24 ms·
1 in 4 Gen Z-ers plan to become social media influencers
- tjpnz 4y agoPerhaps this is another solution to the Fermi Paradox. At some point every race develops their own Instagram or TikTok and people are too consumed by it to notice the asteroid coming towards them.
- danjoredd 4y ago1000 is a pretty small sample size. Not sure how much I believe this.
- krastanov 4y agoThat is not how sample sizes work. If the sampling was actually random, a sample size of 1000 is way more than enough to measure a 25/75 split in a population. The sample size gives you the "random error" in your estimate, and that scales roughly as 1/sqrt(sample size). So 1000 is plenty. But it is reasonable to worry whether the sample was actually random, or biased in some way (e.g. sampling only Gen Z-ers that use a certain website) -- that would lead to a systematic error. However, for a systematic error a bigger sample size would not help much.
- Myrmornis 4y agoI like your comment! However, isn’t it plausible that the underlying population (or the distribution resulting from the ascertainment process) is structured in such a way that N=1000 might well have over-representation of certain subgroups, whereas N=10000 would be likely to have equal representation of subgroups?
- epistasis 4y agoIf your sampling strategy gets a biased group of 1000, it's almost certainly going to be biased in the same way as you pick 10,000. 1000 is plenty of individuals, the real concern is how they were chosen.
- danjoredd 4y agoThat was my concern. How many states did they test in the US? How many people from each state? LA and NYC are famous for being the cities every theater kid wants to live in, so if too many responses come from them, it seems obvious a huge portion want to be influencers. What about the midwest and south? Do they get the same results there?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoHow many Gen X-ers planned to become rock stars?
- amelius 4y ago1 in x HNers plan to become rich in the App Store. Sounds familiar? In any case, more transparency from the platforms is warranted.
- woodruffw 4y agoI'm not sure what that's supposed to tell us. How many schoolchildren in 1969 wanted to be astronauts, or movie stars?
- adastra22 4y agoI’d rather my kids want to be astronauts.
- woodruffw 4y agoSure, that makes sense. But it's completely irrelevant: the point is that kids identity with cultural moments, and that we shouldn't mistake that for what they're actually going to do when they grow up. For the record, I wanted to be a dinosaur.
- adastra22 4y agoIt does affect what they focus on though, and what interests them later in life. The Apollo effect is very real. There’s a lot of boomers and Gen X folks who went into technology and science because of the Moon landings. we should be doing things and making cultural choices that inspire the next generation of scientists and engineers.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe Apollo effect is real, and so is the Scully Effect[1]. Entertainment stars with no particular relation or expertise in the roles they play can have an outsized effect on children and young adults' professional goals. There is no economical scheme in which 25% of all Gen-Z-ers actually become social media influencers, so I'm not going to spend my time actually worrying about that. For the ones who do, the content they produce matters much more to me than their mere job description. [1]: https://fanlore.org/wiki/The_Scully_Effect https://fanlore.org/wiki/The_Scully_Effect
- adastra22 4y ago
- dougmwne 4y agoThere’s nothing surprising about this since it seems common to want to be famous, rich and someone that lots of people pay attention to, especially in your teens and early 20’s. Previous versions of this dream include author, movie star, sports pro, and musician. Influencer is just the cultural flavor of the decade. And of course, most people are terrible at estimating probabilities, so these dreams seem vaguely realistic for awhile.
- angryGhost 4y agoonly 1 in 4!? the world needs more influencers!
- mtoner23 4y agoYeah, social media influencer is a pretty sweet job and has high visibility. Every 5 years someone does this sample and its always the same for the past 50 years, Tiktok star, youtuber, rockstar, tv star, celebrity. almost no one plans to be a truck driver or cashier but they're the most common jobs in the country, and thats fine.
- zach_garwood 4y agoIs this really true about cashiers and truck drivers? I would have guessed the most common jobs are retail and fast food worker. But maybe that's just because I eat too much fast food.
- killyourcar 4y ago
- creaghpatr 4y agoMany of those in the first category will likely work jobs in the latter category before, during, or after their influencer 'career'. C'est la vie.
- ok123456 4y agoBut now the truck driver or cashier or lawyer or doctor can make TikToks about their profession and become a minor celebrity. These people are much more interesting than traditional celebrities because they usually have a few good stories or insider tips they can give you. Like "Mr Rice" giving you cleaning tips from his 20 years of experience running a dry cleaning business, "Mechanic Link" doing showing you how involved some car repair tasks are, or the clinical pathologist that tells you about different kinds of carcinomas.
- InfoSecErik 4y agoI remember planning to do something in video games as I was growing up. Ended up in a different but fairly related field. Maybe this is just a sign of the next generation of people that'll work in advertising/marketing/PR/media/fashion?
- AMerrit 4y agoYeah I had dreams of making video games when I was younger (and still daydream about it sometimes now) and even got to the point of doing some work in modding communities and playing around with my own simple games/clones. Lots of these Gen Zers will likely start TikTok channels or such, but once you find out how difficult it is to make it to the top you tend to at least redirect. Led me to a job in Cybersecurity, and I'm sure most of these kids will turn out fine as well.
- sillyquiet 4y agoYeah, as much as I think the whole concept of social media influencers is sad and dumb, this smells like one of those 'dang kids and their <x>' articles that have cursed us since Aristotle. As a Gen-Xer, I don't know how many times I read similar things growing up about my own generation, except it was metal or hair bands or glam rockers that garnered the worry.
- havblue 4y agoAnd civilizations since Aristotle have only lasted a few centuries on average. So when adults look at younger generations and see inevitable decline, they might be correct.
- cercatrova 4y agoCorrelation does not imply causation however.
- just-ok 4y agoIt doesn’t deny causation, either.
- havblue 4y agoI don't think I implied causation as much as symptoms of decline. In this case we're talking about a large percentage of people who are entering what is historically considered adulthood, 16+, who intend to apply themselves towards a career that (arguably) doesn't offer much utility to anyone. So the ghosts of Ancient Greece would see this as part of the decline of the American civilization and I don't think they would laugh, shrug their shoulders and say, "the kids are alright".
- slothtrop 4y agoFoolishness =/= decline.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI'm confused as to whether you're saying that a few centuries is a decline or not. When these civilizations were first forming do you believe that the elders would have looked at the youth and seen them as strengthening?
- spaghettiToy 4y ago1 in 4 people want to be a leader? Being a social media influencer translates to influencer. Which seems to be either a leader, or some sub variant of leader. Is it a surprise people want to make a difference and be the decider of that difference?
- baliex 4y agoI imagine it's driven by wanting fame and fortune rather than being any sort of leader or making a (positive?) difference in the world
- djohnston 4y agoI don't think most influencers are leaders. They're attractive conduits for corporate product placements. In fact you have to be quite careful as an influencer not to offend your base or get cancelled - I think they tend to be quite conservative and reserved with respect to risks.
- R0b0t1 4y agoYou're right however what he is saying I suspect is more about the perception of leading as opposed to actually leading.
- mupuff1234 4y agoLet's hope that AGI sentients are avid consumers.
- shagie 4y agoI would suggest a read of Accelerando ( https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/accelerando/accelerando-intro.html https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/acceler... ) The economics gets touched on in "decade eight, third millennium". In the world of Accelerando... well... I suspect that the new and rehashed ideas of social media would be a gold mine.
- meltyness 4y agoThis makes me think of the "shark scene" from Back to the Future, and how reality has diverged from this extrapolation. - It's still ubiquitous, like a hologram accosting you in the street. - It's still surprising through targeted ads, the machine understands you. - Unclear privacy concerns, your scream of fear makes it a discussion piece. - It's short and sweet. ...but the form isn't terribly artful. It's like a surrogate video call mixed with lowest-common-denominator talent show. This may be part of the effect as well to produce the -- apparently -- rather-effective drive to engage. This rut, and the congestion may cause things to quickly stagnate. Plus, a horror movie with some 4-dimensional monster that views reality, places, and human connection as some sort of twisted bubblewrap ought to sort these Gen Z-ers out.
- onion2k 4y agoSurvey results show more men than women feel becoming an influencer is their only viable career path. How bad do things have to get in your life for you to feel that "become a TikTok star" is your only option. It's one thing to think you want a fun and exciting career when you become rich and famous (I mean, who doesn't?), but another thing entirely to feel that you have no options for a fulfilling life except internet fame. If a lot of people genuinely feel this way then that is truly terrible, and society needs to start making other careers viable and attainable possibilities.
- rossdavidh 4y agoAgreed, and it's the one line in this article that explains almost all of the rest of it.
- 3pt14159 4y agoI know this is going to get laughed at, but you know how so many in our generation were like "oh man, it was SO EASY to start a tech startup back in the 80s and 90s compared to now!" Same thing is going to be said about how we had it online during the early 2000s. Kids these days go to war for followers and the social media companies have caught up to the new meta and have started just directly paying them. Only going to get more fierce from here.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoAlready is being said. 'Influencers' were a thing early in 2000s and many of them already said 'if I started YT today I wouldn't make it'. Many of them coast by doing what they used to without major changes, but their format would fail today.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is splitting out two things that are really conjoined: people do think that becoming a TikTok star will make them rich and famous. And they're right in a sense: my understanding is that the small percent of "big" influencers make a lot of money. Social media is civically poisonous in a lot of unique ways. But the desire for fame it induces in people, especially young ones, is not one of them.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- parkingrift 4y agoNeat. It looks like we’ve found the Gen-Z boogeyman. For me it was video game hysteria. Waiting with bated breath for the next media driven hysteria.
- rossdavidh 4y agoComing from a generation where lots of people thought professional athlete, rock star, or best-selling author were viable career paths, I will abstain from mocking the younger kids and their unrealistic expectations.
- kurupt213 4y agoWhich one did you want to be? I wanted to be a fighter pilot.
- amitport 4y agoFighter pilot is not such a bad aspiration. Even in the likely event that you fail, you may have worked through a path towards being commercial pilot / air control / engineering... That's not so bad
- kurupt213 4y agoThere are probably more professional athletes at any given time than fighter pilots
- kevinventullo 4y agoSure, but the point is that trying and failing to become a fighter pilot leaves one in a much better position than trying and failing to be a professional athlete.
- amelius 4y ago> Fighter pilot is not such a bad aspiration. It's not all roses: From https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2780168/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2780168/ > Hemorrhoids are a common source of complaint among fighter pilots, who are subjected to G forces. Colorectal disease continues to this day to be a very common and often debilitating complaint, and colorectal surgery clinics in the military generally are well frequented by patients.
- kurupt213 4y agoThat’s a lot of broken dreams and mediocre onlyfans porn in our future
- mikrl 4y agoYea well when I was 20 I wanted to be a cool EDM party boy like my favourite 2010 era artists. My dad had long hair in the 80s and all his friends were into metal and goth. They certainly chose to be like that for some reason too. My grandad likes his rock n roll and folk and... surprise, he was the height of fashion back in the day too. Who cares? Gen Z are fine doing them. If anything, they need us (now uncool) millennials to empathize with them: talk through the destructive parts of social media, while encouraging them to use the good parts to thrive.
- mancerayder 4y agoWhat's the breakdown by gender? I wouldn't be surprised if it skews female. Anecdotal, but it seems a large percentage of online dating profiles just exist to collect followers and increase count (which increases revenue if you sponsor something, right?)
- spacebanana7 4y agoUnlike the generally terrible plan of trying to become a TV/Movie/Music star, the plan of becoming a social media influencer complements most real careers nicely. Just like a software engineer can benefit from having a popular blog, a doctor can benefit from having a successful TikTok account, and a lawyer can benefit from having a highly rated podcast. For some careers like journalism, it's hard to see how someone can become successful without becoming some kind of social media influencer in the process.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoIf they target a good niche it could be a career. I don't mean the traditional "influencer" type that I think of with vapid content pushing products. I mean more like a content creator type on youtube but with other social media presences, its the same concept but niched down. A niche I follow people in, woodworking, there are several that have quit day jobs and produce content. One in particular has reached over 100k in revenue from making content about building workshop stuff. These are people that are creating things though - plans for sale, funny merch, and instructional content that is helpful. In some ways the content is timeless. To me I think the corollary to software is devs (like me) that wanted to pursue becoming a solo or indie software shop. So I say go for it to the Gen-Zers but have alternate plans or a fallback as well if it doesn't pan out.
- lagrange77 4y agoI wonder, if they just want the socioeconomic benefits, or think they would enjoy, what (they imagine) an influencer does.
- HorseNamedCal 4y ago>A total of 1,000 individuals in the United States between the ages 16 and 25 completed the survey Okay, so they're going to group 16 year olds opinions in with people who are over 20. Nah, not buying it as being a remotely realistic portrayal of Gen Z.