14 ms·
Final thoughts on Ubiquiti
- Operyl 4y agoJeez, I was certain at this point he would never retract his articles. I feel like it's too little too late, imo, though.
- cronofdoom 4y agoFunny, I was feeling the exact opposite. They could have just taken down the articles and issued no statement. It is hard to publicly admit that you're wrong and it's good to see they took that step.
- blitzar 4y ago> They could have just taken down the articles and issued no statement. There are people that came bottom of their class and barely qualified yesterday to practice law who easily would have been able to make this not an option.
- selectodude 4y agoI imagine a public retraction was part of a settlement with Ubiquiti.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- riffic 4y agothis reads like he got out-lawyered here. context for the unaware: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-journalist-alleging-defamation-in-coverage-of-data-breach/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-jo...
- kspacewalk2 4y agoOut-lawyered by life and facts.
- duxup 4y agoOut lawyered, because he was wrong?
- bombcar 4y agoA good journalist knows how to verify sources and check before writing. A great journalist finds great sources that are unimpeachable. But a wealthy journalist knows how to write articles from horrible or no sources at all that are not technical defamation.
- mewse-hn 4y agoNext story will probably be that the suit was settled out-of-court :P
- nerdponx 4y agoDo I understand this correctly? There was a minor data breach at Ubiquiti. An employee named Sharp was using this as an opportunity to extort his employer and exfiltrate data. Sharp was telling Krebs some yarn about the data breach being bigger than reported, which Krebs then repeated on his blog, accusing Ubiquiti of covering up a more significant breach. And Ubiquiti is claiming that Krebs knew the truth all along. This sounds like a weird and complicated story, so I feel like I'm probably misunderstanding.
- InTheArena 4y agoSharp did the breach and then extorted Ubiquiti. Ubiquiti got the FBI involved and declined to pay off Sharp. Sharp followed through on his threat and disclosed everything to Kerbs, who wrote an article about it. The FBI and Ubiquiti were on to Sharp, but since Sharp was Kreb's only source, Krebs doubled down on the allegation with a series of articles, and then never retracted it (until now)
- mzs 4y agoThat's pretty much it, yes: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-employee-technology-company-charged-stealing-confidential-data-and-extorting https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/former-employee-technol... https://www.cyber.nj.gov/public-data-breaches/ubiquiti https://www.cyber.nj.gov/public-data-breaches/ubiquiti
- mardifoufs 4y agoI wonder what has changed? The original thread discussing the lawsuit was filled with super dismissive comments, arguing that ubiquity lawyers were incompetent and had no actual way to win the case. Some of the commenters were supposedly actual lawyers too, so it's not even just the normal "terrible armchair law advice" we are used to from HN.
- encryptluks2 4y agoEveryone loves to play the armchair lawyer. Bias quickly fuels whatever side of a case you're on. However discovery and a few court conferences can quickly put things into perspective. Almost everyone's lawyers start off with some encouraging words but eventually they are telling you to settle for X and it is clear that they wouldn't have got paid if they told you that you had a losing case from the get go.
- james_in_the_uk 4y agoPerhaps Krebs has chosen to move on with his life. Defending litigation is often expensive, distracting and stressful, even if you think you have a strong case. The law isn't necessarily always as pugilistic as Hollywood might lead you to believe. Perfectly fine to think you are right, say you were wrong, settle the case and move on. Of course, we have no way to know what Krebs really thinks or what actually went on behind closed doors here. We should take the written statement at face value, exactly as written. No more no less.
- JacobThreeThree 4y agoI guess the Krebs naysayers were right? The wording of this apology makes it pretty clear in my opinion that he's reacting to Ubiquiti lawyers.
- acoard 4y agoAn accurate but pretty lacklustre "mea culpa" and retraction. I don't mind people making mistakes, everyone does, but seeing how Krebs has handled this whole episode has not inspired optimism in how he'll handle future mistakes. He was essentially used as an unwitting party in a cyber blackmail scheme, and he doesn't touch on that at all. There will continue to be nefarious parties trying to misuse his reputation, so long as he remains a popular cyber researcher. I wish he would show consciousness of that rather than simply saying "I was wrong."
- blantonl 4y agoThis is about of straightforward as a "I screwed up, I own it, I apologize" Everyone makes mistakes. Some of the good work Krebs has done seems to be completely overshadowed by a mistake here. Granted, this is probably in response to some legal action either in progress or already settled, but what more do you want from the guy?
- kspacewalk2 4y ago> This is about of straightforward as a "I screwed up, I own it, I apologize" "A source provided info. Source is now discredited. I thus no longer trust the info." That's the gist of the apology. But that's neither here nor there, it does not show understanding of the fact that his reputation was deliberately used for criminal purposes.
- InTheArena 4y ago"This time, I missed the mark and, as a result, I would like to extend my sincerest apologies to Ubiquiti, and I have decided to remove those articles from my website." I think that's reasonable.
- atyppo 4y agoThat seems like a statement not written by a lawyer. It’s possible he’s concerned about legal ramifications
- CaliforniaKarl 4y agoI don’t see this post when I go to https://krebsonsecurity.com/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/, at least on iOS Safari. Also, on the home page, when I scroll down to the list of all posts, I don’t see this one. Edit: It’s there now! Thanks to u/Pharaoh2 for the heads-up.
- Pharaoh2 4y agoI see it there
- CaliforniaKarl 4y agoAh, indeed! I now also see it. I guess parts of the site are cached and take time to refresh? Regardless, thanks for the correction!
- AndrewUnmuted 4y ago
- alexk307 4y agoWow, I wonder how much they were suing him for. Probably tons of money in damages from his report
- ryneandal 4y ago> Ubiquiti is asking for $425,000 in damages. - https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-journalist-alleging-defamation-in-coverage-of-data-breach/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-jo...
- borski 4y agoFrom [1], it would appear to be only $425k. [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-journalist-alleging-defamation-in-coverage-of-data-breach/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/03/ubiquiti-sues-jo...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- InTheArena 4y agoMad props to Brian on this. It's way overdue - and frankly, the Ubiquiti lawsuit was poor PR management - but it's good to put things right given some very poor journalistic choices. Journalists admitting when they are wrong is a key step in rebuilding trust in our institutions - not only news but many aspects of civil society here. Ubiquiti - as a fan of your products - please drop the lawsuit now. I get that this did a ton of damage to the company, but I don't think anyone wins by dragging this out. The product lineup has improved dramatically over the last year, and it would be good to focus there.
- jnwatson 4y agoI’m not aware of any new information in the last 6 months about the matter. I guess better late than never.
- Semaphor 4y agoMad props to him for finally posting a retraction and half-assed apology after Ubiquity forced him to with the lawsuit they never should have done? What?
- vel0city 4y agoIs it really props when you're being sued nearly half a million in damages to continue hosting the articles? If he wanted to take down the articles because he felt he was wrong, he had months to do so. He gets zero props from me for only taking down the articles after being sued.
- bombcar 4y agoOnce sued his lawyer probably told him to shut the hell up and not touch anything. The time to do the right thing was before the lawsuit was filed.
- jonpurdy 4y agoThere was a lot of discussion from ex-Ubnt employees in a January 2021 thread※ related to outsourcing and incompetent management. From what I've read, they still show ads for their products in newer Unifi Controller web interfaces and don't have a way of disabling tracking. But now that the Krebs retraction has occurred, my brain doesn't know how bad/incompetent Ubiquiti is these days. Is there an updated-for-2022 source of info on Ubiquiti's problems? ie. what complaints are still valid, and which ones are not valid due to the cyber blackmail incident? I was a big supporter from 2015-2019 and I still run their AC Lite AP + EdgeRouterX, but haven't updated them beyond 2019 firmware. ※ - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25735032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25735032
- InTheArena 4y agoIt's solidified incredibly over the last year. It no longer requires centralized login, no longer shows ads (or you can opt out of them. I don't see it one way or another). More importantly, the network infrastructure has gotten much much better. I haven't had any stability issues other then testing our new early adopter firmware, and the first versions of policy based load balancing have landed.
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoRecent updates to the base UDM have been noticeably better than before. I don’t know what they’re doing differently but I hope they continue along this trajectory.
- InTheArena 4y agoYeah, the investment is showing. I just installed a UDR at my parents place, and it's awesome. Provides not only the UDM functionality, but also VOIP or cameras out of the box - with everything in a fully managed state. They are doing a lot of enterprisey bits right now, but I think their more prosumer stuff is also doing well.
- flyinghamster 4y ago> It no longer requires centralized login Thanks for the update. I have a couple of UAP-AC-Lites and an EdgeRouter PoE, but the recent "cloudiness" began to set my teeth on edge, and I've been loath to upgrade my controller.
- user3939382 4y agoUbiquiti is so worried about suing Krebs meanwhile their brand reputation has turned to mud due to the quality of their products, both from my own experience and the general consensus I've heard online. If this incident had never occurred I still would have stopped recommending and using their equipment.
- xxpor 4y agoThe problem from my end though is, who really competes with them? No one else offers the same level of control at the same (or even close) price point.
- beams_of_light 4y agoThe old adage "you get what you pay for" applies here. Yeah, it's cheaper than buying Meraki, Aruba, Fortinet, etc, but the IDS/IPS on their Dream Machine is awful, logging is awful, reliability of anything but wireless gear is awful, Protect storage equipment is awful...
- InTheArena 4y agoThis is just getting silly. They use Suricata for the IDS/IPS. I have a UDMP, and I route 2.5GB a second across two load balanced connections (fiber and cable) on full IDS/IPS with no problems. I have logging going to greylog without any issues, but am looking to move to Loki. I have a UDMP, with a single 8TB disk for my camera, but you can grab a UNVR if you need more storage. If you need two, grab two UNVRs to cover a whole site. They pair now. And if you are a prosumer instead of a homelab / busoiness site grab a UDR, with a fast flash disk. You can pair that into Homekit secure with Homebridge (or even better, Scrypted). I have 5 Unifi 6 devices - zero problems with them in well over a year at this point. I get 800mb/s from any location on-site.
- vel0city 4y agoI don't really want to pay for support contracts which cost more than the upfront cost of the hardware after a couple of years to continue to receive software updates for my prosumer level home networking deployments. Does Meraki and Aruba provide free updates?
- CaliforniaKarl 4y agoSitting on the bus, I’ve already changed my mind about the decision to take down the articles, instead of posting a retraction notice. At first I thought Mr. Krebs was being scummy by pulling the posts. The Ars Technica article linked by u/riffic mentions that there was an earlier, denied takedown request. So, now I think the posts were likely taken down as part of a settlement. We’ll probably never know—I expect an NDA to be part of the terms—but I wonder if, from Ubiquiti’s side, it might have been better to leave the posts up, but with a retraction notice.
- obblekk 4y agoBefore people jump on this with super negativity... mistakes happen. What is Krebs' false positive rate? I think low enough that a simple, clear explanation of why it happened is sufficient. There's no weasel words or evasion here - he owns up to the error, apologizes to affected parties, and retracts all original posts. It's true that his reporting probably caused stress for Ubiquity. I'm curious what people think is a fair system to compensate for that, without wiping out independent, generally high accuracy reporters like Krebs
- curiousgal 4y agoHe has a history of doxxing people who have nothing to do with his pieces so yeah excuse my negativity.
- GordonS 4y agoIIRC, he never even apologised for it - just straight up said nothing, like he was pretending it never happened. I haven't followed Krebs' articles since then, he totally lost my trust.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> What is Krebs' false positive rate? What's more important is how those false positives are handled. In this case, it feels like it was swept under the rug and he avoided addressing for as long as possible. If he had simply addressed the problem head-on as the news came out and the FBI information became public, it would have been a different story. The way he rushed to report accusations from an anonymous source (who was actually the perpetrator) felt asymmetric relative to the minimal reporting on the extortion scandal and ensuing FBI investigation. IMO, the story about someone extorting their employer and then abusing security reporters as leverage was more interesting than the original story. Yet Krebs did very little reporting on the latter, likely because he knew he was central to making it all happen in the first place.
- dewey 4y ago> What's more important is how those false positives are handled. Is it really though? If there's a company that has to defend / apologize often (Facebook/Meta maybe) I'd be way more critical of their apology than if one guy who didn't have a case like that before apologying a bit too late for some people or not in the way they wish he would. There's also a lot of information we don't know yet, we don't know what happend behind the scenes and when he was provided with the final verdict and facts.
- physhster 4y agoI trust Krebs so I tossed every piece of my Ubiquiti gear I owned as a result. Ended up with a lesser solution since there isn't a good alternative on the market that would do for me everything Ubiquiti did.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoIt's great that he retracted his story but the way he did it isn't so great. In particular he's removed his older incorrect stories and replaced them with a redirect to the retraction. Thankfully the Wayback Machine has archives https://web.archive.org/web/20220223015405/https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/04/ubiquiti-all-but-confirms-breach-response-iniquity/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220223015405/https://krebsonse... https://web.archive.org/web/20220711220855/https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/12/ubiquiti-developer-charged-with-extortion-causing-2020-breach/ https://web.archive.org/web/20220711220855/https://krebsonse...
- filmgirlcw 4y agoSpeaking from experience with these things (although in my case, the articles we were forced to remove were absolutely and completely 100% accurate -- but the company that acquired us wanted to settle all outstanding lawsuits and ended up caving so that the transaction could close), this might have been terms of the settlement or whatever it was he came to with Ubiquiti. In our case, because our articles were in fact, factual, we were able to re-iterate and even quote, as part of the legal filings, aspects of the original reporting as part of a story that was in response to the removals themselves, but the content at those original URLs was replaced with a notice that the articles had been removed because of litigation with our former parent company. The fact that he didn't (or hasn't) scrubbed the stories themselves from the Internet Archive is a good sign (I think we had to remove our stories from the Internet Archive, though I do know that individuals did make archives other ways). I'm pretty opposed to suing journalists for the act of doing journalism and even though I'm a big fan of Ubiquiti products, I still don't love this sort of tactic. That said, it does seem clear that these stories were not correct and at the very least, flawed because of the single-source who was not a reliable narrator (and admitted to lying to the press), so in an ideal world, these stories would have been retracted anyway.
- ifsothen 4y agoJust because you hang a press pass around your neck doesn't mean you should be allowed to recklessly spread highly damaging lies about people with impunity.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> As a result of the new information that has been provided to me, I no longer have faith in the veracity of my source or the information he provided to me. I always endeavor to ensure that my articles are properly sourced and factual. This is a strange statement given how the details of the FBI investigation have been public for a very long time. Krebs was fast to report on the initial accusations, but seems to have waited as long as possible to write about the revelations that his source was actually the perpetrator. > This time, I missed the mark and, as a result, I would like to extend my sincerest apologies to Ubiquiti, and I have decided to remove those articles from my website. Given that Krebs is a reporter who has historically built a reputation on exposing things and bringing information to light, the brevity and vagueness of this article feels much more like a compromise to settle a lawsuit than typical reporting.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is a failure across many journalists; the inability to view what they're involved with objectively. The amount of scrutiny applied to a source is inversely proportional with how much I want to believe the source.
- IncRnd 4y ago> This is a failure across many journalists Only one journalist was involved here. I think you meant "failing of many journalists" not "failure across many". > The amount of scrutiny applied to a source is inversely proportional with how much I want to believe the source. Why do you disbelieve a source that has been greatly scrutinized? Did you mean "directly proportional"?
- andrewaylett 4y agoThe sense I read from the GP is that if I want to believe the source, I'm less likely to apply strict scrutiny to what they tell me. The more I want to believe, the less I'll dig into what I'm hearing. Some things are just too good to not believe.
- photochemsyn 4y agoThis seems to be the basics of the case: Initial report: https://web.archive.org/web/20211202143043/https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/03/whistleblower-ubiquiti-breach-catastrophic/ https://web.archive.org/web/20211202143043/https://krebsonse... Indictment of source: https://web.archive.org/web/20211202161703/https://krebsonsecurity.com/2021/12/ubiquiti-developer-charged-with-extortion-causing-2020-breach/ https://web.archive.org/web/20211202161703/https://krebsonse... In cases like this it's probably better to leave the article up but plaster a big red 'retracted' banner across it, with a link to a complete explanation as to why it was retracted. As far as defamation, isn't the legal bar on that pretty high in the USA? Maybe there's a negligence issue, i.e. relying on a single source, not doing enough background, etc. that overrides the normal 'good faith' reporting norms?
- filmgirlcw 4y agoAs I said in another comment, I feel certain (based on my own direct experience working for a publication that faced numerous lawsuits over what in those cases were factual articles) that this was a condition of a legal settlement. And the thing is, you settle in this case because even though the defamation bar is really high, if your sourcing was wrong (and you maybe didn't do the best job of vetting that sourcing) and the more complicated aspect is that your source was later indicted in relation to a crime directly connected to the information they shared as the basis of that article, this seems like a pretty straightforward "settle it and move on" scenario, rather than trying to fight it in the courts. Barring the largesse of a large news organization (who also might choose to settle, as the Washington Post did with that kid in DC, even though the New York Times and others were years later found to not have defamed him), this is probably not the sort of thing you want to spend the potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars fighting. Because at the end of the day, the reporting was still flawed.
- blitzar 4y agoDate Filed: August 25th, 2022 "Defendants Brian Krebs and Krebs on Security, LLC respectfully request that the Court extend the deadline for Defendants to respond to the Complaint by an additional thirty days in light of extraordinary circumstances that have delayed the finalization of the parties’ settlement" https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/63197557/21/ubiquiti-inc-v-krebs/ https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/63197557/21/ubiquiti-in... They have been finalizing the settlement for some time. I would guess it is now settled.
- Fnoord 4y agoThere used to be a rule in journalism: one source is no source.
- BLO716 4y agoA bit of extreme ownership in the same vein as Jocko Willink is inspirational. It's not a reward or ego contest, when you have to open up and be humble about leadership and admission as such - so, critics will be on both sides of the judgement and the reporting. I myself believe in being humble and honest to a fault, so I'm more sympathetic in this case. Either way, strive to be better and hey .. humanity is a b*tch sometimes.
- nibbleshifter 4y ago> and I have decided to remove those articles from my website. Updating them with a link to this for context would have been the better move.
- nottorp 4y agoOk no security breach. Can I set up a new ubiquity device without registering with them at all now? Been told that you can delete the cloud registration after the set up, but that’s still unacceptable.
- InTheArena 4y agoyes. You do not need any cloud login at this point.
- nottorp 4y agoThey saw the light :) I have an older device (first in 5 Ghz I think) and I was beginning to think I should upgrade it to <whatever the latest Wi-Fi standard is>.
- nottorp 4y agoHmm I just redownloaded the 'unifi network' thingy. For one I had to go through a screen of threats telling me I shouldn't use a local application that only reminds me of the threats you have to go through when downloading the LGPL version of Qt. For two, the app is incomprehensible, it wanted me to create a "local administrator account" after i opted out of an online account and then it didn't find my old unifi ap that is working just fine thank you. So nope. Still unacceptable, sorry. Note: I still have an old version of their admin app on an old computer and that one just finds the AP and lets me configure it. So if they could do it 10 years ago they could do it now too, should they wish to. Note 2: Why do they want my email even for a "local administrator" account? Note 3: If i click through all the crap it does find my UAP-AC but it says "managed by another console"? With no way of taking control of it. What the... i haven't started the old management app in years. Looks like besides threatening their customers they have gone enterprise.
- strbean 4y ago> it wanted me to create a "local administrator account" after i opted out of an online account What alternative would you prefer? Anyone on the network can configure it? Just a password with no username? > I still have an old version of their admin app on an old computer and that one just finds the AP and lets me configure it. So if they could do it 10 years ago they could do it now too, should they wish to. The answer to security issues is... worse security? > and then it didn't find my old unifi ap that is working just fine thank you. You need to release the device from your old Unifi deployment, or factory reset the device. You don't want anyone on your network to be able to adopt your devices and seize control of your network.
- balentio 4y agoYou guys are thinking about this in a very cloudy kind of way. Assuming that Ubiquiti was being blackmailed, they have a security problem in who they hire (Who held user data for ransom). Assuming they were not being blackmailed, but had a security hole in their software, Ubiquiti has a security problem. Krebs reporting comes from a potential conflict of interest in that the person who might have been trying to blackmail was also the source. Defamation is not really the issue then because the source was pointing at a security problem which they happened to also be the cause of. The entity that hired this person was...Ubiquiti! Hence, it is not really defamation AS SUCH. Rather, if anything, it was true but maybe blown out of proportion to get a larger sum of money from Ubiquiti. We don't know how much info the person got their hands on, because Ubiquiti would be to blame for that, wouldn't they? So, ultimately I think taking down the articles is a mistake in the sense that they reported on a problem either way with Ubiquiti and security. Take off the ad revenue from those articles, and issue a modified retraction on the conflicted interest the source held as a correction. Use it as a cautionary tale on "Sensationalism" and "not always knowing what the hell someone is doing when they report a leak" and move on.
- InTheArena 4y agoKreb's article specifically alleged malfeasance on Ubiquiti's part - that they were deliberately covering up a huge data breach. This turned out to be untrue on three levels: 1) There was no cover-up. Ubiquiti disclosed the attack, and was working with the FBI, working to identify what had happened, and in fact where already onto Sharp as a insider attack. 2) There was no large scale data breach. 3) The claim that there was a huge cover up was part of a extortion scheme, that Krebs was (unwittingly) assisting in. Yes, this is a standard insider attack - and Ubiquti's security needed to be significantly better - but it doesn't change the fact that Brian Krebs reported false information - including information that he should have been in a position to know was untrue at the very least in the second article, if not the first. Ironically enough, the person at Ubiquiti that introduced the wider GITHUB access to production secrets and new policies that allowed Nick Sharp to get production access was - according to former Ubiquiti employees - Nick Sharp. Who watches the watchers?
- 4y ago
- gonehome 4y agoThe HN comments here at the time weren't great either: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30850983 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30850983 Despite it being clear that Krebs was wrong on this issue for some time, it showed the extent of his influence and the attacker's success in leveraging it to manipulate the public (including HN users). Hopefully his retraction at least helps with that.
- itsoktocry 4y ago>The HN comments here at the time weren't great either Amazing, people accusing you of "astroturfing" (an HN favourite, doesn't even make sense in this context). These are the comment threads that cross my mind when people claim this forum is atypically "smart".
- _8j50 4y agoSomeone correct me, but, isn't a journalist supposed to have independent corroborating source/evidence no matter how solid one sole source is? Is that basically where he missed the "mark"?
- Werewolf255 4y agoYeah, at this point I'm taking Krebs off of any alert or recommendation lists. Appreciate the Mea Culpa, but it's not like he's been making stellar decisions before this problem. It also doesn't read as an apology, but an acknowledgment that he was given bad info from a source.
- bikezen 4y agoReads like a lawyer wrote this for him, and is still way too late. It was pretty clear early on that his source was a bad actor. Even if he actually wrote this post himself, it feels like its a result of the ubnt defamation suit against him.
- legitster 4y ago"A lie gets halfway around the world before truth puts on its boots." Another good reminder to take whistleblower claims with a grain of salt. Even someone as professional as Krebs still wants to get the scoop. I still don't understand why it took Krebs so long or why he insisted on trusting his insider so much without any corroborating evidence.
- incomingpain 4y agoUbiquiti got krebbed: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=krebbed https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=krebbed
- wnevets 4y agoOn a related note the number of negative Ubiquti comments on HN appears to have fallen since this person was outted.
- de6u99er 4y agoDid he just delete the previous articles? IMO he should have linked to them from this post, and updated them with a big fat impossible to miss disclaimer on the top of the article because some other sites might still link to them and use wuotes which are not accurate any more.
- duped 4y agoThis is why "sole sources" and publications based on them can't be trusted
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoIf there's one thing I really hope people take away from this entire story is not to use security researchers' statements in constant appeals to authority. I hear so many questionable-to-bad takes on cyber security that basically amount to Bruce Schneier, Brian Krebs, or Troy Hunt said so, so you're absolutely wrong if you don't obey them. It's really important to remember security researchers and experts convey what they feel is the most accurate or best advice or information they have at the time, and it may very well turn out to be completely wrong or misguided later. The fact that these individuals are popular does not mean they are an authority on anything.
- Melatonic 4y agoI agree - and while I certainly trust the people you listed quite a bit it is important to not elevate anyone to cult status or revered leader type stuff. I think we can trust that they have more authority than most but that does not make them the authority.
- johncalvinyoung 4y agoOf that list, I'll listen to Schneier or Hunt way before Krebs. And that was before this story.
- hartAtWork 4y agoI think this was absolutely warranted. Ubiquiti's stance as a reliable and secure networking company was damaged in my mind. Krebs absolutely did damage to their reputation.
- hot_gril 4y agoReminds me of the Bloomberg SuperMicro article with a single anonymous source alleging that several big companies were compromised, which they deny. Funniest part is how Bloomberg itself also claims it wasn't compromised: > Bloomberg LP has been a Supermicro customer. According to a Bloomberg LP spokesperson, the company has found no evidence to suggest that it has been affected by the hardware issues raised in the article.
- happyopossum 4y agoBiggest difference - Bloomberg still hasn't retracted that garbage story...
- hot_gril 4y agoYeah, that's why I'm reminded. Is the moral of the story that reputable, medium-sized reporters without huge legal resources are more trustworthy than something like Bloomberg?
- bombcar 4y agoOr Bloomberg is better at walking the fine line and never actually stating anything actionable.
- jandrusk 4y agoSure sounds like a response to the law suite: https://twitter.com/QuinnyPig/status/1508965090019577856?t=LKYrHm2wTfp42x7H9pLWBw&s=19 https://twitter.com/QuinnyPig/status/1508965090019577856?t=L...
- InTheArena 4y agoIt was, but it’s important to note that Quinnypig was reacting to the assertions made by extortionist claims made by Krebs. I think he’s acting in good faith here - if not somewhat melodramatically..
- system2 4y agoIs there another brand to use other than UI for small businesses? Unifi makes it really easy to manage things and very affordable.
- chriscjcj 4y agoJournalists will sometimes go to great lengths to get a scoop and to make a name for themselves. This passionate desire "break the story" makes many journalists vulnerable. They become easy marks for bad actors who can gain by manipulating them. There are many examples of this occurring. Sometimes the manipulation is just designed to make the journalist(s) look stupid as in KTVU's scoop on the names of the Asiana Airlines pilots responsible for the deadly crash at SFO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L1JYHNX8pdo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L1JYHNX8pdo Sometimes it's more serious as in the case of Matthew Keys, who went to prison. I suspect he thought he was chasing a story but was too naïve to realize he was being played. https://www.wired.com/2016/04/journalist-matthew-keys-sentenced-two-years-aiding-anonymous/ https://www.wired.com/2016/04/journalist-matthew-keys-senten... Dan Rather's desire to take down former president George W. Bush for all intents and purposes ended his own career by not vetting documents provided to him by a source. His producer Mary Mapes was forced to resign as well. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_W._Bush_military_service_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_W._Bush_military_servic... I think we can all learn from these people's mistakes. Our own desires for a particular outcome or to have our personal beliefs confirmed can make us vulnerable to people who might have an incentive to manipulate us. For this reason, it's probably wise to employ a healthy level of skepticism when consuming "news" regardless of how trustworthy we believe the source to be.
- WaitWaitWha 4y ago[x] I made a mistake [x] This is how I made the mistake [x] I am sorry [x] I am going to do better [ ? ] These are the details how I am going to do better
- omegacharlie 4y ago
- fennecfoxy 4y agoI hate Ubiquiti anyway. After helping with an install in our office a couple of jobs ago, I bought a UDM in 2020 thinking I'd have the same experience as I did back then. Oh boy was I wrong. Everything is hidden behind layers of nice looking but useless UI, their software is generally pretty unstable and I get the weirdest things happen that I've never had with other routers, stuff like: * Phones will remain connected but say "connected without internet" without any reason why in the logs * Logs constantly spammed with random errors and other crap that UB is clearly being lazy about * 2.4Ghz unbearably slow, even in an area with no other transmitters (I've tested) and seems to be a software problem but I can't quite pin down why * No real support apart from the forums where often the "solution" to problems is to massively downgrade Sure, they might have "best in class" APs or something but I think I'm gonna go Mikrotik next time I buy. Idc if I get like 70% the speed of UB wifi as long as it's consistent and works properly.