7 ms·
City-based soda pop taxes don’t effectively reduce sugar consumption
- timcavel 4y ago
- bediger4000 4y agoThis must be the only time a tax didn't reduce use of the thing being taxed. The USA can't raise tax rate on capital gains lest we kill all investment. We lowered the business tax rate just a few years ago so as to keep businesses from fleeing the country. It's just plain weird that this tax didn't have the desired effect. I sense an economics doctoral dissertation!
- acchow 4y agoThe article talks about why: it does reduce the consumption of soda pop, but people substitute the sugar intake by consuming other sugary foods. They also travel to neighboring towns without the tax.
- dmix 4y agoIt's also about competition. Global business operates isn a highly competitive market where capital gains tax rates will be closely compared. But taxing soda when it's between ten brands by Coke/Pepsi vs Water. People aren't going to water for just 10c more (or w/e the tax is). I'd imagine with illegal addictive drugs when prices increase 10-20% it won't stop buyers since they are already making a guilty-pleasure/poor choice so a slightly worse one isn't much of a bigger deal. Some product and service categories operate under different dynamics than most things.
- mjevans 4y agoImagine trying to get people to give up Cream and sugary syrups with a dash of espresso -- Wait they aren't taxing THAT drink.
- tomjen3 4y agoSure, but having to travel has a cost in both time and money, which is equivalent to a tax, even if it raises no additional direct income for that city.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> The article talks about why: it does reduce the consumption of soda pop, but people substitute the sugar intake by consuming other sugary foods. They also travel to neighboring towns without the tax. It's also entirely inconsistent; in Boulder they tax the normal stuff like coke and sprite but will exempt for San Peligrino but then also tax Oceanspray juice. Personally, I've always thought it was a lot like the pervasive green-washing that takes place there as an additional stream of revenue in already bloated bureaucratic system. I only ever drank kombucha or Water from the SafewayKingsoopers/WF etc... in town anyhow so it never really affected me; but when I think of just how obtuse it is I start to realize how it's a targeted tax on those with poor diets with no real discernible metric for success, it's merely there to self-perpetuate a bad system as poorer people will continue to eat poorly with less expendable income to buy better products as a result of the tax. The US is obese, and despite Boulder being the time the most healthiest city in the US most of when I lived there it was still clear to see how the economic divide play out where it's most clearest: grocery stores. And it was clear that it was heavily biased to those with larger wages who could fit in 4-5 day workouts per week and the occasional hike and eating from organic sourced restaurants. If we had a universal healthcare system I would totally be in favour of this, despite being in the lower income level most of time there (boot-strapping founder) I was still on the 'healthiest' demographic but without a clear actionable plan to a desirable end this is one of those 'road to hell are paved with good intention' scenarios.
- jfim 4y ago> in Boulder they tax the normal stuff like coke and sprite but will exempt for San Peligrino but then also tax Oceanspray juice Assuming they're taxing based on the sugar content, then that's the expected outcome. Coke, Sprite, and juice have sugar in them, sparkling water doesn't.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> Assuming they're taxing based on the sugar content, then that's the expected outcome. Coke, Sprite, and juice have sugar in them, sparkling water doesn't. But to what end? Those people still ate poorly, and continued to make those poor purchase decisions and had less money to justify making better ones as they didn't miraculously start drinking San Peligrino Italian soda, which also has sugar in them [0]. 0: https://www.amazon.com/Sanpellegrino-Prickly-Orange-Sparkling-Beverage/dp/B01CO54FMW/ref=sr_1_8?keywords=san%2Bpellegrino%2Bsoda&qid=1662532243&sr=8-8&th=1 https://www.amazon.com/Sanpellegrino-Prickly-Orange-Sparklin...
- Supermancho 4y agohttps://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/hec.4586 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/hec.4586 No mention of the fact that this study mixes data that was conducted prior to the pandemic with data collected during the height of the pandemic. Casually, it associates a small tax with TREMENDOUS reduction? > Bleich et al. (2021) similarly found a 42% decrease (6.1 fL oz decrease) in purchases of taxed beverages in Philadelphia > found Philadelphia experienced a far larger decline than the other four cities using a consumer panel from the marketing firm Infoscout. > In Philadelphia, Zhong et al. (2018) used a phone survey and found that within 2 months of the tax's implementation This is bad science, even when it's only a meta-analysis (which necessarily has a lower bar).
- atdrummond 4y agoThis study is flawed in that it didn’t account for purchase increases outside the survey area. In Chicago the tax was ineffective as there were many close municipalities without the tax - in addition to grey market stores that didn’t charge the tax - allowing buyers to easily avoid paying it.
- akira2501 4y agoThe USA was famously founded on a tax that didn't reduce use of the thing being taxed, nor was it actually designed to. Tax isn't magic, and the devil is always in the details.
- imtringued 4y agoIt had the desired effect. People stopped buying soda in the city. It turns out that what they needed was a sugar tax and that the tax has to be applied on a broader geographic area.
- specialist 4y agoCorrect. Further, while I support a sugar tax, on public health grounds, I'd much rather we stop subsidizing sugar production (esp HFCS). But ending subsidies for corn, sugar beets, etc. is still a non-starter. Because Electoral College and US Senate. So we're stuck with virtual signaling our displeasure towards harmful agricultural policies with impotent measures like soda taxes. Meanwhile, like this OC suggests, we absolutely should be investing and subsidizing in healthy drinking water. It's CRAZY that people in places like Flint MI and Jackson MS cannot safely consume their own tap water.
- kennend3 4y agoThis!. Your post touches on several key points. The US "anti-subsidy" laws where they put duties on products they deem were government subsidized, while CORN is massively subsidized. "Subsidies for corn—the most abundant crop in the United States—have far surpassed those for any other crop, estimated to have totaled more than $116 billion since 1995." One has to question the logic here. Use tax dollars to subsidize the price of corn, which leaves the country awash in HFCS and "ethanol" to find creative ways to get rid of all the corn. Then attempt to tax the HFCS later? Seems removing the subsidy would cause the price of HFCS to raise but we cant do that due to powerful lobby groups? These "sugar taxes" always have so many exemptions to feed some special interest groups requirements creating an ever-increasing complex set of laws.
- exabrial 4y agoSimply incredible. We should try it again and see if it works the umpteenth time. Then do it again with something else.
- readonthegoapp 4y agoReminds of the coke funded research from a few years ago -- I don't expect coke or any Corp to ever stop their PR campaigns https://www.eatthis.com/coca-cola-paid-scientists-study-sugar/ https://www.eatthis.com/coca-cola-paid-scientists-study-suga...
- diebeforei485 4y agoEveryone seems to be doing this differently. It makes no sense to not have this apply to candy and cookies. Look at the nutrition facts label, see how many grams of added sugar there are, and to keep things simple set the the tax at one cent per gram of added sugar. I can't see this being hard to implement.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MarkLowenstein 4y agoOr just tax the original sugar production or importation and be done with all the complexity of chasing down a million food companies across thousands of jurisdictions. (Or let people eat whatever they want and stop being a busybody.)
- temporalparts 4y agoProduction is usually not within the jurisdiction of cities (as they are produced elsewhere and shipped there usually), so cities are limited in what they can do. As to busybody, excess sugar consumption is a public health problems that governments should intervene on, as I believe it is right for them to do in areas like tobacco.
- irrational 4y agoWhat about alcohol? They tax it, sure, but the tax isn’t high enough to discourage consumption. I’ve never heard of anyone getting in a car and killing people after consuming too much sugar.
- wyre 4y agoAfter moving from Idaho (no liquor tax) to Washington (heavy liquor tax), the higher taxes certainly discourage my consumption, at least slightly
- Schroedingersat 4y agoI just want some front of package labelling. It's so hard to find drinks, portable snacks, and similar that are in the 3-8% sugar range with no artificial sweetener to make them inedibly sweet. You finally find one and a few weeks later the sugar doubles or it is replaced with 5x the sweetness in erithrotol Just x g of sugar, and y equivalent grams of sweetener on the front in a standard format.
- dehrmann 4y agoWhat you're looking for is rare. It's basically coconut water.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoDrinks like iced teas or watered down fruit drink or 'vitamin water' around that level were common in australia, but one by one are going from being the less cloyingly sweet options to being the most via other sweeteners. Usually one ariund the 5% sugar range will get extremely popular because it is actually slightly different, then get bought out or price dumped out of existence by coca cola followed by being focuse grouped into being exactly the same as all the others and falling into obscurity. There's usually one or two items on the muesli/nut/cake bar shelf, but you have to read the nutrition info for half of them every time to find it.
- 41b696ef1113 4y agoWhat is a y equivalent gram of sweetener? A cursory look says a 12oz Coke Cola has 39grams of sugar while a Diet Coke has 0.2 grams of aspartame. How would you like it to be labelled?
- Someone 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspartame https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspartame: “Aspartame is an artificial non-saccharide sweetener 200 times sweeter than sucrose” ⇒ I expect they would like to see something like “39 REAL”, respectively “40 ARTIFICIAL” on the label. Of course there’s a can of worms in that there are multiple ‘real’ sugars (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sugar) and producers will try to talk down that 200, but I think that’s solvable. What’s less solvable is that producers will talk down the unit size used to compute the amount of sugar, just as they do with the unit size used to compute the number of calories. Alternatively, this could be shown as a sweetness rating with “x% artificial” added, or just as a sweetness rating alongside the existing ‘calories’ rating.
- PeterStuer 4y agoOver here in the EU these taxes are specifically designed not to reduce consumption. The relation between a tax and consumption is not linear. Below a certain treshold there is 0 consumption impact. In fact, taxes need to be rather huge to change behaviour especially for addictive/craving substances. We learned those lessons many decades ago with the tobacco industry.
- exabrial 4y agoGood lord, sugar taxes were a way to stifle competition, not do anything for public health. As an example in Seattle, Starbucks was exempt even though you can buy a 450 cal drink in a few seconds.
- prirun 4y agoFor anyone 100lbs overweight, suspend insurance coverage (and premiums) unless they are losing 5lbs per month on average for the last 6 months. Weight loss & nutrition counseling are always free.
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoNow your just fat-shaming. But I totally agree with you, but how is weight any different than any other voluntarily arrived at (e.g. skin cancer because of no sunscreen and too much sun exposure) "pre-existing conditions" that must be covered?
- exabrial 4y ago"Fat Shaming" is being mean to someone and humiliating them with the intention of harming them or for entertainment. Raising their insurance rates to correlate with their free-will choices is another matter. Am I being "speeder shamed" if my insurance company raises my rates for getting speeding tickets?
- ThunderSizzle 4y agoI was pointing out thr current absurd social media trends when people talk about being overweight negatively in any context. This context would be an egregious offense too, regardless of your common sense. I guess you haven't run into that yet.
- kleene_op 4y agoExcuse this rethorical question, but is there any context where being overweight is something positive? I agree that shaming people for being fat is counterproductive. But dismissing honest attempts at breaking the status quo under the pretense that it is insulting to fat people is really doing them a disservice.
- rexpop 4y ago> free-will choices Obesity is not a choice, it's a result of food insecurity[0] and a common response to child sexual abuse.[1] 0. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4584410/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4584410/ 1. https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/12/sexual-abuse-victims-obesity/420186/ https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/12/sexual-ab...
- thedracle 4y agoI imagine part of the strategy should be to use the funds from the tax to counter the negative effects of the product. This was an effective strategy for smoking. Stopping ads for soda, and similarly producing ads that inform people of the risks of high amounts of soda consumption with the tax.