22 ms·
FAA approves unleaded fuel for piston fleet
- jimnotgym 4y agoSo when are we seeing the sunset date of leaded fuel? The government should step in and set it to help the industry move along
- unglaublich 4y agoIt will stay around as long as it's free to poison the environment with lead.
- sokoloff 4y agoOriginal headline seemed far less communicative (and was far too long to use in the submission), so I did the best I could to faithfully summarize. For the record, the original headline/subheadline is: GA moves closer to unleaded future FAA approves GAMI unleaded avgas STCs covering piston fleet
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwawayx134ax 4y agoThis is great! Expect the EPA and the FAA to finally ban 100LL, which will be a great boon for everyone. Note, you will require an STC, but not poising yourself with lead will probably net out the costs in the long run. * I am a pilot of piston engines, and I really don't like 100LL being the only option
- V-eHGsd_ 4y agoul94 has been around for a year or so (I've had the stc since last december), but yeah for high compression engines, it was 100LL or nothing. I'm hoping the stc is comparably priced, $100 or so. this is really awesome. edit to add: for the non av geeks, an stc is a supplemental type certificate. it's basically an faa stamp that says, "this aircraft has been changed from when it was initially certified, but it's an approved change" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supplemental_type_certificate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supplemental_type_certificate
- sokoloff 4y agoGeorge Braly in the video interview indicated it would be similarly priced to the Petersen STC, which used to be $1/rated HP and now appears to be $2/rated HP. In short: it’s no barrier whatsoever to adoption.
- V-eHGsd_ 4y agoso a little more expensive than the swift stc but yeah still totally worth it.
- NikolaNovak 4y agoNice. I hope this ushers approvals across the planet. I am just starting the journey to private license in Canada and I kinda hate how inefficient, but also how primitive and unhealthy the engines and fuel are :-/
- avalys 4y agoThe engines are actually fairly efficient. Unlike an automobile engine, they really only operate in a very narrow range and are usually run at a substantial fraction of full power (60% or more). Automobile engines are very challenging because the power demands are highly variable and they can’t be optimized for any specific load.
- bombcar 4y agoAmusingly enough the Piper Cherokee I flew got better ground gas mileage than the '66 Fury I had at the time.
- ketzo 4y agoWow, that’s a hilarious stat. How is that even… possible?
- sokoloff 4y ago1960s cars were terribly inefficient is a big part of the story.
- NonNefarious 4y agoIt's quite possible for a plane to net higher mileage than many cars today, especially light-sport planes that only burn 5 gallons per hour or so.
- Filligree 4y agoYes, but this was while taxiing.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoPrevious: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30943466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30943466
- stevage 4y agoHuh. I had no idea leaded fuel was still a thing in aviation.
- na85 4y agoIt lets you run comparatively higher manifold pressures than an otherwise identical but unleaded fuel.
- bombcar 4y agoMore importantly most aviation engines were designed in the 50-70s and need the lead to keep the valves happy.
- p_l 4y agoAnother issue is that replacements for TEL that were fine for cars had issues with high altitudes (and high ambient temperatures)
- NonNefarious 4y agoIt's about detonation; I don't think it's about the valves.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoIt's about the valves. Plenty of 100+ octane unleaded fuels out there.
- bombcar 4y agoThe 100 octane is about detonation; the lead is about lubricant for the valves.
- NonNefarious 4y agoMmmm, not sure about that: https://generalaviationnews.com/2011/10/24/why-lead-reduces-knock/ https://generalaviationnews.com/2011/10/24/why-lead-reduces-...
- humanwhosits 4y agoI sure hope they ban the leaded fuel soon
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mips_avatar 4y agoI live by lake union in Seattle, and I love watching the seaplanes taking off and landing. It's high time that there's a lead-free option. Seattle doesn't need that kind of lead in its air.
- walrus01 4y agoThe rotary engine tech in a DHC beaver is barely changed from WW2 era rotary piston engines... Assuming we're not talking about the more modern turbine beavers and otters. The turbine ones already run on Jet-A
- s800 4y agoRotary or radial?
- repiret 4y agoRadial.
- walrus01 4y agoMy brain was clearly not working right when I wrote that, though the mental image of a Mazda RX-7 engine strapped to the front of a beaver is certainly amusing.
- dreamcompiler 4y agoWonder if anybody ever tried that. Somebody must have, decided the gallons per hour was ridiculously high, and abandoned the idea.
- mechanical_bear 4y agoIn a similar way, there are kit planes which use EJ and EA series Subaru engines. These tend to be a bit more fuel efficient than Mazda rotaries though.
- clamprecht 4y agoHow will California cities justify closing general aviation airports now?
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoNoise
- V-eHGsd_ 4y agonoise. "the airplanes landing at this airport that was here when I moved are very loud and should not be allowed to land here anymore."
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoThis is a standard in my country but with farm smells and noises. People buy a house "in the country", then they complain about manure on fields, cows mooing and tractor noises.
- shitlord 4y agoThey could also argue that the airplanes will cast a shadow on neighboring parks/houses.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoConsidering that FAA lowered a bunch of flight paths over the last ~5 years, kinda feels like a bait and switch. My parents' place was always pretty quiet since it's 20+ miles from the nearest major airport, but after FAA Nextgen was implemented it got fairly noisy from all the airliners passing over.
- clamprecht 4y agoI'm curious, where did this happen?
- Rebelgecko 4y agoKONT, here's a video of the NIMBY (NOMBY?) complaints: https://youtu.be/MenUDN35uCM https://youtu.be/MenUDN35uCM
- sv123 4y agoWow, I can't believe they got it done. After watching all the Paul Bertorelli videos on it I assumed it would be stuck in bureaucracy from here to eternity. Incredible work by the whole team, very exciting.
- NonNefarious 4y agoAgreed, but sadly it's still a niche fuel. Although I have to admit that for a (hopefully) brief time, we've seen airplane gas and corner-gas-station gas the same price in California! I think that unless a large number of GA airplanes can run on true automotive gas (which means gasohol now) in the near future, GA is doomed. This is something the industry should have been tackling with abandon for the last 20 years. But they failed to take lead seriously for the last 50, so can we expect better? Maybe. I think there is one Rotax engine that can run on gosohol (10% ethanol). We need much more of that, and widespread adoption of fuel injection and electronic ignition ASAP. Oh, and we need more people to stand up for their local airports. Corrupt local politicians, developers, and fake-NIMBY land speculators are all arrayed to destroy our nation's aviation infrastructure for personal profit. Even airlines are in on it. Innovations like this unleaded fuel and electrification will cease if there's no place to deploy them.
- sokoloff 4y ago“George Braly, chief engineer at GAMI, said the fuel can be made with components “that are found inside the fence of any refinery.”” Now, that quote comes from the principal at GAMI and in a GAMI newsletter, but over the last decade and a half of following this, I’ve found him to be pretty damned straightforward. https://gami.com/g100ul/AvGas0211.pdf https://gami.com/g100ul/AvGas0211.pdf
- boppo1 4y agoLowering the financial barrier to entry would help. Idk how, but part of the industry's problem is that people who want to learn to fly can't afford to.
- LadyCailin 4y ago
- kurupt213 4y agoHow do they replace the lubricating function of the triethyl lead?
- orangepurple 4y agoI hope not by burning PFAS (lol)
- kurupt213 4y agoYou jest but a fluorinated hydrocarbon is probably particularly well suited for the task
- orangepurple 4y agoI think they worked around the detonation problem by using massive concentrations of MTBE, methanol, and an organic manganese aromatic compound to keep corrosion at bay
- kurupt213 4y agoMTBE...something else absolutely horrible for you when the leaking underground storage tank (LUST) contaminates the water table.
- orangepurple 4y agoEh... the Methylcyclopentadienyl Manganese Tricarbonyl (MMT) seems worse to me. Instead of burning lead they're now going to burn organic bound manganese and manganese causes some god awful diseases.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoI'm not so sure they're trying to compensate for any lubricating features of lead. See my other message for what's really going to be in this fuel. They are using hydrocarbon enhancements that have already been a smaller natural component of unleaded gasoline since forever. MMT could only have ever been a consideration after toxic lead was well accepted, and then it was too late to become mainstream. MTBE is Methyl tert-Butyl Ether, which is a form of ether that does not evaporate as fast as the traditional Diethyl Ether which people might be more familiar with as a medical product. The diethyl ether is almost like a gas, not nearly as much as butane but it's getting there. In the laboratory the diethyl ether commonly comes in a metal can to protect from overpressure if it gets too warm. The MTBE can be stored in an ordinary bottle like alcohol. But whew do people remark about about the sharp ether odor when you open a bottle of MTBE. When MTBE was in lots of gasolines, and the underground tanks had been leaking down into aquifers further underground, that smell in peoples' water turned out to be the canary in the coal mine which indicated that other more toxic gasoline components were bound to be there too. MTBE was shamed then lost more popularity than the gasoline itself after that, in an exaggerated way with political implications leading to ethanol. I don't think everybody would want the general public to be able to smell leaking tanks in the future as well as they could when this issue first came up anyway. However there have been some experimental medical treatments which involved directly injecting patients locally with truly strong concentrations of MTBE as a natural liquid. Unlike the diethyl ether as an anesthetic which was basically breathed in as a gas.
- dfgert 4y agoI am shocked to read this. Why are they still using leaded fuel? There are so many well known research that links lead in fuel to unstable mental health and crime in population.
- andrepd 4y ago
- neximo64 4y agoCessna's are used to access small regions in many countries can't even be accessed if it wasn't for a Cessna due to lack of funds, places that take up to 3 days by motorcycle. The fuel mix is basically copied worldover. I believe the typical American who sees the upper middle class, the same way the rest of the world sees america as.
- S201 4y agoOh please. Single engine planes are far more than toys for rich people. General aviation is training new airline pilots, medical flights, aerial surveying, charter flights otherwise inaccessible areas, and a method to fly supplies to areas during emergencies. This level of ignorance is extremely frustrating.
- worewood 4y agoYeah, but what is the proportion of these flights relative to rich-people hobby flights? That matters.
- tjohns 4y agoQuick napkin math here... The estimate is that about 65% of general aviation traffic is related to "business and public services". [1][2] The other 35% is personal in nature. From that, about 22% is flight instruction for new pilots - most of whom are trying to get into the airlines. [3] So that would mean about 13% of general aviation is recreational. (Also, for what it's worth, many general aviation pilots I know aren't rich by any stretch.) [1]: https://download.aopa.org/hr/Report_on_General_Aviation_Trends.pdf https://download.aopa.org/hr/Report_on_General_Aviation_Tren... [2]: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-GAO-01-916/html/GAOREPORTS-GAO-01-916.htm https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-GAO-01-916/ht... [3]: http://www.dviaviation.com/files/45181042.pdf http://www.dviaviation.com/files/45181042.pdf
- bmismyname 4y agoFun fact: many major US cities still have lead pipes[1]. It costs about $20,000 to replace a lead service line from the water main to your home if you live in an older home/building, and the cities are not exactly working hard to replace lead mains. The cheapest way to lower your risk of lead exposure is to install an RO filter if you believe there are lead pipes (there are many different brands, but the one from APEC is popular and affordable). It has the added benefit of reducing exposure to other nasty things which have pretty much contaminated all the drinking water on earth like PFAS. I have an unsubstantiated pet theory on correlation between lead poisoning and crime in poorer neighbourhoods due to landlords refusing to replace these (why bother if you don't have to drink the water? landlords have no incentive so long as they can extract rents). In many cities you can get your water tested for free by the city, just do some searching. They've usually got an online form you can fill out and they'll send you a kit that you have to send back. [1]: https://www.nrdc.org/resources/lead-pipes-are-widespread-and-used-every-state https://www.nrdc.org/resources/lead-pipes-are-widespread-and...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 4y agoAt least you can prevent leeching from lead pipes. Can't really stop the lead from getting out of an engine.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amluto 4y ago> The cheapest way to lower your risk of lead exposure is to install an RO filter That’s much more expensive than the average NSF-listed filter. I believe most of them work by ion exchange, and they are a lot simpler and cheaper than RO. Get RO if you have serious hardness issues or taste issues that are not mitigated by a good NSF-listed filter with a carbon stage. https://www.nsf.org/news/concerned-about-lead-drinking-water-choose-filter-certified-to-reduce-lead https://www.nsf.org/news/concerned-about-lead-drinking-water... > if you believe there are lead pipes Just test your water. Even without lead pipes, lead solder on copper pipes can be a problem. Or lead in city pipes. Or anything made out of non-“lead free” brass or bronze. (Some of the latter has a shockingly high proportion of lead in the alloy.)
- TedShiller 4y agoWe live in an age where "less terrible" is sold as "great".
- bmismyname 4y agoIt'll keep working until it stops. You'd think that with Wikipedia and all the information at our fingertips people would be able to tell a sheep from a wolf, but instead they're more likely to believe the authoritative talk show host because that person makes the tribal signals they like the best.
- missedthecue 4y agoI'd hate to live in a world where no achievement is worthy of celebration unless it passes all your purity tests
- TedShiller 4y agoYou do
- aaaaaasss 4y ago
- ramesh31 4y ago>FAA approves unleaded fuel for piston fleet Yay! Primary flight training costs will come down 20-30%! >While the cost of the fuel has not been determined, Braly said the small-batch production process that will initially earmark the arrival of G100UL at airports means that the fuel will cost slightly more than leaded avgas. “Small volume batches cost money,” he said. “Until we can get [production] revved up that we’re making millions of gallons at a time, there will be an incremental [additional] cost,” he said. Oh.
- outworlder 4y agoGive it time.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoCongratulations to GAMI. They are a really interesting and innovative small company. Their calibrated fuel injectors are a great upgrade for many planes letting you save 5-15% of fuel. They make an innovative turbo system for the Cessna Cardinal that is quite a challenge. But taking on the task of creating an unleaded avgas and shepherding it through an arduous approval process for literally decades.. Good for them. (GAMI is still independently owned, right? Sometimes it feels like the last American GA company that wasn't bought by a Chinese aviation company.)
- davidwihl 4y agoI took their in-person class in Ada, OK back in the day. Highly recommended the training material. https://www.advancedpilot.com/ https://www.advancedpilot.com/ They have a great test bed for validating their science.
- sokoloff 4y agoI took that same course (in Fall 2013 I think); it was excellent. Sadly, both John and Walter have passed away, leaving only George as the last amigo standing.
- IncRnd 4y agoWhen I read your comment too quickly, I saw Ada training. [1] Of course, you meant what you wrote, Ada, OK! [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_(programming_language) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ada_(programming_language) [2] https://adaok.com/ https://adaok.com/
- greggsy 4y agoI recall watching a YouTube video a little while back that went into the modern history of light aircraft engines, and how there have been several failed attempts at redesigning existing technology over the past 20 (40?) years. Is it genuinely workable? Or is there some weird edge case that makes it completely impractical from a maintenance or reliability perspective?
- 4y ago
- supernova87a 4y agoWhat was the innovation? A new different chemical additive to take the place of lead? Does it require any hardware changes to work right? (spark plugs, etc)
- outworlder 4y agoThe whole point is that it had to be a drop-in replacement.
- marcelo123 4y ago
- martincmartin 4y agoWait, airplanes don't already use unleaded fuel?
- skykooler 4y agoJets do (as well as turboprops), but piston-engine planes (aka almost all general aviation aircraft) currently burn leaded gasoline.
- midoridensha 4y agoJets and turboprops do not use "unleaded fuel", they use jet fuel (which is basically kerosene). "Unleaded fuel" doesn't mean any fuel without lead, it specifically means gasoline (petrol) without lead. Hydrogen gas (or liquid) can be used as a fuel, but no one would call it "unleaded fuel".
- throwthere 4y agoReminds me of the xkcd comic-- https://xkcd.com/641/ https://xkcd.com/641/
- midoridensha 4y agoYeah, that one is exactly like all the "gluten free!" stuff being marketed, which never had gluten in the first place.
- codalan 4y agohttps://www.faa.gov/newsroom/leaded-aviation-fuel-and-environment https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/leaded-aviation-fuel-and-enviro...
- dreamcompiler 4y agoNope. Not piston engines anyway. Airplane engines have to be much more reliable than car engines in a much harsher environment, and until today leaded fuel was the only solution that produced the requisite level of reliability.
- nawgz 4y agoFinally
- londons_explore 4y agoIs the full composition of this fuel public knowledge? Or is there some secret ingredient that acts as a lead replacement? Some PTFE precursors would be a really unfortunate choice for example...
- fuzzfactor 4y agoIt's not actually a secret. The abundant, affordable low-octane base fuel stocks that refiners and blenders work to bring up to specs have always been a no-brainer - just add a few grams of lead to your tank, and wow you've got high-octane rated fuel. And lead is heavy so that's only like a small number of mL. Very few oil wells naturally yield a very high octane gasoline fraction, so for adequate engine performance, some enhancement has always been necessary. The "pipeline" ended up being built basically around gasoline and additive, where the additive amount directly and straightforwardly controls the octane. Alcohols were always known to bring up the octane rating too but you need to add gallons of alcohols to your tank not just grams. However the energy density is lower with alcohol so you get fewer miles per gallon, not what you want in an aircraft. Well this is more like blending two bulk fuels so that was one of the infrastructure adjustments that needed to be made as the lead additive approach was phased out. Now major percentages of alcohol are blended with base stocks to achieve the target "clean-air" and octane-rating requirements, so this has been well in place for decades. For the G100UL they do not use alcohol, instead they blend in many gallons of other flammable liquids like xylene, which is a hydrocarbon itself, just happens to increase the octane, and increases the energy density as well. Xylene is traditionally handled as a solvent and paint thinner, so they can get trailerloads (but not nearly as cheaply as alcohol is in automotive gasoline). Xylene has always been one of those dangerous flammable hydrocarbon cargoes, supplied as a petro-chemical by a lot of refineries, it's just one of the chemicals that is normally considered too expensive to burn. So they're not replacing a few grams of lead with a few grams of something else, GAMI has replaced a few grams of lead with a few gallons of something else completely different from lead. And that "something else" are actually hydrocarbons that have always existed naturally in all kinds of gasoline (only in far less significant percentage). GAMI is scientifically bringing up the percentage of this type of component while maintaining the drop-in characteristic.
- londons_explore 4y agoIt's a shame that it took some districts fully banning leaded fuel to force this change through. The wheels of American bureaucracy don't move without some serious outside forces!
- lbriner 4y agoI don't think the wheels of any bureaucracy turn quickly. There are two fallacies in bureaucracy: 1) With enough organisation, we can please all parties 2) Process can solve all of our problems My experience (and I suspect others) is an enormous budget of people paid to have meetings, not making much headway, if any, but not being held accountable for outcomes. Imagine a Department having paid a team of people for 30 years to make this happen!
- salawat 4y ago> 2) Process can solve all of our problems I'm gonna have to stop you right there, if only because process gets a bad rap from people who have never tried to implement systems in which more than a handful of parallel agents can safely work without stomping on or interfering with one another. Process is critical to coordination. You cannot "thread-safe" without the right process primitives. While I'm using the computing term, I'm using them in a non-computing/abstract system way. Information doesn't magically communicate to the parties who need it. Process gives you the blueprint to quickly create an environment whereby people can do their thing, but information still propagates to those who need it. If people follow it.
- tjmc 4y agoIf this prevents spark plug fowling as claimed it will be great and brings back a fond memory. During the Sydney Olympics in 2000 I flew a Piper Warrier over the Hawksbury River north of Sydney and the engine started missing - quite possibly due to this issue. A bit of a nervous prospect as there is basically nowhere to land there. At the time there was a huge air exclusion zone over the Olympic Park and there was excited talk of how quickly jets would be dispatched to shoot you down if you violated the airspace. Anyway, the moment we reported engine trouble we were given clearance to head straight back to Bankstown - pretty much right over the top of the games. Good times!
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- inamberclad 4y agoThank god, this is decades overdue. Seeing the white powder left on my fingers after I spilled some gas while sumping (to check for impurities, before every flight) always made me cringe. If the fuel is impure, standard procedure is to keep draining the impurities (water usually) out and just throw it on the ground.
- watersb 4y agoOnly 30 years! I trained in a Cessna 152 that was certificated to run on high-octane unleaded auto gas. No modifications, the EAA just demonstrated that it would run fine like that. But my 172 had to use Aviation gasoline. Until now.
- spitfire 4y agoSo this is a 100octane fuel? Can it be sold through regular retail chains? Since avgas is such a small market I’m thinking that might raise its TAM as a “premium plus” sort of product.
- once_inc 4y ago> The FAA signed on September 1 supplemental type certificates that allow .... As a non-native English reader, why is this not written as: > The FAA signed supplemental type certificates on September 1 that allow .... The current sentence feels disjointed and doesn't '_flow_' like natural sentences normally do in English.
- kleiba 4y agoThis is so that the following relative clause is closer to the noun phrase it modifies.
- moffkalast 4y agoNewspaper title text written stupidly for shorter headlines.
- someweirdperson 4y agoDoes anyone have a link to the STC? FAA stc search didn't return anything new for GAMI.
- shultays 4y agoWhat makes lead such a magic substance that makes it used in many places and hard to replace? I know leaded solder wires have lower melting temp. What else?
- _s 4y agoCheap, abundant, easy to acquire, easy to transport, inert, mostly harmless if left alone, maintains its properties in harsh conditions over extended periods of times, mixes well with some other chemicals. Very harmful if ingested or absorbed, directly or indirectly.
- londons_explore 4y agoWhat are the chances some airports have signed 20 year fuel supply contracts with some leaded fuel supplier? I think for this to have much traction, some carrot and stick needs to be applied... A $1/gallon tax on leaded fuel that doubles every year ought to be a good incentive to start using lead free stuff.
- sokoloff 4y agoI think you’ll see the fuel supplier unable to supply 100LL somewhere between 10 and 20 years as this rolls out. The critical element is this is miscible fuel. It doesn’t need new tanks, new pumps, airplane mods, or any big-bang adoption. It takes refineries licensing the formulation and individual airplanes to spend around one fillup’s worth of fuel on a piece of paper. That’s a 5-10 year process, not a 20. Once the volume drops off, the one plant making TEL will plan to shut down I think. I’d expect to see an EPA Clean Air Act update to ban 100LL in the 10-20 year timeframe as well.
- spaghettiToy 4y agoDidn't expect to see good news today! Talk about making my body fill with happy chemicals!