12 ms·
Why are Pakistan’s floods so extreme this year?
- R0b0t1 4y ago
- time_to_smile 4y agoI think it's worth pointing out that the impacts of climate change are often presented as singular effects: rising sea level, warmer summers, increased drought, etc. But as we can see here there is also a very strong interaction effect between all of these (and it tends to magnify the issues rather than having them cancel out). This is also why many major climate reports tend to inherently be on the conservative side: it's really, really hard to correctly model these interactions so you can only earnestly report the predicted change in individual variables rather than the impact on the system. And keep in mind this is not the "new normal", we're entering a period of transition that will not end within our life times. The rate of CO2 accumulating the atmosphere is accelerating and the rate of methane in the atmosphere is rapidly accelerating. We will likely see a blue ocean event in the next 20 years and it's really hard to imagine how that will even play out with the global climate, Thwaites glacier could collapse without much warning (very rapidly causing sea level rise beyond our current projections), the AMOC slow down could reach a tipping point, etc. Everything we're witnessing now will in the future seem relatively mild.
- 88840-8855 4y ago
- jibe 4y agoHow about not shutting down German nuclear plants, and not buying "clean natural gas from mother russia".
- 88840-8855 4y agoBeep boop. Not a Russian bot, a German one who is just pissed of by the current politics and the elitist decisions. And I hate it that any alternative proposed to the current kamikaze politics is called "Russian bots". Yes, German nuclear plants was yet another trash decision and pushed again by the fear agitated by the Green Party. And yet, the majority wants nuclear, the Greens are against it. We need REALPOLITIK and not this ideological trash. And REALPOLITIK to beat the biggest thread: global warming... and not some random conflicts between random countries nobody cared about 7 months ago and some random old pseudo-dictators that will anyway not be alive in a few years anymore.
- jibe 4y agoGet natural gas from Canada and the US. North America can supply Europe. Frack in Germany, supply yourself. You have to choose, is Ukraine worth short term financial pain? The choice is to surrender Ukraine to Russia and take the gas, or suffer for a year financially while you ramp up other energy sources.
- barbazoo 4y agoIs there such a thing as "clean gas" and if so, how does Russian gas qualify here? Also, isn't it Russia that's throttling gas delivery to 20% right now?
- 88840-8855 4y ago
- barbazoo 4y agoRussia invaded Ukraine. What did the EU do to justify this? I don't mean what Russia's reasons are (NATO expansion) but what morally justifies it.
- mc32 4y agoHighlighted by the stupidity of not buying directly from Russia at normal prices but instead buying the same hydrocarbons extracted by Russia from war washing third parties like China and India who resell Russian hydrocarbons to those who for political reasons can’t buy directly but can buy indirectly at inflated prices!! It’s the height of stupidity.
- barbazoo 4y agoAs far as I can tell, e.g. (1), the EU does not get gas from China or India. (1) https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/commodities/european-energy-crisis-where-the-eu-gets-its-natural-gas-2022-8?op=1 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/commodities/europea...
- 88840-8855 4y agoThere you go https://www.ft.com/content/1e20467a-5b53-42b7-ad89-49808f7e1780 https://www.ft.com/content/1e20467a-5b53-42b7-ad89-49808f7e1...
- barbazoo 4y agoYou're right it seems. Here's a non-paywalled article https://news.yahoo.com/china-reselling-natural-gas-energy-145711758.html https://news.yahoo.com/china-reselling-natural-gas-energy-14...
- unmole 4y agohttps://www.vortexa.com/insights/products/indias-diesel-exports-set-new-record-is-this-sustainable/ https://www.vortexa.com/insights/products/indias-diesel-expo...
- bena 4y agoI had to look up what a "blue ocean event" was. So, for others, here it is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_sea_ice_decline#Impacts_on_the_physical_environment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arctic_sea_ice_decline#Impacts...
- barbazoo 4y agoI chuckled when I saw your username together with your probably not far fetched but damning prediction of what's to come.
- ageofwant 4y agoPretty disheartening to see the downvotes in a forum like hn which are supposed to be informed about these things. If people that are supposed to be able to critically assess data and have access to as much information they need to verify any claims come to the conclusion that you are full of shit, what hope is there to educate grandpa screaming at the wokes on the street.
- Sharlin 4y agoIt is difficult to get a man to understand something when his startup idea depends upon his not understanding it. –Upton Sinclair, paraphrased
- mempko 4y agoI love technology and have to keep telling my friends that it's possible there won't be a computer industry in 30 years. I'm not joking. Our technology requires a highly complex and organized society to continue to function and develop. Complex and highly organized societies developed under a stable climate. We created societies built on cities that don't move. If you love technology. If you love computers. Then global warming is your biggest threat and something you should care about deeply.
- notabee 4y agoIt's not surprising, actually. The problem with very smart people is that they're often very smart in their particular domains of expertise, but socially they will be treated as just very smart in general. This often leads to an emotional overconfidence in assessing fields outside their domains of expertise, and that extreme cleverness becomes more of a tool to create complex rationalizations of uninformed biases rather than being used humbly, empirically, and diligently as should be the case for a beginner in any topic. And yes, I'm aware that's essentially a paraphrase of the Dunning-Kruger concept. We're all probably making similar assumptions about domains of knowledge we don't know much about, because that's what the brain does. Just like human vision appears solid and complete but is actually a stitched together amalgamation of the small, receptor-dense fovea in the center darting around constantly, and the rest being filled in by the brain instead of direct perception, so is our impression of the world, and we won't know things for sure unless we take time to study them up close.
- eldaisfish 4y agoalso missing is yet another aspect of a very complex system - parched soil has lower ability to retain water. These floods follow an intense heatwave during which large swathes of pakistani soil dried up. Come the rains and you have a massive problem. Like you say, this is just the beginning. If floods like this happen in the Indian plains - and they will - the human and social costs will be immense.
- dylan604 4y agowe just saw this in the DFW area last week. 3 months of triple digit temps and zero precip followed by a single 24 hour period receiving 5-7" of rain. the ground was so hard, that it might as well have been concrete. that just allowed all of the water to run off into the streams that fed the lakes. fortunately, those lakes were well below normal levels, so this just helped them come back to where they were. if there were multiple days of that level of rain, a la Harvey, we'd have been really screwed.
- alexose 4y agoIt's not a foregone conclusion that we're doomed to a life of accelerating climate change. We could deploy solar geoengineering to see us through the transition to renewables. Then, as fossil sources are retired and direct air capture comes online, gradually draw down our geoengineering efforts. It may seem like a non-starter right now, but what about five years from now? What if our best climate models agree that it will do less damage to the planet than allowing the permafrost to thaw?
- AftHurrahWinch 4y agoI think it's a political problem, not a technical problem. If we can imagine that our best climate models could drive decision making to enable geoengineering... why don't our best climate models drive earlier interventions?
- alexose 4y agoGeoengineering is a unique prospect in that it's inexpensive-- Cheap enough that a couple of billionaires could pay for it if they wanted. In terms of interventions, it's a much easier pill to swallow than something in the trillions of dollars. The pushback comes from the risk. While we know that it'll cool the planet, we don't necessarily know how it'll affect weather patterns. If we can figure that out with some level of certainty, I believe there will be a point where the rewards outweigh the risks.
- AftHurrahWinch 4y agoI think there are probably several billionaires who independently have the resources the pursue significant stratospheric aerosol injection. I wonder how such an individual would imagine their liability for stochastic effects on agriculture. Those risks make me think it's most likely a government with a nuclear arsenal would pursue this... perhaps India? Mumbai could become a very difficult place to live in a few decades.
- johnchristopher 4y ago
- hotpotamus 4y ago
- polygamous_bat 4y agoI believe this is one of the largest challenges when trying to make effective changes in the system to address climate change: those whose actions can create the largest changes are not the ones who have to bear the burden first or directly. I really don't know how to appeal to a crowd denying all the evidence, so devoid in empathy for people across the world, while, as an immigrant, I can see my neighboring countries literally drowning.
- buscoquadnary 4y ago> I believe this is one of the largest challenges when trying to make effective changes in the system to address climate change: those whose actions can create the largest changes are not the ones who have to bear the burden first or directly. You mean the corporations and companies that continue to produce emissions on a massive scale while trying to constantly shame me and tell me what a bad person I am for having the audacity to drive to the grocery story once a week or so?
- hotpotamus 4y agoThat's an aspect, but the thing I find the most maddening is that people cast doubt on the science by saying that the effects of changing the mixture of gasses in our atmosphere are ultimately not completely knowable. That's obviously true, but to me that's all the more reason why we probably should avoid doing it as much as possible.
- hackerlight 4y agoI am certain that's part of the psychology. Wealthy people in the colder north know that even if shit hits the fan in poorer and hotter countries, they can pull up the draw bridge and still survive, despite being the people that caused the situation. It's like a long slow genocide perpetrated by a billion people.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> The rate of CO2 accumulating the atmosphere is accelerating It's a small point, but the ratio of CO2 on the atmosphere is definitively not accelerating. On the last couple of decades it has been growing steadily, and the noisy few months look like they have negative acceleration. https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/carbon-dioxide/ https://climate.nasa.gov/vital-signs/carbon-dioxide/
- prpl 4y agono mention of the Hunga Tonga–Hunga Ha'apai eruption? It sounds like that eruption at least changed atmospheric composition by throwing tons of water into it.
- bagels 4y agoDo you have any sources that discuss this?
- morsch 4y agoThe undersea eruption also ejected 146 million tons of South Pacific Ocean water into the stratosphere.[56] The amount of water vapor ejected was 10 percent of the atmosphere's typical stock.[57] It was enough to temporarily warm the surface of Earth. This water vapour was estimated to remain for 5–10 years.[55] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Hunga_Tonga%E2%80%93Hunga_Ha%27apai_eruption_and_tsunami#January_2022 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Hunga_Tonga%E2%80%93Hunga...
- sebazzz 4y agoInteresting as water vapour is in itself also a greenhouse gas.
- bagels 4y agoThanks for sharing this. That certainly is a lot of water.
- throwaway7980 4y ago
- selectodude 4y agoYou could always click on the source that Wikipedia has literally next to the sentence. https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01544-y/ https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01544-y/
- 4y ago
- pornel 4y agoThe extent of the flood is massive: https://static.dw.com/image/62963931_7.png https://static.dw.com/image/62963931_7.png (source: https://www.dw.com/en/pakistanis-outraged-by-inept-government-response-to-monsoon-floods/a-62959022 https://www.dw.com/en/pakistanis-outraged-by-inept-governmen...)
- Erlangen 4y agoThe scale of the flood is crazy. Since the image data is sourced from UNOSAT, I found out more updated data from its website: https://unosat.org/products/ https://unosat.org/products/
- jmyeet 4y agoWhile it's absolutely true there is a confluence of factors here (eg glacial melt, heat wave and a depression) and that these events are more likely with global warming, I'm disappointed this article didn't cover another important factor: dams. Flooding used to be a much bigger problem in the Western United States and it was solved with dams. Yes, there is thd risk of dam failure but we're weighing up the real and present risk of flooding regardless against the possible risk of dam failure. Unfortunately, there has been increasing opposition from the environmental lobby against building dams in the developing world in recent decades (eg [1]) and this matters when such countries are usually dependent on the World Bank and/or IMF to fund their construction. Dams not only reduce the risk of extreme flooding but also provide cheap hydroelectric power, which is of incredible value to a developing nation. Pakistan has some dams but clearly not enough. Given these extreme events that led to this catastrophic flooding are increasingly common and that no action in climate change will change this in the short or even medium term, it's time to build dams. Lots of them. [1]: https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2017/jan/09/dams-building-let-rivers-flow https://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals...
- _eht 4y agoWe need to airdrop more beavers, clearly.
- Melatonic 4y agoThis might actually not be a bad idea. That being said I think a lot of the environments would be too dry for beavers and not contain enough trees. Or conversely be too alpine. So basically we need genetically engineered super beavers that are adapted for high altitude mountaineering. On another note I find it hilarious and also cruel that beavers are apparently absolutely obsessed with stopping the sound of any running water. To the point that if one wanders near your home and can regularly hear water running inside of pipes it drives them crazy.
- andirk 4y agoUsing naturally skilled animals to pick up where we humans either fail or deny an issue is something we should seriously consider as a hedge at this point. If we can get extremely rich people even more rich by doing so, we may have a chance at it catching on.
- CommanderData 4y agoI read someone else suggest Permaculture as a way of mitigating some of the affects of monsoons in these types of areas. Does anyone have any evidences of such a thing working?
- peteradio 4y agoSounds ridiculous on its face, and that is as a practitioner of permaculture. I couldn't really get my head around how it could possibly make even a slight dent against the massive flooding witnessed here.
- loonster 4y agoThe more water that is retained on the property, the less that is available for entering streams.
- bergenty 4y agoLots of small water retaining walls and pits makes it so it doesn’t run off and accumulate in some low central area.
- Panino 4y agoWhen Gabe Brown switched from conventional agriculture to regenerative agriculture, he increased water infiltration in his soil from 0.5 inches (1.25cm) per hour to 30 inches (75cm) per hour. So imagine if he and all his neighbors had the same beautiful soil -- flooding just couldn't happen. I haven't seen a list of such measurements from permaculture, but I know it can be used to regreen deserts (as shown in Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Arizona and elsewhere). And I assume permaculture vastly increases water infiltration. Geoff Lawton has videos showing Zaytuna Farm happily surviving drought and flood alike. If farmers switched from conventional agriculture to some combination of regenerative agriculture and permaculture, most flooding would be prevented. Their own fields would easily infiltrate rain, eliminating runoff that builds up into flooding. The article mentions that in addition to Pakistan getting double the normal amount of rain, increased glacier melt is filling the Indus river. I assume that in the theoretical situation of all farmers in Pakistan practicing regenerative ag or permaculture, that land on the Indus would flood. But not 1/3 of the country as we're seeing now, and the flooded areas would recover faster.
- baybal2 4y agoBecause rains been going on for so long this years. Heavy rains went for 2+ months so far across different parts of the country. Way longer that 1-2 weeks intense monsoon downpour.
- raffraffraff 4y ago"You have two life lines left: 50/50, and ask the audience" "I'm gonna go with A. Climate change "
- umvi 4y agoClimate change has made us all incredibly intellectually lazy. Literally anything happens and we don't bother trying to understand why past "climate change". Natural disaster? Climate change. More or less insects/birds/rodents than usual? Climate change. More or less rain/snow/hail/heat/cold/storms/floods/droughts than usual? Climate change. Wildfire? Climate fire. Crypto currencies using record breaking amounts of electricity year over year? Climate change (impoverished countries ravaged by climate change turn to crypto currencies to escape their local inflated currency which further exacerbates climate change in a positive feedback loop - see what I mean?). In all of these cases climate change may indeed be a piece of the puzzle, but due to intellectual laziness it has become the vast majority of the pie and we don't bother to understand if there are other factors more influential than climate change.
- munk-a 4y agoClimate change is happening and most of us live in a country (or next to a country, yay Canada!) where half the political body actively denies that it is happening and refuses to take action. As long as half of America continues to engage in such dangerous denialism there is no amount of drum beating that is excessive.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoThere are so many things factually incorrect here > most of us live in a country No we don't > here half the political body actively denies By actively deny, you mean that they force everyone like you? If you mean that, then it's factually wrong. > no amount of drum beating that is excessive. Umm, as a suggestion you should look for more effective way of convincing people.
- marcosdumay 4y ago
- mring33621 4y agoClimate change is real and has changed the temporal distribution of rainfall, often increasing the interval between rainfalls, while also increasing the amount that falls, during rainy periods. Longer durations of 'no rain' cause the ground harden to a much less porous, concrete-like surface that cannot absorb the rain, when it does come, fast enough. So the water pools and flows, causing flood conditions.
- nerdponx 4y agoThe article also blames high amounts of glacial melt (to the point of bursting through glacial dams) sending a lot of extra water through waterways in a short amount of time.
- sremani 4y agoWith all due respect why are Glaciers melting in August.. or July or June. April and May are hot as hell in Indian Subcontinent. edit: glaciers melt in summer, I am surprised why they are melting in rainy season. No matter how you vote, just explain why this odd behavior.
- aeternum 4y agoExcept it has happened about every 12 years throughout history The ancients even created a name for it: La Nina.
- 4y ago
- zackees 4y ago
- rr888 4y agoReminder that population is Pakistan's population 6x it was at 1950. In 2050 its expected to be 370 million people compared to 37 million in 1950. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Pakistan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Pakistan
- hh3k0 4y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here and say that Pakistan's population in 2050 will be closer to 37 million than to 370 million.
- rr888 4y agoNukes?
- o_m 4y agoThe population of a country peaks a few years after it has gotten developed. As in low child mortality, high educated population, etc.
- CydeWeys 4y agoWhat countries do you think this is true of? Even, say, France is still growing. Let alone the US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- meowtimemania 4y agoAre those countries growing with birth rates alone? I thought immigration was what was helping the populations stay stable
- highwaylights 4y agoUS birth rate: 1.70 France birth rate: 1.87 Japan birth rate: 1.36 Pakistan birth rate: 3.45 So Pakistan, unlike many more developed countries, has a birth rate higher than the replacement rate, but significantly lower than it’s 1950 to 2000 highs over 6 - and trending downwards. The population would be expected to drop precipitously, but not soon.
- andyjohnson0 4y ago"Pakistan is home to over 7,200 glaciers, more than anywhere outside the poles. Rising temperatures, linked to climate change, are likely making many of them melt faster and earlier, adding water to rivers and streams that are already swollen by rainfall." https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2022/8/30/23327341/pakistan-flooding-monsoon-melting-glaciers-climate-change https://www.vox.com/science-and-health/2022/8/30/23327341/pa...
- nomel 4y ago> Pakistan is home to over 7,200 glaciers, more than anywhere outside the poles It seems odd to give a measure of ice as the count of the pieces.
- booboofixer 4y agoSee 'List of longest glaciers on Earth in non-polar regions' https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_glaciers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_glaciers
- nomel 4y ago57 is much less than 7,200.
- booboofixer 4y agoIm lost, what unit of measurement would satisfy your doubts about the presence of a lot of glaciers in Pakistan?
- throwaway09223 4y agoKind of, right? But it also makes sense. We might talk about a highly populated country having a lot of cities -- even though cities are just somewhat loosely defined pieces of the population total.
- MichaelZuo 4y ago
- bmismyname 4y agoHigher temperatures mean more moisture in the atmosphere and aridification at the same time. That's why there can be drought plus record breaking rainfall at the same time. Plus, when you have drought, it damages the soil and plant life which would normally aid in capturing and retaining the rainfall. And when the rain does fall, instead of being absorbed into the soil it just creates erosion instead as the top layer dies. People think about soil as just dirt, which it is not. Soil is effectively a living organism (or ecosystem of organisms).
- ok_dad 4y agoCrazy to think we might actually kill the soil. Imagine a place like mars, because of the soil dies so will everything else.
- ErikVandeWater 4y agoI'd love to see nature write an article about why a certain part of the world has had such unusually moderate temperature and precipitation of late. Also, if you want to search the whole globe for something extreme happening, you're guaranteed to find it in spades.
- jamiek88 4y agoWhat does this even mean? Are you denying that climate change is a thing? Now? In 2022?
- nyc_data_geek1 4y agoA sadly prevalent line of rhetoric here on HN. We could be living on venusian Earth and some HN pedant would be splitting hairs
- wahnfrieden 4y agowaiting for absolute apocalypse before taking up a curious mind about it
- esperent 4y agoFor example, if you search through the whole globe for people holding extreme anti-science views denying climate change in the face of overwhelming evidence, you'll find literally millions of them.
- bosswipe 4y agoHere's what the temperature anomaly looks like for "the whole globe" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haBG2IIbwbA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=haBG2IIbwbA
- Nydhal 4y agoclimate change.
- butUhmErm 4y agoI clicked back through the years available for my city on weatherspark.com Back in the 90s, never above 90-91 in Sept. In the last 10 years we started seeing 94-95 in Sept. Coincidentally air travel has doubled in that time period; from 2.25 billion people flying in 2010 to 4.56 billion in 2019. Of course that cratered since 2020. Thanks AirBnB and other apps that make burning fossil fuels a thoughtless, trivial thing?
- humanistbot 4y ago> Thanks AirBnB and other apps that make burning fossil fuels a thoughtless, trivial thing? Your outrage is misdirected to something you probably personally relate to. Leisure travel is a minuscule component of the carbon in the atmosphere. Leisure travel is a fly hitching a ride on the beast that is global logistics, and AirBnb making leisure travel slightly cheaper and easier is a drop in the bucket for all leisure travel in general.
- butUhmErm 4y ago“Outrage”. Your qualification of my emotions is way off. 2.4% when talking tonnes may be a small percent relative to the “big picture” but it’s not 0 tonnes, it has an impact, and production of machines to produce planes, production of more planes to keep up with rising demand are not included in that 2.4%. Leisure travel across the planet is not exactly a requirement for the survival of the species. It’s still pushing our choices onto future humans. Since statistics are what matters to you; you’re one of seven billion; your perspective is not that important. Probably best to avoid overly reductive rhetoric, the basis of which (statistical relevance) can be easily used against you. More co2 is released in service of the airline industry than just planes flying. The world is not made of singular statistical objects in a vacuum.
- andirk 4y agoI doubt people going on a vacation a couple times per year is even a line item in the list of causes of burning fossil fuels. However, at the beginning of the pandemic, with fewer cargo vessels and even fewer personal vehicles burning fuel, we saw a measureable improvement to the environment within days.
- aaaaaasss 4y ago
- aaaaaasss 4y ago
- yrgulation 4y agoPersistent corruption and poor management.