11 ms·
It's also very expensive engineering. That's how a coal plant works, and the last coal plant that the US built cost $2B for a 600MW plant. Given how much che
by bryanlarsen 4y ago
It's also very expensive engineering. That's how a coal plant works, and the last coal plant that the US built cost $2B for a 600MW plant. Given how much cheaper solar & wind are, fusion will be dead in the water if it doesn't come up with a cheaper way of extracting energy from the reaction.
- nemo44x 4y agoSolar and wind are not serious solutions to the energy needs of the planet today or in the future. As billions more people become part of a global middle class our energy requirements will expand dramatically from today.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> As billions more people become part of a global middle class our energy requirements will expand dramatically from today. https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/35097.pdf https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy04osti/35097.pdf "In the United States, cities and residences cover about 140 million acres of land. We could supply every kilowatt-hour of our nation’s current electricity requirements simply by applying PV to 7% of this area—on roofs, on parking lots, along highway walls, on the sides of buildings, and in other dual-use scenarios." "We would need only 10 million acres of land—or only 0.4% of the area of the United States—to supply all of our nation’s electricity using PV."
- robertlagrant 4y agoI really wish this sort of thing would either be better thought through or better articulated. 10 million acres is enormous. And is it continuous supply (if so, how?) Or just supply when it's sunny?
- ncmncm 4y agoIsn't it amazing that no one has ever thought about these things before you dropped in?
- robertlagrant 4y agoYou've missed my point.
- ncmncm 4y agoEverybody has known all along that renewables generation is intermittent. Mentioning it adds no light. And renewables happily coexist with other uses of the same land, so none is used up.
- robertlagrant 4y ago> Everybody has known all along that renewables generation is intermittent That doesn't mean it's made clear in statistics. I've read plenty of people say "X generates as much as Y", where X is intermittent and Y is suitable for base load. Certainly enough to disagree that everyone knows it and is able to discern that from context-free statistics.
- ncmncm 4y agoLiterally every single person on Earth who even knows what renewables are knows they are intermittent. No one imagines solar panels produce peak power all the time, or any power at night.
- robertlagrant 4y agoYou've missed my point again. Every time someone says "renewables supply 80% of power required" or similar, without stating the context of what that means, it creates false impressions in people's minds. Is it 80% on the sunniest day ever? 80% of actual load but using storage? 80% of the load 5% of the time? I'm not saying if people think it through they won't understand it, I'm saying that context-free stats like that create false impressions in some people's minds based on whatever the assume about the stat, and annoy people like me who'd like to know where the stat came from.
- didericis 4y ago0.4% of the entire country is a massive amount of land. That’s 10 million acres of wires, maintenance, habitat and all kinds of mischievous creatures, not least of which are humans. And it only works when the weather is good. And not all countries have the grid or engineering and maintenance capacity of the United States. It’s not a realistic solution. By all means, lets put solar panels everywhere we already have buildings and roofs and power hookups and make a dent. Maybe at some point it’ll be possible to use solar alone, and we can keep up the maintenance. Going all in on solar right now would be suicide. It’d be worse than the effects of anthropogenic warming. People are going to freeze to death this winter in Germany because they bought into the promise of renewables before it delivered and didn’t diversify their energy supply. You should only phase something out when you can meet demands without it. Nuclear is a way to do that. Natural gas is a way to do that. Renewables are a way to do that. But you have to actually exceed demand and have a solid diversified base before you panic switch because of climate change. Otherwise you kill and impoverish more people than climate change.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe argument from incredulity has rather a poor history. Are you sure you want to join in with all its previous failures?
- pfdietz 4y agoI'm waiting for him to realize that agriculture will use two orders of magnitude more land than is needed to power the US with renewables. Will he conclude that eating is impossible?
- didericis 4y agoOne of the things I like about this site is the restraint (at least in comparison to other places) in substituting an argument this kind of snarky scoffing and engagement. It’s brainless. Agriculture is already working, or was until its been starting to be shut down and curtailed due to alleged environmental issues like in the Netherlands. You can manage much larger chunks of land with plows and combines and other vehicles because of how you interact with the land when farming. You can’t plant solar panels and have them just grow out of the ground and repair themselves and reproduce largely independently. It’s a totally different type of land use. Managing solar farms is magnitudes more effort to build and maintain than agriculture.
- nprz 4y agoIsn't the intermittency of the energy source the issue? And there's currently no scalable solution to efficiently store excess energy generated from solar panels?
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure, that's why no one proposes only solar, nor do they propose solar in only one place at a time.
- ncmncm 4y agoIntermittency means you need storage too. So, you build out storage too. The observation is vacuous. A renewable grid includes storage. Storage is cheap and getting cheaper.
- pfdietz 4y agoIt's rather amazing that you think that people haven't already thought of this issue and addressed it. In fact, it's long been addressed, and the cost of dealing with intermittency of renewable sources appears acceptable. https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9837910 > Even former critics must admit that adding e-fuels through PtX makes 100% RE possible at costs similar to fossil fuels. These critics are still questioning whether 100% RE is the cheapest solution but no longer claim it would be unfeasible or prohibitively expensive.
- switchbak 4y agoI think the truth is in the middle. Solar is becoming ridiculously cheap, but even if the panels were free there's still a lot of other costs to factor in. As explained elsewhere, a mix of energy sources is necessary. And your statement is devoid of context. Solar is already working well in North America (and elsewhere), and uptake will continue to increase. It won't be a panacea for the rest of the world, and solar+wind won't replace all other generation types.
- nemo44x 4y agoYes by all means deploy it but by no means is it a strategic solution.
- switchbak 4y agoIt's an important component of a strategic solution. Where it makes sense, aka: not in the artic circle. Not sure why you're dismissing it so out of hand. I agree it's not the panacea that many want it to be, but it's still very important, especially given its recent cost declines (solar specifically here).
- flavius29663 4y agosolar and wind can be free, if the sun does not shine and wind is not blowing 100% of the time...
- ncmncm 4y agoThis trivial observation, always trotted out, is always meant just to distract. Trolling, really.
- flavius29663 4y agoIt's not trolling, look at what Germany and California are struggling with... Also Texas, another state where they pushed green energy (wind) and slowed the investment in fossil fuels. We all want cleaner energy, but we must acknowledge that it is not easy.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoOn the contrary, California is struggling with with electricity generation during times of high A/C loads due to a heat wave. Those times correspond with high solar power generation, without solar they'd be doing a lot worse. On the contrary, Germany has met their goal of 80% full natgas storage several weeks early despite the French nuclear reactors being offline due to higher than expected renewable energy supplies.
- flavius29663 4y agoYou're saying that Germany and California are not struggling with the electric grid...now I believe you're trolling They invested a lot in solar power, which is expensive, so they couldn't afford to invest enough in transmission and backup generators, and now they have expensive electricity and unreliable grids. Ignoring current year, I think Germany is second in the world in regards to expensive electricity (after Denmark) and California is one of the most expensive states in the US.
- 4y ago
- sdenton4 4y agoIt's easy enough to solve... point an energy-collecting device at the giant pre-built fusion reactor in the sky.
- gridspy 4y agoYes, but most of the time that fusion reactor is behind a giant hunk of iron covered in various other matter. Even when in the sky, the sky itself is an effective insulator that only allows 1/4 of the energy through. That's why we are considering placing a converter above the sky to more efficiently pierce the sky with energy.
- markdown 4y agoTowing the converter outside the environment is something I can get behind.
- u320 4y agoYou cannot build a grid out of solar and wind alone.
- zardo 4y agoYou also need transformers and batteries and power lines.
- ncmncm 4y agoMost storage won't be batteries.
- salty_biscuits 4y agoThen don't do it. Grids are expensive. Microgrids and storage seem like a winning plan.
- u320 4y agoMicrogrids and storage cost way more than any method of generating power we are currently using. Please stop using buzzwords and look at the actual numbers.
- ben_w 4y agoAt grid scale, batteries were about the same cost as a functionally equivalent fission reactor last time I looked (a few years ago). Despite which, batteries are one of the more expensive ways to store energy at scale.
- u320 4y agoI don't know where you looked then because batteries are not anywhere near low cost enough to be deployed at grid scale at the amounts required to run a grid of wind and solar. Even in a sunny climate with reliable solar output, if you assume that there is a 10% chance that in any year you will have a 10 day period of cloud cover and 50% lower solar output and your entire grid cost goes up by 5x! The math for storage is BRUTAL.
- tomatotomato37 4y agoSpeaking of solar it would be nice if we could just plate the inside of a reactor with photoelectrics instead of blowing all the budget on a clusterfuck of a steam system. Too bad silicon doesn't like 100M degrees... Actually thinking about it figuring that out would make fission a lot more tenable too
- u320 4y agoFusion produces neutrons, not photons.
- DFHippie 4y agoI'm pretty sure it produces both.
- fy20 4y agoIs there an equivalent of the photoelectric effect for neutrons?
- ncmncm 4y agoNone. Hot neutrons are the lowest-grade sort of energy.
- blincoln 4y agoMaybe a dumb question, but could one use bricks of depleted fission fuel as the neutron shield in a fusion reactor, and swap them back into a fission reactor every time they become fuel-grade again?
- ncmncm 4y agoIt would be an overwhelmingly smarter and better use of money to burn uranium in an ordinary fission plant, and maybe breed up extra fuel there. But we already know that fission, too, is uncompetitive, moreso each day as costs for renewables and storage continue relentlessly downward. Fusion has no chance of ever catching up.
- compumike 4y agoI'm not sure where your numbers are from, but just because $2B sounds like a big number, it isn't inherently a dealbreaker. If that's 600 MWe, running at 80% capacity factor, amortized over 30 years, then the $2B becomes: 2e9/(600 * 1000 * 0.8 * 24 * 365 * 30) = $0.0158 / kWh -- the $2B capital cost amortizes to 1.6 cents per kWh of electricity sold. Not zero, but 1.6 cents is far less than the current market price of a kWh. If you're going to compare to utility-scale solar or wind, be sure to include their much lower capacity factor: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#/media/File:US_EIA_monthly_capacity_factors_2011-2013.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#/media/File:US... (Admittedly: we don't yet know the capital cost of a working fusion heat source, or its capacity factor. Both will determine whether this is economically competitive.)
- dtgriscom 4y agoYou aren't including fuel costs; any guesses?
- compumike 4y agoYou might be interested in Lazard's "Levelized Cost Of Energy" PDF (https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-of-energy-version-150-vf.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/451905/lazards-levelized-cost-o... , from https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-levelized-cost-of-storage-and-levelized-cost-of-hydrogen/ https://www.lazard.com/perspective/levelized-cost-of-energy-...). On page 15 note "This analysis does not take into account potential social and environmental externalities or reliability-related considerations", and that solar and wind do not get the checkmark for "baseload" -- only "intermittent". Pages 13 and 14 show Fuel Costs as: Wind: 0 Solar: 0 Coal: $13-$18/MWh ($0.013 - $0.018 per kWh) Fission: $9/MWh ($0.009 per kWh) Natural Gas: $21-34/MWh ($0.021 - $0.034 per kWh) As a retail consumer, I'm paying about $0.15 per kWh, though I know that includes transmission and distribution and retail markup. Fusion has the potential to be very low on fuel costs. But the capital costs are an unknown. In my original comment, I tried to show that when amortized over enough kWh for sale, even $Billions in capital costs could make sense, if they give us a machine that produces zero-carbon baseload electrical generation at scale.