11 ms·
Pakistan's floods have created 100km-wide inland lake, satellite images
- NonNefarious 4y agoCalifornia needs a looooooong straw to drink up that milkshake. I DRINK IT UP!
- rch 4y ago> turning what were once agricultural fields into a giant inland lake. It's a shocking transformation Is the agricultural capacity of this area dependent on periodic flooding, similar to historical patterns of the Nile?
- UncleOxidant 4y agodoubtful that it's depending on this level of flooding.
- rch 4y agoIt could be unprecedented on 100-1000 year timescales, and still be within geologic norms. Just trying to categorize this event relative to e.g. Greenland ice sheet melting.
- dwringer 4y agoReading this thread got me to pull up a map and notice the Mohenjo-Daro site[0] is evidently being damaged by the current flooding, particularly in excavated areas[1]. It would appear that in the 1960's there was a flurry of publications arguing about the idea that perhaps the Mohenjo-Daro civilization declined precisely because its cities had been destroyed by catastrophic floods. There's a lot to read, but I found this article[2] from 1965 that goes into a lot of detail about studies of flooding in the area, and mentions some of the research of the time. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohenjo-daro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohenjo-daro [1]https://odishatv.in/news/international/pakistan-floods-damage-iconic-mohenjo-daro-ruins-death-toll-reaches-1-162-184385 https://odishatv.in/news/international/pakistan-floods-damag... [2]https://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/civilization-and-floods-in-the-indus-valley/ https://www.penn.museum/sites/expedition/civilization-and-fl...
- sa1 4y agoPeriodic floods bringing down alluvial soil are definitely part of what made these regions fertile and highly populated. But I do not know if floods are continually needed to maintain the fertility, or how this flood compares to historic floods.
- alephnerd 4y agoSome amount of flooding is expected in Kaccha/Katcha Doaba land, but this level of flooding was very anomalous due to Climate Change plus some questionable urban planning. Add to that the fact that ongoing local elections in Sindh has paralyzed the state's civil service and this became a horrible calamity. edit: Je tussi ek kissan da mundeh ki comment nu downvote kar rehe hai, tenu khuch galt fami hegi. Sindh, Pakhtunkwa, Punjab, Himachal, Jammu, Kashmir, Haryana, Uttarakhand, aur Delhi NCR di kissani saili ta bilkul same to same hege Angrezo aur Environment di whajese.
- icemelt8 4y agoFirst comment in Punjabi on Hacker news :) ... You right, we are together in this climate change disaster
- alephnerd 4y agoAgreed! There needs to be much more coordination at the SAARC level to solve these issues. Honestly cross-border trade would be amazing for Northern India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. The Partition and instability of the 70s-90s really destroyed the economic potential of the region.
- selimthegrim 4y agoTranslation: Those of you who are downvoting a farmer’s (Edit: son’s, munda can be more generic term for person too) comment are misinformed. Farmers of Sindh, …, and Delhi NCR are in the same boat because of the British and the environment.
- alephnerd 4y ago* son of a farmer. never lived on a farm myself (grew up here in North America) but my dad did growing up and during summer vacations we'd often help my grandfather as well with the kharif crop.
- mistrial9 4y agoIs it true that only 30,000 years ago the level of the sea was very different? lower in that case, exposing the land bridge at Alaska, and connecting the Islands north of Australia.. and previous to that, the sea level was much higher? evidence is the inland sea that is California Central Valley..
- nigerian1981 4y agoI don’t see how given the Earth is only 6000 years old.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoAnd flat, so any excess water will just run over the edge.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoGood thing turtles are OK getting wet.
- munk-a 4y agoIf they can put up with elephants standing on their backs then a bit a water is clearly not going to bother them.
- thro388 4y agoYes, there is periodic cycle, depending on ice ages.
- wcoenen 4y agoThe past 5000 years have been quite stable, but there have been dramatic changes from melting ice caps before that. See https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Post-Glacial_Sea_Level.png https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Post-Glacial_Sea_L... With a high enough warming rate, we might get a chance to see what a "meltwater pulse" looks like :-/
- 4y ago
- sremani 4y agoI heard the Punjab has a great irrigation program and that is the reason why they do not suffer floods like Sindh, outside of the usual regionalism are there any constraints in developing similar irrigation and flood control apparatus in Sindh.
- alephnerd 4y agoDisclaimer - I'm not from that area, but I was talking with a buddy of mine from Larkana about this and the region of Sindh and Punjab that was badly affected is basically a badland with bad governance [0][1][2][3][4]. Also fits in line with the Saraiki folk songs I've listened to. On the northern and central Punjab side I'm not surprised that it was not badly effected thanks to the Canal colonies that the British built out there [5]. My mom's side of the family is from the Jhelum Colony originally before Partition [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shikarpur_Operation_2021 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shikarpur_Operation_2021 [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazroo_Narejo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazroo_Narejo [2] - https://tribune.com.pk/story/2370767/dacoits-kidnap-torture-two-hostages-in-sindh https://tribune.com.pk/story/2370767/dacoits-kidnap-torture-... [3] - https://www.dawn.com/news/1625938 https://www.dawn.com/news/1625938 [4] - https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.476.1647&rep=rep1&type=pdf https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.47... [5] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_Canal_Colonies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punjab_Canal_Colonies
- jfk13 4y agoSindh does also have a pretty extensive irrigation network; e.g. see https://www.arcgis.com/apps/View/index.html?appid=21082183d13140809705fdd5647f91fc&extent=64.5245,23.1609,73.2476,29.0085 https://www.arcgis.com/apps/View/index.html?appid=21082183d1.... (I don't know how it compares to that in Punjab, though, nor whether it is well or badly maintained and managed.)
- alephnerd 4y agoBased on the GIS dataset it's mostly Wahs, Distis, and Nullehs. You need an actual high capacity canals and locks to mitigate the kind of flooding seen in over the past few days. But the law and order situation in that region is a bit erm, lacking, compared to Northern+Central Punjab where industrial level canals the Brits left behind appear to be maintained. A lot of these regions where the flooding happened are also former princely state areas, so there wasn't that much infrastructural investment.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThere is a book called Salt Dreams about the history of water in the Southwestern US. One of the things it details is that the Salton Sea is something that has come and gone before. This time around, it is failing to evaporate and disappear due to run off from agricultural irrigation. Water interacting with otherwise arid landscapes is complicated. It can be simultaneously devastating and life giving. It is perhaps a thing humans need to get better at interacting with given the state of the climate.
- hahaitsfunny 4y ago
- anon291 4y agoThe Salton sea is shrinking.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoIt began shrinking after 1999 when water use became more efficient. Without agricultural runoff, it should have disappeared decades ago.
- mikestew 4y agoThe Salton Sea shouldn't exist at all. Had arrogance not overtaken those thinking they'd bring irrigation to the desert, the Salton Sea would still be the bone-dry Salton Sink. But after the canal and headgate failure, et. al., and the Colorado River flowed into the Salton Sink for two years, now we go from Sink to Sea. (And to be fair, it wasn't all due to arrogance; several floods one after another didn't help.) In short, the Salton Sea was the result of what was probably one of the worst humanitarian and ecological disasters in California history.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThe evidence is that this isn't the first time there was water there. Regardless of what contribution human activity made this time, the area has a long history of periodic flooding creating a temporary lake as evidenced by geological markers and Indigenous oral traditions.
- aniijbod 4y ago> Pakistan's floods have created 100km-wide inland lake, satellite images Is an 'inland lake' different to an 'offshore lake'?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Is an 'inland lake' different to an 'offshore lake'? I think it refers to an inland body of water with no access to the sea, sort of like a salt lake [1]. (I upvoted because it's an interesting question. But it would be better received if phrased plainly versus sarcastically.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake
- robertlagrant 4y ago> But it would be better received if phrased plainly versus sarcastically. The perils of thinking people receive things objectively. I didn't think it was sarcastic; it's phrased about as neutrally as I can imagine.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> it's phrased about as neutrally as I can imagine Try “what is an inland lake?” It’s the question, plainly. You aren’t levying a guess against a contrived hypothetical (“offshore lake” isn’t a thing, and could objectively be parsed as facetious).
- aniijbod 4y agoI agree with your claim that this was something that I posted as both facetious and sarcastic. I apologise. The word 'inland' in this context just seemed to be a wholly redundant adjective to use to describe a lake, such that it surprised me that the title of an article covering something of such genuinely extraordinary importance would have what seemed to be such a glaring error left unattended to, or at leased not commented upon. So I sought to attract attention to it in the most attention-catching way that I could come up with at that time, which was to be sarcastic about it.
- andy_ppp 4y agoUm, I really hope I’m incorrect on this but is the green bit that has flooded fertile farmland next to a river? I’m asking if a famine will be a down stream result of this catastrophe.
- erellsworth 4y agoI don't know about that image in particular, but most likely the answer is yes. https://time.com/6209889/pakistan-food-floods/ https://time.com/6209889/pakistan-food-floods/
- pvaldes 4y agoAt short term, yes, at least until a next rice harvest. Could be alleviated in part if fish invade the areas and start reproducing massively; freshwater ecosystems can be very productive. I don't know the area, but if the climate allows it, their best bet could be to rely on edible aquatic crops that typically grow very fast. Lotus rhizomes are edible, same as Typha stems or the seeds rich on starch of Trapa bicornis that taste like sweet chestnuts. Must be cooked to remove their toxins (and eventual parasites) before eaten.
- kube-system 4y ago> turning what were once agricultural fields into a giant inland lake From the article
- hedora 4y agoYou're correct: https://time.com/6209889/pakistan-food-floods/ https://time.com/6209889/pakistan-food-floods/ tl;dr: This will lead to rice and cotton shortages, compounding this year's wheat shortages (climate, Putin) and olive / sunflower oil shortages (Spain's megadrought).
- pvaldes 4y agoSpains drought [1], fueled in part by more than 50 criminal mega-wildfires. What happened in Spain in 2022 is not climate change, is environmental terrorism. Last week a woman was caught starting a wildfire in Galicia by a police after seven wildfires occur in the same area. Environmental terrorism... and maybe even economic sabotage. If there is a team of puppets, there must be a puppeteer somewhere. Right?. We had a interesting high number of events targeting tourism. More than 6000 wildfires with many very big wildfires in categories rarely seen before, several train sabotages (optic fiber stolen for no reason, and a train exiting from a tunnel directly into a wildfire) in a country with an economy based in tourism. A high number of wildfires also in France, Portugal and Romania but Spain suffered the bulk of the attacks. [1] I don't think that the mega prefix is justified still
- pvaldes 4y agowater can kill but brings new life also.
- photochemsyn 4y agoYes, I imagine a lovely bloom of Vibrio cholerae is likely to arise from mass flooding of this sort. https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/20/1/13-0428_article https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/20/1/13-0428_article > "In August 2010, Pakistan experienced major floods and a subsequent cholera epidemic. To clarify the population dynamics and transmission of Vibrio cholerae in Pakistan, we sequenced the genomes of all V. cholerae O1 El Tor isolates and compared the sequences to a global collection of 146 V. cholerae strains..."
- pvaldes 4y ago> I imagine a lovely bloom of Vibrio cholerae is likely to arise from mass flooding Fixable. All European capitals had cholera epidemics in their past. Scientists like John Snow sweated blood and tears and failed and failed again until fixing it. The Pakistani government could find useful to adopt the solutions that the evil UK developed 200 years ago and are freely available for everybody. Not need to reinvent the wheel anymore. In any case they had twelve years to do something about it, so are probably much better prepared now. In a desert I would chose having water over dry-to-the-bone land, all the time. Water is money
- nomel 4y agoIt brings fleeting new life, if it's not consistent.
- black_knight 4y agoIf water kill your child, na water you go use Water no get enemy
- daveslash 4y ago"Well, a little rain never hurt anybody..." "Yeah, But a lot can kill you" - Bonnie Hunt, Robin Williams, Jumanji, 1995 (approx 78 minutes in).
- photochemsyn 4y agoPakistan foreign minister: > "And while we understand that the new reality of climate change means more extreme weather, or monsoons, more extreme heat waves like we saw earlier this year, the scale of the current flood is of apocalyptic proportions. We certainly hope it's not a new climate reality." Pakistan also had major record-breaking flooding in 2010, and rainfall patterns appear very similar to this event: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Pakistan_floods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Pakistan_floods It's probably a safe bet that Pakistan will continue to see these kinds of events at least once every ten years for the foreseeable future, with a likely increase in frequency and severity. Warming the planet means pumping more moisture into the atmosphere, which in combination with more random global atmospheric circulation patterns, means more extremes of flood and drought.
- hertzrat 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoIt's pretty clear that the increased water vapor in the atmosphere, in combination with continued Himalayan glacial melt, is loading the dice. Note also that decadal flooding in Pakistan has been a trend going back to at least the 1970s.
- killyourcar 4y agoThat's not the causality the parent is drawing. They are saying these two events are likely because an increase in temperature increases moisture in the air, increases flooding. We're seeing more floods as an effect, not a cause.
- petre 4y agoIt's just politicians shifting the blame on climate change. Makes you wonder why the Netherlands don't have record-breaking floods.
- nicbou 4y ago
- indus 4y agoRead it somewhere that the Indus valley water system was the setting of the biblical floods. The delta of five rivers used to be as big as Alaska.
- hertzrat 4y agoThis is apocalyptic. Imagine something 100km from where you live, and that whole span between you and there being under water tomorrow. in a movie, that wouldn’t feel real no matter how good the special effects are, it’s too out there
- ElijahLynn 4y ago100km == 62miles
- hotpotamus 4y agoIt's the kind of story that gets passed down across generations and even makes it into holy books.
- jimjimjim 4y agounderrated comment. semi-localized catastrophe + oral history + time => whole world catastrophe for a population
- 3pt14159 4y agoThis is Great Lakes of Canada and the USA type distances here ladies and gentlemen. Crazy stuff.
- lhorie 4y agoI was trying to figure out a relatable comparison on a map. Looking from one side of the flood lake to the other would be like trying to spot Niagara Falls from Toronto, or San Jose from San Francisco - never mind that the distance is large enough for Earth's curvature to get in the way. And that's just thinking of it as a cross-sectional view of the lake, which doesn't say much about area. The way I ended up explaining it to my kids was that 33M people were affected. San Francisco population is ~800k, so around 40 SFs worth of people are impacted.
- boppo1 4y agoWell, not quite. The great lakes are rather deeper. That's not to say this isn't shocking or a sign of radical climate change.
- yrgulation 4y agoPoor management, corruption and a careless society amplify disasters times over. I am sorry for the people of pakistan, but this will happen again, and again. With climate change it will get even worse.
- dc-programmer 4y agoI don’t disagree with the analysis but the thought that crossed my mind reading it is that the developed world is trending towards the Pakistans of the world, not away. Every year kleptocracy and corruption become more normalized and the “me-first” popular movements that have arisen as a response to elite corruption are wholly unequipped to correct course. I am not optimistic my country will properly account for the long effects of climate change on human well-being.
- yrgulation 4y ago> the developed world is trending towards the Pakistans of the world, not away Think again. > I am not optimistic my country You should be tho. Things change and they sure will for pakistan. At least based on the mindset of the people i met from the country i am pretty darn optimistic they will, but they / you need to gain control. > elite corruption are wholly unequipped to correct course Sack them.
- munk-a 4y agoIt's important to specify where that blame of corruption and a careless society are placed - if Pakistan lived in a vacuum this flood wouldn't have been nearly as devastating. Countries that produced outsized amounts of pollution, deny climate change and refuse to act to address it deserve to be in the spotlight as well. China still has their head buried in the sand on this issue and the US is politically divided and all of the actions that have been taken have happened despite strong resistance from half of the political institution.
- yrgulation 4y agoThe US has always done dumb shit but it has two things all other countries lack. Introspection and the capacity to adapt. China is irrelevant in all this. It's a nuisance, not much else. It will do as told.
- acomjean 4y agoI always like the Nasa "earth observatory" pages: they have the before and after as a zoomed in image. https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/150279/devastating-floods-in-pakistan https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/150279/devastating-...
- lstodd 4y agoThat's what you get when you refuse to maintain and develop infrastructure and then build over floodable areas, as many in this thread said. Same stuff as Katrina and many other less-visible disasters related to "sudden" "floods". Californians can remember the Oroville Dam spillway failure - it's all the same, negligence multiple times over, just on a bit less scale.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- buescher 4y agoYes, but how deep?
- enviclash 4y agoAny urban planner out there with info about the influence of urbanisation on the disaster? Increasing climate change and increasing urbanisation are a global ticking cocktail.
- sporkland 4y agoFrom the article for those that don't click: > Killed 1,162 people, injured 3,554 and affected 33 million since mid-June. Shocked I haven't heard more than tiny references to this before now.
- random314 4y agoAccording to some commenters here (eg rayiner) this is simply called monsoon. The damage that conservative, right wing thinking does to the society, environment and a person's brain is preposterous. Not even the example of Nazi Germany can cause conservatives to course correct.
- amriksohata 4y agoThey desperately need aid however I fear the money will again fall into the wrong hands, isi or military to use it to fund war and weapons. Be careful who you donate to
- Animats 4y agoFor years, there was a lot of political pressure on climate scientists to not overestimate future damage. Now it turns out that damage was underestimated. Sea level rise used to be talked about in terms of inches. Now, meters.[1] [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/29/major-sea-level-rise-caused-by-melting-of-greenland-ice-cap-is-now-inevitable-27cm-climate https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/29/major-se...
- brunosan 4y agoYou can use this link to see the appalling scope of this flood. The layers you can toggle in the bottom right: 1) Lastest radar, 2) Last year radar for reference, 3) nighlights as a proxy of population. I selected radar because it's really good at detecting standing water on the ground (as blue). [Disclaimer I direct the PC project at Microsoft] https://planetarycomputer.microsoft.com/explore?c=68.0200%2C28.2492&z=11.08&v=2&d=sentinel-1-rtc%7C%7Csentinel-1-rtc%7C%7Chrea&s=true%3A%3A100%3A%3Afalse%7C%7Ctrue%3A%3A100%3A%3Atrue%7C%7Ctrue%3A%3A100%3A%3Afalse&m=cql%3Ace2e1119cd824953d6e81cbfcc828378%7C%7Ccql%3Abc27233161824d1bfa17d5de06fc5858%7C%7CMost+recent+%282019%29&r=VV%2C+VH+False-color+composite%7C%7CVV%2C+VH+False-color+composite%7C%7CNighttime+light+composite&ae=1 https://planetarycomputer.microsoft.com/explore?c=68.0200%2C...
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoWhen it comes to "climate change", most of the focus is unfortunately on the degree to which human activity is involved. The fact is that the climate of the earth has been changing, drastically and continuously, throughout the history of the planet. Just 13,000 years ago the oceans were 360 feet(!!) lower. While nobody should have any doubt that pollution from human activity has a small influence on the climate (as well as many other harmful side effects), we should all keep in mind the big picture. The climate is going to change, drastically, in the near term (geologically speaking), whether or not our behavior is involved at all. If we were a forward thinking society, we would be putting our efforts and our resources into preparing for inevitable climate changes that will have drastic effects across the globe, rather than keeping our heads in the sand and believing that the climate will remain stable if we just cut our carbon output. https://www.e-education.psu.edu/earth107/sites/www.e-education.psu.edu.earth107/files/Unit2/Mod4/Figure16.jpg https://www.e-education.psu.edu/earth107/sites/www.e-educati...
- dredmorbius 4y agoFor unified coverage and an excellent headlining side-by-side image showing flood and non-flood Indus River Valley, Wikipedia: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Pakistan_floods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Pakistan_floods> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Pakistan_floods#/media/File:2022_Pakistan_Floods_-_August_27,_2021_vs._August_27,_2022_in_Sindh.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_Pakistan_floods#/media/Fi...>