16 ms·
John C. Mather: “There is no first moment of time” (2017)
- sixQuarks 4y agoInteresting stuff, can someone recommend a good book that deals more into this subject? Preferably a book that’s entertaining to read rather than engrossed in mathematics
- jeandenis 4y agoThe Order of Time by Carlo Rovelli is accessible to all (no math)
- mindcrime 4y agoYou might enjoy Time Reborn[1] by Lee Smolin or About Time[2] by Paul Davies. Note that the latter book is fairly old now (from 1996 or so) and I'm not sure how well it holds up now. [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Time-Reborn-Lee-Smolin/dp/0544245598 https://www.amazon.com/Time-Reborn-Lee-Smolin/dp/0544245598 [2]: https://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revolution/dp/0684818221 https://www.amazon.com/About-Time-Einsteins-Unfinished-Revol...
- belter 4y agoJohn C. Mather is the senior project scientist for the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_C._Mather https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_C._Mather
- zibby8 4y ago> There’s another way in which the giant firecracker idea misleads us, because even scientists often talk about the “universe springing into existence.” Well, it didn’t, as far as we can tell. The opposite is true. There is no first moment of time, just as there is no smallest positive number. In physics we have equations and laws of nature that describe how one situation changes into another, but we have no equations that show how true nothingness turns into somethingness. So, since the universe did not spring into existence, it has always existed, though perhaps not in its current form. Or the equations are only approximations that hold under certain conditions?
- philosophyfirst 4y agoYeah this is kind of a laughable position in the article. I don’t mean the conclusion, which might be right, but the method. The laws of physics as we know them are just reflections of … nothing more than what we know. The fact that we have no account of what came before the big bang is not evidence of anything except that we don’t know, especially when a very plausible theory is that what came before is totally different in kind than what came after. Being a good scientist doesn’t mean you’re a good philosopher.
- lupire 4y agoThe point is that the theory works -- matches observed reality -- even without a "0 point", analogous to the positive Reals or Rationals.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hsn915 4y agoThis is neither here nor there. Suppose you have a "working theory" about how birds fly, but no theory about other things might hypothetically fly. Does that afford you to claim "Nothing other than birds can fly"?
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y ago
- qaq 4y agoDid the Big Bang happen? --Sabine Hossenfelder https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAVUvq6BE1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CAVUvq6BE1E
- frivas 4y agoIt should be called "everything, everywhere, all at once"
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoI sometimes feel that’s the reality I’m in now.
- rosywoozlechan 4y ago> even though there’s no first moment of time, we can still measure the age. This seems to be a contradiction? The time that's passed since some kind of transformation, but not the age? What is the age of something that has no beginning?
- lupire 4y agoOpen Interval / Zeno's Paradox / White Holes / time passing more slowly closer to Big Bang.
- pdonis 4y agoYou can still take limits as the Big Bang is approached, even if the limiting case of the Big Bang itself can never be reached. Just as you can take limits of things as some positive parameter approaches zero even if the parameter never actually takes the value zero.
- patcon 4y agoI felt similarly. Thinking through the article's comparison between first moment in time and "smallest possible positive number", maybe it's sensible... > even though there’s no first moment of time, we can still measure the age. > even though there’s no first [positive number after zero], we can still measure the [range between zero and one]. That second variation doesn't seem so contradictory, so maybe the original isn't :)
- joombaga 4y agoThe second variation does not seem equivalent to me. If there's no "first moment of time", you should be measuring the [range between negative infinity and one]. Using a fixed point like "zero" is the same as assuming there _is_ a first moment of time.
- aasasd 4y agoI'm a perpetual noob at this topic, so might be completely wrong, but: what I vaguely got from Hawking's books is that both black holes and the before-bang universe have matter in some kind of quark soup, in which our conceptions of space and time just don't exist. Since our spacetime depends on the non-soup layout of matter, the spacetime can be said to exist only with the universe after the bang (and until the crunch, if it comes). That's the age of the universe that we can reason about. Curiously, Hawking still relates the hypotheses that (very roughly) calculate some kind of time that it would take for the soup to form into the proper universe—via Hilbert's spaces of configurations. I.e. these theories somehow count possible arrangements of matter in the soup, in the absence of space, and its movements from one arrangement to another, in the absence of time. That confuses me to this day.
- AlbertCory 4y agoNot very satisfying, but I suppose that's because no one really knows enough to make it satisfying.
- xwdv 4y agoNot only might there not be a first moment, there might be no time at all. Every possible instant of time could be randomly distributed with some very small but not infinitely small probability of occurring. On an infinite timeline, everything should occur, forever. When a moment occurs, a structure of your brain exists coded with memories of past events that feel real but never happened. Since each moment is pure and has no external state, you do not perceive the trillions of years that could pass in between two moments occurring, nor do you have any way to realize you are perceiving moments out of order or that other possibilities of realities exist.
- fallingfrog 4y ago“On an infinite timeline, everything should occur, forever.” I can imagine scenarios where that isn’t true- maybe the universe cycles through a long loop of states and just repeats that infinitely for example.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoIsn’t that saying the same thing but a little differently? In your scenario, everything is re-occurring, forever (obviously beyond our perception)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> you do not perceive the trillions of years that could pass in between two moments occurring, nor do you have any way to realize you are perceiving moments out of order or that other possibilities of realities exist This is intriguing. But how does cause and effect work? If there is no “external state”, say I burn my hand by spilling hot coffee on it. There’s a burn in my skin. Trillions of years pass and I experience the next moment… with burned skin?
- xwdv 4y ago
- gorgoiler 4y ago”The observable universe was once compressed into a volume the size of a golf ball, but that golf ball was only a tiny piece of a universe that was infinite even then.” What a helpful way of thinking about it. I’m surprised I’ve never heard this before. Mind expanding, no pun intended.
- aasasd 4y agoRather the opposite for me, I'm now even more confused about what was where. Not that I quite get the picture of an infinite universe anyway, which I guess is the prerequisite here.
- danwills 4y agoAgreed, so helpful! There's logical traps one can easily fall into (I frequently realise I'm making this mistake when trying to think of the concept of the universe) where my mind seems to want to be able to 'enclose' the universe as if it were an object so it can be referred to, like a golf ball. But I understand the concept to mean everything, all objects/information, no exceptions, and then the idea of anything outside that becomes problematic, but the golf ball is only the light that has reached us so far, and maybe the universe is really spatially infinite outside that too? How could we find out? Fascinating! great read!
- aasasd 4y ago> there is no sign of an edge of the universe How is this determined? I would think that the observable universe puts a limit on our view anyway. Is it the redshift receding into infinite wavelengths? Can the instruments even detect this?
- sounds 4y agoI'm going to skip the more philosophical part of your question. Or in other words, if you're asking, "is there any observable evidence of something outside the observable universe?" My answer is: no comment at this time. If you're asking, "what did John C. Mather mean in talking about the edge of the universe?" I'm not John C. Mather, but here's my guess -- The curvature of the universe [1] has been computed from distortion of the Cosmic Micrwave Background and independently using other measurements. The current consensus is that the universe is indistinguishable from a flat universe. [2] A curved universe would have an edge, meaning there's a limit to how much could be observed. If it's x light-years until you wrap around the universe, then plant an observer into this universe at a time greater than x years and that observer (if lucky) could observe the same things in two directions by seeing "all the way around the universe." A curved universe might lead to a "big crunch" since the curvature of space-time is caused by the quantity of matter, or not. Depends on if the matter is tightly packed enough. A flat universe has no limit -- no matter how far in the future you plant an observer, the speed of light is not fast enough for them to observe the entire observable universe. There's a relationship between the curvature of the universe, how dense the universe is (how densely packed the matter is), and how fast the universe is expanding (the Hubble Constant). It's likely the universe is flat, implying that the Hubble Constant is on the high end of possible values. [1] http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/beginners/curvature.html http://background.uchicago.edu/~whu/beginners/curvature.html [2] https://astrobites.org/2020/12/03/cosmic-clocks/ https://astrobites.org/2020/12/03/cosmic-clocks/
- aasasd 4y agoThanks! > no matter how far in the future you plant an observer, the speed of light is not fast enough for them to observe the entire observable universe I'm guessing it's just ‘universe’ here, instead of ‘observable universe’—since afaiu the definition is that light inside the observable universe is able to reach us? So, if I understand the whole comment right, a curved universe is guaranteed to have an edge, but with a non-curved one it's a toss-up because no one knows what it would look like. Then, when the article says: > It’s often said that the whole universe we can now observe was once compressed into a volume the size of a golf ball, but we should imagine that the golf ball is only a tiny piece of a universe that was infinite even then. Does the author essentially mean that the smaller universe still had only a part of it observable? Or am I mixing things up here? In fact, if the universe expanded faster in the early days, I would guess it was less observable than now (even disregarding all the matter getting in the way).
- fortran77 4y agoI still like to believe there was, no matter what they say.
- tremon 4y agoWhat's the reasoning behind that? Because I feel the other way: for me, it's much harder to accept the idea that the Big Bang that spawned our universe was a singular event, because that would mean that there is only one inevitable end: heat death. And even though it's unlikely the human race will still be there by that time, I don't like the prospect of such a pale and bleak ending. If, on the other hand, you assume that there was some form of time/matter before the Big Bang, there is no reason to assume that there can be (or has been) only one big bang event. And that means there might be a multitude of "universes" outside of our visible field that we can never know about. Still, it's oddly comforting to me to believe that when our universe dies from heat death, others might go still on or start a new cycle.
- mensetmanusman 4y ago“Big Bang that spawned our universe was a singular event, because that would mean that there is only one inevitable end: heat death.” It doesn’t necessarily imply heat death, especially with inflation and non zero space time energy being generated somehow.
- fallingfrog 4y agoThe way I understand it, time is defined in terms of entropy- the points in the space of configurations of the universe adjacent to ours are all possible, but the ones that are most likely are all possible future points and the ones that are least likely are points in the past. Entropy is always increasing, on the macro scale. (The past, like the future, is uncertain and there could be many past states leading to this point.) But, in the early early universe, all the configurations are equally likely, or rather there are no points any more unlikely, so there is no past, every direction is the future. That’s not very precise but basically as I understand it that’s why there is no earliest moment.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoYes but it wouldn’t matter because for us it’s strictly equivalent to experiencing time linearly. That’s the epistemological limit of science. Physics don’t concern itself with truth, only empirical evidence and models. That’s also why for all his brillance John C. Matter is very wrong here. "[…] we have no equations that show how true nothingness turns into somethingness. So, since the universe did not spring into existence, it has always existed, though perhaps not in its current form." is a conclusion which doesn’t follow from its premise. We just have no idea and no way to test anything.
- russellbeattie 4y agoThere is no time, only movement. No movement == no time. You can't measure time without movement. If everything in the universe stopped moving, no time would pass. The first moment happened when space was created and something in it changed its position. (Of course, that something is matter, which is just a wave, and a wave by definition is movement... So really, time started when reality started wobbling.)
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> So really, time started when reality started wobbling “It’s all wiggles” —- Alan Watts
- russellbeattie 4y agoI never heard of him before! He was definitely into wiggles. And psychedelics apparently. > "But the real world is wiggly, wiggly, wiggly. Now when you have a wiggly system like a cloud, how much wiggle is a wiggle? Well, you have to draw the line somewhere. And so people come to sorts of agreements about, uh, how much of a wiggle is a wiggle; that is to say a thing. One wiggle, you can always reduce any one wiggle into sub-wiggles. Or see it as a subordinate wiggle in a bigger wiggle. But there’s no real fixed rule about it.” He and Schrödinger would have had a blast together.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoMany of his lectures are on YouTube (audio only). I hope you enjoy him. He’s a great entertainer/speaker.
- nyc111 4y agoDoes anyone know how the validity of a linear extrapolation is determined? I mean is there a standard way of measuring an extrapolation, like sigma? The only way I can think of is to take the ratio of the sample with the population. For instance, if sample = 24 and population = 200 billion, their ratio is 0.00000012. How do we know if this is a valid linear extrapolation? In this case, sample is the number of galaxies Hubble observed in 1929 for his famous paper and the population is the number of known galaxies. Is there a rigorous way to evaluate an extrapolation in statistics?
- blooalien 4y ago"If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_a_tree_falls_in_a_forest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_a_tree_falls_in_a_forest This feels kinda like that… Certainly "time" passes, but if nobody is measuring it (or even conceiving of it as "a thing") at what point is it relevant in any way?
- wruza 4y agoCertainly I certainly have vague ideas about how it works, but it feels like some physicists feel that time is emergent too. Even if not true, consider this thesis: There is no time at all, not before BB, not after. We only “see” our time because it is a consequence of non-euclidity of what we call spacetime, which is otherwise a timeless structure in which one could recognize “entropy” vectors. Then our emergent time could not exist before BB. And when you apply “exist” or any other temporal tense to that structure as a whole, it’s just a semantic error.