12 ms·
What Should You Work On?
- steele 4y agoThielthink is a red flag
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jahewson 4y ago> Those who would work in government but choose not to say there’s too much red tape and the pay isn’t high enough Whoa there tiger. Maybe some people do, but there’s plenty of people who simple never, ever want to work for politicians. Why on earth would I want to work for those lamentable grifters? Most of them are not solving anything. Even when it works it fails. Any attempt at long-termism leads to short-term pain that opens up a weakness that the opposing party uses to grab power and undo it. And why should it work? With an electorate that skews towards retirement age the system is delivering exactly the result one would expect - enriching retirees at the expense of future generations. For my generation: no housing, no healthcare, no pension, no climate. For retirees: no taxes. It feels like we need a fundamental change to enfranchisement. Perhaps parents should be able to cast votes for their children?
- ethanbond 4y agoThe only fundamental change that’s both required and possible is young people with good ideas stepping up to the plate instead of throwing up their hands and declaring the whole system bankrupt.
- jahewson 4y agoHard disagree. The system showers rewards on the older generations in exchange for votes. It offers young people almost nothing. Retirees also have nothing better to do than sit around watching and reading conservative propaganda which is close to impossible to compete with.
- ethanbond 4y agoYep, all those things are true. And yet still the only realistic solution is as advertised up above.
- jahewson 4y agoI don’t think it’s realistic to expect people who don’t hold power, who have the least resources, the least leverage, to be able to take power. The nature of power is that it can be used to stop people from doing exactly this. And it’s a moot point because if you figure out the magic formula for getting this huge turnout then the same approach will be used by your opponents and the largest demographic will still win, and that’s not young people.
- fatbird 4y agoCounterpoint: the flight of smart people to less regulated, entrepeneurial segments of the economy has drained intelligence and conscientiousness out of the more staid sectors of society, leaving them to the petty, the vicious, the stupid. It’s a good thing that many Harvard grads go into boring careers because those keep the vast majority of the machinery of our world running. If more people said “I’m not going to work on a startup making a moonshot, I’m going to be the best, most effective health insurance executive I can be,” the world would be a better place. The fact that it’s hard to succeed and less rewarding in incumbent industries tells you where the real challenges are, and where the best of us are most needed. Escaping to startupland is dodging your reponsibility to give back. It’s taking the easy way out.
- xwowsersx 4y agoI'm torn on whether to provide the following feedback/critique since it doesn't really respond to the substance of the points put forward in this post, but I feel it can't be ignored: there is something ironic, off-putting and hypocritical about a person whose primary occupation is writing, podcasting and running a writing school penning an article about how most people are working on piddling matters and that everyone should be focused on energy, education, housing, healthcare, and transportation. Does the claim that everyone is working on trivial matters apply to the author as well? If it doesn't, then apparently it is not the case that most people are working on trivial matters...in which case one core assertion of the article is undermined, no? To be sure, my critique is mostly directed at form and tact. It is one thing to say: "we have really stagnated on energy, education, housing, healthcare, and transportation and need to double down on it. How can we incentivize more people to focus on these problems?" and quite another to say "Most people are working on trivial matters and/or pretending to be busy."
- FlyingSnake 4y agoThe term you’re looking for is “skin in the game”. I would prefer if the advice comes from the man in the arena, not the one sitting in the gallery.
- xwowsersx 4y agoYes, well said.
- Stamp01 4y agoYou are not defined by your work. Anyone who looks at you and only sees your most recent accomplishment is not worth your time. It's okay to not be productive sometimes. It's okay to do nothing sometimes. Everyone needs to hear that. I'm just as guilty as anyone. I've been sold the lie that because I'm a programmer, I'm soon to be rich. I just have to work a little harder. When I'm not working for a paycheck, that time is supposed to be for me to be working towards my dreams and striking it rich and making the world a better place. Don't fall for it. It's okay if you need to spend that third of your day not spent sleeping or working for the man to recover.
- AndrewKemendo 4y agoThere is plenty of space between "Grindcore Gary Vaynerchuck" and "Fart around Kurt Vonnegut" Find out what sustains your passions and figure out how to contribute that in a pro-social, community focused way Does it need to be full time? No!
- badpun 4y agoLet's start one step before that: do you want to work at all?
- praptak 4y agoSo you want young people to start working on some interesting ideas which have potential to help humanity? Well, my top priority at that age was not to be poor. The optimal strategy was to work in the boring parts of IT and hopping to a better job whenever an opportunity arose. (This worked for me, thank you) So, sorry but the deal where I work on some crazy idea and become poor if it fails was just unattractive to me (and probably isn't to a lot of people who are not born rich).
- hinkley 4y ago> Well, my top priority at that age was not to be poor. There's a weird case of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs where the bubble you live in during college has a lot of people worried about self actualization because their support group (or loans) is helping take care of things like food and shelter. Historically, the moment you graduated you were responsible for all of that stuff, but that's been blurred by people moving back in with their parents. I don't know if that's enough to change the equation but certainly for a lot of previous generations we were trying to get our own oxygen masks in place before helping others. The problem is that your ideals become immediately in conflict with logistics and you end up having to compromise. Even mentorship is fraught because mentors are human and some of their non-negotiables may be wrong. If you refuse you may be entirely on your own. All of a sudden you're 30 and the asshole in the mirror is someone you hardly recognize. That's probably a better demographic to target for such things, both because they're more interested and they have practical knowledge that increases the likelihood of your efforts to be described as "effective" instead of the dreaded, "well-meaning".
- elliekelly 4y agoAre you going to keep submitting links to this crappy “blog” that’s just a funnel for the author’s (presumably equally crappy) writing course all morning?
- BMc2020 4y agoI’m on a mission to teach thousands of people to write online, share their ideas, and build an online audience. In order to do that, I teach an online course called Write of Passage. In five weeks of intense instruction, I give hundreds of students the tools to publish their ideas, build an online audience, and accelerate their career. The essence of the course is described in my essay, The Ultimate Guide to Writing Online. Students also leave with a network of friends who share their curiosity for learning. Yes, David, please teach me how to write great OC that Arianna Huffingon can steal.
- gumby 4y agoRichard Hamming gave a famous talk on this back in 86 (and repeated many times -- I heard him give it in '88 and it affected me greatly. His essay on the subject has circulated widely: https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html https://www.cs.virginia.edu/~robins/YouAndYourResearch.html Actually this talk is on the topic of the title of this blog post. The blog post itself seems mainly a complaint about current circumstances.
- mfuzzey 4y agoI think a big part of the "problem" is that the skill set required to be an "innovator" in some field (coming up with an idea and making it work) is generally very different to that of being an "entrepreneur" (building a sucessful business around it). It's quite rare to find the two in a single person and very often the best on one side are the worse on the other.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blacksmithgu 4y agoNo, we don't need more "smart" people working on important problems in transportation, health, education, and so on. We already have plenty of smart people with good ideas, they just have no institutional power to affect anything. These fields need zealous reformers and activists with the time and money to push through mountains of entrenched interests, complacency, and politics. The work sucks, and people capable of doing it will always be in short supply.
- afpx 4y agoFix search, first. Then, we can all find what we want to work on.
- KerrAvon 4y agoMy god, Peter Thiel said something potentially interesting for once. I don’t know if it’s actually statistically true, but it makes sense that people on the spectrum might indeed be more inclined to stick with their ideas, because they are less likely to be swayed from what they know is correct (for some value of correct).
- houstonn 4y agoYou could be surprised. Read Zero to One or watch his Stanford lecture.
- joshdick 4y agoThis is partially a collective action problem. It might be socially optimal for people to take more risks working on crazy ideas, but for individuals there's less risk in working for a large corporation on incremental improvements.
- igorkraw 4y agoWhich would be fixable with a UBI. Make it feasible for everyone to live a life of failing at high risk endeavours, not just the privileged ones
- jahewson 4y agoUBI is hardly sufficient to fund most high risk endeavours.
- igorkraw 4y agoNo, but if you can spend decades building up convincing PoCs and pitch decks without needing to worry about starving, rent or healthcare you are more likely too. Sweden is more entrepreneurial than most of the rest of Europe for this reason afaik
- jahewson 4y agoIf I spent decades on PoCs they’d be obsolete before they saw the light of day.
- mkl95 4y ago> Too many of our smartest minds are working on trivial tasks and spending their time in corporations where they feel invisible. The vast majority of my friends who work for big companies say they’re bored, unchallenged, and under-employed. They don’t see the tangible benefits of their hard work. If you work for a big company you could potentially work on exciting stuff. In my experience the smaller places tend to be risk averse or they just can't afford the bleeding edge stuff. So you'll often be stuck fixing obscure bugs introduced by former employees and dealing with bad infra decisions.
- 4ndrewl 4y ago"We need more people like Dominic Cummings" - not sure this aged well...
- jahewson 4y agoActually at this point I think Dominic Cummings has fully redeemed himself.
- pjc50 4y agoHe's still hugely responsible for Brexit, and indeed for trusting Johnson in the first place. Even if he does write huge intellectual-sounding blog posts, when given the chance to put his ideas into action he's failed spectacularly.
- jahewson 4y agoOk maybe not fully.
- Apocryphon 4y agooof https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7zkejgYSlg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U7zkejgYSlg
- pjc50 4y ago> "We need more people like Dominic Cummings, a senior advisor to Boris Johnson, who is probably the most forward-thinking politician in the world today." This aged incredibly badly.
- edjw 4y agoI’m not sure when this was published. But Johnson has been a well-known politician in the UK for at least 10 years. I’m not sure he’s ever really been thought of as forward-thinking. Maybe, if you’re being charitable, he’s moved the UK centre-right a bit greener.
- chasing 4y agoIf the United States had universal healthcare and education wasn't brutally expensive then more people could justify being entrepreneurial. You can't have society in which almost all wealth flows upwards and normal people are comfortable taking business risk. Want start-ups? Raise taxes on the wealthiest of us, increase social services and safety nets and access to education. If people feel safe, they'll take more risks. Make it so people don't have to risk their kids' futures on their idea. Also maybe put some protections in place so massive incumbents can't just stomp potential competitors and squash innovation...
- californical 4y ago> Want start-ups? Raise taxes on the wealthiest of us, increase social services and safety nets and access to education. If people feel safe, they'll take more risks. Make it so people don't have to risk their kids' futures on their idea. Many countries have done this — do you have any examples of one of them becoming more entrepreneurial? Because I don’t think we can just assume it to be true. Just because people said that was their biggest barrier to starting a business doesn’t make it true. And I say that as someone who generally supports universal healthcare/insurance. People make up tons of reasons for not making a huge change in their life (like founding a company): “if only X then I’d finally do Y”. But if you fix X, they’ll find some new reason that they can’t do it.
- hotpotamus 4y agoI don't have a well researched answer, but I think Israel might be a possibility.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- QuarterReptile 4y ago>Many countries have done this — do you have any examples of one of them becoming more entrepreneurial? Because I don’t think we can just assume it to be true. Also needed is a consistent explanation that explains all the other countries doing this which have nonetheless failed to become more entrepreneurial.
- jeffreyrogers 4y ago> We don’t need a 17th bottled water brand at CVS or a 28th CliffBar competitor at Walgreens. We need our best and brightest people working on important problems that wouldn’t be solved otherwise. This is a fairly common take, but it is wrong in my opinion. I've worked on some fairly difficult engineering problems (related to signal processing) and one of the remarkable things is that multiple people in the room usually have a workable idea about how to approach it. And if you think about the really productive periods of science the number of scientists was very limited. There's no shortage of smart people who want to work on interesting problems. What there is a shortage of are people with the organizational, and other, less tangible, skills that are needed to bring complex projects to fruition. At a high level, we know things that work for most of the list that Perell provided (energy, education, housing, healthcare, and transportation) and even assuming zero technological progress they could be hugely improved with existing technology, but someone has to figure out how to break the status quo and reach a new equilibrium. Definitely those are important problems, but just being smart won't solve them. They already attract lots of smart people. You need to bring something else to the table to make progress.
- jahewson 4y ago> What there is a shortage of are people with the organizational, and other, less tangible, skills that are needed to bring complex projects to fruition. I don’t think that’s the case. In fact, I think we have more capable people than ever before. The problem is that we deny almost everybody such opportunities. Companies are structured too hierarchically.
- ethanbond 4y agoYou’re arguing for GP’s point, not against it. Companies don’t just wind up being too hierarchically structured to be impactful (assuming that’s a problem). People who lack organizational skills create companies that are too hierarchically structured to be impactful.
- jahewson 4y agoGP said projects, not companies. I’d argue the same point for companies though, we have plenty of skilled people, we just enable people with other personality traits to found/rise in leadership.
- kretaceous 4y agoIn the spirit of the article, https://80000hours.org/ https://80000hours.org/
- whattoworkon65 4y agoThank you! I deleted my other comment just made, because this is exactly the sort of thing I was hoping to fish for in a reply to my now-deleted comment. It is in the spirit of the article and a good follow-up for people (like me) who might be looking for a career change to something a more positively impactful and less detrimental.
- wnolens 4y ago> Too many of our smartest minds are working on trivial tasks I find this a bit condescending. Too many people act like entrepreneurship is something everyone has the stomach/personality/capacity for. Too many people write blog articles about how if you're not building the next big thing, you're not contributing to society. Most people I've met in my professional and personal life are supporting their families, trying to raise kids well, making time/$ for their passions, or just generally trying to live a decent life despite the difficult circumstances that life throws at you.
- polishdude20 4y agoEspecially this first quote: "People aren’t deliberate enough about choosing what to work on." Hold up. What is this based on? Is it based on a feeling of the author's inflated sense of worth compared to others? Or is this really some objective and measurable metric? Is it possible the author doesn't actually know or has taken the effort to deliberate on this statement themselves? Playing devil's advocate with your own ideas is probably the greatest service you can do for yourself but it seems that's not practised here. I can come up with many examples of how people ARE very deliberate in what they work on. Like you said, raising a family, enjoying time outside of work, just straight up trying to survive. These all seem pretty deliberate.
- lelandfe 4y ago> Is it possible the author doesn't actually know It’s a very HN mindset to reject articles not backed up by objective facts. This is an inherently subjective post, pointing out the lack of hard data shouldn’t be an indictment of the author’s thesis.
- altdataseller 4y agoHe is projecting himself. Everything he is saying is a reflection of himself
- wnolens 4y agoPrecisely. He likely had a revelation about himself, and writes about it with the language, "people are mostly xyz." What a joke.
- wyre 4y agoWas this supposed to be inspiring? It seems the author is just complaining about how this countries best and brightest go on to work in finance or management instead of using their talents to start a business. Which is true obv, but it doesn’t offer any real solutions or answers. Starting a business is hard; find an unsolved problem and then work your ass off until it’s solved and the solution can be marketed. It takes a certain type of person to be able to succeed in this endeavor, while the rest are going to be better off in their cushy office job where they can have something of a work-life balance. It takes a lot of money and experience to build something meaningful in the industries the author mentioned. Healthcare, energy, housing, education, and transportation. It must take a lot of insider knowledge to be able to identify the unsolved problems in these industries. A Harvard MBA won’t know how to fix the healthcare industry, but I bet a nurse that’s working 60 hours this week has some ideas. The former might have the connections and capital to build the change but they lack the experience and motivation, while the latter could have the solution, but lacks the connections, time, and money to build the solution.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoThe best and brightest do not work in finance or management. They become mathematicians, physicists, astrophysicists, chemists maybe also computer science and other areas of research. They are more interested in discovery, than rising through the ranks of management or possession of great wealth. They research in their area of expertise with a passion. Of course they are not all business starters or entrepreneurs. The things society and competition, and law put you through when starting a business could well mean, that these people would never even consider starting a business, because it would take away way too much of their time, which they spend on working on the fringes of human knowledge. They simply don't have the time for such mundane things.
- wyre 4y agoI totally agree with you. I never said that the best and brightest go on to do finance and management, but that’s what the author was alluding too.