6 ms·
Yes, but art school just turned into a one-semester course.
by amelius 4y ago
Yes, but art school just turned into a one-semester course.
- sigmoid10 4y agoNot yet, but I can definitely imagine a future where these tools get more capable and refined, to the point where all the shortcomings listed above will be overcome. Knowledge about cameras and scene composition are already encoded in the networks to some degree, it just needs to become more accessible. There's probably also a better way to seed new images than by starting with random noise, so we could get similar variations easier. We have already made the big step towards creativity and real world understanding of objects and their lighting, the remaining issues are more technical and unless we are incredibly unlucky and run into a true show-stopper, we'll probably all have access to a high quality digital artist that can reduce production times dramatically.
- thrown_22 4y agoYou need to give some information about the scene to the network. Camera settings is just a short hand to describe the field of view and depth of focus (at the very least). If you make that implicit you'd still need to give the network the steradians, focal length, circle of confusion, etc. etc. etc. that you want your image to use. You'd need to understand everything in Hecht's Optics to tweak all the parameters of an AI generated image.
- sigmoid10 4y agoThat's an implementation problem, not a technical or conceptual one. Diffusion models have shown that they can learn practically all of these things if you make them sufficiently big.
- WJW 4y agoOf course not, it just gained a new "advanced stable diffusion usage" track. Photography didn't displace painting from art school, and even outside art there are plenty of examples to be found. CNC machines are awesome, but every machining class in existence still teaches manual lathing and milling.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoNobody gets paid to be a telephone operator or a cobbler or a steeplejack anymore either. If new tools come along that automates and further commoditizes the production of art, I don't see the issue. Automatic driving for trucking, public transport, taxis would economically impact vastly more people, and everyone here seems to be cheering for that. There's nothing special about art. People will still do it as a hobby, like they do with a lot of other dead trades and professions. In many ways I think the personal aspect of the creation and sharing with people you know is the special thing, rather than the creation or performance of a commercial success (not that I've had any experience with the latter, mind you). And I'm not against the mass consumption of art, just that it needn't be produced by people if it has the same entertainment value then that's great.
- fingerlocks 4y agoCobblers still exist. I visit one regularly for shoe repair. https://www.davepagecobbler.com/ https://www.davepagecobbler.com/
- throwawaylinux 4y agoWell you got me. I guess chimney sweeps and black smiths and loom weavers and carriage drivers still exist too, not sure about steeplejacks since the passing of Fred Dibnah. But you get what I'm trying to say, hopefully.
- fingerlocks 4y agoYou included “cobbler” only because it sounds old-timey to you, and I was pointing out that it’s not. Repairing expensive shoes is not an automated process. It’s more like fixing a roof leak, landscaping, or changing a flat tire. Jobs for those things still exist and aren’t going anywhere.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoNo I included it because it used to be a common profession and now it is an extremely niche one. I could have also put chimney sweep in there knowing that it's still a thing. Someone is still going to pay for a person to perform or create art for them. Some professional driving jobs will continue to exist long after most are automated. When I said "nobody", that's what's known as hyperbole.
- rvz 4y agoNow let's have a real oil on canvas hard copy painting of that digitally generated image please? SD is limited to only digital art first of all, so let's not get too over-excited and hyped around this tool just yet.
- ekianjo 4y agoi dont think it would be a massive stretch of the imagination to be able to train a robotic arm to hold a brush and reproduce something that is on screen and do it really well.
- omnimus 4y agoMachines like that already exist but specifically with oil painting there is a lot of important information in how was the paint applied. So it is really really hard. Too many decisions in tools used, angles of the strokes, pressure, thickness of the color etc. You might make painting that looks identical from far away but when you come close it will be completely different.
- Filligree 4y agoSounds like a job for machine learning. "Just" need a decent simulation of how that works, first!
- SyzygistSix 4y agoNo, it didn't but people who took only one semester of art classes may remain under the delusion that art is about making pretty pictures. People who need illustration or graphics with no particular style can meet their needs with this tool but that is far from art. This replaces commercial illustration, not artists.
- bsenftner 4y agoExactly, this replaces general illustrative commercial art. This is great for illustrations at the head intro of fiction stories. However, fine artists that produce art where the object created is merely the totem for their actual art: intellectual conceptualization of an idea, often concerning the finality of life and the immature behaviors we playout within; that type of Fine Art is completely out of reach of modern AIs. I'm sure there are attempts by AI developers to mimic such art, but that mimicking will be gibberish. It requires a sentient being to create Fine Art, because Fine Art is an 360 degree expression of existence, not some pretty picture.
- shagie 4y agoI can see this replacing the clip and misappropriated art in slide presentations that no one is paying for currently with a $20/month service that lets you do "line art angry man in toga at computer" to put into your talk on Kuberentes. It might replace the "nice pic, do you have it at {size} so I can use it as a desktop image" comments on various social media sites. I don't see it replacing an actual photograph as a wall hanging (or a painting) because they are subtly wrong in some ways. The reflection in the lake doesn't match the landscape... that one cloud has its lighting at slightly different angle than the rest.
- roywiggins 4y ago> because they are subtly wrong in some ways Well, they are now. Give it a year and we'll see.
- 4y ago