15 ms·
Increased wind turbine rotor blade visibility to reduce avian fatalities
- Symbiote 4y agoThere's a picture in the original paper, Paint it black: Efficacy of increased wind turbine rotor blade visibility to reduce avian fatalities: https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592 https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592 (And with a name like Jens Åström, he should be researching hydropower.)
- mellavora 4y agohint: Å is the Swedish word for a stream/small river. translating ström is left as an exercise for the curious.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoSpoiler alert! ... I'd have guessed ström = stream. Seems like I'm right, more or less.
- diydsp 4y agobased on German, yes it is a stream, but not necessarily of water...
- Ma8ee 4y agoNot only stream but current.
- gruturo 4y agoYou're right, but it also means current, and that meaning is often used (in German too) to refer to electricity, which I imagine is what OP had in mind. It's indeed a perfect surname for researching / working on hydro power.
- brnt 4y agoThere are two rivers (creeks?) called Aa in the Netherlands. We don't have Aa or A in our dictonairy but now I wonder if there's a shared root somewhere.
- Symbiote 4y agoWiktionary is usually good with words like this: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Reconstruction:Proto-Germanic/ahw%C5%8D#Descendants https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Reconstruction:Proto-Germanic... And it thinks "a" is an archaic Dutch word meaning stream: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/a#Dutch https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/a#Dutch
- Beltalowda 4y agoThere are far more than two, and according to [1] it is indeed related via the proto-Germanic "ahwō" for stream or river. [1]: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aa_(waternaam) https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aa_(waternaam)
- fastball 4y agoI was really hoping for a video of what this actually looks like when the turbine is moving.
- ravenstine 4y agoAs if windmills weren't enough of an eyesore already. The value of windmills (yes I know they're wind turbines but I don't care, I'm calling them windmills) is very limited. Most of the places I've seen with lots of windmills really should be nuclear powered instead, but politicians get a lot of brownie points for windmills. They can be a good thing for rural areas or places with limited infrastructure, but the whole windmill thing is beating around the bush when it comes to a practical solution that also doesn't engage the carbon cycle.
- HPsquared 4y agoBeing highly visible is an advantage (politically): they give a strong impression of "look, we're doing something!". Plastic straw bans are a more extreme example, but the same effect.
- wmeredith 4y agoYou're going to need to provide a source for claiming that the value of wind power is "very limited". Land-based utility-scale wind is one of the lowest-priced energy sources available today, costing 1–2 cents per kilowatt-hour after the production tax credit[0]. Please note that governments still spend more subsidizing fossil fuel extraction and production than wind power generation. About double[1][2]. 0. https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/advantages-and-challenges-wind-energy https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/advantages-and-challenges-w... 1. https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2018/03/16/how-much-do-renewables-actually-depend-on-tax-breaks/ https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2018/03/16/how-much-do-ren... 2. https://www.iea.org/topics/energy-subsidies https://www.iea.org/topics/energy-subsidies
- HonestOp001 4y agoPlease delineate in your comment that this is for the world. Not for the United States or other western countries. Those governments listed in the report have to quell their population to avoid an uprising. Wind power’s limits: 1. Not a base load provider 2. Requires an energy ready base load provider 3. Is dependent on an energy source that is not providing steady inputs 4. Has larger footprints than nuclear plants 5. Blot the natural landscape
- wmeredith 4y agoWith wind power killing 20,000 birds a year, and fossil fuel extraction killing 14,000,000 in the same time period... does it matter? I mean, paint the turbines or whatever, but it's hard to care about sweeping the porch when the house is on fire. The source for those numbers is linked in the article itself: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0960148112000857?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09601...
- nickff 4y agoIf you want a proposal to succeed, it is usually better to address concerns from others, rather than to dismiss them. Dismissing concerns not only alienates the people bringing them forward, but also makes bystanders see you (and the proposal) as inflexible and rigid.
- wmeredith 4y agoI am totally on the same page with you in most cases. Having said that, I've got doubts about the sincerity of people arguing against renewable power for environmental reasons. It's hard to take it seriously.
- ok_dad 4y agoIt’s just a tactic those people use to force rational actors to become irrational. We should just ignore those who would throw the baby out with the bath water, when it comes to environmental “concerns” like this.
- ncmncm 4y agoYou can take bird deaths seriously without reducing build-out of renewables. The blades are painted all over, regardless. It doesn't cost appreciably more to put a stripe on.
- HeyLaughingBoy 4y agoPerhaps not, but if the stripe makes them more visible to the people living nearby, then they may not want the turbines there at all.
- driggs 4y agoGiven that wind turbines are universally(?) white, I've always assumed it is to minimize heat absorption. If so, painting 1/3 of the blades black would increase heating of the painted blade, especially in lower latitudes (this study was done at high latitude in Norway). What's the side effect? Also, this strategy will obviously have zero impact on bat deaths, given that a white blade and a black blade are identical to echolocation at night. Curtailment of turbines in low wind condition - which is when bats are able to fly, and when turbines produce the least amount of energy - is the proven way to minimize bat deaths. But wind farms want to maximize energy production (profit), so are not fond of curtailment as a strategy.
- actually_a_dog 4y agoA lot of things are painted white because titanium dioxide is a super cheap, white pigment.
- exmadscientist 4y agoIs carbon black not a super cheap, black pigment?
- samatman 4y agoA lot of things are painted black as well.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoEcho-reflective surfaces. Plus I agree bats have worth, but these guys carry crazy amounts of diseases like cough cough Covid-19 cough.
- unethical_ban 4y agoNot really, and they are great pest control. In South Texas we have bat colonies under freeway overpasses, and trust me, bats are not a source of disease concern here beyond "don't mess with them even if injured".
- MaxBarraclough 4y agoI suggest the link be changed to point directly to the open access paper ( https://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592 https://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592 ). The linked article adds nothing and, as Symbiote's comment points out, doesn't even include an image.
- dang 4y agoOk, changed from https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2020/09/a-simple-paint-job-can-save-birds-from-wind-turbines/ https://www.anthropocenemagazine.org/2020/09/a-simple-paint-.... Thanks!
- mlatu 4y agoexcept that link to the paper doesnt load at all here...glad the old link was conserved
- MaxBarraclough 4y agoHow about these should-be-equivalent links? * https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.6592 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.6592 * https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592 https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.6592
- ncmncm 4y agoIt would have been helpful to see if painting a stripe, or the leading or trailing edges would suffice or work better. I had gathered that somebody tried wires sticking out of the trailing edges, to help warn away bats, successfully. It would be good to get a lot more deployment and experimentation out.
- Dig1t 4y agoHonestly I think natural selection will take care of this problem. Just let the birds kill themselves, eventually they will learn to stay away from the giant whirling death blades. Most birds are afraid of humans and other animals because of this exact mechanism. We should just worry about making these things as aesthetically appealing to humans and as efficient as possible.
- mey 4y agoNatural selection works on a timescale that is longer than you are imagining. It is entirely possible for an ecosystem to be radically altered before there is a chance for adaptation by existing species. There is no reason not to take ecology into the consideration of any project. Just another trade off.
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago1) Why is this article sabotaging itself by not showing the picture provided in the original paper? 2) Just like many other low effort high impact discoveries, we will never ever see this used on a significant amount of wind turbines, which is very depressing.
- wiredfool 4y ago> It was not effective at all for willow ptarmigan, ground birds which tend to run into the turbines’ base rather than its blades. That certainly says more about ptarmigans than turbines.
- tonymet 4y agowind turbine bird deaths are vastly underestimated
- kerblang 4y ago> It was not effective at all for willow ptarmigan, ground birds which tend to run into the turbines’ base rather than its blades What is wrong with these birds
- driggs 4y agoHa! Ptarmigans are fat ground-dwelling birds related to grouse and chickens. They would probably collide with the broad side of a barn. I can't imagine they spend much time flying, especially not flying high or far, but apparently they're known to migrate up to 100 miles.
- sohkamyung 4y agoUnfortunately, a paint job may not save vultures from collisions [1]. I learned of this from Ed Yong's new book, "An Immense World". > Vultures have such large blind spots in their visual field that they cannot see objects directly in front of them when they fly. This discovery explains why vultures frequently collide with conspicuous structures such as wind turbines and power lines, despite having some of the sharpest eyes of any animal. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2012.10214 https://www.nature.com/articles/nature.2012.10214
- fastball 4y agoSo do they frequently collide with trees in nature or...?
- sohkamyung 4y agoWindmills are much higher than trees, I believe. Vultures don't expect structures to be that tall when they are looking for food.
- JetAlone 4y agoThat's bad news, vultures are quite ecologically important.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoThe numbers are trivial - in one study posted here, no more dead birds were found under wind turbines than anywhere else. And that would be in the single digits per area studied. The truth is, birds are born to die. A bird has a nest of eggs - but the bird population is normally quite stable. So on average, nearly all new birds die by the end of the year. Cold, hunger, natural predation, disease. This is a solution looking for a problem.
- japanuspus 4y agoAt some point I saw a report on the actual numbers (was working in a big wind power company and a colleague was heading our research on this topic). One big take-away for me was that the number of bird fatalities due to windows in high-rise buildings was orders of magnitude larger than the number caused by wind turbines.
- alias_neo 4y agoMy school, 20+ years ago had a huge glass side (possibly still does) that at just the right time of day was utterly indistinguishable from the sky to the human eye. I sat in many an assembly to the huge "thud" of birds flying into it at full speed. The school never did anything about it in the time I was there. This was one school with some 20-30m wide windows, imagine just a single building with an order of magnitude more glass. The glass balcony of the flat I used to live in caused issues for birds, I imagine glass is a much, much larger issue than wind turbines given its prevalence.
- atoav 4y agoMost bird protectionists on Germany are of the opinion that instead of barring wind turbines while citing birds as the reason, birds would be better served if for every wind turbine some amount of space would be dedicated to the protection of those birds. Wind turbines are a (somewhat small) danger to a very specific subset of (bigger) birds, so this is essentially a plea to priorize the good of the bird population over the good of the individual bird.
- pjc50 4y ago
- dreamcompiler 4y agoNumber of birds killed annually in the United States by Wind turbines: 140,000 to 328,000 [0] Cars: 340 million [1] Building collisions: 365 to 988 million [2] Cats: 1.3 to 4.0 billion [3] [4] [0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0006320713003522 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00063... [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/05/29/bird-deaths-car-crashes/9623931/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/05/29/bird-deaths-c... [2] https://bioone.org/journals/the-condor/volume-116/issue-1/CONDOR-13-090.1/Birdbuilding-collisions-in-the-United-States--Estimates-of-annual/10.1650/CONDOR-13-090.1.full https://bioone.org/journals/the-condor/volume-116/issue-1/CO... [3] https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms2380 https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms2380 [4] https://www.npr.org/2013/01/29/170588511/killer-kitties-cats-kill-billions-every-year https://www.npr.org/2013/01/29/170588511/killer-kitties-cats...
- dylan604 4y ago"It was not effective at all for willow ptarmigan, ground birds which tend to run into the turbines’ base rather than its blades." I want to see these numbers. They can't be very high. Actually, I want to see a new horror flick where the blond protagonist is ambushed by ground birds running into her house. I'm guessing it won't have the same affect as the Hitchcock's
- therockspush 4y agoBirdemic might give you what you crave.https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZH1SNmY_1XY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZH1SNmY_1XY
- TheDudeMan 4y agoWow.
- rainbowzootsuit 4y agoThat movie has the most ludicrously poor mix on the audio that I've ever experienced. I saw it in a theater and the levels ranged from threshold of pain to inaudible. I thoroughly look forward to revisiting it in this alternative presentation. Thank you for sharing.
- bogrollben 4y agoI don't understand why they only painted a single blade black. Why not all of them?
- fastball 4y agoA. 3x the work B. I imagine part of the benefit is from alternating colors which makes the blades more visible as they spin.
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoFrom the paper, painting a single blade reduces 'visual smear'.
- jdeibele 4y agoI'm surprised they didn't try UV-reflective paint. Amazon sells decals [0] that people can stick to their windows to reduce birds flying into them. The Humane Society has other approaches. [1] UV-reflective paint would hopefully be visible to birds and not to people so a windmill wouldn't be any more distracting than a current one. I could see where 20 or 30 windmills in sight, each with one black blade, might be visually distracting. [0]https://smile.amazon.com/s?k=bird+window+decals https://smile.amazon.com/s?k=bird+window+decals [1]https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/make-your-windows-bird-safe https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/make-your-windows-bi...
- ordu 4y ago> Willow ptarmigan carcasses were excluded from the analyses as these are known to collide with the tower base (see Stokke et al., 2020[1]) How?! It takes some mental effort to not blame victim in this situation. The article linked gives only one actual observation of bird managing to kill itself this way: > it was observed that one individual, part of a group of 10 birds, crashed directly into the tower base at 2.7 m height above ground (25 September 2011, at 07:05 a.m.). The rest of the group passed the tower on both sides. [1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.6307 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/ece3.6307
- anovikov 4y agoBirds may be badly disoriented when seeing the moving blades close by. Not at all surprised. Their sense of perspective, distance and speed may fail them badly when seeing an object bigger than they were instinctively supposed to ever meet, moving faster and on unusual trajectory.
- ajuc 4y agoBirds are colliding with skyscrappers and bridges all the time despite no moving parts.
- pjc50 4y agoDo not underestimate how stupid some birds can be. Corvids are intelligent, pigeons not so much.
- Zobat 4y agoI think they excluded birds colliding with the base as that was suspected to be unrelated to the actual turbine blades. Removing confounding variables is part of statistics and always up for debate but the article/paper did not measure the effects on birds colliding with wind turbine bases, just birds killed by turbine blades. Then again, a lot of bad research results have come from ignoring the "right" data points.
- registeredcorn 4y agoThat's nice. Can anything be done to not make them look like a monstrous eyesore?
- tsimionescu 4y agoBy far the best cure for that is to learn to like them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 8bitsrule 4y agoThere used to be a bird called the 'Passenger Pigeon'. It "was once the most abundant bird in North America, numbering around 3 billion, and possibly up to 5 billion." It was hunted to extinction by 1901. Glad to see people more concerned about bird populations. But, of course, that isn't why this wind-turbine meme is kept circulating.
- hetspookjee 4y agoA story that stood by me is the one of the lyre bird and the hunt to near extinction in the early 1900s for their impressive tail feathers. I cannot find the source on wikipedia anymore nor can I find these conservation efforts in a quick google search, but what stood by me is that 120 years ago people were also concerned about conservation of species.
- topynate 4y agoThe Israel Nature and Parks Authority studied bird and bat kill and the effectiveness of mitigations and ended up calling for a moratorium. So did the environment ministry and the Society for the Protection of Nature [1]. That article is worth reading not so much for the absolute numbers of birds and bats killed, as for the mitigation study. The wind company, Enlight, put a Portuguese radar system in to stop the turbines when large birds flew close. (This was a condition of their permit.) The INPA cross-checked this against data from bird tracking tags. The system didn't activate even once when the tracked birds entered the supposed range of the radar. I've had a bee in my bonnet about bird kill since reading the last graf: "An Enlight spokesperson defended the company’s actions. The company did not respond to requests to comment on the INPA study showing the Portuguese technology to be ineffective." Either the radar really is that bad, which I think is unlikely, or Enlight configured it not to trigger. Either way it's pretty unconscionable for them to play coy. For all the comments here and elsewhere about no-one really caring about incidental bird take, this seems a clearer case of bad faith to me. It's a company refusing to engage with the public about a proven failure of its systems while seeking additional concessions. It's OK to be an anti-NIMBY. Saying everyone who cares about birds is arguing in bad faith isn't laudable, but it's besides the point, really. Just bear in mind that wind companies are not operating to save the environment, but to make a profit. They can act in bad faith too. Therefore, if you have any interest in reducing the ecological stress turbines create, you should also be interested in keeping those companies honest. [1] https://www.timesofisrael.com/environment-minister-seeking-moratorium-on-new-wind-farms-to-probe-impact-on-nature/ https://www.timesofisrael.com/environment-minister-seeking-m...
- topynate 4y agoJust to give an idea of what the actual trade-offs are between the benefits of wind and the immediate ecological impact, I ran some numbers a few months ago and reached an estimate of somewhere between $1700 and $2500 saved in "social cost of carbon" per dead bird, for on-shore wind power in Scotland and the north of England. Social cost of carbon is the estimated value of the benefits of reduced carbon emissions, including benefits to human health. For a non-endangered bird, even $1700 saved is a good deal. Clearly a pigeon's life is not worth $1700 (not that pigeons are particularly at risk from turbines). For a critically endangered bird, it is not a good deal at all (extinctions are very bad). At some point there's a cross-over. The problem is that as you build out wind power, you kill more birds, which starts putting populations under stress that weren't stressed before. In other words the cross-over point moves. That makes effective mitigations more important the more wind power gets built. Ideally a doubling of capacity should be accompanied by a halving of the kill rate per unit of capacity. A mitigation strategy that could cope with all the planned capacity increases would probably look like: paint jobs on all new build, plus effective radar that can brake the turbines, plus a form of active deterrent (i.e. microwave or sonic repellent). All this while policing the wind companies by tracking tagged birds.
- PostOnce 4y agoWhat if we went the other direction and made windmills out of transparent materials so the NIMBYs and Kennedys would not bitch about them? Glass-effect windmills would look pretty cool.
- szszrk 4y agoWow, what does this mean? I mean it for real, what does those sentences mean? I get the transparency concept but windmills produce flour and are not that common anymore, so why is anyone bothered by them? Also Nimbys sound like critter-like horror animal and Kennedys are ... ex president's family?
- PostOnce 4y agoWindmill and wind turbine are interchangeable in English, and have been for quite some time. You can occasionally make a distinction for a traditional windmill for actual grain, but if its a bunch of blades spun by the wind, windmill works to describe it. NIMBYs are people who complain about things being built near them. Ted Kennedy famously opposed wind turbines near his home.
- Cenk 4y ago“Estimates of up to a million or more birds a year are killed by turbines in the US but that is far exceeded by collisions with communications towers (6.5 million); power lines, (25 million); windows (up to 1 billion); and cats (1.3 to 4.0 billion) and those lost due to habitat loss, pollution and climate change”
- gregmac 4y agoLooks like this [1] is where you got that. Has a decent chart, and I think the last part of the paragraph is also interesting: > Even if there were twenty times more wind turbines, enough to supply the US with electricity, the number of birds killed, assuming no improvement in wind turbine design, would be about 10 million--still far less than most other causes of bird deaths. [1] https://www.sierraclub.org/michigan/wind-turbines-and-birds-and-bats https://www.sierraclub.org/michigan/wind-turbines-and-birds-...
- navi0 4y agoThe lack of nuance here is troubling and commits the fallacy that birds are a homogeneous population where one bird killed by wind turbines = one bird killed by a domestic cat. From the paper's abstract: "The treatment had the largest effect on reduction of raptor fatalities; no white-tailed eagle carcasses were recorded after painting. Applying contrast painting to the rotor blades significantly reduced the collision risk for a range of birds." A cursory Internet search reveals that raptors (and bats) are particularly vulnerable to wind turbines[0], and many raptor populations have been threatened for a long time due to a variety of threats and biology (they take longer to reproduce and recover). And if one were to describe all the threats to birds listed here, they are basically iterations under the "loss of habitat" super-category. Yes, power lines are also a big threat to raptor and other threatened avian populations, but wind turbines (and the power lines they use) are still being built, so reducing avian deaths from both sources seems worth researching and implementing. Especially when the parent article notes how little it would cost to paint the blades during manufacture (vs. post-installation). [0] https://abcbirds.org/wind-energy-threatens-birds/ https://abcbirds.org/wind-energy-threatens-birds/
- effnorwood 4y ago