9 ms·
Why do we focus so much on TDP or max boost? How often and for how long are you running your CPU at max? I'd like to have the performance there when I need it b
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y ago
Why do we focus so much on TDP or max boost? How often and for how long are you running your CPU at max? I'd like to have the performance there when I need it but for most of the day I am sitting near idle.
- dagw 4y agoHow often and for how long are you running your CPU at max? On my workstation? 8-16 hours at a stretch is common, several times a week.
- vlovich123 4y agoWhat are you doing that’s pegging your CPU at 100% for 8-16 hours? Or do you just turn off throttling?
- 867-5309 4y agotorrenting linux isos
- fomine3 4y agoIt must be IO bound.
- exhilaration 4y agoOne word, bro: Docker!
- elheffe80 4y agoWhat happens in the bedroom stays in the bedroom, and we don't kink shame here. :P I would imagine some machine learning/development or video editing. Or playing dwarf fortress.
- capableweb 4y agoIf someone is doing ML or video editing and the software is not using the GPU for most parts of the workflow, I'd like to invite that person to 2022. Now Dwarf Fortress, that's another beast with no cure...
- KronisLV 4y ago> If someone is doing ML or video editing and the software is not using the GPU for most parts of the workflow, I'd like to invite that person to 2022. That sounds like a pretty strong statement, so I decided to try it out on some hardware from the last 5 years (an AMD GPU with VCE 3.0 and a 6/12 core/thread AMD CPU), in particular, encoding the same video: 1080p, 30fps with similar quality settings. Here are the results for various encoders (using ffmpeg, through Handbrake and/or Kdenlive): How File Size Time CPU h264 105 MB 03:15 GPU h264_amd_vce 198 MB 03:22 CPU h265 99 MB 07:44 GPU h265_amd_vce 361 MB 04:36 CPU mpeg4 102 MB 02:07 CPU mpeg2 72 MB 02:04 CPU vp8 55 MB 06:13 (low CPU usage, <50%) Seems like the quality settings don't actually mean much across different encoders, so these results aren't that conclusive in regards to comparing the codecs against one another, however one can surmise out that GPU isn't an order of magnitude ahead of CPU in regards to video encoding, at least on mid tier consumer grade hardware. That probably changes on more specialized or recent hardware (something newer than VCE 3.0), or things like the aforementioned ML.
- pohuing 4y agoAMDs Hardware encoders are also notoriously bad. Maybe the situation is better on some nvidia cards.
- smoldesu 4y agoA proper hardware encoder will absolutely smoke CPU decoding. Switching from OpenGL software rendering to NVENC/VAAPI reduced power consumption considerably for me. Nvidia and Apple's hardware-based decoders are both top-notch, with Intel's also being fairly decent. Like the other commenter said, I've heard mixed things about the AMD decoders (not to insinuate that their GPUs/iGPUs are bad, though). As for machine learning, most metrics right now suggest that conventional GPGPU calculations scale with power consumption. If you want high-performance ML without specialized hardware, your only choice is high-wattage hardware.
- tjpnz 4y agoElectron apps.
- P5fRxh5kUvp2th 4y agook, I know you're being snarky, but that legitimately made me laugh.
- pjmlp 4y agoA possible answer would be running Android Studio, another one, piles of Electron apps.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoMicrosoft Teams.
- nuclearsugar 4y agoMaya or Blender batch rendering
- noobermin 4y agoYes, this will only be useful for servers, workstations, and performance nodes. I heavy doubt this will be useful for generic home computing any time soon.
- devwastaken 4y agoCPU temps will spike, computer turns into revving jet engine. Opening a program is all it takes. Shouldn't have to have the biggest noctua cooler on the market to keep a CPU below 90C. They're meant to be quiet.
- pc86 4y agoKind of hard to say they're "meant to be quiet" if opening a program is all it takes to make them... not quiet.
- rowanG077 4y agoDaily for a couple of hours at least. TDP max is basically the only interesting metric. Because this is what you have to design your power delivery and cooling for. Average TDP is only interesting for your energy bill.
- pizza234 4y agoTDP is correlated with consumption, so a higher TDP is indicative of how much the CPU will burn in general.
- formerly_proven 4y agoCompletely false, idle and low load power consumption has little to do with TDP. Case in point: Ryzen
- pizza234 4y agoPost your exact numbers. I've done wall-power measurements with different Ryzen models.
- lm28469 4y agobig numbers good. we need big numbers. big numbers better than small numbers. big numbers please monkey brain. monkey brain happy = more sales = more money = bigger number in bank. bigger number in bank good
- bhedgeoser 4y agoSeriously, reading semiconductor news these days feels like watching dragon ball z. I won't even be surprised if someone announced a cpu that runs at over 9000MHz.
- babypuncher 4y agoI collect and rip Blu-Rays. Whenever I buy something big (like a complete TV series box set), it usually means my 5900x will be churning away in Handbrake non stop for a few days straight. It makes my basement a bit toasty.
- peheje 4y agoWant to be friends?
- DaiPlusPlus 4y agoBut given that space is cheap and transcoding means you're necessarily compromising image quality, why bother re-encoding?
- babypuncher 4y agoBecause I have a lot of shows and space isn't that cheap, especially on mobile devices. Video compression has improved a ton since the introduction of Blu-Ray in 2006. I can cut the average size of a 45 minute TV show from ~8-10GB on the disc to ~2GB with minimal or no perceptible quality loss. This makes a huge difference when I go to load up my iPad with movies and TV shows before I travel. I do not bother re-encoding anything on a 4K disc, I just rip them straight to my NAS and strip out foreign audio and subtitle tracks.
- paulmd 4y agoHEVC can produce extraordinary quality for the size (especially on cartoons/anime) but man it is a fucking CRUNCH to get it there. It makes even x264 look easy by comparison. And AV1 is a whole 'nother level past that... minutes per frame basically. But great size/quality. Just as a casual observation, you should look at hardware AV1 encoders once they come out, because they'll beat software HEVC with a hardware (read: fast) encoder. Of course you also have to have support in the devices to play it back... which can be a problem with HEVC as well.
- 4y ago
- bpodgursky 4y agoHN is full of Intel bears / AMD bulls so they're going to latch onto whatever they can complain about.
- mhh__ 4y agoAlmost no one is capable of the nuance to actually compare these on real workloads without buying one.