9 ms·
California asks people not to charge EVs during heatwave
- Proven 4y ago
- 16890c 4y agoWell, this would suck if you banned combustion engines state-wide. Oh wait...
- chrjxnandns 4y ago
- cloutchaser 4y ago
- vlovich123 4y agoIf you read, it’s promising that EVs can actuallly be upgraded with tech that will have EVs plugged in will be a great help. And banning them now isn’t going to have a meaningful impact on the number of EVs this summer. The thing that’s despicable is the lack of nuclear power. A few more plants would completely stabilize the grid.
- workingon 4y agoYeah the rest of the world is thrilled that you want to build nuclear power plants on the most famous fault line in the world.
- vlovich123 4y agoYup. 1. Nuclear can be built safely to handle emergency scenarios. It's not the catastrophe you see in movies. Fukushima which used a very primitive design, suffered from bad maintenance, and suffered a historic tsunami, still was kept fairly safe. 2. You don't built right ON the fault line. Electricity delivery over long distances is a thing even without HVDC. The fault lines for Diablo Canyon were discovered after the fact but the design was adjusted to handle that information. 3. New reactor designs are waaay better. And guess what. The more reactors we build, the more nuclear scientists there are, the better we get at building them. Why do you think America, the country that invented nuclear power, has 55 plants while China ALREADY has 47 with another 11 along the way while most construction started ~7 years ago. China is going to absolutely OWN the US on energy policy unless we get our head in the game.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> China is going to absolutely OWN the US on energy policy unless we get our head in the game. Pretty much already has. Their wind, solar and hydro build out has slightly outpaced their nuclear as well. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-elec-by-source?country=~CHN https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-elec-by-source?coun...
- vlovich123 4y agoI guess a nuclear reactor is only 2 typical coal plants so they'll need to 10x their current nuclear capacity to get rid of coal. The only annoying thing is they're still building coal plants. I don't understand what I'm missing since nuclear is supposed to be cheaper. Maybe SNF still poses a logistical challenge they can't handle vs venting CO2 into the atmosphere.
- hk1337 4y agoNuclear power is good for providing base power not for reacting to spikes in demand. You cannot just spin up production of a nuclear power plant when you need it and shut it down when you don’t. They’re always producing so when demand is low, they’re producing too much and wasting it. If the California grid cannot meet its demand at its lowest, then yes, base power like nuclear would be a good solution. Heatwaves generally pass though.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoA surplus of energy is always better than a deficit. You could have scheduled applications to divert the energy to if storage is not built out. Desalinate the pacific, for example, pump the water inland for drought time when supply exceeds demand.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYou could charge the EVs. But it seems very hard to find someone who likes both nuclear power and EVs despite them being so well suited.
- tjansen 4y agoThat's pretty much the same issue you have with renewables, especially wind. Sometimes it will just produce more than you need. The solution is the same: use overproduction to produce hydrogen or for desalination plants. It's actually easier in the case of nuclear, because demand is more predictable than weather, and you have excess energy day, not only on a few days per week or month.
- zibby8 4y ago> The solution is the same: use overproduction to produce hydrogen or for desalination plants. Does anywhere actually do this? Storing hydrogen at scale seems insanely difficult and desalinating water wouldn't let you use the energy later. AFAIK, most places deal with surplus energy by putting it into a big battery, usually the physical kind of battery like pumping water up hill and holding it behind a hydroelectric dam.
- themitigating 4y agoSince they haven't banned combustion cars nor will they in the near future your comment has no value
- pwarner 4y agoBetween 4 PM and 9 PM. Everyone charges at night anyways I think? Even without an elictricity shortage, it's expensive between 4 and 9..
- Sakos 4y agoI would assume that the load through EV charging starts increasingly rapidly after work, which is precisely in that time period. But it's also not like they're singling out EV's. They mention a number of measures they'd like people to take to reduce electricity consumption.
- msh 4y agoBut most EV's have settings to do delayed charging. In mine I can set it to either start charging after XX:XX or I can set it to be ready at a certain time, fx 7:00 in the morning. Some chargers also supports these settings.
- pwg 4y agoIn the deep past, given how many VCR clocks remained at 12:00 because their owners never set the clock, how many EV owners to you think are going to bother explicitly setting a "charge time" in their EV? Unless it ships from the factory with "charge only during hours X to Y" preset and turned on, the vast majority are not going to get set for a delayed charge time, and will simply charge whenever plugged in. And their owners are likely to "plug them in" at the end of every trip so they are sure to be "topped up" for their next trip.
- zamfi 4y ago> Unless it ships from the factory with "charge only during hours X to Y" preset and turned on, Hey look, you answered your own question!
- mechagodzilla 4y agoMy utility gives me half-rate electricity if I charge after midnight ($0.11/kwh vs $0.23/kwh) - people will line up and wait for 20 minutes or drive across town to buy gas that's $0.03/gallon cheaper, I think they'll figure out how to set the 'delay charging' option on their car if it gives them the equivalent of half-off gas prices.
- formvoltron 4y agokind of ridiculous when there is sun that is causing a heatwave. sun. install some more panels folks.
- MisterTea 4y ago> install some more panels folks. You paying?
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoPanels are great for VERY SPECIFIC USE CASES. They do not fill the role of energy security. You need reliable , clean nuclear plants. The ones from fifty years ago are great, imagine what we could do if the fucking NRC stopped adding such incredibly dumb and onerous requirements on any new permits for new tech.
- themitigating 4y agoThe VERY SPECIFIC case is adding power to the grid? How many other situations besides continuous power and intermittent power exist that makes it a "very specific" case?
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoI can add as much power to the grid as i want to, if there's no storage and demand is low, that makes zero difference to the grid. Storage being what it is, we either accept the costs of routine (10 year cycle) swap outs or we dont. Simple. Oh, and please remember that present demand will be a fraction of future demand and hence any storage you build must grow in capacity over time. Photovoltaics serve a very specific use case of aiding domestic energy production at times when conditions are right. They are great for a lot of reasons, but for cases where there is a high demand for reliable supply such as industries producing things, they are . . not the first choice. Given the equivalent amount of dollars spent by an entity as large as the state of California, with the laws of physics as we know them today, there is only one logical solution in Nuclear energy. The energy density and scale just can not be beaten.
- duxup 4y agoIn Minnesota I signed up for a device that the electric company installs on the electrical connection to our AC unit. Between 2pm and 7pm (I think those are the hours) the company can shut down your AC for 20 minutes at a time. I can think of twice in 15 years that I noticed it. For that you get a small discount on power June through September. Good deal. I like that this allows for more immediate / targeted impact for folks managing the grid. Something like this for car charging (or even just slower charging?) might be useful? https://mn.my.xcelenergy.com/s/residential/heating-cooling/savers-switch https://mn.my.xcelenergy.com/s/residential/heating-cooling/s...
- jamesrom 4y agoIt's great that you're doing your part to help the grid. But we don't need to live life in low-battery mode. There is another option.
- duxup 4y agoWell we don’t because it is hardly ever used.
- Havoc 4y agoAlso works with electric boilers and ripple switches. They can hold temp for 24h+ so you don’t easily notice if the supplier kills it for a couple hours
- 1123581321 4y agoWhat’s the discount? We have a similar device in northern Illinois and only get $10 off four months each year.
- duxup 4y ago15% June through September. Updated my post after I looked it up. I got a few details wrong initially.
- 4y ago
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoBuild a FUCKTON of nuclear plants and never worry about a fucking electricity bill ever again. Want to keep the Air conditioning on while you're not even home? Yup, No one cares. Want to run an audacious amount of carbon capture devices near dense population centers? Yep, absolutely. Want to desalinate the waters of the pacific and have it ready to pump inland during large scale drought? OF COURSE!!! The trouble with Nuclear is that it invalidates all the reasons for "Green" politicians to impose excessively wasteful and stupid ideas that dont work, but serve as a slush fund. If we wanted to solve this great pressing carbon emissions problem, we would be building a large nuclear base. For anyone who's reading this comment and thinking "Wow, AC all day?? What a wasteful way to live!" Congratulations. You are immune to the audacity of using science to solve problems that previous generations considered impossible. An infinite amount of energy represents the greatest opportunity for humanity for a thousand years. We should have invested and take a giant leap in our quality of life half a century ago.
- generalizations 4y agoUncouth way of putting it, but I think you hit the nail on the head. A massive increase in the available energy supply would allow us to do things we can barely dream of these days. To me, it almost feels like energy availability corresponds to how advanced the society is, and from that perspective it's weird to me that there's such a push for actually reducing our energy usage and output.
- TheDudeMan 4y agoWant a ton of cheap hydrogen for all your clean non-battery vehicles/rockets? You got it.
- sergiotapia 4y agoIn the US what political party is the "Nuclear Party"? This is one of the major things I'm going to be looking for come voting season.
- jgwil2 4y agoNone. We have a "Fossil Fuels Party" and a "Renewables Party."
- crims0n 4y agoCan someone provide a reasonably unbiased take on the state of Californias electric grid? From the outside looking in, it seems their push towards renewables was perhaps too aggressive and now they are having issues meeting demand - but admittedly (living on the east coast) I am pretty ignorant on the intricacies.
- theshrike79 4y agoAs far as I know, the problem in the US in general isn't the amount of power they can produce. They have the prodcution and installation capacity to put up huge amounts of renewables (solar + wind) in a short time. BUT the problem is that their electric grid is World War 1 era tech in many parts. The Camp Fire[0] fire was caused by close to 100 year old power lines mechanically failing. This combined with the insane amount of permits and licenses needed to install new power lines makes this a tough nut to crack. (IIRC _anyone_ can complain about a transfer line as long as they can see it from their property.) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_Fire_(2018) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camp_Fire_(2018)
- inanutshellus 4y agoI'm also surprised to see this in context of the mandate that came this week from California to retire fossil fuel vehicles. If current population and load is straining their power grid because it's hot they have some serious infrastructure to implement before 2035 rolls around. I'm sure it's not lost on anyone, just... the timing on the two articles is noteworthy.
- manicdee 4y agoA grid mostly powered by thermal electricity is going to struggle when it gets hot. California does have serious infrastructure issues, mostly due to deliberate lack of maintenance on the part f the commercial operators trying to squeeze every dollar of profit out of their ageing infrastructure. There’s an entire distribution grid that needs to be replaced before it literally falls apart. California has had problematic energy supply since the ‘80s. The problems have been getting steadily worse due to lack of maintenance, lack of upgrades, heat waves getting longer and more numerous, more frequent droughts, and poor water resource management. There are a lot of people pushing this article on every social network. It’s a rude awakening to see how many people just take the headline and run with it before they spend any time considering the claims in the context of reality.
- mfer 4y agoAlong with this, California is phasing out ICE cars. Which will only make the power issues worse. Who is working to make the California power grid (and the other grids in general) capable of handling the shift away from ICE cars?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y agoEV are helpful, because we can charge them when we consume little energy (at night) or when we generated to much renewable energy (solar). We just have to incentivize charging at the right time and to pay EV owner to make their battery available for the grid as a virtual power plant (see https://www.tesla.com/support/energy/powerwall/own/california-virtual-power-plant https://www.tesla.com/support/energy/powerwall/own/californi... currently set up for powerwalls but could support EV once most of their battery are LFP)
- msh 4y agoI am not from the US but I have a somewhat intelligent charger. It can communicate with the power company and be set to only charge my EV when the load is not high (it still guarantee the amount I want charged, so I wont risk not having my car charged). If thats turned on they give me an approx 12% rebate.
- mleo 4y agoI am in Southern California and have special EV electric rate that offers much lower rate between 9PM and 1PM. However, between 1PM and 9PM, the rate is a bit higher overall. The charger has this info and won’t generally start charging the car until that time unless overridden.
- 1over137 4y agoCalifornia should be asking people not to buy EVs at all! They should be massively investing in public transport and active transport. But no, the obsession with private automobile ownership will continue to damn us all.
- vsareto 4y agoIf we can't afford houses, we'll at least need a car.
- zamfi 4y agoThe state is doing a lot on all three of these fronts. Public transport is hard because construction costs are absurdly high in areas of high density, there aren’t enough people in areas with low density, and asinine restrictive zoning prevents increasing density over time. But it is happening. In the meantime, people love their cars, and will continue to drive them. Banning cars entirely would disproportionately affect folks who have to commute long distances to afford housing, not great. So might as well mandate that the fleet turn over to something less harmful to the planet’s ability to support our way of life.
- papercrane 4y agoAssuming the Governor signs the bill they will be giving a $1000 tax credit for people who don't own a car. They put an income cap on it though, so I doubt it will have much impact. https://www.phillytrib.com/california-wants-to-give-residents-1-000-not-to-have-a-car/article_485650a6-69f7-5aa1-b133-453cfb57a7d8.html https://www.phillytrib.com/california-wants-to-give-resident...
- generalizations 4y agoI seriously doubt that $1000 is worth the inconvenience of not having a car. How often do you leave the city? Those car rentals add up fast.
- papercrane 4y agoIt depends on individual circumstances. A thousand dollars plus no car payment, parking, insurance, maintenance, and fuel costs vs. public transit, occasional Uber and car rental might be attractive for some. It would've been much more effective though if they had gone with the original plan of $2,500 and no income limit.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago
- helf 4y agoI hate this sort of reporting/commentating. "Hur hur they wanna ban new gas vehicles but now asking people to not charge their EVs!! hahah what morons" ok, what? That plan is years out. And it is specifically because of issues like these heatwaves that they are attempting to push through new rules. And there is the obvious plan on massive infrastructure upgrading between now and the mandate. I mean, really, wtf? I am so tired of the braindead low hanging fruit "reporting" you see everywhere.