11 ms·
Launch Attempt Scrubbed
- thesuitonym 4y agoActual link is here: https://blogs.nasa.gov/artemis/2022/08/29/launch-attempt-scrubbed/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/artemis/2022/08/29/launch-attempt-scr...
- dang 4y agoChanged from https://twitter.com/NASA/status/1564232429279272962 https://twitter.com/NASA/status/1564232429279272962. Thanks!
- gsibble 4y agoWord is they will need to bring the rocket back to the VAB to fix the engine issue so we're now looking at an October launch date. (Might need to swap engines)
- nordsieck 4y ago> Word is they will need to bring the rocket back to the VAB to fix the engine issue If this is true, it's not super surprising. The "clean pad concept" means that the amount of work NASA can do on the rocket when it's on the pad is pretty limited.
- sebazzz 4y agoWho knows, maybe Starship takes the title of “most powerful rocket” then away.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gmiller123456 4y agoWhere is a good place to watch these? I was on NASA's official Youtube channel waiting for the feed to start at 8:30 (EDT), when 8:30 rolled around, it jumped to 9:00, when 9:00 rolled around it changed to something generic, still with no info on what was going on, or that it had been scrubbed. Looking at Youtube now, there are clips from some feeds, so it was being streamed somewhere.
- shthed 4y agoNASA TV Live stream: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21X5lGlDOfg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=21X5lGlDOfg
- komodo 4y agoEveryday Astronaut has some good coverage
- TT-392 4y agoNasaspaceflight (independent youtube channel) has good coverage
- linkdink 4y agoThis one has commentary. https://youtu.be/0_vyZiVxEEo https://youtu.be/0_vyZiVxEEo
- Udo 4y agoFranLab and EEVBlog did a livestream together, there also was done by the Angry Astronaut, as well as one by the Everyday Astronaut. I'd say if you're on HN there's a decent chance you know at least one of these channels already, Youtube just isn't doing a good job of notifying subscribers to livestreams :)
- coryfklein 4y agoApparently this is developing into a pattern, and has happened 16 times already! > The original launch date of Artemis 1 was planned in December 2016, but it was delayed at least sixteen times due to technical issues with the SLS and the Orion spacecraft.[0] [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_1
- ilaksh 4y agoSounds like a well-established pattern.
- javajosh 4y agoI do find myself wishing for a candid assessment from NASA engineers & techs about this problem, and the set of problems plaguing the STS. Is there a forum where they can and do speak plainly (and perhaps anonymously)? If not, maybe someone should make one and call it "feynmanesque.space"
- ilaksh 4y agoComparing the SLS program to SpaceX with their multiple vehicles in progress and constant updates to the systems, seems to prove that the people pushing for more private space industry were completely right. It seems though that having multiple component vendors should be advantageous. Is there any company working on that premise of integrating systems from multiple vendors? Because somehow it's not working out economically with NASA. Seems like we are still in early days, with a lot of the money wrapped up in bloated contracts for oversized military companies.
- jmyeet 4y agoI wonder what the issue is/was. As an aside we seem to be having storms developing in the Atlantic for what has otherwise been a very quiet hurricane season so I wouldn't be surprised if Artemis has to be moved back to the VAB and we miss the next launch window (Sep 2). As excited as I am about the prospect of another super-heavy launch vehicle and a manned return to the Moon, the whole SLS/Orion project still feels like a giant waste of money. We're $40 billion in and each SLS launch costs ~$4B.
- dEnigma 4y agoAccording to the updated description of the YouTube livestream: "Teams are currently troubleshooting an issue with engine number 3 on the SLS rocket core stage. A new launch date has not yet been confirmed. The next available launch opportunity is Sept. 2."
- kordlessagain 4y agoCooling issue.
- preisschild 4y agoIssue with one of the engines.
- belter 4y agoThe reasons why it's postponed matter. It was not weather, but clearly technical issues the program is struggling with. 50 Years ago...With less experience, more challenging technical issues, doing something never done, the Kennedy Space Center to the Moon line, had no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second. Think about that... https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/37482/reason-of-apollo-17-launch-delay https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/37482/reason-of-ap... "...Only Apollo 17 had a long launch delay of 2 hours 40 minutes, Apollo 14 of 40 minutes. Most delays were less than a second..."
- justapassenger 4y ago50 years ago no one wore seatbelts and things were great? Nowadays everyone wears them, which means cars got more unsafe? Half of century is a a lot of advancement in safety. You have many orders more of magnitude of data, sensors and understanding of what to look for. Is Artemis a good program? Hell no. But that’s not a way to compare it.
- advisedwang 4y agoBesides Apollo 1, which other commenters mentioned, I wanted to do a fair comparison so looked up the first numbered apollo mission, 4. Wiki has a whole "Delays" section. I guess the closes equivalent was that it was originally rolled out Aug 26, 1967 but only launched Nov 9. So "no scrubs and typical schedule delay was 1 second" is totally untrue.
- belter 4y agoTotally true from Apollo 7 to Apollo 17. These are the missions in the reference link. But if we are going to include previous programs before Apollo 7, then we should include the predecessors programs of Artemis 1. Meaning, none...What speaks to the delays and lack of execution. Also caused of course, by Congress mandates.
- mikece 4y ago> "...Only Apollo 17 had a long launch delay of 2 hours 40 minutes, Apollo 14 of 40 minutes. Most delays were less than a second..." NASA is out of practice (and it's not being run by Germans anymore).
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoAccording to SpaceFlightNow > “SCRUB. NASA launch director Charlie Blackwell-Thompson has called off today's Artemis 1 launch attempt due to an issue with an engine bleed on the core stage.” https://spaceflightnow.com/2022/08/29/artemis-1-launch-live-coverage/ https://spaceflightnow.com/2022/08/29/artemis-1-launch-live-... Given the other issues (crack in the interstage section, comm link issue) mentioned in the live thread, I wonder how many engineers are secretly relieved the launch was scrubbed this morning.
- albertopv 4y ago
- MerelyMortal 4y agoThey probably do, I think it's the U.S. Senate that doesn't (which is why it has the nickname Senate Launch System).
- sashahrzg 4y agoIt's not like NASA hasn't been launching rockets in the time since Apollo or STS. SpaceX has spent upwards of 10 billion dollars on the Starship program, with a finished product still not on a launchpad. SLS is the largest rocket ever produced and will cost an insane amount of money, the actual price for this launch is actually around 4 billion dollars according to NASA itself.
- macinjosh 4y ago
- shadowgovt 4y agoFWIW, scrubs are common. https://www.floridatoday.com/story/tech/science/space/2022/01/30/cruise-ship-enters-launch-hazard-area-forcing-spacex-scrub-again/9279135002/ https://www.floridatoday.com/story/tech/science/space/2022/0... The larger issue is that it's 2022 and Artemis doesn't even have a track record to determine how frequent scrubs can be expected yet for this launch stack.
- GartzenDeHaes 4y agoSLS is made by Boeing https://www.boeing.com/space/space-launch-system/index.page https://www.boeing.com/space/space-launch-system/index.page
- nordsieck 4y ago> SLS is made by Boeing SLS is at best partially made by Boeing. There are 5 prime contracts: 1. Core stage - Boeing 2. Upper stage (both ICPS and EUS) - Boeing 3. Upper stage engines - Aerojet Rocketdyne 4. Core stage engines - Aerojet Rocketdyne 5. Solid rocket boosters - Northrup Grumman NASA does the software, integration and operations. There's also Orion, which is being done by Lockheed Martin. It's not technically SLS, but the vast majority of SLSes will launch Orion, so it seems not unreasonable to lump it in.
- macinjosh 4y agoSame thing, they wouldn't exist if it weren't for the taxpayer's teat provided to them by the MIC.
- p_l 4y agoSame teat provides for SpaceX - they wouldn't exist without DoD funding (and not just for early days - Starlink was heavily financed by US military)
- alecfreudenberg 4y agoWhat's more likely to orbit first now: SLS or Starship?
- the_duke 4y agoA Starship launch is months away at best. I'm betting on 2023. Unless there are some serious issues with SLS it will launch first. Significant delays would be really, really bad for SLS. They already extended the lifetime for the SRBs...
- panick21_ 4y agoWho remember when we were talking about what will launch first, SLS or Falcon Heavy. Good times. I remember being called a idiot SpaceX fanboy that understands nothing about engineering when I said Falcon Heavy would launch first. And by somebody who worked at NASA as far as I can tell. Unless there is a longer delay with upper stage refuel, they likely make it first.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoYeah, the comments boiling down to "Starship doesn't exist, SLS does" are hilarious. > "Let's be very honest again," Bolden said in a 2014 interview. "We don't have a commercially available heavy lift vehicle. Falcon 9 Heavy may someday come about. It's on the drawing board right now. SLS is real. Falcon Heavy launched four years after he said that. SLS still hasn't.
- Karellen 4y agoWill Starship's upcoming test flight count as "to orbit"? IIRC they're not planning on circularising the orbit - i.e. perigee will be well inside the atmosphere, and the vehicle will re-enter and splashdown before getting back to the starting longitude.
- fallingknife 4y agoIf they can get it out of the atmosphere, up to orbital velocity, and back in, and land it in one piece, they will have done the hard part, and getting it fully to orbit will be a foregone conclusion.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- colechristensen 4y agoThis is a minor mechanical issue scrub that nearly everyone will use to express opinions they already had about the program. Please just stop.
- ekianjo 4y agoalternatively you could see it as "yet another issue in a program that's been plagued with issues for years". When you find the 300th bug in the same piece of code, it's a pattern, not a coincidence.
- tdehnel 4y ago“Your opinions are no longer valid and will not be acknowledged. Please stop talking.”
- MichaelCollins 4y agoIf the opinions being expressed were "SLS is great, that launch was fantastic", would you still be trying to silence the expression of those opinions? I seriously doubt it. I guess we'll find out if you leave such a comment in 4 days after SLS successfully launches right? Well, maybe not..
- qbasic_forever 4y agoSeriously. It seems like the two things that really rile up all the garbage opinions here are NASA launches and COVID posts. Holy cow, just some pure trash comments.
- GuB-42 4y agoAnd cryptocurrencies, and everything by Elon Musk, and Kubernetes, and AI, and search engines, and privacy, and China, and... Trash comments everywhere (but also good ones).
- koheripbal 4y agoI've definitely correlated those topics to lower quality comments
- bcarr 4y agoMakes me wonder if it’s related to the hydrogen bleed issue that ended up halting the July rehearsal twenty seconds earlier than it was meant to.
- gatonegro 4y agoFrom what I understand, it's only "related" to the July issue because the rehearsal back then was stopped before they got to testing engine bleed. If they'd finished the WDR properly in July, it's likely that today's problem would've been caught.
- abrax3141 4y agoNASA should stick to what it does best, space science and robotic operations. The Hubble, Voyagers, the rovers and Webb are amazing. Do more of that. Let Musk do the now boring stuff of near earth, and the idiotic stuff like putting people in mars.
- sashahrzg 4y agoWhat do you think the Artemis missions are for? The goal isn't a PR win or anything. Real science is happening. Even stuff like the Apollo missions gave us technology we still use today. With NASA those discoveries are more open and available to all. Elon and other oligarchs would have a financial incentive to hoard any advancement they make.
- gatonegro 4y ago> What do you think the Artemis missions are for? To justify pumping billions of USD into Shuttle-era contractors who would've otherwise gone bankrupt a decade ago. NASA is doing the best it can with what it's been given, but Artemis and its predecessors are a Congress-mandated jobs program.
- nordsieck 4y ago> To justify pumping billions of USD into Shuttle-era contractors who would've otherwise gone bankrupt a decade ago. You might have a case with Aerojet Rocketdyne - not sure if they can survive on RL-10 sales alone. But the others: Boeing, Lockheed Martin, and Northrup Grumman, aren't depending on SLS contracts to survive. It's just a nice cherry on top of their defense and commercial contracts.
- gatonegro 4y agoYou're right, that was somewhat hyperbolic on my part. Last time I checked, AR was in rough shape after losing the contract for the Vulcan first stage engines to Blue Origin. Losing SLS would probably break them, but the rest aren't in such dire straits.
- gsibble 4y agoCalled it. Boeing can't do anything right. Furthermore, the SRBs are way past their expiration date: https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/rfu32c/d https://www.reddit.com/r/SpaceLaunchSystem/comments/rfu32c/d... And the fuel and oxygen tanks are only rated for 9 fills which, while I don't have an exact figure, I believe they are close to if not exceeded with this most recent fill and scrub. They can't afford another mistake.
- hef19898 4y ago>> Boeing can't do anything right >> while I don't have an exact figure Well, that is what I call a fact based comment...
- gsibble 4y agoMy comment on Boeing not doing anything right is based upon: - Multiple failures of Starliner - 737 MAX - 787 - USAF Replacement Tanker Do you have any fact based comments that they are an engineering powerhouse? And don't quote me projects older than 10 years.
- mrcwinn 4y agoIt’s worth noting Krispy Kreme continued with its Artemis donut mission nonetheless. Another victory for private space flight. In all seriousness, can’t wait to see this thing take off safely!
- stjohnswarts 4y agoArtemis will rocket into outer space and we will do the same to your insulin levels! --KK Marketing
- sashahrzg 4y agoI'm not sure why a Twitter link is the source for this on HN, https://blogs.nasa.gov/artemis/2022/08/29/launch-attempt-scrubbed/ https://blogs.nasa.gov/artemis/2022/08/29/launch-attempt-scr... is the proper source for this news. It should also be mentioned this is NOT a major failure. Important launches like this often see delays, often the first launch of a new system will see multiple delays. This rocket alone has cost billions and NASA wants to ensure that money is not wasted.
- Invictus0 4y agoIn the age of SpaceX, a rocket costing billions is a waste of money before it ever takes off.
- sashahrzg 4y agoHow much do you think starship launches will cost? Hint, it's billions
- Invictus0 4y agoLOL! More than a billion dollars to refill a rocket with fuel? You are bugging.
- sashahrzg 4y agoThat's not how a launch cost is calculated. The cost of the rocket's construction is included in every launch, hence the cost going down with subsequent launches. RND costs must also be included, as well as support system costs, staff costs, etc. Also, current starship designs require refurbishment between launches, as well as an expensive set of checks and tests on systems. 1 billion as the cost for the first fully test launch is not at all out of the ballpark.
- Isinlor 4y agoSpaceX is contracted to deliver people to the Moon surface for 2.8 billion dollars total (development + actual mission). To do it they need around 6 launches for refueling in orbit. Therefore, the very upper limit on a single Starship launch is 0.5 billion (2.8/6). And that's without development cost of Starship HLS. Single SLS launch cost without Orion, including development, will be around 4 billion dollars. 20 billion overall for SLS development + 20 billion for Orion development.