6 ms·
Sham investigations silence professors at Central Florida and Princeton
- jwuphysics 4y agoI hadn't heard of this organization but their headline certainly didn't pass the sniff test. From their Wikipedia page: > In 2017, FIRE was listed as one of the sponsors of the conservative campus group Turning Point USA's Student Action Summit, according to tax records.
- epicureanideal 4y agoFrom what I’ve read, seen, and experienced first hand, they seem like a reputable organization to me.
- bpodgursky 4y agoLife must be easy for you, when you give yourself such easy ways to avoid contemplating views you disagree with.
- vba616 4y agoThis is like a comedy routine. Free thinker #1: Check out Wikipedia on FIRE (but I hope you don't, so I won't provide the link) Free thinker #2: Don't be closed minded and read Wikipedia! (I too won't provide the link) So I will do it, said the little red hen. (Are you using reverse psychology on me?) I had to poke through a fair amount of "disambiguation" to find it, as FIRE is such a common name/acronym. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundation_for_Individual_Rights_and_Expression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foundation_for_Individual_Righ... What seems to me relevant context is that originally it was founded by Harvard faculty, one of whom was an ACLU board member in Massachusetts, but may have drifted/evolved as funding is allegedly coming more and more from right wing and (faux?) libertarian sources. Also, like practically everyone, it seems to be engaging in mission creep, expanding from E=education to E=expression. But in fairness, college and college campuses have become such litmus tests of which side you are on in the culture wars, that that is probably driving them to widen their focus if they have any desire to preserve a non-partisan image. I recommend reading the "Cases" section. One of the most recent things they have allegedly done is: `FIRE announced a lawsuit challenging Florida’s "Stop Woke Act"' I'm not convinced they are pure and non-partisan and uncorrupted, but after skimming the list of controversies they have been involved in, they don't seem too transparently partisan. They seem to have defended an organization threatened with a defamation lawsuit for criticizing electro-shock therapy.
- someguydave 4y agoSo they once dealt with someone you dislike?
- jameshart 4y agoFor an organization purporting to support academic freedom, that they have funded or worked with Turning Point USA, an organization which literally runs a ‘watch list’ of academics whose political views they disagree with, seems relevant to assessing their true goals, yes.
- allears 4y agoRead the link a bit above this one about how the ACLU is praising this group. Free speech can be problematic in this age of disinformation and media manipulation, but it's also under attack from the left. FIRE seems non-partisan and sincere.
- Test0129 4y agoWould you apply this same logic to a group like Occupy Democrats? It seems like a very poor litmus test to immediately be dismissive of someone's view because of an association with (what seems to be) a political party you don't like.
- nerdponx 4y agoYes, especially when it comes to a "mainstream" Democratic Party organization like Occupy. I mistrust "conservatism" a bit more than whatever the mainstream Democratic Party is, but only a bit. Both generally seem to be disingenuous and concerned more with the appearance of having principles than with actually having principles.
- rayiner 4y agoSo political parties purport to have principles? That’s a very weird way to look at them. Fundamentally, political parties are groups of people that have just enough in common to work together. There’s general themes, but it doesn’t make sense to ascribe to them principles.
- selimthegrim 4y agoPrinciples have to live in a constitution now?
- nerdponx 4y ago1) Conservatism isn't a political party as such, 2) conservatives in particular seem to be very big on emphasizing their strong principles and adherence thereto... as long as it doesn't inconvenience them or expose them to icky things like new ideas or social progress.
- Test0129 4y agoCould you not argue the same thing about progressives? They are very big on the emphasis of so-called "social progress" even when they don't do it themselves. Most famously I could argue that this entire push for climate change by the progressives has done nearly nothing to stop the actual producers of it (the 1%) and instead puts yet another burden on the everyman. These limousine liberals are the party-equivalent of the very people you are saying exist exclusively in the conservative parties. Both dogmas have their place. The problem we have isn't that the two exist, it's that there's now a gap between them you can measure in AUs. Some ideas are better expressed by conservatism. That is, keeping the status quo. Some ideas are best expressed with progressivism. Right now the two parties are being turned in tribes by the media (twitter especially in this example) which benefits absolutely no one but the people who actually hold the power. As for democrats and republicans, it's my opinion they play on the same team. Your reply strikes me as sitting further on the edges of the horseshoe than you might realize.
- phantom_of_cato 4y agoThen read it the way you'd read a blog post by random person posted to HN. We live in an age in which social trust is declining, so we should probably be skeptical of even the more "reputable" sources.
- songeater 4y agoI dont know the organization but fwiw they also seem to be supporting this: https://www.thefire.org/fire-urges-twitter-carnegie-mellon-not-to-censor-professor-who-wished-queen-elizabeth-excruciating-death/ https://www.thefire.org/fire-urges-twitter-carnegie-mellon-n...
- illuminerdy 4y agoFraming it as "support" is extremely disingenuous. You can defend someone's right to say something offensive without actually being in support or agreement with said statement.
- koshergweilo 4y agoIs that true? Didn't the ACLU defend the speech of Neo Nazis?
- illuminerdy 4y agoI'm not sure I understand your question. Is what true? I don't think the ACLU actually supported the Nazis in Skokie or their message. But sometimes people miss the forest for the trees with that case. In oder to defend your own rights, you have to defend everyone else's rights too. First they came... But the ACLU has changed quite a bit since those days it seems. It's my understanding that they no longer take the "sunlight is the best disinfectant" approach to free speech and the free and open exchange of ideas.
- bawolff 4y agoWould be nice if we could judge this individually on its merits (or lack thereof), instead of automatically disbelieving (or for that matter automatically believing) based on what we think of the org.
- Vaslo 4y agoThe next article that I saw on that site defended a cmu professor who said negative things about the Queen on the day of her death. This professor is as far left as you get.
- Test0129 4y ago> On Twitter, offended students and others called for Negy’s termination with the hashtag #UCFFireHim. The next day, a UCF press release called his tweets “not only wrong, but particularly painful,” announced an investigation into Negy, and directed students with complaints to a website and phone number. Regardless of whether you agree with this person's opinions or not I think it's safe to say Twitter has become an actual cancer on the world. Especially in America. I've heard plenty of times at work people unironically say "I don't want to get canceled on Twitter" for saying something relatively mundane that in context was fine, but if written in a small tweet would start a feeding frenzy. It is absolutely silly to me that we've let a bunch of upset over-educated under-worked twitter goons have so much external power. Some people deserve to be "canceled". It's not twitter users job's to form a mob and prevent people from ever being employed again. I have no idea why or where this started but it probably has to stop for political discourse in America to turn into anything less than immediately incendiary. Reddit has the same problem. I rarely say anything super inflammatory on the internet but this mob mentality has prevented me from contributing to various projects on github, joining discords, etc for fear one of these eternal-victims gets their feelings hurt and decides to dedicate a large portion of their life to destroying mine.
- prepend 4y agoInterestingly, it seems like people joining a mob would be a signal of poor judgement and all around jerkiness. I wouldn’t want to fire someone who tweeted “#ucffirehim” but it would be good to know who was in such a mob.
- Test0129 4y agoI've had a pet theory that a lot of these "action committees" (for lack of a better word) in tech companies are supported by the company because of that. You may want to know who in your company tends to be incendiary and keep them away from the clients. I have no real evidence of this but from a intelligence standpoint I think a company would have a lot to gain from that at almost zero cost.
- nerdponx 4y agoIs the problem Twitter, or the people that use Twitter? What honestly do you think Twitter's hand in this is? Even with a purely chronological feed, people with "selective" critical thinking skills, inconsistent value systems, and a disrespect of personal liberty will still surround themselves with other such people. Twitter's only option would be to take a "paradox of intolerance" approach and start banning such activity, but then you are trusting a corporation to make such judgments fairly, rather than just expediently. And if Twitter disappeared tomorrow, what then? Old-school student protests, picketing, signs/posters/pamphlets, letters in the school newspaper, and "cancel-prof-foo.net" getting thousands of views per day. Ultimately the problem is that people are too willing to join the dogpile and/or are unwilling to stand in solidarity against the dogpile. Twitter doesn't cancel people; people cancel people. Edit: I also want to be very clear that Professor Katz, who accused a radical student group of being a "terrorist organization" was absolutely in the wrong for doing so and in my opinion does deserve to be censured for that statement. And making public statements about "black privilege" is even worse, which frankly leads me to question Professor Negy's moral compass and fitness to be an educator. I fully agree with the assessment that they used their rights to free speech irresponsibly, at best. But I also think it's completely wrong to dig up an old incident for which they had already been judged and punished. I'm sure that the members of the Black Justice League are strongly opposed to policies that take away the rights of convicted felons, and I'm sure that they all have the critical thinking skills to recognize the parallel here, and I'm also sure that none of them would be interested in admitting such. In my opinion the only correct move by the University here is to dole out wrist slaps on both sides and tell all parties involved to drop it or face further consequences.
- RappingBoomer 4y agothis nation has changed dramatically in the last few decades...the elites have clamped down on the little people in so many ways...so many laws and regulations now...i was reading a comic book from the 1950s the other day, and the premise was that a female college student was having an affair with her professor...and there were other plot elements...but the amazing thing was that the other characters did not think the relationship was unusual at all...nowadays, in a movie or in the media, such a relationship would be portrayed as scandalous... the hit movie american graffiti from the 1970s showed a high school teacher having an affair with one of his students...but it was just a casual aside in the movie plot...no one made a big deal about it... this nation is entering some sort of neopuritanical hell hole...and it aint gonna be pretty...
- paulcole 4y ago> this nation has changed dramatically in the last few decades...the elites have clamped down on the little people in so many ways Wait until you learn about slavery. > but the amazing thing was that the other characters did not think the relationship was unusual at all...nowadays, in a movie or in the media, such a relationship would be portrayed as scandalous... Wow, it’s almost like standards for what’s acceptable evolve.
- rasz 4y ago> female college student was having an affair with her professor...and there were other plot elements...but the amazing thing was that the other characters did not think the relationship was unusual at all Thats because females in 1950 USA had very little rights. It was barely 30 years into letting them vote, but only as long as they stay in the kitchen homemaking 'where they belong'. >would be portrayed as scandalous exploitative is the word, balance of power is pretty clear here. >this nation is entering some sort of neopuritanical hell hole because you cant willy nilly fuck people you have authority over? indeed end of the world.
- jollybean 4y ago??? An adult female and an adult male having a consensual relations is related to 'rights' in what way exactly? Because I don't think that has anything to do with the situation. Exploitative by whom? Students don't have to f** profs, it's never been that way. Your posture is actually sexist, implying that somehow adult females cannot make their own choices.
- unethical_ban 4y ago[May 2022]
- jollybean 4y agoWe need to do far far more than re-instate the profs - the school adminstrators need to be investigated, and damages need to be paid so as to keep them from these shenanigans. Finally, they need to change the administrative situation so that these things never happen again.
- azeemh 4y ago