18 ms·
The fight against drought in California has a new tool: The restrictor
- ggm 4y agoheavily used in South Africa from news I saw some decade ago, to deal with township water use and lack of meter payment: Basic human rights demand they have access to water, but its kept to a trickle until some meter payment is done.
- ars 4y agoI wonder what it will take for people to start leaving the state. And it's going to be the wealthy who leave first.
- Bud 4y agoLaughable. The wealthy are going to leave the best weather in the Western Hemisphere and the best culture in the United States and the best restaurants and the best job market and... Stop fooling yourself. The wealthy are going to double-down on California. They already are.
- CharlesW 4y agoCalifornia has the largest economy in the U.S. and (if it were its own nation) the fifth largest in the world, with agricultural production/processing representing under 3% of total state GDP. There's lots of money and lots of strategies for mitigating water problems, including things like desalinization on a scale never seen before. In contrast, Arizona is relatively poor and landlocked. It seems like they're far more likely to be the canary in the coal mine.
- oceanplexian 4y agoArizona is a fast growing state but it's hardly a fair comparison. A better comparison would be Texas or Florida, which people on the coasts seem to turn their noses up at. Both are growing at roughly 3 times the pace of California, with Texas predicted to surpass California's GDP in under 20 years (Perhaps faster, if things accelerate). If you look at the East Coast situation, e.g. Florida and New York, it's much more damning, FL's population surpassed NY only a few years ago, and its GDP will likely surpass NY in less than 5 years (1.2T vs 1.9T). Not sure what will happen with the water situation but it seems like the final nail in the coffin of bad policies that have sent CA into a downward spiral.
- mackmgg 4y agoI don't think they were trying to say Arizona is the alternative California people would move to. I think they were saying it's the state that's going to feel the effects of prolonged drought first, because they have less access to seawater to desalinate and fewer resources to try and buy what little water is left compared to California.
- CharlesW 4y agoExactly, thank you.
- jpollock 4y ago"Both are growing at roughly 3 times the pace of California" I'm sorry, where is that number coming from? 3x growth anywhere in the USA vs California would be majestically impressive! I found: Growth : (1yr, 3yr, 5yr) Texas : 7.35%, 2.24%, 12.32% California : 7.17%, 8.06%, 16.69% Florida : 6.45%, 8.04%, 14.91% Is the 3x growth in a different statistic? https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/california/ https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/california/ https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/florida/ https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/florida/ https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/texas/ https://www.deptofnumbers.com/gdp/texas/
- tuatoru 4y agoGP was talking about population, not GDP. Do you have those numbers?
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- kortilla 4y ago> In contrast, Arizona is relatively poor and landlocked. It seems like they're far more likely to be the canary in the coal mine. This isn’t a great bet. Arizona had to solve this problem long ago and already has a good water rights system to cut out the most egregious users quickly as the Colorado river goes through its drought categories. Farmers aren’t guaranteed effectively free water with seniority over others willing to pay like they are in California. Farming in Arizona might die, but the people are more than rich enough to continue residential usage with the large portion AZ gets of the Colorado river.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> In contrast, Arizona is relatively poor and landlocked. It seems like they're far more likely to be the canary in the coal mine. <<< New Mexico waves >>> ps. NM is much much poorer than AZ (but also has less people)
- RichardCNormos 4y agoDesalination is an ecological catastrophe, and it costs over $1,000 per acre-foot, and that's before the cost of water delivery to the end user. For comparison, my local irrigation district charges ~$150 per acre-foot, delivered. Desalination doesn't work for California.
- Dylan16807 4y ago1) You can make it not be a catastrophe. 2) People that really want a green lawn will pay.
- bombcar 4y agoThe wealthy can afford to stay, and the poor can’t afford to leave. Watch the middle class, as those are the most likely to move first.
- jeffbee 4y agoThis goes against all available evidence. The rich are the only group who are still on balance migrating into California.
- georgeburdell 4y agoDo you have a source? I think your statement is only true of domestic migration https://lao.ca.gov/laoecontax/article/detail/265 https://lao.ca.gov/laoecontax/article/detail/265
- jeffbee 4y agoPPIC regularly covers this topic but most migration data hasn't really fully incorporated COVID effects yet. https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/whos-leaving-california-and-whos-moving-in-may-2021.pdf https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/whos-leaving-califor...
- halffaday 4y agoI think net domestic migration is negative for California, so it’s already happening. For perspective, I live in Arkansas and my family and I live in a 2000sf single-family home on 0.5 acres. Our mortgage is <$800/mo. My income isn’t significantly different from my coastal counterparts.
- patwater10 4y agoNice
- mikestew 4y agoI’m approaching retirement age, and that’s been the fantasy of many for as long as I’ve been alive: CA either falls into the ocean, or people leave it in droves. And yet for all its problems, the population of CA keeps going up. Even if people leave, someone else is more than willing to take their place.
- CodeWriter23 4y agoPopulation declines for 2nd year in CA https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/04/us/california-population-decline.html#:~:text=Before%20the%20pandemic%2C%20the%20average,the%20easing%20of%20pandemic%20restrictions https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/04/us/california-population-.... AND, there is a social ritual that has developed. We now have the "FINE, GO." cake which is shared with those departing at a say-goodbye party. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fine+go+cake&t=osx&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?q=fine+go+cake&t=osx&iax=images&ia=i...
- hadlock 4y agoIn a dry year agriculture uses as much as 50% of all water, urban use ranges between 8-13%. https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/content/pubs/jtf/JTF_WaterUseJTF.pdf https://www.ppic.org/wp-content/uploads/content/pubs/jtf/JTF... Agriculture is effectively unrestricted by law in their water use. I think we may be targeting the wrong group
- twblalock 4y agoAgriculture is also a small portion of the state’s GDP and we could do without some of the most water-intensive crops, such as almonds. There won’t be food insecurity or famine if we cut back on almonds.
- CitrusFruits 4y agoI talk with my friend who works in water law a lot about this, and he always comes to basically the same conclusion as this. Almonds and pistachios are a huge waste of water. The problem is that farmer's water rights are constitutionally protected (California constitution). You need a super majority in the California senate to do anything about it, and that's not going to happen anytime soon. IMO I think we should tax the heck out of pistachio and almonds and just make them unprofitable to sell.
- grandinj 4y agoThe Dems already have a super-majority in the california senate, so that problem has been solved?
- CitrusFruits 4y agoFrom what I understand it's not a democratic vs republican thing, it's a rural vs urban. There are enough rural democrats that they wouldn't be able to pass a constitutional reform.
- tffcccdredf 4y ago
- avalys 4y agoThe obvious solution here is to have a tiered pricing system for water, where the price per gallon increases with consumption. Increase the price of the higher tiers and/or rate of increase until consumption drops to level you need. And then you don’t need to pay government employees to drive around and inspect celebrity lawns all day.
- z3c0 4y agoAs the saying goes, "when the punishment is money, it's only a punishment for the poor." There are plenty of mega-wealthy people in California who would pay the premium to maintain their image of wealth, no matter how large. It may raise more money, but I can't imagine that it would deter consumption much, as it's already the rich using the most water.
- lalaland1125 4y ago> it's already the rich using the most water That's not true. The main water use is agriculture, which is a pretty small portion of our GDP and would cut down usage if we raised prices.
- z3c0 4y agoGiven the context of the article, I thought it was fairly obvious that I was referring to domestic use, but if it was not, I was.
- throwaway09223 4y agoSure, but your complaint is that it's punishing the poor. The reason we need to properly price water isn't to increase costs for municipal use. Those rates can stay the same, or even be reduced. The problem is that the agricultural sector is paying a fraction of the prices that municipalities pay -- or in some cases they are paying nothing at all.
- z3c0 4y ago
- IG_Semmelweiss 4y agoChile has private, water brokers. Water goes to the highest bidder The industry employs hundreds of people. I bet this would be a disaster for CA farmers, though
- theshrike79 4y agoChile is also changing their constitution next month to revert the privatisation of water. It's that bad of a shitshow.
- s0rce 4y agoI'm not so sure it would be a disaster (Societally, sure many farmers livelihoods would be disrupted...), would many food become unprofitably expensive or a rare luxury, yes. Would many farms be immediately incentivized to move to more efficient irrigation or even more efficient crops, probably. Seems like we should subsidize farmers with grants for improved water use instead of just giving them cheap endless water.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoWhat's old is new again. The restrictor device described here is more or less the same as the "miner's inch" that defines water rights in parts of California. At least in Nevada County, some tracts of land include rights to "miner's inches" of water. A miner's inch was customarily the amount of water that'd flow through a inch diameter hole in a wooden board that was used as a sort of valve at the irrigation ditch. It's defined here nowas 11.22 gallons per minute (the amount varies by jurisdiction). It doesn't sound like a lot but sure adds up quick if you're filling a reservoir or storage tank. Historically the water was used by miners to wash gold out of ore (or later, to hydraulically blast apart hillsides).
- sidewndr46 4y agoAm I doing my math right? 11.22 gallons per minute works out to 1/2 a million gallons a month or so. That seems like an insane amount of water.
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoI just want to make a note and an aside to the whole conversation happening around water right now. Aside from the 9000lb gorilla of ag/industrial versus urban/ suburban water use, I think that its clear that tiered rate based structures are a clear failure. We knew this half a decade ago, but its become impeccably clear with articles like these. Its very very easy to see blame the millionaire/ elite class in this situation, but its important to acknowledge that the fact that these homes use 20-40% of a water districts total use has been well known for years. Likewise, water districts are not incentivised to decrease this class of water users overall use because that 20-40% of water use might represent 60%+ of a water districts total income. This is due to tiered rates. The reality is that famous person XYZ never ever sees the water bill and they just don't care. This is something one of their assistants or manager deals with, and relative to their income, even if their water bill is 50k a month, it just doesn't matter. So to be clear, districts, through tiered rates, have been incentivised to not act on who they already know are their most wasteful customers. Those most wasteful customers do not care how they spend on water a month.
- madelyn 4y agoRaising tiered rates enough, intuitively, is effectively the same as a cap. Yes, it's absurd to think about charging ex. $50k a gallon for gallons over 10k, but that's basically a cap. No one has the money. (But yes, I'd say we should implement caps rather than being ridiculous)
- RosanaAnaDana 4y agoI don't have the data in front of me, but iirc, its kind-of your standard pareto. Around 20% of the users use 80% of the water in a district. I mean you say no one has the money, but that 20% might be 2-3 oom higher in total use than the median of the 80%. I think there are two or three issues bundled into one here. One is that water is managed at the district level. Districts are a patchwork of county, city, and private entities, some with elected leaderships, some with appointed leadership. The state has no direct control over water use in this way, although they have significant authority in other ways that can very much impact water use. However, that authority is split between a set of state agencies that have research and policy power, but no regulatory authority, and an elected/ appointed state water board that is just chasing the next election cycle. Finally, at the district level, these organizations are just a hot mess. Its a complete clusterfck of frankly, shockingly arcane methods for assessing and managing water (ever heard the term miners inch?). Half of these districts barely know where their water is going. I see the whole mess as a failure of neoliberalism, an undue faith in markets.
- whitepirate20 4y agoI’ve been a long distance runner for 11 years now. I’ve been plagued with injuries, ebs and flows of progression and regression and the same attitude the author wrote about that matched his intense rides. It made me lose love for the sport running at a high heart rate every time. I tried swapping to low heart rate training. There is a lot of research in this area. My dad (58) also started doing the same and can now run 7-8 miles without getting tired. It’s truly great to slow down. Not just physically, but mentally.
- googlryas 4y agoHopefully you don't have a flow restrictor on your heart!
- amluto 4y agoI’m not convinced that bashing the “A-listers” is productive. Urban water shortages can, with a bit of political will, be addressed by money. It seems to me that allowing people to buy large amounts of water at an appropriate price is just fine and maybe even a good idea. (Even at egregious CA private utility electricity rates, the energy needed to desalinate water is rather less expensive than the cost of residential water. Other technologies are less expensive. There is no water shortage per se, at least for residential use — there is a shortage of water available with current infrastructure.)
- TheRealPomax 4y agoBuy large amounts of water from where? California has none to buy, that's kind of what "the largest drought in recorded history" means. The problem is over-consumption of water, not "people not paying their fair share for the water they do use"; there's no budget deficit, there's a water deficit. And when the problem is folks wasting water, the solution is to stop giving them unfettered access to this critical resource. They still get enough water to live off of, but nothing more.
- amluto 4y agoOne can buy out farm water rights and use them for residential use. Or one can buy machinery and electricity to turn sewage into tasty potable water or turn the Pacific Ocean into tasty drinking water. The Pacific Ocean is a functionally unlimited supply — it just has the solvable problem of having minerals dissolved in it.
- a1371 4y agoUnrelated to the article, I noticed that the article's page loaded extremely fast, and the reading was refreshingly focused. I had never been to the "lite" subdomain of CNN until now, but it's a reminder of what we are missing with all those news articles that take a while minute to load the autoplay videos and the parallax ads.
- kortilla 4y agoTypical stupid California government response. Rather than charge the market rate for water we’ll come up with elaborate Orwellian schemes to have people get visibly shamed and have to visibly cutback to comply. Meanwhile this reduces total state water usage by maybe 0.5% while industrial and agricultural use hums along each consuming far more than all of residential combined. This is banning restaurants from handing out cups of water 2.0. But now it has the added bonus of getting to spy and rat out your neighbors.
- shlurpy 4y agoWater is a necessity. Making it unaffordable literally is a death sentence. Those who would mass murder poor people rather then have a yellow lawn are morally reprehensible.
- kortilla 4y agoForest for the trees my friend, forest for the trees. If every water user paid market rate, including industrial and agriculture, the residential rate would likely be lower than what it is right now. You fell into the same classism distraction trap designed to cause residential users to go at each other’s throats rather than address the whale users.
- tomohawk 4y agoDid someone force all of these people to move to cities built in the middle of a desert?
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoDo you want the food that is produced in the CA Central Valley (a huge, huge proportion of all US produce) or not?
- s0rce 4y agoThis is a straw man, no one is suggesting to stop growing food on irrigated farmland but to focus on efficient irrigation and grow things more suitable for the limited water, see the suggestions from the SNWA https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/22136304/2022-8-15-nevada-letter-to-interior-department.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/22136304/2022-8-15-ne...
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoLet’s not forget that California does not permit well drilling in most incorporated towns and cities. If homes are allowed to put up solar and drill their own wells..they don’t have to pay for water and power. But that just won’t do, would it? Even in some parts of Sonoma, there is talk that they will not allow septic tank installation on lots less than 1.5 acres which is really awkward because most lots minimum size is 1 acre. And the city doesn’t annex all areas in the county effectively denying sewer and hence residences. But none of this surprises me. I am very familiar with the unholy corrupt alliances between Big Gov and real estate mafias. Altho I have only seen in it developing countries. I guess that’s what California is now..it is what it is…
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoPrivate wells draw from the same aquifer(s) as every other non-surface water source. They are public, not private resources.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoLand comes with grandfathered water rights in CA. What’s good for the goose..
- userbinator 4y agoI've always wondered why they don't build more pipelines to balance the water supply --- many other states have plenty of water available.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoActually, they don't.
- bombcar 4y agoWe could divert the Columbia. 265,000 cubic feet per second (7,500 m3/s) just begin to be used.
- dredmorbius 4y agoResurrect NAWPA, GRAND, and GCNA!!! </s> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_Water_and_Power_Alliance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_American_Water_and_Power...> <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Recycling_and_Northern_Development_Canal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Recycling_and_Northern_D...>
- bombcar 4y agoI suspect there should be some open discussion about things akin to these, if not them exactly. I have a sneaking suspicion that some of our issues are caused by the older projects having been incredibly massive in scope and daring, and now refusing to consider similar projects with what we have and know now. For example, I'm not sure we'd even consider let alone build the Oroville or Hoover dam today. That may be a good thing ... or maybe it's not even considered.
- dredmorbius 4y agoStarting by studying closely why the original proposals ultimately became Instant Hot Steaming Death might be a good starting point. The proposals are not politically popular / are highly politically divisive.
- plankers 4y agoGood. The only way we're going to get these selfish Americans to sacrifice anything is if we force them.
- jwie 4y agoConsumer water restrictions are 8th order concerns. If we had a serious government in the United States they’d be talking about our annual export of 4.887e11 gallons of water to Mexico from the Colorado River. That’s 1.5 million acre-feet for those more familiar with agricultural water units. There’s your weapon against drought. Just, don’t export hundreds of trillions of gallons of water. Also alfalfa exports to China are, in essence, water exports on the same magnitude. But that might be harmful to politically connected California farmers.
- NegativeK 4y agoI'm pretty sure Mexico's water rights from the Colorado are protected by treaty. Sure, we could break the treaty - just like the state of Colorado could decide to keep all of their snow melt to themselves. But it's probably better to acknowledge that our actions (like building a dam and diverting a river for local use) can severely affect other people. Or to reduce frivolous water use in a desert.
- jwie 4y agoThey are part of a 1940s treaty. But it’s more about what’s not being considered in the drought solution. The US can back out if it chooses. That’s not the best first option, but if it comes down to it that should be considered. The water rights of the Colorado have been friendly up until now, as there’s always been enough water to go around. Giving water to Mexico is only one driver, but it is a big one. The primary driver of water use is agricultural. That treaty needs a refresh, but also maybe so does farming in the southwest. Chastising over-watering suburbanites just isn’t going to solve anything.
- idontknowifican 4y agoi don’t understand why a country on a natural river suddenly has no right to that river. if we were to dry up a river on purpose, to prevent another country from it is an incredibly hostile act. i assume you see this climate thing as an emergency and therefore we must take extreme measures. this argument is as flawed as “chastising over-watering suburbanites”, but instead of shifting the blame from agriculture to city dwellers, you’re allowing humans to suffer in another country so you don’t have to. shame
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoThe workaround for this is to have smaller irrigation zones that will work with a lower flow rate.
- VectorLock 4y agoThe restrictor sounds like a great idea but it seems like very quickly the worst offenders will install tanks to buffer the water they need to keep their lawns green. Maybe 1 gal/minute across all their greenery might not be enough though but at least they can shower and do dishes at the same time then.
- azth 4y agoWhat's the cost of water salination? California has a coast.
- thedougd 4y agoWatching from the East Coast I’m a bit baffled that more measures haven’t been deployed or have only been deployed as of late. Stories of municipalities that don’t even meter water. Back in the 2000s we had a significant drought here. (1) Maybe it’s not that bad. We saw many wells run dry and entire neighborhoods without running water for weeks. Some things I remember at various stages of the drought: - lawn watering went from staggered days to none allowed - must request water at restaurants - restaurant flatware and dishes were replaced with disposables - car washes were closed unless they used an untypical water recycling system - tiered rates either steepen or added - gray water lines were laid in new development areas - old quarries were bought by municipalities for water storage and lines run to them - codes updated for low flow everything https://climate.ncsu.edu/blog/2015/11/nc-extremes-2007s-drought-emerged-quickly-affected-millions-in-nc/ https://climate.ncsu.edu/blog/2015/11/nc-extremes-2007s-drou...
- DoreenMichele 4y agoRespect to the guy for dogfooding it and trying it at his house. I also like that they say it's not intended to be punitive, just practical.
- killyourcar 4y agoThis is the same thing as economic sanctions - it targets indiscriminately and it targets the wrong use case, but proponents will say it encourages people to press against the real problem and demand change. Just like, say, random Cuban citizens do nothing to meaningfully harm the US, random houses in urban California aren't where water waste is worst. The real problem is agriculture and water rights that disappear if unused, encouraging farmers to pour water in a ditch so they don't lose their rights. If you believe broad based economic sanctions work, you should believe this works under the same principles - the citizens will be so annoyed they have to deal with this they'll get the government to change. If you don't believe this will work, then one must assume you believe broad sanctions wouldn't work either.
- dghughes 4y agoI live on Canadian island province of PEI and we have water restrictions here too, on an island! Yes there are lots of farms here and water is a big issue. With 50% of the entire population living in the capital city and growing fast water is getting scarce. We don't have restrictor devices her yet. Water meters were only introduced about fives years ago and paying for water has been a shock to most people. It's not just dry places like California. The eastern US or Canada don't necessarily have all kinds of water, and an island can also run out of water.
- WalterBright 4y agoCalifornia resorts to rationing. Nobody seems to understand how supply & demand works (and that it can't be repealed). Rationing means half the people will get more than they need, half will get less. To reduce water consumption, raise the price.
- cplusplusfellow 4y agoSince obviously California is going to do nothing about this, can we just tackle the problem at the source and restrict water outflows from the Colorado river authority itself?
- ec109685 4y agoAren’t there secondary costs to not watering lawns and whatnots? What happens to trees that were used to drawing from the ground replenished with sprinkler water? Also, at least some of the water for lawns goes back into the aquifer, effectively recycling it. At the end of the day, all water, even water used for irrigation or watering lawns is recycled.
- meltyness 4y agoThere are a lot of steps that I've observed in CA that would seem to cause drought rather than prevent it, this is one of them. - Aggressively irrigating water away from hills / plateaus, presumably to prevent mudslides onto road infrastructure. - Tree-farms, everywhere throughout Southern California. - Steps like this that appear to further prevent maintenance of any sort of below-ground aquifer. And even better, - Offshore wind farming for the stated benefit of reducing hurricane storm force / total rainfall. - Building new cross-country infrastructure (CHSP) which will demand more aggressive irrigation to protect. - Delaying construction of a large water reservoir for financial reasons, and failing to collaborate with neighboring states to fund it effectively. Moves like this look like 4D-chess rather than any sort of science.
- hardnose 4y agoI was amazed when I learned that building out your own rain catchment system using rain barrels, in California, is illegal. It's considered theft of natural resources. I wonder how much cumulative effect regulations like that have on keeping peak usage rates high?
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoJust got a restrictor showerhead free in the mail from my power company. Because hot water I guess. Since we have no water shortage in my state.