13 ms·
The Dead Internet is a mirage caused by the unreasonable effectiveness of digital marketing. You simply aren't able to find the living internet behind all the n
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
The Dead Internet is a mirage caused by the unreasonable effectiveness of digital marketing. You simply aren't able to find the living internet behind all the nonsense. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist. You just need to get off social media and google to find it.
Refresh this page as many times as you want, and I'll show you the living Internet: https://search.marginalia.nu/explore/random https://search.marginalia.nu/explore/random
- ianai 4y agoIf the majority (vast majority) of users of the internet rarely break out of social media and you posit that social media is largely 'dead', then isn't the internet effectively dead for the vast majority of users?
- IIAOPSW 4y agoWhat does it even mean for it to be dead for the majority of users if it was never alive for that same majority?
- WalterSear 4y agoMaybe a better term for it is the zombie internet.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoIf largest social media platforms all went *pOoF!* today, where would our dead-headed majority be in a year?
- cosmojg 4y agoOne or two of the remaining smaller social media platforms?
- doubled112 4y agoWould those smaller social media platforms then be large, end up commercialized some how, smaller ones pop up, and something else take over until we repeat the process?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIs that necessarily a bad thing?
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoSomething like TV but it makes me feel good about myself.
- mayoi 4y agoJust a wild guess based on past 2 years, but probably outside.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoYes, and let's celebrate! Access to the real, genuine Internet people and places will be made invisible; protected by the gargantuan SEO-fed lipid-berg of AI-generated content, keeping the social media peasantry ever-corralled in the cattle pen where they shall be kept happy and fed by their keepers. Is September 2022 the final Eternal September?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoThe problem isn't really with the internet, but a handful of websites that have come to mediate the internet for a lot of people (despite appearances to the contrary, the two are not the same). This is a critical distinction, because the former is a problem like "the water is too wet", like you can't really fix that. You can build new digital infrastructure though. That's a solvable problem.
- JohnFen 4y agoAnd then that new infrastructure will be subverted just as the current one has been. I don't think this is an issue that can be solved through engineering. I think the problem lies in different domain.
- harimau777 4y agoCan't we just build a new infrastructure at that point? The current infrastructure worked well for about a decade. If we have to rebuild every decade then that's not so bad.
- fourstar 4y ago>You just need to get off social media and google to find it Isn't that the point? The general populace isn't getting off of social media and Google, thus, dead internet theory continues to compound itself..
- wmeredith 4y agoIn the bygone* days of the weird internet the general populace wasn't there either. *The weird internet's death has been highly exaggerated.
- mayoi 4y ago
- hombre_fatal 4y agoThis just comes across as mean-spirited. Even if you think it's a net positive when human attention is centralized in a few things like TikTok or Fortnite, you should still be able to enumerate downsides. At that point, you'll see that you are disagreeing with the subjective weight of the upsides and downsides thus it doesn't make sense to attack someone like this.
- TheRealDunkirk 4y agoAu contraire. Yes, the beauty of the late 90's-early 00's internet was Alta Vista, and then Google, which allowed you to find the parts of the living internet that were interesting to you. Now, search engine results will almost never serve you up a single-user's web site. They will dutifully shovel you to one of the dozen walled gardens that has become "the internet." The search engines themselves have become the gatekeepers of this dead, corporate internet, and there's no breaking out of it.
- danielvaughn 4y agoIt would actually be lovely to have a search engine that only serves up single-creator or few-creators websites. I'm sure one exists, but I'm not aware of any.
- syeare 4y agoI haven't used it (or their browser Orion, which is allegedly better-performing and more battery-efficient than Safari), but have you tried the "premium" search engine called https://kagi.com/ https://kagi.com/ ?
- Terretta 4y agoKagi with lenses is tremendous. I recommend it elsewhere in this thread. One should subscribe to it out of support, hope, and to send a signal if nothing else. But it’s actually considerably better on most searches, perhaps similar to a mid-2000s Google, except with mild structure added that isn’t ads. (You can still !g like ddg if you feel you absolutely must.)
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoImagine websites having a captcha, that proofs that they are handcrafted by a person, proofing the time invested, the back and forth. You could filter for that.
- dicknuckle 4y ago
- haskell_melody 4y agohttp://readsomethinginteresting.com/ http://readsomethinginteresting.com/ is also great.
- ihateolives 4y agoRefreshed few times. 99% of sites were about IT, programming, gaming, tech, STEM in general. That's really narrow representation of internet. Maybe it's just my luck.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoTurns out, people who make websites are usually the sort of people who make websites.
- ihateolives 4y agoThat's the problem with the approach you've taken. You're showing domains, not web pages. Not all hobbyists or interest groups outside tech have domains.
- mayoi 4y agoYou can always contribute by crawling ipv4 range searching for http servers that don't necessarily have a domain pointing at them and posting a list for us when you're done crawling it merely once :)
- lolinder 4y agoI'm assuming you're referring to Facebook groups or similar walled-garden web presences? If so, I'm assuming indexing those is an explicit non-goal for OP, and I'd agree with that. The walled gardens are very hard to index (often actively hostile), which means the returns would be rather low. Plus, most such places have searches of their own if you're really interested in finding something there.
- harimau777 4y agoIn my experience, part of the problem is that often (usually?) the search on those places is nearly useless. For example, I shudder to think what will happen if old.reddit ever stops working.
- Kaibeezy 4y agoCool. How? Can you elaborate on "I crawl myself." Do you mean you are the search engine and your search engine is an index of stuff you found that fits your criteria? What criteria, precisely?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt's basically a 1998-style Google which discriminates against javascript-heavy documents and uses a Personalized PageRank[1]-algorithm to promote content that is adjacent to human websites. [1] http://ilpubs.stanford.edu:8090/422/1/1999-66.pdf http://ilpubs.stanford.edu:8090/422/1/1999-66.pdf (ch. 6)
- Kaibeezy 4y agoThanks. Tried some searches, good stuff. Recipes are a well known disaster area these days, it's nice to be able to find just an explanation and instructions, with nothing else.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt's a bit hit-and-miss. The index is pretty small right now, I'm working on that, as well as getting better results when you have many keywords. Right now it's absolutely amazing if you have like a broad topic you want websites about, but kind of weak when you want something more specific.
- Kaibeezy 4y agoI got tortilla-making tips, I’m good ;)
- hackarimoo 4y agoI assume you've considered this, but what about deprioritizing precisely what spam sites use to SEO, or concocting some other identification algorithm, to filter precisely those out? While yeah, marginalia finds interesting stuff, I've not been able to find anything useful that I've tried searching for with it so far.
- fallingknife 4y agoI would dispute that digital marketing is unreasonably effective. In fact I would say the dead internet is a result of the exact opposite. Digital marketing is so ineffective that basically the only strategy that works is spamming it everywhere. If you don't believe me look at the revenue per user of ad driven tech companies.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoEffective is a slippery word. I use it to mean effective in the sense of affecting what is presented. You use it to mean effective in the sense of making sales. It is extremely effective in the first way, but extremely ineffective in the latter.
- kosh2 4y agoIf I type a new marketing relevant keyword into google, I will get a perfect add for that in 5 minutes watching youtube. Influencers are some of the most popular people on the planet for young people.
- DebtDeflation 4y agoAnd you will continue getting those ads for months after you made the purchase.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wmeredith 4y agoI had the same reaction to the main thesis of this article. This is like people taking roadtrip across the United States who are only willing to go 1/4 mile off the federal highway. They then decry the state of cuisine because the only restaurants left in America are the same 5 fast food joints. Getting outside one's comfort zone and putting in the time to find something good/interesting/new is highly underrated. But it is work. And many a corporate empire has been built by making a mediocre or sufficient experience the most convenient thing.
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- tunap 4y ago>This is like people taking roadtrip across the United States who are only willing to go 1/4 mile off the federal highway. Urban Spoon was an amazing resource for us road warrior types. I found many fantastic places > 1/4 mile off the interstate. Nowadays, I ask employees at worksites for their opinions. If they recommend a box chain, I ask someone else.
- bombcar 4y agoIf you know you're going to be in or near a particular town and want food, a good place I've found to start is the restaurants that advertise in the local church bulletins.
- warkdarrior 4y agoWhat's a "worksite"? (asking for a friend who works remotely)
- tunap 4y agoThe physical location where a field tech installs and implements technology &/or equipment. I worked in Building Automation Systems(BAS) in big box retail stores and covered >400 sites in 5 US states.
- dirtyv 4y agoWow, awesome tool! Seriously, thank you for this. This really brings back that sense of wonder I experienced when I was younger and began exploring the internet in the early 90s
- RGamma 4y agoThanks for helping to keep the internet alive :)
- MikeDelta 4y agoI think google and the other engines are part of the problem: ads, walled gardens, fake sites, and more. A colleague showed me a website the other day from 2013 that was an absolute jewel in terms of knowledge. I am sure more recent sites like that exist, but I am afraid finding those with google are almost zero.
- emptyparadise 4y ago>Refresh this page as many times as you want, and I'll show you the living Internet You take the red pill, you stay in Wonderland, and I show you how deep the rabbit-hole goes.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoFrankly, Marginalia shows how many of these glorified websites are just dead, forgotten projects that are only still running because nobody remembered to take them down. While I like using Marginalia to find these websites, I don’t think it’s a demonstration of how “alive” the internet is but more like a lens into what the internet used to be, like walking around an archaeological dig site.
- marktangotango 4y ago> You just need to get off social media and google to find it. Maybe if you know the exact url or specific keywords, but generally not now. Google has turned into ad placement the same level ask jeeves and their ilk were. It's atrocious for surfacing anything other than click bait. Duckduckgo is better, but not by much imo.
- MisterTea 4y ago> You just need to get off social media and google to find it. Have you tried searching lately? It feels like it is becoming increasingly difficult to find actual articles with useful information in a sea of SEO trash.
- coldtea 4y ago>You simply aren't able to find the living internet behind all the nonsense. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist. It's not about it being not existent. It's about it being too small a percentage. And will algorithmic generation and rampant re-posting of news content 1000s of times on different outlets, this is probably true... 8 billion people are able to manually create much fewer content than thousands upon thousands of automated generation scripts and bots...
- moomoo11 4y agoSweet! This is an awesome resource