 4y agoTrolling for violent reaction was one of the reasons the Westboro Baptist Church would post up outside of funerals. So far as I know it rarely worked, if ever.
- mjhay 4y agoThere has been a examples of this happening in the US, yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Hampton https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/20/us/protests-policing-george-floyd.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/20/us/protests-policing-geor... https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/oct/29/us-police-brutality-protest https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/oct/29/us-police-br...
- teachrdan 4y agohttps://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/seattle-protester-hit-car-latest-casualty-dangerous-far-right-trend-ncna1233525 https://www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/seattle-protester-hit-... "As protesters took to the streets in Indiana on July 6 to decry an alleged hate crime at Lake Monroe, a red Toyota Corolla sped toward them, dragging two protesters along, on the hood and on the side of the car. Both suffered non-life-threatening injuries. A few days later, a 66-year-old white woman was arrested and charged in the incident." It was a point of pride for many right wingers to threaten to crash their cars into non-violent protestors.
- tmpz22 4y agoYou say this but IMO its not exactly true. By far my favorite example is the UC Davis pepper spray event. Where sitting sedintary protestors were pepper sprayed by campus police (the school then engaged a PR firm to attempt to wipe evidence from the internet...) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UC_Davis_pepper_spray_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UC_Davis_pepper_spray_incident
- miles 4y ago"The three dozen student demonstrators, meanwhile, were collectively awarded US$1 million by UC Davis in a settlement from a federal lawsuit, with each pepper-sprayed student receiving $30,000 individually."
- carabiner 4y ago/r/ShitAmericansSay/ material right here.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- haunter 4y agoThat reminds me to my favorite Soviet-era joke An american reporter visits a communist country and asks a person on the street about freedom. He says "America is so free I can stand up on the subway and criticize and say anything about the president, no one would care about it. How is the situation here?" The person replies: "Well I can can stand up on the subway and criticize and say anything about the US president here too, no one would care about it!"
- vkou 4y ago> What I won't get is arrested. You must have missed the summer of love that we had two years ago, when crowds of protesters were regularly beaten and gassed, and often arrested (Charges would, of course, get dropped, because it's not actually illegal to protest.) But you are correct, it's possible to protest the British monarchy as much as you want in the US, with next to consequences. :)
- thrown_22 4y ago
- vkou 4y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/Seattle/comments/gy5knm/latest_escalation_on_cap_hill/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Seattle/comments/gy5knm/latest_esca... The only fire and violence I see in that one is started by the guys in uniform.
- thrown_22 4y agoPretending that a country which regularly arrests people for saying mean things on twitter is somehow more civilized than the US is both brain dead and extremely dangerous. The UK is a medieval hell hole whose sole redeeming feature is that it's contained by the Atlantic ocean. Least we forget a main part of the protest are against a pedophile who probably ordered the murder of Epstein.
- tialaramex 4y agoMaybe what this says is that you're not paying attention, maybe it says you belong to a group who US police are less likely to target for arrest. Or maybe you'd just end up dead in a ditch instead of arrested, which doesn't seem better than getting arrested. Bad taste isn't grounds for arrest in the UK either. In the unlikely event any of these people end up actually in court, they'll be charged with something else, in most cases it seems like public order offences. The same sort of charge you'd get if the cops arrest you drunk outside a bar yelling abuse at people and they decide you won't just sober up and go home with a caution. Here's what the ACLU were able to have released from the White House (in the Bush era) about what the Secret Service do to prepare before a presidential visit: "As a last resort, security should remove the demonstrators from the event site" It doesn't say they get arrested, but of course if you're not free to go about your business, then does it really matter whether you were "arrested" or not ?
- sokoloff 4y agoWhen later answering questions on a security clearance SF-86 application or other background check “have you been arrested in the last seven years?” would be one way in which it could matter.
- ipaddr 4y agoThat is not a question you would be asked. You would be asked if you have ever been convicted of a criminal offense a pardon wasn't granted for.
- waiwai933 4y ago> Section 22 - Police Record > For this section report information regardless of whether the record in your case has been sealed, expunged, or otherwise stricken from the court record, or the charge was dismissed. You need not report convictions under the Federal Controlled Substances Act for which the court issued an expungement order under the authority of 21 U.S.C. 844 or 18 U.S.C. 3607. Be sure to include all incidents whether occurring in the U.S. or abroad. > 22.1 Have any of the following happened? (If 'Yes' you will be asked to provide details for each offense that pertains to the actions that are identified below.) > - In the last seven (7) years have you been issued a summons, citation, or ticket to appear in court in a criminal proceeding against you? (Do not check if all the citations involved traffic infractions where the fine was less than $300 and did not include alcohol or drugs) > - In the last seven (7) years have you been arrested by any police officer, sheriff, marshal or any other type of law enforcement official? > - In the last seven (7) years have you been charged with, convicted of, or sentenced for a crime in any court? (Include all qualifying charges, convictions or sentences in any Federal, state, local, military, or non-U.S. court, even if previously listed on this form). > - In the last seven (7) years have you been or are you currently on probation or parole? > - Are you currently on trial or awaiting a trial on criminal charges?
- googlryas 4y agoYou can do that in the UK too, just not during a funeral procession. The US has laws against protesting at the funerals of Armed Service members. If you really want to rage against something, why not the thing from your own society, instead of the thing from some other society?
- lupire 4y agoThere is a bit of a correlation between people who are ignorant of the world around them, and people who don't see a need for civilized behavior.
- rconti 4y agoCitation? I've never heard this before. I'm aware of the westboro baptist protesting at funerals of gay people or other "sinners" they don't like; they're wholly awful people. I didn't realize it was illegal to protest at a servicemember's funeral, though. Does this come out of the Vietnam war?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- umvi 4y ago> You can do that in the UK too, just not during a funeral procession. Can you though? I seem to remember someone getting arrested for tweeting some joke about a UK war hero because the joke was in poor taste or something. See: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30156923 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30156923 I'm sure tweeting something "grossly offensive" about the late queen would also be grounds for arrest and prosecution.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoBut you can be arrested for crossing the street in the wrong place, and you can be shot by the police for any reason, including because they feel like it.
- tialaramex 4y agoTo be fair the British cops sometimes shoot black people for dubious reasons too. It's taken a bit more seriously here (there will automatically be an investigation if anybody dies after police contact not only the extremes of "a cop shot them" or "he apparently committed suicide while in police custody" but even something like "Police called for a welfare check, decided everything was fine, but an hour later her boyfriend strangled her to death") - but it does happen which isn't great, and it is more notable since the vast majority of British cops don't have guns, so this means they specifically brought in armed police.
- jen20 4y agoTo be clear, this has likely happened fewer times in two decades in the UK than the average month in the US. It does happen, though, as you say.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoI tried to post "fewer times in 20 years here than in one hour in the US", but apparently I was posting too fast, because apparently HN doesn't like people to have conversations.
- klyrs 4y ago> I can go downtown with a sign that says "Not my president", Try that at the next ex-President's funeral.
- cies 4y ago
- Jabbles 4y ago> It's not grounds for arrest, though... in the US Are you sure? It's not absolutely certain. https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1112/funeral-protests https://www.mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/1112/funeral-pr...
- Kukumber 4y agoThat's indeed very worrying, considering their stance on "political arrests": Not too long ago: (Anti-war protesters arrested and beaten in Russia) https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-60641749 https://www.bbc.com/news/av/world-europe-60641749 And i suspect the US will follow the UK in the upcoming midterm election, 2024 is shaping up to be very interesting too Democracy is taking a huge hit in the west
- cies 4y agoWhen a govt allows itself to be professionally lobbied, and those lobbiest are well know by political science profs to have "more say in policy decisions than the voters", do you think such a govt can ever be truly democratic? At what point "democracy: becomes a facade, an empty ritual? (And sadly, more an more a justification to go at war)
- amelius 4y ago> For all its faults, I love the US. I can go downtown with a sign that says "Not my president" You're still stuck with a rigid 2-party system and a rather meager choice when it comes to electing a president.
- encryptluks2 4y ago
- pedrocr 4y agoI wouldn't be so sure. The US has the concept of "Free speech zone" exactly for this situation. Designate a zone away from the event where all the protestors have to go and arrest those that don't. Seems even more draconian than what the UK is doing right now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_speech_zone
- culi 4y agohttps://www.npr.org/2022/09/06/1121322520/a-black-protester-voiced-anger-at-police-in-south-carolina-she-got-4-years-in-pr https://www.npr.org/2022/09/06/1121322520/a-black-protester-...
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago> For all its faults, I love the US. I can go downtown with a sign that says "Not my president", and I may get some cheers, may get some boos. What I won't get is arrested. The situation is not that cut and clear. I had a joke hat that looked like a MAGA hat (red with white text). I never wore it out of the house because at the time I took public transit everywhere and I didn't want to wind up wearing somebody's coffee or be assaulted (sure it probably would have taken awhile but still, not worth the risk). Were that to happen I can just about guarantee the crime would be pursued by the police about as vigorously as a petty theft report. The government probably would have left me alone but how much is that worth when other people will do their dirty work for them?
- lern_too_spel 4y agoWhat fun is a monarchy if you can't have a revolution?
- metacritic12 4y agoIn order to get towards that goal, Charles III should up the ante and use his reserve powers to dissolve parliament. Would make for a good show to see what the reaction would be.
- krona 4y ago> Would make for a good show to see what the reaction would be. Mostly supportive.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat might even turn British communists into royalists. He'd be the English Juan Carlos I.
- dijit 4y agoThey aren’t being arrested for being anti-monarchy though. They are being arrested for being rude about it. Was the fella on radio 4 who stated to the entire nation that ‘King Charles and his family should be put in a council house and that the Monarchy should be abolished’ arrested? No. If you are going to attend a funeral, any funeral, be it the Queen’s or anyone else’s and hurl abuse or hold up signs with obscenities, you will be arrested. There were arrests in which the arrestee has been unarrested, when the police made a mistake. Like the fella who stated that ‘we didn’t vote for him’ when King Charles was pronounced King. You can, quite legally, protest the Monarchy. Being a dick about it and trying to upset people mourning will however be considered a breach of the peace or some other public order offence.
- throwawaymanbot 4y ago
- closewith 4y ago> They aren’t being arrested for being anti-monarchy though. > They are being arrested for being rude about it. Got it. Arrested for poor taste. Hard to see the justification for that in a democracy?
- dijit 4y agoYou will be arrested for hurling obscenities at mourners regardless of who the dead person is. People were arrested at Margaret Thatchers funeral for the same thing. It’s not rocket science. You’re not allowed to do that.
- ISL 4y agoIn the United States, with certain limits [1], one can picket funerals and be massively disrespectful. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westboro_Baptist_Church#Laws_limiting_funeral_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Westboro_Baptist_Church#Laws_l...
- 4y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoWell, I guess this is progress. In the past, anti-royal protestors used to be hung, drawn, and quartered.
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoThat's looking on the bright side! A glass half full type of person i'm guessing. lol
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoIn the past, 50% of King Charleses were executed too.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI think that will improve to 33% so we are making progress on that front as well!
- account42 4y agoSounds more like a regression.
- user764743 4y ago> The new law allows police to act in cases which they deem to be "unjustifiably noisy protests that may have a significant impact on others" or seriously disrupt an organization's activities. Doesn't take a political science degree to see what's wrong with this law. When cops get to decide what is a justifiably loud protest and what isn't you no longer have the right to protest. Protests are meant to disrupt, if you can't be loud about it then it no longer has its intended effect.
- koheripbal 4y agoProtests are not meant to disrupt. They are meant to convince your fellow citizens of your position. Being a disruptive $#@t, not only defeats that purpose, it actually causes more people to vote against you. Moreover, emotionally driven teenagers (or stunted "adults") use these protests as a pubescent venting mechanism to smash business and mistreat adults they encounter, like some narcissistic violent therapy session. It should absolutely be illegal.
- bawolff 4y agoIm totally A-ok with arresting people disrupting a funeral. Like sessh. These are people too. Let them have a funeral, you can protest them afterwards.
- mhh__ 4y agoThis "funeral" is basically shutting down lots of the country for a week.
- alasdair_ 4y agoDisrupting a funeral is one thing. Disrupting a funeral the public is forced to pay millions of pounds for, while other members of said public can't afford food and electricity, is a completely different matter.
- bawolff 4y agoI don't think that it is. The rich and powerful are still real people with real grief. I'm not opposed to people protesting parliment or whatever, but let the mourners mourn in peace.
- kennend3 4y agoI think you missed his point. The public paid for this funeral, and therefor they have every right to participate in it. They should show some respect, it is a funeral after all. If they wanted a "private funeral" they should pay for one.
- karaterobot 4y ago> The public paid for this funeral, and therefor they have every right to participate in it. Since when? This seems like a misunderstanding of how taxes work. Taxes pay for a lot of things which taxpayers have no right, or even access to.
- bawolff 4y agoIs it your view that just because the state pays for something the public has every right to do whatever they want with it? This seems obviously false. Try walking into the petagon some time proclaiming "the public paid for this military base and therefor i have every right to participate in it." And see how far that gets you.
- Janicc 4y agoThis is a country in which people who share memes mocking the trans flag are arrested. At least they're being consistent. Although obviously I'd prefer neither being arrested in the first place.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe official reason that guy got arrested was for "a tweet causing anxiety"
- pyuser583 4y agoPerformance reviews give me anxiety.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoGreat. But that law causes me anxiety. Can we arrest the people who passed it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whateveracct 4y agoThis thread shows that many commenters of HN can understand free speech incorrectly from both ends simultaneously. When it comes to government-sponsored situations, free speech is very broad in the United States. The OP is a good example to point to when people act like the US isn't special for its Constitution.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- datalopers 4y agoI didn't know we had a king. I thought we were an autonomous collective. [1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8bqQ-C1PSE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-8bqQ-C1PSE
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- culi 4y agoAh yes, the United Anarcho-Syndicalist Kingdom
- aaron695 4y ago
- jdoliner 4y agoLèse-majesté is the crime of "offending majesty." It's been an awfully long time since it's been a real law in Europe but I guess anti-royals are pissing the state of enough that they've decided to revive it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A8se-majest%C3%A9 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L%C3%A8se-majest%C3%A9
- bArray 4y ago> "Let her go! It's free speech!" The UK unfortunately doesn't have freedom of speech, it has freedom of expression. > The woman, 22, was arrested "in connection with a breach of the peace," a Police Scotland spokesperson told NPR, adding that she was formally charged and released, and her case is now pending at Edinburgh Sheriff Court. Just to add, you can also be arrested at speakers corner if you upset enough people there and there is "reasonable cause" that they may become violent, despite you speaking peacefully. This NPR article is false and clearly doesn't understand the laws of the UK.
- delecti 4y ago> doesn't have freedom of speech, it has freedom of expression Can you help me understand that distinction? With a pretty limited understanding of UK law, my assumption would be that freedom of speech would cover any words but maybe not the specific way they're presented, while freedom of expression would cover even if those words were expressed in less polite way.
- bArray 4y agoWorth checking this out: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/42/schedule/1/part/I/chapter/9 https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/42/schedule/1/part... Notably: > The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties and responsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others, for preventing the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary.
- delecti 4y agoWow, that's an awful lot of stipulations. It almost makes the preceding "Everyone has the right to freedom of expression" seem laughable.
- pessimizer 4y agoThis is a great time for the British to have a little revolution with very modest aims like this. Both the government and the opposition are indistinguishable warmongering austerians who hate working people, British energy bills are tripling due to elite adventurism, posturing, and US ass-kissing, and the ex-colonies are openly proposing separating from the Commonwealth. What's more, the Queen alternated between a benign pleasantness and a prickly terseness that kept her internal states pretty mysterious and a bit charming, but now they know for a fact that their new King is a useless moron. Getting rid of their magical fairy kingdom trappings (again) might give the population an impetus to flex some popular sovereignty over their own country. Pair it with the abolition/democratization of the Lords, and they'll finish the revolution that Cromwell spoiled.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Pair it with the abolition/democratization of the Lords, and they'll finish the revolution that Cromwell spoiled. Ironically, in the last decade the Lords have a much better track record that the Commons. They applied real scruitiny to the opressive protest bill, the Brexit bill and the bill to deal with unsafe building we discovered in the wake of corporate manslaughter, which was a result of rampant fraud in the construction industry. As a result the lords were threatened with dissolution https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-56905882 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-56905882 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-54882088 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-54882088 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-60032465 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-60032465
- becquerel 4y agoExtremely dire sign that this is what we have to place our trust in!
- H8crilA 4y agoLol. The British monarchy is completely irrelevant. It is useful as a target to release some of that social tension, though, like is the case here.
- noncoml 4y ago“Strange women lying in ponds distributing swords is no basis for a system of government” And no, I don’t mean it as a joke If Britain wants to survive the next 100 years, they need to make some brave decisions. Dissolve monarchy and the class system, get back into EU, and hope Scotland will not declare independence. Also, USA, wtf, why are you flying the flag at half staff? Did you forget what you fought about in 1776? (edit: Actually I looked it up and apparently it has flown at half staff for foreign leaders a few times in the past. My bad, knee jerk reaction.)
- snickerbockers 4y ago>Also, USA, wtf, why are you flying the flag at half staff? Did you forget what you fought about in 1776? yeah, i thought that was weird too. It was ordered by Joe Biden, he might actually have forgotten what our ancestors fought about in 1776.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- afarrell 4y ago> Did you forget what you fought about in 1776? Not having our views represented in parliament whilst having our taxes decreased to bail out the British East India Company.
- somewhereoutth 4y agoThe problem with the monarchy in the UK is not so much them themselves, but that they are the cornerstone of the remnants of the feudal system. We never had a cataclysmic revolution like the French, though the English Civil War was close. We've also been uninvaded for nearly a thousand years (unlike the French). So we have a fair amount of cruft built up.
- WalterBright 4y agoAmerica has free speech. Anyone can insult the President of the United States. Soviet Union has free speech, too. Anyone can insult the President of the United States!
- random_upvoter 4y agoI've been a bit disconcerted at the level of unmitigated adulation that's been showered on the late queen by the media. I have nothing bad to say about Elizabeth II but I too do my job every day -- without a staff of hundreds to prepare my breakfast -- and I don't think I will be sanctified the day I keel over. It's all so serious and deeply conservative you'd think we are back in the 1950. In the 1970s Monty Python were allowed to laugh at anything on national television, I suspect that would not be possible today.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoWhy in the world are you disconcerted? There is nothing surprising about the adulation at all, it's been this way for literally decades. Were all these people who are "shook" and "jarred" in a coma?
- HyperSane 4y ago"Why in the world are you disconcerted?" Because it is gross to worship a useless, elitist parasite like the Queen.
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoI like and admire the Queen, but I also wonder about this. How much of our admiration is the result of the British media giving the Queen essentially 100% positive coverage at all times for 70 years straight? (Unlike politicians, who will be gone in 4 years or so anyway, media outlets are terrified of upsetting the royal family, who are permanent).
- seydor 4y agoit is weird. Even bloomberg seems to have a newfound religious worship of the british monarchy I understand that it is popular among the general public because fairytales and costumes and stuff , but i have to shake my head at how some reporters talk seriously about "peaceful transition of power", when there is no power
- eternalban 4y ago
- some_random 4y agoAwful lot of Brits learning the crucial difference between the right to free speech, and the privilege of being allowed to speak freely.
- nautilius 4y agoAmericans too. https://www.npr.org/2022/09/06/1121322520/a-black-protester-voiced-anger-at-police-in-south-carolina-she-got-4-years-in-pr https://www.npr.org/2022/09/06/1121322520/a-black-protester-...
- jdkee 4y agoFTA: "The jury acquitted Martin of inciting a riot and reached no verdict on whether she threatened officers' lives. Her legal team was "elated" when jurors found her guilty only of breaching the peace, punishable by no more than a $500 fine and 30 days in jail, investigator Tony Kennedy recalled. State law defines breachers of the peace as any disturbers, "dangerous and disorderly persons" or people who utter "menaces or threatening speeches." But prosecutors presented the charge as a "high and aggravated" crime, which carries up to 10 years imprisonment. "
- nautilius 4y agoIn summary: four years in prison for talking to a cop.
- some_random 4y agoAmericans are constantly learning that unfortunately you have to fight for your rights. The First, Second, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth, and Ninth have been eroded to various degrees in direct violation to the Constitution, but that doesn't mean that they aren't still rights.
- nautilius 4y agoNo. It just means that the prevalent drivel in this discussion about how much better it is in the US vs UK concerning ‘what are you allowed to say so the government isn’t mad’ is moot. I’d wager that those arrested in the UK won’t even see a judge but will be released right after, unlike in the ‘free’ US where what you say to a cop will be fully persecuted and lead to actual jail time of several years, for saying words to a government representative.
- Gatsky 4y agoWhen some people were posting “fuck the queen” comments on the original “regina mortua est” HN megathread I thought that was pretty poor form. But I don’t have an issue with protestors. It’s a form of public accountability, which should generally be encouraged. It is quite unpalatable mind you, but then so are monarchies.
- culi 4y agoWhen has a "palatable" protest ever accomplished anything?
- snickerbockers 4y agoHow much power does the British monarch still have? I'm from America so I didn't learn much in school about British history post-1776, but my understanding is that they never had an event like the French Revolution or American Revolution that suddenly ended their monarchy, just a long series of minor reductions in the royal family's power going back to the Magna Carta. From my own (admittedly uneducated on this topic) perspective, British government doesn't make any sense as it looks like a modern republic from a distance but they still have lords, kings, dukes, and other titles of nobility that seem incompatible with that. Does the King still have the ability to order people around and pass his own laws?
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoFunctionally zero. In theory, the monarch has power, but it is never exerted, because they know that if it was exerted a) it would be ignored, and b) they’d immediately be overthrown. They act as a head of state in the same way that e.g: Germany has a President. Noble ranks like Duke and Baron are also completely irrelevant to governance. Lords _are_ relevant, on the other hand. They form the House of Lords, which plays a role as (simplifying) a check on the power of the House of Commons.
- bombcar 4y agoIt is not entirely clear they’d be immediately overthrown - in the right situation it could spark a civil war.
- nly 4y agoWhich isn't necessarily a bad thing?
- cpleppert 4y agoPractically, the UK Monarch (or Japanese emperor) has no discretionary political power at all. Republican Parliamentary systems usually leave some discretionary power to the head of state in either emergencies or for the purpose choosing a party to attempt to form a government. Hereditary Lords (i.e. the noble aristocracy in the UK) have almost no political power. The ninety or so still in the House of Lords are elected by fellow members of the House of Lords. The remainder (600+) of the peers are appointed by the party in power in the commons.
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoNo-one should be surprised by this. For years now in the UK, people have been being arrested, fined and even jailed for offences like this (including under one particularly egregious and vague law against “gross offence”). Up until now, it had been people with, admittedly, rather unpleasant views. Perhaps that is why it had been ignored. But we’re now seeing why ignoring it is dangerous.
- dboreham 4y ago
- jwmoz 4y agoAs a Brit, the monarchy should be abolished.
- y5y5y5jjjj 4y ago
- MattPalmer1086 4y agoI agree, but I wouldn't trust our current government to create the replacement political structures...
- tim333 4y agoAs another Brit you are in the minority with that. Personally I don't mind them really.
- HyperSane 4y agoHow can anyone tolerate being a "subject" instead of a citizen? How can you obsequiously sing "God save the Queen\King" as your national anthem? It is just shameful.
- tim333 4y agoI've never been called a british subject to my knowledge. Googling has "Until 1949, nearly everyone with a close connection to the United Kingdom was called a ‘British subject’".."Since 1983, very few people have qualified as British subjects." The god save the queen stuff is kind of traditional and doesn't mean much. "God save the queen / The fascist regime..." (Sex Pistols) is also kind of traditional and quite popular. No one forces you to sing either but the Pistols did much better in the charts. A lot of non UK folk seem to have some strange ideas about how it works here. The royals haven't had much power for centuries. At least we get a figurehead who is generally popular vs say electing a Trump/Clinton and having half the population hate them until they get ejected for someone the other half hates.
- 4y ago
- simple10 4y agoI was mostly indifferent about the role of the royals until listening to this interview of Jordan Peterson [1]. It's an excellent argument for 4 branches of government. Specifically, where monarchs play a symbolic role within government, diverting celebrity worship out of the executive branch. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5os9bT9zuo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_5os9bT9zuo
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thrown_22 4y ago
- austinjp 4y agoThe UK media (not just the BBC) continue to profess "amazement" at the speed and efficiency of the transitioning from a dead monarch to a living one. There's been much speaking in awed tones at the pace of the various proclamations, committee meetings, document signings, etc, as if this pace tells us why we should be impressed. Personally I've found it borderline sickening. If there was a curtain that could have slipped, we all knew what would be behind it: a bunch of cherry-nosed coffin-dodgers with old-school-tie chums ensconced in the machinery of state, parliament, the military, whatever. Sure. Fine. Yadda yadda, blah blah. The "deep state" dancing hand-in-hand with the old school elites. Yuck. Disgusting but hardly a clear and present danger. But to see this machinery spring rustily, creakily into action has been truly eye-opening. Hitherto unknown people wearing ritualistic outfits have marched into public spaces in several cities, and declared that a member of the elite has been replaced, the continuum is unbroken. And this has been broadcast 24/7 by pretty much all media in the UK and in other countries. Elected representatives from all political parties have fallen into line. It is not okay to ritualistically march a bunch of military-state personnel into multiple public spaces across the country, under the protection of the police and with the consent of multiple international media outlets, and expect public passivity and capitulation. And yet, that's what has happened. And it keeps happening. It's bizarre in the extreme, and we really should not be okay with this.
- brutusborn 4y agoWhat is sickening about a smooth transition of power? The main thing you seem to criticise is the ritual itself, which to me seems pretty normal, albeit grandiose.
- MereInterest 4y agoThere's absolutely nothing sickening about smooth transitions of power between elected officials.
- rgavuliak 4y agoA considerable part of the US seems to disagree
- ncmncm 4y agoThere are reasons Brits are "subjects", not "citizens". And why America declared No Truce with Kings. And why US presidents are not allowed to bow to kings. (Well, weren't until W did.)
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoSource? I thought it was Obama who bowed to kings.
- ncmncm 4y agohttps://www.heraldnet.com/opinion/bush-also-bowed-to-saudi-king/ https://www.heraldnet.com/opinion/bush-also-bowed-to-saudi-k... People made a lot more fuss about Obama because, you know, "Barack Hussein Obama", etc. Trump was seen doing it too.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoIf so, then you singling out W seems... a bit slanted. But if those three did, then did earlier presidents, and they just weren't documented? Or weren't made a big deal of when they did?
- ncmncm 4y agoW did it first. So, no, citing W doing it first is not "slanted". Instead, claiming that Obama and Trump also violating their public trust makes my observation "slanted" is actively dishonest: I said that W did it first, and W did it first. Period.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agohttps://theculturetrip.com/asia/japan/articles/to-bow-or-not-to-bow-in-japan/ https://theculturetrip.com/asia/japan/articles/to-bow-or-not... HW, not W. And maybe others before; HW is just the first I found a reference to. (Also Clinton.) So it seems to have happened a lot more than I thought...
- geenew 4y agoThe monarchy has only fared well if it changes with the times, which it has, gradually giving more power to parliament over the centuries. We have gone from a system of divine right to a harmless institution that provides an apolitical centre. In a practical sense, the institution today is unrecognizable from the institution 1,000 years ago. And there is no reason to think it will not continue to change, gradually, as social change requires.[1] For better or worse, the monarch is the legitimate sovereign. There is a chain going back almost 1,000 years.[2] Are we, now living, the ones who get to break that? If we are, then we should have a good reason to do so. A future change where the monarchy effectively ceases to exist is entirely plausible. But any change like that should only happen by agreement. And there is no pressing need for it that I can see. [1] Take, for example, the Crown Estate. Lands that the sovereign controlled but which were effectively given to the state. A huge transfer of economic power, done bloodlessly and within the laws of the nation. [2] Yes, there was a civil war. But there was also a restoration.
- doctor_eval 4y ago> For better or worse, the monarch is the legitimate sovereign. Legitimacy is not a currency; it derives directly from consent. If the “we, now living” no longer consent to a monarch, then the monarch has no legitimacy.
- HyperSane 4y ago" If we are, then we should have a good reason to do so." Its mere existence is sufficient reason to end it. The very concept of Kings and Queens is anathema to democracy.
- nly 4y agoI mean I think it's clear Harry and Meghan saw the writing on the wall a number of years years ago and decided to go and establish a backup income, separate from Royal ties, in California. Signing lucrative Netflix contracts, selling "Sussex" branded trinkets, going on Oprah, and bringing out autobiographies (no doubt containing scandal) has no doubt already made them a 7 figure sum.
- rhacker 4y agoThis is what fake news is made of: Something that 0.0001% of the population is doing (protesting) The ONLY story that makes it on the various news sites (it's eye catching) Everyone gets a skewed reality that no one likes this new King and has been against the monarchy this entire time. We had another study a few days ago about how one way to convince people to change their mind is to convince them that everyone else already has. The media is controlling people more than anyone realizes.
- esharte 4y agoThe issue is the "Mourning period" is being used as cover to crown a new monarch with no opposition. People are being told "not now", and how disrespectful they are. This is by design. Meanwhile it's somehow not disrespectful to replace the Queen within hours.
- soared 4y agoHow would a monarch have opposition?
- lamby 4y agoI think that's OP's point.
- netsharc 4y agoYour "meanwhile..." doesn't make sense, why is it disrespectful, technically it's the kingdom's/the monarchy's rules, and this family is the monarchy. And the replacement happened not within hours, but Charles became king at the instant Elizabeth died, that's why the sentence is "The Queen is dead, long live the King!".
- ohiovr 4y agoI'm from Ohio and surprised of this news. I didn't like Charles but I was not expecting this. If the monarchy system was removed, would there be anything to replace it that had a veto power?
- grumblepeet 4y agoJust wanted to remind people that the funeral of the Queen isn’t until next Monday. These people are getting arrested for shouting at royal proclamations and ceremonies of remembrance. The Police here seem to have a zero tolerance to any form of protest, and that is indeed concerning. For those who object to public sycophancy and pomp whilst ordinary people here have to use food banks to survive (me included this last month) I’d advise waiting until after the funeral to say something. Despite all the public displays of wealth and royal theatre the UK is in deep trouble and is very unstable. When that has happened in the past the authorities here overreact out of fear.
- tim333 4y agoLiving in central London we have several protests per week pretty much all of which are tolerated by the police unless they go violent or piss off the general public too much. This recent stuff kind of goes in the pissing off the public category.
- nailer 4y agoThis is fake news. The kid that yelled at the funeral procession was arrested for yelling at a procession for the public to mourn the queen.
- tarunmuvvala 4y agoIts 21st century, I feel that the UK citizens need to rethink on the concept of Monarchy. There are lot successful republic nations. The goal is prepare UK for the future not for the past
- SunghoYahng 4y agoI have heard that the king or queen of a constitutional monarchy is a symbol. Why not just use Queen Elizabeth as a doll?
- lavezzi 4y agoBit bored of some of these articles where peoples' opinions are based on anonymous twitter accounts that could be owned by anyone in the world.