9 ms·
The relationship between plant-based diet and risk of digestive system cancers
- causi 4y agoTL;DR: Avoiding meat causes a reduction in the risk of digestive cancers between 12% and 30%
- cies 4y agoIs that per type of digestive cancer? They were testing 5 different ones.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoAnd apparently, the risk of getting just colon cancer in your lifetime is ~4%: https://www.cancer.org/cancer/colon-rectal-cancer/about/key-statistics.html#:~:text=Lifetime%20risk%20of%20colorectal%20cancer,25%20(4.0%25)%20for%20women https://www.cancer.org/cancer/colon-rectal-cancer/about/key-.... So a potential ~30% reduction in 5 different types is not exactly non-trivial.
- biomcgary 4y agoMore accurate TL;DR: Reporting on an annual diet survey that you avoid meat is associated with a reduction in the risk of digestive cancers between 12% and 30%.
- zwieback 4y agoDo you get most of the benefit by eating meat say once or twice a week?
- electric_mayhem 4y agoYou get the most benefit by reading the abstract instead of asking questions after just reading the misleading title.
- metamet 4y agoI'm curious about how much of that is due to the charring that comes from grilling meat, or simply cooking meat to well-done, generating heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). It'd be really hard to do a controlled study on such a thing, though.
- hoosieree 4y agoYeah, as a vegetarian who enjoys grilling, I'm curious about this too.
- brnt 4y agoI mean what else can you do that's palatable? Boiling is obviously not an option.
- rngname22 4y agobaking, air frying (aka convection oven baking), steaming, sauteeing, sous vide.
- lapetitejort 4y ago> sous vide That's the ticket. A properly cooked sous vide carrot tastes completely different from any other cooking method. All of the nutrients and flavor stays in the carrot. Add in herbs and spices and it will completely transform how you experience vegetables.
- kingnothing 4y agoOf course you then have to be concerned about your food sitting in warm water in a plastic bag leaching chemicals. Silicone is an option but most people don't do it.
- uoaei 4y agoGonna echo steaming. The trick is to stop shortly before it's at optimal doneness. Doneness can frequently be assessed by the bright, rich color of the veggies: too raw and they're dull and tough, too cooked and they're gray and mushy.
- oh-4-fucks-sake 4y agoReally curious to see what (if any) increase in digestive cancers a low-mercury-pescatarian diet would confer over a pure plant-based one.
- candiddevmike 4y agoLow mercury won't save you from all the other pollutants most fish are exposed to these days: https://scripps.ucsd.edu/news/study-finds-toxic-pollutants-fish-across-worlds-oceans https://scripps.ucsd.edu/news/study-finds-toxic-pollutants-f... Enjoy your low mercury Catfish with a hint of flame retardant and industrial coolant.
- q7xvh97o2pDhNrh 4y agoMan, that is a depressing link. (Thanks for posting it, though.) I still can't resist the occasional sushi outing, but I've mostly stepped away from eating fish otherwise, largely because of pollution concerns like these. I do wonder if there's room for some notion of "ultra-clean sushi." What if a restaurant went fully vertically integrated, farming its own fish in its own aquariums? Then fish could be pulled out and sliced up as needed, and you'd know they were pollutant-free.
- brnt 4y agoSo, yeah, farmed fish are the only ones making it on the list for pregnant woman and young children. So those are what I limit myself to too. No wild catches.
- the_af 4y agoI thought farmed fish (especially farmed salmon) were among the worst possible kinds of fish to consume, both environment-wise and health-wise?
- brnt 4y agoNope, precisely because they can be controlled for heavy metal intake and the like. Surprised me too. Make sure to buy from a traceable certified farm. There ate still farms that feed their fish trash and waste, they are no longer allowed to be imported where I live. Source: https://www.mcsuk.org/goodfishguide/ https://www.mcsuk.org/goodfishguide/
- aunty_helen 4y agoI would be happier eating meat than living longer, caring about its carbon footprint or any ethical issues people have with farming. I don’t mind daily exercise, drinking a green tea now and then and not over indulging on the booze, but I’m not going to be a vegetarian for any of the reasons I’ve come across so far.
- ajdegol 4y agoI am curious, I’ve seen several people recently quite proud they cause environmental harm. I can understand ignorance, I can get you believe something contrary; I just can’t fathom why you’re pleased that you’re actively causing harm for the planet we all live on.
- ohCh6zos 4y agoEating meat is part of the good and moral life, and while we need to take care of the planet we need to preserve the good.
- AlexandrB 4y agoCan you elaborate on why eating meat specifically is good and moral?
- ohCh6zos 4y agoI should start this by saying I don't support forcing anyone to do anything they don't want to, and for environmental reasons I very rarely eat meat. That being said I believe everyone aught to eat at least a little meat because we are omnivores and it is advantageous for us to be able to, we don't know what the future holds and in evolution if you don't use it you lose it.
- rtev 4y ago(citation needed)
- black_light_man 4y ago
- smm11 4y agoMy personal experience is that plant-based diets cause aging at a far greater rate than diets including meat.
- cies 4y ago> My personal experience That's why high N studies, or (like this study) meta studies are so important. What is aging anyway? Those who follow a plant-based diet live certainly longer...
- samatman 4y agoThose who follow a plant-based diet until they die live longer. The confounding factors there are enormous.
- blue_light_man 4y ago
- rowinofwin 4y agoThis is a meta analysis. Meta analyses are done by collecting other studies and trying to pull the results out of each to apply to the main question of the study. The problem is of you have bad studies to start with you end up with a bad meta analysis, or garbage in, garbage out Nutrition studies are very frequently awful. The use of questionaires to find out what someone eats is inherently flawed (do you remember how many times you ate brocoli this year?) and leads to biased results. People who care about their health will tend towards vegetarian and vegan diets because they are claimed to be healthy, but they will also be more likely to exercise, not smoke, be wary of alcohol, and so on, reducing the likelihood of cancer through those other mechanisms. Unless you actually randomly assign a diet for a long period of time and control for all of those factors your study is worthless, completely swamped in noise and misattribution. Let's also bot forget that people who are richer and more educated are more likely to be lower in stress and have more resources while also being more likely to go to a plant based diet. Now take a bung of studies that are too short to see the effect, rely on bad data collection, stratify people by diet while also happening to get richer and more health conscious people in one group, and then bring them all together in one big study. You will find an effect. Is the effect because of the plant based diet or is it because that group is richer, less stressed, drinks and smokes less, works a better job, has a better education, and visits their doctor more frequently? I would expect and effect from the latter half, but the former in not shown by this or any other study thus far.
- NyxWulf 4y agoIn the introduction to the study they include this statement, which I think agrees with your comment: "This study systematically searched two databases and included six cohort studies included with limited types of digestive system cancers. Therefore, the evidence is not sufficiently strong to evaluate the relationship between digestive system cancers and plant-based diets. Comprehensive evaluations are scarce, especially for various digestive system cancers and multiple dietary patterns."
- hombre_fatal 4y ago> do you remember how many times you ate brocoli this year? People always use this extreme example to slam nutritional surveys but the data can be strong. You know what you ate today, every day. Are you guessing or did these studies actually ask people to recall how much broccoli they ate over the last year?
- blue_light_man 4y ago> Diets containing red or processed meat are associated with a growing risk of digestive system cancer. Does meat in this context also includes fish and chicken? Or is it meat only from cows, buffalo, pig etc?
- dacox 4y agoThese studies are conducted using nutrition surveys typically given out every year (or five) asking the subject about their eating habits over the last period. They are notoriously bad data, and also do not account for the healthy user bias (or the inverse effect). Of course that doesn't seem to stop researchers from using them to tease out extremely small effect sizes
- boltzmann-brain 4y agowell said.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoYou haven’t asserted how it’s bad data. Perhaps it’s also inconvenient data?
- brokenkebab2 4y ago"...asking the subject about their eating habits over the last period"
- hombre_fatal 4y agoWell, that sounded like a blanket dismissal of food logging rather than a specific criticism. Which study asked people to recall what they ate a year ago?
- drekk 4y agoWe know separately from this study that red meat is carcinogenic. https://www.cancer.gov/news-events/cancer-currents-blog/2021/red-meat-colorectal-cancer-genetic-signature#:~:text=Evidence%20Mounts&text=In%202015%2C%20based%20on%20data,probable%20carcinogen%20(Group%202A) https://www.cancer.gov/news-events/cancer-currents-blog/2021....
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoOh so more contradictory nutrition and food wankery. There has been a concerted effort to push this narrative for a while, even before all the "studies". Why don't they ever bother to look into the specifics of what is eaten, not just amounts. Or control for the fact that people eating vegan and veg only, in many cases are much younger health obsessed types to begin with. Who exercise etc. Not to mention looking at the full affects on overall health. Nobody seems able to explain why an omnivore species would suddenly have a problem with meat. In the end though, these types of studies always seem to miss or ignore the wider points as well as the full reality of things. We shouldn't be pushing people to endanger their health in order to potentially negligibly lower some rare cancer risks.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoThis comment reads 100% that you’re just reacting to something that you don’t want to be true with sweeping dismissals rather than replying to the specifics of the research. Almost seems like your response to research is to invoke personal superstitions about what must be true.
- rtev 4y agoUnfortunately, that seems to be the norm for people with diet. For some reason, personal food choice and health ideology seems to fall into the same category as religion and politics.
- seizethecheese 4y agoCare to address the methods section? Are you sure they didn’t control for age and physical activity? Why would this only affect cancers if the digestive system?
- drekk 4y agoOmnivore species? You sure about that one? We're opportunists. Don't believe me? Go ahead, rip into some meat raw with your "canines" and let me know how that one goes. Our ancestors ate bone marrow because it was the only thing other scavengers didn't know about. We transcend our biology all the time, but I wouldn't point to our modern and obscene meat consumption as a historical constant. Most peasants didn't get the luxury.
- t0bia_s 4y agoI'm curious what Mikhaila Peterson's response to this study would be.
- sk1pper 4y agoWe can make a pretty good guess. I found this link on her website: https://justmeat.co/docs/health-dangers-of-a-plant-based-diet.pdf https://justmeat.co/docs/health-dangers-of-a-plant-based-die... A cursory review of her website doesn't reveal any references or links to actual scientific studies of any kind. Well, except for this one, which seems to be about Homo Erectus species in the Levant region being dependent on eating elephants for a source of fat about 400,000 years ago: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0028689 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... However, I found lots of affiliate links to various products. edit: oops, here's a link to her site for reference https://liondiet.com/ https://liondiet.com/
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ameixaseca 4y agoFrom the study: > The vegetarian diets (12) include vegan (eats only plant-based foods but no red meat, poultry, fish, dairy or eggs), pesco-lacto-ovo-vegetarian (eats fish, dairy and eggs without red meat or poultry), lacto-ovo-vegetarian (eats dairy and eggs without red meat, poultry or fish), pesco-vegetarian (eats fish, but no red meat, poultry, dairy or eggs), ovo-vegetarian (eats eggs but no red meat, poultry, fish or dairy), lacto-vegetarian(eats dairy, but no red meat, poultry, fish or eggs) and semi vegetarian (eats dairy, eggs and some red meat, poultry and fish ≥1 time/month but only 1 time/week). So plant-based diet also includes "eats eggs, dairy, some read meat, poultry, fish". What's the conclusion? > The correlation between vegan and other plant-based diets was compared using Z-tests, and the results showed no difference. IOW: being a vegan or being an omnivore that eats some red meat has no difference in risk.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoPlants and grains are routinely sprayed with glyphosate, which has been linked to cancers.