16 ms·
Welcome Home, Garry Tan
- threefiftyone96 4y agoCongratulations, Garry! Huge fan of your work, especially the high-value YouTube material. One question: what does this mean for Initialized Capital?
- threeseed 4y agoJason Calcanis commented about this on his recent Youtube video which was strangely enough deleted. That it could be a massive conflict of interest situation where Garry could funnel the best YC startups into Initialized before demo-day.
- thenerdhead 4y agoCongrats Garry! Huge fan of your work and demeanor.
- syrusakbary 4y agoI'm incredibly happy with this move. I got to chat with Initialized (Garry was one of the co-founders) a while ago and I must mention that I was greatly impressed by Garry down-to-earth questions, knowledge, kindness and humility. I've been following him since on his Youtube channel... it's a gold mine for any entrepreneur out there. Excited for what lies ahead for YC. [1]: https://youtube.com/garrytan https://youtube.com/garrytan
- NCC1701DEngage 4y agoI actually found his channel with the alternative YouTube recommendations database I'm working on. He was one of the top links off the list for Y Combinator's channel. The list for his channel includes some likely suspects like TechCrunch, Y Combinator, and a16z but also some smaller names doing business advice like Section4 and David Perell: https://channelgalaxy.com/id%3DUCIBgYfDjtWlbJhg--Z4sOgQ/ https://channelgalaxy.com/id%3DUCIBgYfDjtWlbJhg--Z4sOgQ/
- breck 4y agoI've used a lot of great products from Garry over the years. My favorite is the software he built that YC alums get to use. From 2008-2012 we had an email list. Garry wrote a Rails site (IIRC) in 2012 and that was a clear inflection point for YC alums. Total game changer for many of us and has provided lots of value over the years. I think it was also the starting point for online SUS. Congrats Garry/YC!
- upupandup 4y ago
- maram 4y ago“Garry Tan is a moral canary in a coal mine. When people hate on Garry Tan, they out themselves as either evil or stupid, because in fact Garry is as close to a 100% good guy as you get”. —Paul Graham https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1460931338131890180 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1460931338131890180 ———— Congratulations Garry! Your blogs were my inspirations when I was running my startup. I always remember this line: “The ideal startup team involves really two major roles — builder, and hustler. I used to say it took three roles (designer, engineer, hustler).....In reality, I think designer / engineer can be abstracted to builder”.
- stakkur 4y agoI have no strong opinion of Tan, but calling a person who happily worked for (and profited from) Palantir a 'moral canary in a coal mine' seems a bit of a stretch.
- LewisVerstappen 4y agoTan worked at Palantir prior to 2007, so if you’re blaming him for Palantir’s work with ICE then… > they out themselves as either evil or stupid
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 4y agoI dunno, but Palantir has always been a little bit… I mean, it’s kinda in the name.
- hackernewds 4y agoNot really
- Apocryphon 4y agoBy the time of the LoTR timeframe, when have the palantiri ever been used for good? Seems like malevolently misleading things happen even to the evil characters after they use it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palant%C3%ADr#Characteristics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palant%C3%ADr#Characteristics
- tosh 4y agoGreat person/institution-fit!
- hellomyguys 4y agoI guess everyone Garry has blocked on Twitter will not be applying to YC any time soon :)
- smcl 4y agoWhat's the story here, did this happen a lot or something?
- password4321 4y agoMany who get into it start blocking lists they get from their bubble.
- hellomyguys 4y agoFrom my understanding he autoblocks anyone who likes a tweet that pushes back on his political takes.
- daniel-cussen 4y agoMessages just like it are evenly diffused with death threats. That's why. I've gotten death threats, no joke. Hitman showed up at my house one time. No joke. No joke.
- smcl 4y agoOK so I was waiting for a reply like this that explained the accusation. I read this, liked a few @garrytan replies that weren't positive and ... it appears I'm now blocked!? What the hell!!??
- smcl 4y agoedit: so apparently I conducted my test at a really unfortunate time when Twitter was having some global problems. It has recovered and I am not blocked at all.
- garry 4y agoTwitter has been a tough one - I got involved in local politics which has been a challenge. Large accounts typically do have to block a lot to make it usable, and in particular I've had problems with folks doxxing my former home address (I had to sell that house and move), and making threats of violence against me. I'm sorry if I got it wrong, and I am happy to unblock if I did get it wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- balentio 4y agoWhile I acknowledge business as a driving force behind tech, I think if you want to "change the world" all you really have to do is provide solid financial support to open source tech since that is where most of the "For profit" inspiration is coming from anyway.
- brianliou91 4y agoWhen I was in YC Garry showed me how to be a founder. After YC Garry showed me how to be a more compassionate human to myself and others. I'd recommend everyone check out the inner work Garry has also achieved beyond his external achievements. Congrats Garry!
- jtemplestein 4y agoWhat a great appointment! I've had one brief interaction with Gary a long time ago, and he's been a role model ever since I had a difference in opinion with my cofounder and wanted to leave the startup we'd founded, even if it meant leaving the YC program (which I adored), and would likely lose my visa to stay in the US. Seeing how distressed I was, Gary took me aside somehow simultaneously made me feel heard, but also told me that it's up to me to come back stronger from this moment. It made all the difference to me, and I've thought back to that moment many times in the years to come.
- extent-connifer 4y ago(Throwaway because it’s a small world) This is disappointing. YC needs a fresh perspective. Recycling older members is not a positive sign for continued innovation. I wouldn’t point to “HODL diamond hands” crypto hype (suddenly disappeared..) and personal brand-building content creation as the type of leadership YC needs at this stage. Specifically in this, someone who has been running a large VC fund for the past half-decade with considerable inside deal access through YC. The conflicts of interest are sizable, and we can’t really pretend that they won’t compound now that Garry’s at the head of YC. Lastly, to balance flood of positive reviews, there have been consistent (if quiet, again, small world) reports of pettiness and using power/influence against personal grudges. I have not worked with Garry directly, founder friends have and back channels are..not same as the public comments here. Everyone has weaknesses. This isn’t a good one for the position.
- ignoramous 4y ago> YC needs a fresh perspective. Recycling older members is not a positive sign for continued innovation. That they may need [0], but I wouldn't be as dismissive about their current crop of partners either, given their ridiculous and sustained success. > Lastly, to balance flood of positive reviews, there have been consistent (if quiet, again, small world) reports of pettiness and using power/influence against personal grudges. I wouldn't know for sure, but there's two sides to every coin: With great power comes great responsibility" / "With great power comes the absolute certainity that you will turn into a right c*" [0] In the lieu of other firms doing things differently, including ex-YC Daniel Gross' Pioneer.App, BeOnDeck, Enterpreneur First, Sequoia Arc, a16z Start, and others.
- goldenchrome 4y agoThat’s pretty funny. A sizable chunk of leaders I’ve encountered left a wake of discontent behind them. And it’s always in the form of pettiness and grudges. Some people just have weak morals. I imagine that’s why they chase power for so long—to prove that they don’t.
- baxtr 4y ago> (Throwaway because it’s a small world) So you don’t think they can check your email? Sincere question.
- sneak 4y ago> After earning a degree in computer engineering from Stanford, Garry was an engineer at Palantir and then created one of the earliest and best-designed blogging platforms, Posterous. This is a reminder that Palantir is the firm that sells data mining software to US police and military organizations that then use it to violate human rights. It should be a black mark on anyone’s record.
- Aeolun 4y agoI don’t think it’s necessarily his, or Palantirs’ fault that the US government is evil.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoAll states are evil
- dang 4y agoPlease keep generic ideological rhetoric off HN, regardless of ideology. It's repetitive and therefore tedious and therefore not what this site is for. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=generic%20ideolog%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deepspace 4y ago> It should be a black mark on anyone’s record. Exactly. I have always maintained that a small but significant way to put pressure on 'evil' companies, like Palantir, is to blacklist any employees who have them on their resume, making it difficult for them to attract talent. Unfortunately, I have found that very people share that view, and I am hard-pressed to figure out why.
- novok 4y agoYou don't create an ability to have redemption, forgiveness, rehabilitation, or regret. The first step to get someone to change their mind is to remove the dependency of them having an income on said philosophy, and one of the best ways to do that is to give them a chance to not work there anymore and move past it. By forcing them into an association ghetto, you create stronger supporters for the group you dislike, because they have no other options left. Also everyone's personal set of shit companies doesn't overlap, so it's very easy for no one to get hired fairly quickly, and sometimes people chose the unpopular place out of necessity vs. choice at the time. A large amount of employees people want to hire have probably worked at a company that people didn't like at one time or another. It's pretty easy to think of a set of nerds who don't like that you've worked at any one of google, microsoft, apple, amazon, facebook, netflix, robinhood, stripe, hospital system, any bank/finance/fintech, government, etc. Pretty much the only companies left are the ones that are not relevant enough to do anything to the world that would lead to someone being a hater in the first place.
- fourstar 4y agoCongrats, Garry. You told me when I interviewed to have a co-founder. I'm happy to report I still can't find a co-founder but you were right.
- justinzollars 4y agoGarry is an awesome individual. Not only a mentor in tech, but a community advocate in San Francisco! I'm so happy about this news!
- throwaway20222 4y agoCongrats! Tons of respect. What is happening to your current VC fund? I may have missed it, but who do you hand the reins to?
- cedricd 4y agoJen Wolf and Brett Gibson https://blog.initialized.com/2022/08/jen-wolf-and-brett-gibson-are-promoted-as-initialized-capitals-newest-managing-partners/ https://blog.initialized.com/2022/08/jen-wolf-and-brett-gibs...
- bobbygoodlatte 4y agoThis makes me so optimistic for the future of YC. Congrats Garry!
- anotherfounder 4y agoCongrats, Garry! Seems appropriate to start to unblock founders on Twitter?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- exhaze 4y agoI think Garry changed my life in 2013 and might be reason why an awkward inarticulate engineer got into YC. He believed in my me and my cofounder. To me, Garry is one of the people that embodies the spirit of YC. See some kind of potential in early founders (my cofounder called this "a twinkle in his eye"). Believe in them. Give them a shot. Being a founder is SO lonely. Especially when few believe in what you're doing. So happy that Garry's back.
- sabotista 4y ago
- cercatrova 4y agoWhat's the context for this for someone not following?
- wahnfrieden 4y ago"MOC" is an online blowhard with a cult-like following
- psi75 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoA surprisingly, almost realistically cult-like following.
- Kiro 4y agoI don't find anything when searching for "MOC" in this context. Any links?
- wahnfrieden 4y agoI won’t platform him directly, no
- podviaznikov 4y agoGarry is incredible. I've met him 10 years ago during YC. He helped company I worked for a lot. Probably one of the most available people from the whole YC - at least it seemed that way to me. Also, I did attend Garry's 30th birthday party. Great memory how casual and down to Earth everything was. Good luck with new/old adventure.
- felixchan 4y agoGarry Tan has been the most influential figure that I have ever had a chance to come across. He appeared right at my critical moments of life and death, at the turning points of the tide. I am certain to say that without Garry and his helping hand, my life would not be what it is today. I consider myself very lucky to have met him. Congratulations, Garry!
- cdelsolar 4y agoCongrats Garry!!
- TimCTRL 4y agoOn the light end here, Aproova Mehta once said; "I learn't two important lessons, First and foremost, Gary Tan loves his beers..haha" We probably wouldn't have instacart where it is if it weren't for Gary. Thanks Gary. https://youtu.be/wkmR7TYUt_c?t=653 https://youtu.be/wkmR7TYUt_c?t=653
- replwoacause 4y agoI could be wrong but I think he spells his name Garry, not Gary.
- TimCTRL 4y agoThank you. Had missed that
- bluelightning2k 4y agoI've always liked Garry.
- bluelightning2k 4y agoSmall thing, but I asked Garry in the comments of his YC videos what his production setup was. He took the time to answer and I remember & appreciate that.
- s5300 4y ago
- replwoacause 4y agoCan you elaborate? I'm seeing a lot of positive things said about him here so contrarian viewpoints make me genuinely curious.
- s5300 4y agoYes, you’re on HN. You’re going to be seeing mostly positive things said about him from this user base. As for elaboration - I can only implore you to go look at the history of his actions.
- replwoacause 4y agoI’m aware of the website I’m using. You’re also here but are saying negative things and declining to provide more detail to back your position. I don’t have a dog in this fight and haven’t even heard of Garry until today, but since you had such a strong negative opinion of him I thought you might be able to tell us why.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoworking to advance surveillance state, pro-cop activism and political action, shilling crypto pump and dumps, gig economy, etc good returns for investors on a lot of the above hence the interest and respect from business community. simple as that, accumulated dollars talk. someone can be a ghoul and a charlatan and still be pleasant, friendly, helpful on a personal level to many.
- replwoacause 4y agoThanks for the info, I’ll go read up on him some more to see what I can find. If any of this is true, he sounds like an odd choice for the CEO of YC.
- cammikebrown 4y agoI know Garry as “the fellow who I’ve never interacted with who has me blocked on Twitter”. Seems I’m not alone!
- Rafuino 4y agoI almost feel bad he hasn't blocked me on Twitter
- gnicholas 4y agoGarry took the time to meet with me almost a decade ago, when my startup was just a side project and I was still a full-time corporate lawyer. I wish I'd been more ready to take his excellent advice, which I still remember! I also remember being surprised that he drove a humble old car, perhaps a late-90s Camry? Respect.
- aglazer 4y agoCongratulations Garry and thank you Geoff! Very excited to see the next chapter of growth at YC!
- jmtame 4y agoExciting news and big congrats to you Garry!
- fblp 4y agoThis is an impressively casual press release!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gmays 4y agoAny thoughts on a program for open source startups like there are for nonprofits and hardware?
- grepsci 4y agoCongrats Garry! Thank you for sharing your thoughts and views through content you put out. Thank you for also standing up for what you believe in and I share strongly in that sentiment. As a HN lurker and YC fan, it's very exciting to see this. Bless up!
- noisy_boy 4y agoITT #blockedbygarry
- CarbonCycles 4y agoCongrats!
- 0547228595 4y ago
- 0547228595 4y ago
- todd3834 4y agoI didn’t understand the title. Is it common to say welcome home when someone departs a company? I almost thought maybe he passed away and it was a reference to being “in a better place”
- garry 4y agoI spent 5 years as a partner at Y Combinator previously, left to work on Initialized Capital (which is in good hands now with incredible early stage investors Jen Wolf and Brett Gibson), but now will be returning in the new year to work on the next phase of Y Combinator with many of my old friends and colleagues.
- todd3834 4y agoThanks for the clarification. Congrats Gary!
- garry 4y agoBelieve it or not, my journey to Y Combinator started similar to how you may experience YC — through being a regular lurker and reader on Hacker News. I went to Startup School, me and my cofounders applied, we got an interview, and we got in. I was an engineer, designer and PM. I'd built teams and products, but I'd never built a company. YC gave me a shot, a community, knowhow, and the ability to access capital, talent, and customers. YC changed my life. I want it to help a lot more people achieve their dreams and goals. It did for me, beyond my wildest dreams.
- math-dev 4y agoGood luck! May the force be with you
- mritchie712 4y agoWhat's your take on YC batch sizes? YC has gotten criticism for making them too big, but it seems totally natural to me to scale them up. Do you think they are right-sized now?
- FerociousTimes 4y agoI like how this is turning fast into sort of a press conference minus the audio or video signal.
- Carlee 4y agoCrazy to see you end up at the top! Excited to have you run the programme for all the newcomers!
- tomrod 4y agoI look forward to learning more about your journey. I've recently launched a company and I am finding the YC Startup School content fascinating. Being from a non-coastal area, my HN engagement has for many years been a lurker and general technology trend interest. I'm pleasantly surprised how well developed YC content is.
- upupandup 4y ago
- chidog12 4y agoGarry, I only have one ask (maybe two)!... Force them all to keep making those YC Office Hour videos lol! Even better, whoever your editing team is for your channel... add them to the team as well. All the best!
- gitfan86 4y agoCongrats! What is going to happen of the next few years with AI is going to be mind blowing. The more people you can stear away from crypto and towards democratizing AI, the better, IMO.
- EddySchauHai 4y agoYou say to the guy who wrote the first seed check of Coinbase
- gitfan86 4y agoCrypto has run it's course, I don't think Gary did anything wrong by helping the crypto experiment happen. But YC is about the future, not the past.
- EddySchauHai 4y agoRealistically YC is about maximizing ROI and I would happily bet a crypto-related startup will be in Summer '23s cohort - they have crazy valuations and liquidity out of the gates. Personally I want those startups to showcase problems crypto is useful at solving rather than selling pickaxes to the gold rush but I'm less sure that that'll happen. Certainly the idea that Crypto has ran its course is, IMO, premature - people have said that during every bear market since the beginning yet overall usage appears to be increasing and institutional buy-in again appears to be increasing.
- gitfan86 4y agoIs it premature to say beanie babies or tulips have run their course? There will continue to be many hardcore fans of tulips and crypto regardless of the price, but marketcap adjusted for inflation has passed the max
- bluelightning2k 4y agoAs a crypto sceptic I'd still love to have been the person who wrote that check
- richarlidad 4y agoWelcome back, Garry!
- Sytex 4y agoCongrats Garry!
- nik736 4y agoThis is good news. Congrats!
- milkers 4y agoCongrats Garry, I am happy to see you with that title and I am very curious about what is ahead of the YC following your lead. Best wishes!
- cinntaile 4y agoYour profile is outdated now! ;)
- spacesarebetter 4y agoAre you going to continue with your youtube channel? I hope you do, learned so many things from that channel
- cheerioty 4y agoWow, love it, go Garry!
- talhof8 4y agoWow, exciting news! Congrats Garry. Feels like a John Frusciante comeback. Really hoping to be part of the W23 batch.
- Rauchg 4y agoCongrats! Exciting news for YC
- caslon 4y agoNow that there's been some regime change, and now that it's been a while, can we finally get a report on why YC killed YCR, or at least (and most importantly) HARC & VPRI (which had become dependent on YCR funding)? And, in these times of VC prosperity, could there be another attempt at it, this time with longer-term dedications than "Whenever we get bored of the PR from funding computational research or there's a momentary lapse in market conditions?" Long-term computing research is one of the best ways to ensure YCombinator's continued growth and avoid dominance from companies that are increasingly avoiding the publication of their own research (and, divorced from either of those two things, it would do a substantial amount of good, which is more important to some people but less an immediately-swaying argument to capital); it seems absurd how it was sort of thrown to the wayside on what seemed to be a whim (judging by when VPRI shuttered and the other two stopped seeing activity, possibly by the 2017 crypto crash causing YC to momentarily get more conservative in its funding).
- cheeko1234 4y agoPlease revive Posterous!
- swyx 4y agocould you elaborate what Posterous did well, for those of us who never saw it?
- graderjs 4y agoI liked the ability to cross post to Twitter, Facebook, Plurk etc. It was like the one place blog control panel, make a post there and spread it out.
- panicpanicpanic 4y agoHe did in the form of Posthaven [1] but I'd say please keep it updated. The last post on the Posthaven blog is five years old.[2] [1] https://posthaven.com/ https://posthaven.com/ [2] https://blog.posthaven.com/read-about-how-fly-has-helped-with-posthavens-infrastructure https://blog.posthaven.com/read-about-how-fly-has-helped-wit...
- wahnfrieden 4y agoIncredible, a public + private UGC hosting service with no service terms or code of conduct (that I could find, even in onboarding). That's so brave lol