11 ms·
"Might be used for illegal purposes" is a significant understatement. The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering, which is in and of itself a c
by woodruffw 4y ago
"Might be used for illegal purposes" is a significant understatement. The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering, which is in and of itself a crime in both the US and Netherlands.
Normally, there'd be an aspect of plausible deniability: torrent index operators can, for example, rightfully claim that they're facilitating legal filesharing, or that they're entirely agnostic to the content being shared (if all they're doing is sharing URLs). What's key in this case is that law enforcement claims that Pertsev was aware of the crimes his service was being used for. Whether or not that's actually true is up to a court to decide.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoThe chief selling point of Tornado Cash is that it's distributed open-source software, with no man in the middle, no single point of failure. That's right: Government sanctioned open-source SOFTWARE. Are you sure you want this precedent set?
- woodruffw 4y agoI have no problem with Tornado Cash being openly available software under a permissive license. I have a problem with people running a Tornado Cash-based service that is really just a money laundering service. You should take a step back: "open source" does not rinse away the underlying properties of a service. I can't write and deploy a web application that contracts hitmen and use the MIT license as a defense; the latter simply isn't being litigated.
- theplumber 4y agoWhat's the difference between money launderying features and privacy features? Tornado Cash in itself does is not launderying money because you still have to prove to the IRS how you got the money or the asset(i.e bills, invoice etc) and you still have to obey KYC rules. You can't just say the money is from Tornado Cash and be done with it. Is the U.S Mint a money launderying service because it provides an untraceable method (cash) to conduct transactions?
- woodruffw 4y agoThe features don't matter. What matters is intent and demonstrating that intent. Both the Treasury and Dutch authorities have reason to believe that Tornado Cash was operated with the intent of facilitating money laundering. It's up to a court to determine the veracity of that accusation.
- npc54321 4y agoGuilty until proven innocent (they are blacklisted/sanctioned) I see.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoFWIW, the money sanctioned under OFAC is still that of the owner so there is a process in place that has a semblance of the rules of law. However, getting that money released by the bank is nothing short of a herculean effort based on cases I have seen over the years.
- woodruffw 4y agoNot only am I not a court of law, but I specifically said that it's up to a court to make a decision of legal guilt here. In the mean time, yes: the government is allowed to halt activities that it believes are part of an active criminal scheme. Every country with a functioning legal system proscribes this, and establishes a broad swath of controls to ensure that the government can't indefinitely tie up resources.
- mattficke 4y agoTo your last question, this is why financial institutions are required to report cash transactions over $10,000. There are a number of constraints on how untraceable cash is.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoHas this amount ever been adjusted for inflation? It is my understanding, that $10,000 at the time this law was set, was about ¼ the price of a small home.
- sam0x17 4y agoMoney crimes should be prosecuted and solved at their start points and endpoints, not within the financial system. Failure to adhere to this standard is why we no longer really control the money in our bank accounts anymore. Want to send a wire to your friend living in the middle east with a sketchy name? Might get flagged. Want to purchase something out of the ordinary for you online? Your debit card will probably block it at least at first. Law enforcement has become lazy and we have as well. Instead of solving actual crimes, we just use ML algorithms to find sketchy-looking transactions and then block them and investigate later maybe. This has significantly reduced our privacy and freedom at a much higher cost than the purported gains. This is the whole motivation behind the original push into crypto in the early 00s. We need something not beholding to any government that is as good as cash but digital, and the US gov sanctioning a mixer is just proof of this dire need.
- sofixa 4y ago> Money crimes should be prosecuted and solved at their start points and endpoints, not within the financial system. Failure to adhere to this standard is why we no longer really control the money in our bank accounts anymore That's easier said than done. It's drastically easier to catch crime by it's results (money) than in the act. Famously that's how Capone was caught. And what would be the advantage of that, to anyone? I doubt that erroneously flagged transactions are a real problem. Do you have any numbers on the matter?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoAnd this is where it gets fun. Banks will absolutely not tell the customer that their transaction is flagged for one reason or another partly so that they do not lose their 'safe harbor' status under BSA. Any numbers you will see might be from the government, but FinCEN is relatively tight lipped about those for a variety of reasons. The discussion is taking place now, because it has become fairly onerous on an average person, who sends anything to MOHAMMED HASSAN. Instead of data, I can only offer anecdata. Long long time ( or not long ago depending on your perception of time ), we had a person, whose transaction matched some OFAC info, which resulted in bank holding the transaction. I cannot go into details beyond saying that eventually even OFAC representative seemed to admit to that it does not seem to apply to him. To the best of my knowledge, a year after that person still did not get his funds. It may have not happened to you, but I do not think it is as uncommon as you think. Parent is right. We are doing this backwards.
- whatisweb3 4y agoYou actually could publish “illegal code” because code is protected under 1st amendment, as free speech. Legal precedent has been set by Bernstein v US DoJ. There is an open question about whether publishing non custodial contract code on Ethereum counts as providing a service. If you post 10 lines of immutable code onto Ethereum, and some years later a user chooses to run this code on their machines for criminal behavior, should you be prosecuted?
- everfree 4y ago> I have a problem with people running a Tornado Cash-based service that is really just a money laundering service. The treasury ban is on the contract itself, not TC-based services that people might run.
- duped 4y ago> The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is that it's distributed open-source software, with no man in the middle, no single point of failure for laundering money. You can't remove the key feature from metaproperties of the software and call the latter the "chief selling point."
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoSo say you, and yet my claim is self-evident, while yours needs hordes of robe&badge clad bureaucrats, and the promise of violence, to enforce.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> yet my claim is self-evident, while yours needs hordes of robe&badge clad bureaucrats You’re describing due process. That’s a feature. An AK-47 being metallic may be self evident. That doesn’t make it relevant to a murder investigation.
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoAn AK-47 is not relevent to a murder investigation. There are thousands of them in the U.S. and owned by innocents. It would be unreasonable to come after all AK-47 owners because one was used in a crime. Rather, it would be up to the cops to find other facts about the weapon, perhaps how much more metallic it looked than your standard AK, and in which spots. Wear marks can be just as revealing as serial numbers.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> would be unreasonable to come after all AK-47 owners because one was used in a crime Every mixer isn’t sanctioned. Just the one used to launder money by Pyongyang. None of this is novel.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoPGP set that precedent decades ago. They just need to publish the source as a book.
- adastra22 4y agoThe chief purpose of a mixer is financial privacy. It’s just that on a public blockchain privacy from snoops and privacy from law enforcement can’t be differentiated.
- woodruffw 4y agoIf the Treasury or Dutch authorities are to be believed, the chief purpose of this mixer was to facilitate money laundering. That is key to this entire discussion: they have reason to believe that Pertsev knowingly ran a money laundering service, rather than running a service that criminals can abuse to launder money.
- dannyw 4y agoThat's interesting. As a Tornado Cash user, I have never associated this with an intentional money laundering service, but rather a bunch of developers advancing zk-SNARKs and other cryptographic primitives. As someone who was excited by the original Bitcoin whitepaper back in 2011, zk-SNARKS was what excited me about cryptocurrency again in 2021.
- woodruffw 4y agoYour association isn't what regulators are concerned with. They're concerned with the intent of the creator and operator of the service, which is why he's the one who's been arrested.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoAnd you're buying into propaganda suggesting someone pushing the envelope in cryptography is creating tooling specifically for money laundering. 30 years ago, the NSA toed a similar line in their war on PGP, saying it was used in practice for "money laundering, child pornography, and terrorism" - https://reason.com/video/2020/10/21/cryptowars-gilmore-zimmermann-cryptography/ https://reason.com/video/2020/10/21/cryptowars-gilmore-zimme...
- jnovek 4y agoGP isn’t wrong, though. Even if the primary value of Tornado Cash is dubious, I’m still uncomfortable with the contemporary attitude of “block first, ask questions later (maybe)”.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> the contemporary attitude of “block first, ask questions later (maybe)” The sanctions followed Tornado being fingered as the laundering service used by Norrh Korea [1][2]. [1] https://hub.elliptic.co/analysis/the-100-million-horizon-hack-following-the-trail-through-tornado-cash-to-north-korea/ https://hub.elliptic.co/analysis/the-100-million-horizon-hac... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/30/north-korea-likely-behind-100-million-horizon-crypto-hack-experts.html#:~:text=North%20Korean%20state-sponsored%20hackers,U.S.%20crypto%20start-up%20Horizon https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/30/north-korea-likely-behind-10....
- chrischattin 4y agoDPRK uses SSL and PGP. Should we sanction those code bases as well?
- ok123456 4y agoThey tried that in the past with export restrictions.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> Normally, there'd be an aspect of plausible deniability If it was publicly known that you had exactly 1 ton of legally acquired gold in your house, would you feel perfectly safe sleeping at night? Is there not 1 sicko out there that would be willing to torture your family to find the combination to your vault? Plausible deniability exists here. It's called wanting privacy, and there's perfectly valid and non-criminal reasons to want privacy, despite repeated false claims. Here is the problem. Many cryptos are not actually anonymous. If somebody has somebody's wallet address, they can look into tracing information about them like their net worth and their purchasing history. Even if you were smart enough to use a different wallet address for each transaction, you inevitably have to spend money to live or send money to others and then you can be traced. As tools grow more sophisticated and more data about wallet address ownership gets out there, the more at risk people will be. And once your identity gets out there, there's no shaking the ability to track it short of some form of mixing or obfuscation. In an of itself, mixing or trading to obfuscate your identity shouldn't be considered a crime or unreasonable in the slightest.
- vkou 4y agoIf I had 45 million dollars in my house, I'd look into whatever the hell individuals of that net worth are doing to protect themselves. Which, as I understand it, mostly consists of not keeping it as a gold brick in their basement, and not living in a shitty neighbourhood. It's harder to rubber hose attack someone who isn't keeping all their wealth in a crypto wallet.
- eropple 4y ago> In an of itself, mixing or trading to obfuscate your identity shouldn't be considered a crime or unreasonable in the slightest. "Financial privacy" isn't a real thing, because you owe taxes on income and investments. Can you explain to me how your tax assessor is able, then, to properly identify your income and tax you on it as appropriate? (Money laundering and tax evasion do not always go hand-in-hand. Many launderers pay taxes as a cost of doing business. Cryptocurrency mixers seem to treat tax evasion as a feature.)
- 4y ago
- Karunamon 4y agoNote that "money-laundering" is only a thing you have committed if you are dealing in funds that are the proceeds of another crime. If you are not committing another crime, you are more than welcome to conceal the source and destination of your financial transactions. The chief selling point of Tornado Cash was addressing the significant privacy problems inherent in a currency based on a public ledger. The idea that we should destroy privacy tools because criminals use them is ridiculous.
- intrasight 4y agoSuch tools are fine as long as they adhere to KYC regulations.
- Karunamon 4y agoKYC regulations apply to corporations and businesses, not code.
- intrasight 4y agoThey apply to what the president can apply them to. So if he's able to apply them to code, then they do apply.
- Karunamon 4y agoI think the First Amendment might have something to say on the matter of "the president" unilaterally prohibiting people from interacting with code, something that has already been determined to be protected by the right.
- intrasight 4y agoI doubt the court will second-guess the administration on this.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering, which is in and of itself a crime in both the US and Netherland Also, law enforcement publicly announced Tornado was used to launder billions by North Korea [1]. Months ago [2]. Everyone continued as if nothing happened. This wasn’t based on hypotheticals. [1] https://hub.elliptic.co/analysis/the-100-million-horizon-hack-following-the-trail-through-tornado-cash-to-north-korea/ https://hub.elliptic.co/analysis/the-100-million-horizon-hac... [2] https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/30/north-korea-likely-behind-100-million-horizon-crypto-hack-experts.html#:~:text=North%20Korean%20state-sponsored%20hackers,U.S.%20crypto%20start-up%20Horizon https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/30/north-korea-likely-behind-10....
- josh2600 4y agoJust going to point out that Tornado cash did invoke chainalysis oracles for all of their interface tools. The problem is that on ethereum it's not possible to censor a deployed contract. There is a possibility that miners could collude not to authenticate blocks with tornado cash transactions in them, but that gets into some interesting game theory in a globally distributed system. Not every miner is subject to US law. It's a very fascinating story. https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2022/04/15/tornado-cash-adds-chainalysis-tool-for-blocking-ofac-sanctioned-wallets-from-dapp/ https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2022/04/15/tornado-cash-adds-c...
- hef19898 4y agoSanctions against North Korea are not just US law, in fact they apply in basically every jurisdiction that actually worth operating in.
- qeternity 4y agoThe onus is for technology to comply with laws, not the other way around.
- dontknowwhyihn 4y agoTell that to Uber.
- hef19898 4y agoEverytime a major bank is caught doing something like that, UBS and Deutsche Bank come to mind, there is huge outcry about the lack of consequences. If a crypto exchange get's caught doing it, and there are consequences, there is huge outcry (among certain people) because there are consequences. Added severity, in the case of tornado cash, was helping North Korea. So not just money laundering but also circumventing sanctions that are taken very seriously by every political power that actually matters. Heck, even the Chinese at least try make it look like they adhere to the North Korea sanctions.
- ChrisLomont 4y agoDeutsch Bank has been hit with $600M for laundering, $7.2B over mortgage assets, $2.5B for interest rate manipulation, among a lot of other fines. These are some pretty astounding sums.
- phatfish 4y agoIt's plain old double standards, Tornado Cash is the "peoples" money laundering service, anyone can use it, so it could be of benefit to them at some point. Global banks that could facilitate the same thing would only consider doing it for the super-rich to hedge against the possibility of getting caught and fined. So are not open to the average person, hence people have no problem calling for them to be held to account. Both should get the same treatment. That goes doubly for the global banks that have historically caused far greater problems than TC.
- everfree 4y agoBanks are organizations made out of people who can be held responsible. Tornado Cash is a piece of software that is not run by any person. Banks can be fined and people can be imprisoned, but you can't fine or imprison software. The Treasury ban is a direct ban on software, which is a departure from precedent. That's what makes this legal case unique, and why it's not simply a double standard.
- Bombthecat 4y agoSooo buying and using monero is automatically money laundering?
- zionic 4y ago>The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering Privacy =/= laundering. Tornado is/should be perfectly legal to use to pay IRL vendors without revealing the entire contents of your hot/cold wallets. It’s also useful to move money between hot/cold wallets safely.
- Fnoord 4y agoIt can be proven they're not agnostic by doing the bad data test (malware, supposed (not real) child porn). If it gets removed, that's a sign of moderation. And all big, previously known torrent or DHT hosters remove such. Combine it with the fact an %x is illegal content (e.g. copyright infringement) which does not get removed and you have a case.
- downandout 4y ago"The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering, which is in and of itself a crime in both the US and Netherlands." You have a fundamental misunderstanding of US law with regard to money laundering. Obfuscating the source of funds, by itself, is not money laundering. Money laundering requires a "predicate offense" - the money that is being laundered must be proven to have had an illicit source. Further, the entity accused of doing the "laundering" also must know that the source of funds is illicit before doing it. Intent to promote the carrying on of "specified unlawful activity" must also be proven in order for a money laundering conviction to occur. You can read the entire statute here [1]. Therefore, the "chief selling point" cannot be money laundering, at least under US law, because the contracts were deployed with no prior knowledge of how or by whom they would be used. One cannot form intent without prior knowledge. The chief selling point was anonymity, not money laundering, which has a highly specific legal meaning. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1956 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1956
- 300bps 4y agoMoney laundering requires a "predicate offense" Structuring is one of the most common methods of facilitating money laundering. No predicate offense required. It’s illegal all on its own. https://bsaaml.ffiec.gov/manual/Appendices/08 https://bsaaml.ffiec.gov/manual/Appendices/08
- downandout 4y agoYes, but the same intent provisions still apply to the entity that enabled the structuring. Tornado Cash has legitimate use cases - I had one prior to the OFAC issue (hiding the source of funds to an address in order to prevent certain bots from reacting to it). So the devs cannot have formed intent to aid in any of the crimes that TC may have unwittingly enabled. Casinos are used as vehicles for structuring and money laundering every minute of every day - on a much larger scale than anything Tornado Cash could ever have achieved. They don't have the intent to aid in these activities though, which is why they are allowed to operate.
- 4y ago
- unboxingelf 4y agoThe chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering Firmly disagree. The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is a mixer. Please see my reply to essentially this same misconception a month ago, which includes concrete, legal use cases: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32443738 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32443738
- ok123456 4y ago> The chief selling point of Tornado Cash is money laundering The same thing could be said about paper money.
- woodruffw 4y agoNo, it can't. The chief selling point of fiat is being an efficient medium of exchange. This is a very nice property to have!
- ok123456 4y agoYes it can. The vast majority of crime is done with paper money. This is also why cops willy-nilly decide to seize it if you have too much of it. There are countless examples of normal people who happened to have large sums of paper money, on their way to buy a vehicle, being stopped and their life savings being taken away through civil asset forfeiture.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]