5 ms·
So basically, their self driving software assumes that stop signs are all the same size and is using some simple scaling algorithm to judge where to stop? And
by jqpabc123 4y ago
So basically, their self driving software assumes that stop signs are all the same size and is using some simple scaling algorithm to judge where to stop?
And this is what passes for AI? The singularity is upon us folks.
Just give me a simple car with analog guages and a Bluetooth radio so I can talk hands free and listen to the 100+ albums I have stored on my phone. I'll provide any "intelligence" required, thank you very much.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>And this is what passes for AI? Autopilot is kind of a scam. Marketing and economic pixie dust from Elon over a basic camera lane assist system to make sure Teslas attract customers and hold their prestige and value. But no, FSD is perpetually 6 months around the corner for him.
- d_tr 4y agoI do not know what buyers actually expect, but the phrase "FSD Beta" should sound very stupid to anyone with half a brain. It means that it almost drives like a human or better and it needs a bit of polishing. It is not only false, it is irresponsible too in this context.
- jqpabc123 4y agoAutopilot is kind of a scam. AI is kind of a scam --- and autopilot is just one example. FSD is perpetually 6 months around the corner for him. And will probably remain so for decades to come.
- Hellion 4y ago“AI” is not a scam, but it’s a very wide term that people abuse. The self driving software packages that work, the Cruze and Waymos and Mercedes of the world, are in limited careful rollout. These companies and teams want to make sure it’s safe and robust before entering mass market adoption. Tesla is one of the weakest and most immature offerings of the major players, and it has been given the widest distribution. It is utterly frustrating.
- jqpabc123 4y ago"AI” is not a scam, but it’s a very wide term that people abuse. The abuse starts with using the phrase "artificial intelligence".
- kadoban 4y agoIf it's a scam, it's a really old one. It's been called AI since the state-of-the-art was a few "if" statements chained together.
- jqpabc123 4y agoIt's an oldie but goodie --- but still a scam. Selling what we call a computer as "intelligent" is like selling a DVD player as "creative" for it's ability to produce video. They are both just play back devices --- reproducing the work of others. Useful for sure but no more "intelligent" or "creative" than a hammer.
- kadoban 4y agoWhat would you call the field of Artificial Intelligence then? I can't think of anything.
- jqpabc123 4y agoPattern Recognition? Automated Learning? Adaptive Software?
- jqpabc123 4y agoA new one that I'm kinda fond of --- Probabilistic Programming. Any answer that "AI" provides has no assurance of correctness. It's up to you to judge if the probability is acceptable. Do you really want to trust a self driving vehicle that misinterprets it's environment 20% of the time?
- parkingrift 4y agoAutopilot is just a marketing name for assisted cruise control. I think a majority of new cars have assisted cruise control at this point. My 2019 CRV has it. Full self driving is the scam. And it goes up in price to $15,000 next week. It’s almost comical to imagine even one single person buying that.
- syntaxing 4y agoThis is true because they use cameras and camera lack depth information despite it being used with “state of the art AI”. This would not be an issue if they have any real depth based measurement system like a LiDAR.
- jeffwass 4y agoHow hard is it to use multiple cameras to gauge depth perception, as per human binocular vision? (Serious question, I know nil about machine vision)
- refulgentis 4y agoIt's well understood to be impossible / not there yet, the argument then shifts to "but ML is awesome so it could happen?" to which the correct response is "anything is possible but we're nowhere close"
- Gaessaki 4y agoIn some ways, it can be better than lidar. The colour signal can be perfectly matched with the depth signal to provide further context. This is particularly useful for tracking moving objects. Vision-based systems also have a far greater resolution, especially when additional cameras are added. But having both would be best. The drawbacks of camera are additional compute being necessary for stitching and the risk of occlusions occurring due to something like adverse weather conditions. It also only offers a calculated estimation rather than a true distance measurement.
- syntaxing 4y agoIt’s extremely difficult, the biggest issue is that any vision based depth system is so damn noisy.
- hnburnsy 4y agoDo Teslas have 2 main forward cameras? I know that Subarus do as you can see them https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2012/03/subaru-uses-stereo-3d-tech-in-new-eyesight-adas/ https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2012/03/subaru-uses-stereo...