8 ms·
Got a rejection for mentioning Apple pre-release software, but I am not
- dinobones 4y ago
- colonwqbang 4y agoSuch stories have been posted at regular intervals for as long as I have been reading this site. It seems to be the reality of publishing on app store. In which case, Apple is funding a bad PR campaign against themselves.
- lapcat 4y agoNo, Matthias Gansrigler has been an indie Apple dev for well over a decade. Every Apple dev has stories like this.
- gnicholas 4y ago> I literally haven’t changed the text in my marketing description in many months. After 5 years in the App Store, and having my app featured in the Accessibility section, we were flagged for a characteristic that had remained unchanged since launch. In almost every case, our rejections were not related to newly-added features.
- altairprime 4y ago> In almost every case What were the exception(s)?
- Natsu 4y agoYou'd think this should be something they'd check for one way or another...
- googlryas 4y agoWhen this happens, I assume a shady competitor kept flagging your product until they got it taken off the app store.
- gnicholas 4y agoThis was for unrelated feature upgrades. I suppose it’s possible people had flagged us and the flags weren’t reviewed until we submitted an update though.
- detaro 4y agoOk, that's a particularly funny reason for on of these.
- blendergeek 4y agoUpdate from original tweeter: > Long story short: Two features (one from iOS 12, one from iOS 16), and one name: Continuity Camera. https://twitter.com/eternalstorms/status/1560304401922854920?s=20&t=efh16F_gK-sJsA5-RIG2EA https://twitter.com/eternalstorms/status/1560304401922854920...
- kylec 4y agoSo he did mention features of pre-release software
- ignormies 4y agoNo he mentioned an iOS 12 feature which has the exact same name (Continuity Camera) as an upcoming iOS 16 feature. His app uses the iOS 12 feature
- nabeards 4y agoThanks, I was at a loss as to how Continuity Camera was related.
- thiht 4y agoEven if he did, the problem here is canned answers. Not getting any specifics of what you should correct is a nightmare. It’s like a stupid escape game where you can’t win. They can say it’s in the description but not what specifically? Wtf kind of crappy support tool do they use that they can’t customize canned replies?
- pimlottc 4y agoI couldn't find the quoted tweet from your link, here's a direct link: https://twitter.com/eternalstorms/status/1560311974034120704 https://twitter.com/eternalstorms/status/1560311974034120704
- lapcat 4y agoTL;DR Apple re-used the term "Continuity Camera", which now applies to both a preexisting feature from iOS 12 and a prerelease feature in iOS 16. The app's description refers to the preexisting feature, but app review metadata-rejected the app anyway. Also, app review initially neglected to mention the specific problem, instead simply hand-waving about the rule against mentioning prerelease features.
- mistrial9 4y agothey can't tell you which rule you broke, because that would give away the secrets </snark>
- chihuahua 4y agoIf/when the government (US or EU) goes after Apple for antitrust violations, they should use that same line of reasoning.
- lijogdfljk 4y agoAppreciate the TLDR. I was reading the tweets and confused on what the problem was.. Apple's naming scheme here seems awful.
- Tao3300 4y agoMore like discontinuity, amirite?
- projektfu 4y agoWould it have killed Apple to highlight the offending words in the original review?
- fishfood23 4y agoThis is the most annoying part of rejection. They won’t point to anything specifically, but continue to send vague summaries of the issue. If you’re staring at a plist file and there’s an issue, why not just tell me you found an issue with the plist? It’s infuriating.
- neurostimulant 4y agoI guess this depends on the reviewer. I had one rejected update where the reviewer listed the offending contents in the rejection message.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI've had a few rejections (not "dozens," as someone above mentioned), and, in my case, I have had to often deal with the vague, "canned" responses, but also, a couple of times, I actually had detailed indications, including screenshots. I am always unfailingly polite and professional, even though I may want to strangle them. I dunno. I consider this "the cost of doing business." Not thrilled with it, but it's better than friends of mine have had to deal with, when a couple of thugs walk into their new restaurant, and say "Where ya want the video games set up?"
- faeriechangling 4y agoI understand the mistake that led to the rejection. The arrogant, obnoxious, unhelpful, and entitled way the mistake was handled is what’s infuriating.
- userbinator 4y agoarrogant, obnoxious, unhelpful, and entitled That's just Apple being Apple. It's also one of the reasons I don't use their products despite how nice they look. They always think they're right, and smugly so. "You're holding it wrong", etc. The attitude is endemic.
- encryptluks2 4y agoGetting rejected on Google Play sucks, but at least you can still sideload apps while you dispute it. Getting rejected by Apple should be illegal until they provide a way to use an alternative app store.
- 1over137 4y agoThis is for Mac though, the App Store is not obligatory.
- grishka 4y agoI do wonder what makes people voluntarily publish their apps there. It's not like they can't DIY Mac app distribution.
- lapcat 4y agoSome developers have versions both inside and outside the Mac App Store. Customers definitely request Mac App Store versions, for various reasons. Also, if you already have iOS App Store versions of your apps, then Mac App Store is not much of a stretch.
- DaiPlusPlus 4y agoExposure. Also, IIRC/AFAIK, only macOS App Store-distributed apps have the ability to use parts of iCloud, especially w.r.t. data synchronization.
- threeseed 4y agoUsers like it. For example I almost never use apps outside of the App Store and brew. It's great to be able have updates and purchases managed in one place and if I ever get a new computer I can simply login to my account and re-download everything in seconds.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tambourine_man 4y agoThe little experience I had with AppStore approval is that it’s mostly a game of persistence. They probably see some benefit from a little friction to prevent spam or perhaps it’s just pure stupid bureaucracy. I was rejected for asking access to the camera. The App applied filters to images taken. I stated as much in XCode, something along: this app needs access to the camera in order to apply its effects. Rejected for not being clear enough. I reworded, basically adding more cruft: accepted. I doubt the second version was clearer, in fact, it probably wasn’t. It feels much more like a test to see how much does this account want/need to publish and are willing to cooperate, than actually following rules that make any sense.
- lapcat 4y ago> They probably see some benefit from a little friction to prevent spam or perhaps it’s just pure stupid bureaucracy. More likely the latter, because the crApp Store spammers/scammers seem to have plenty of persistence and somehow manage to make it through review.
- threeseed 4y agoYou also need to have a little understanding. It's never going to be a perfect process when you have people who aren't technical making sometimes subjective decisions. The trick is to plan well. Assume delays and the need for re-reviews and don't tie anything to when you think it might be approved.
- lapcat 4y ago> The trick is to plan well. No, the trick is to run to the press and raise a big fuss, bypassing app review to get to Apple execs who want to quickly shut down bad PR.
- saagarjha 4y ago> Assume delays and the need for re-reviews and don't tie anything to when you think it might be approved. This also, you know, sucks majorly when planning anything. If Apple had to deal with this kind of review when releasing iPhone they’d put a billion dollars into lobbying it away.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 4y agoNext they will take down all iOS apps, because there is a prerelease version of iOS and all of the existing apps refer to that word. Robots, saving us all time and energy!
- smooc 4y agoWhat I find interesting is that we seem to perceive the App Store Review process as some kind of black and white thing, while it isn't. Like a pure function that only works with the input variables provided and no side effects. Guess what, there is an actual human on the other side that is reviewing your app (with support of automation tools obviously). That person will make mistakes, will bring his/her own opinion and might not be consistent and often won't be very elaborate. Kind of refreshing actually. Interestingly, that's probably how most customers are handled by many of the submitted apps, if at all.
- friedman23 4y agoYou must love going to the DMV
- rzwitserloot 4y agoNo, it's a distopian fucking horrorshow. You're right, of course. Humans are involved, it's not consistent, you're witnessing a state machine where 'opinion and carefulness of the human(s) that are part of this process' is a significant chunk of how it works. But, __the escalation features__ are clichéd Catch-22-esque lunacy, and the actual information you receive in order to ascertain which part of the big state machine caused the rejection is non-existent. If this was how a government worked, I'd expect literal "shoot a leader in broad daylight and storm their palace" levels of unrest in a week. Apple (and other corps) are perfectly capable of reasoning beyond the almighty dollar. Tim Cook did it, presumably, in a rather famous incident yelling down someone on the earnings call questioning apple's decision to spend extra cash on environmentally friendlier packaging and distribution processes. Possibly Tim really is a short sighted moron who just thinks its worth wasting money on the environment ('wasting money' in the sense of the amoral stockholder only, of course!), but I'm assuming someone of Tim's caliber is a bit more intelligent than that, and Tim's thought through the (potential) brand damage, let alone the benefits of exuding an imagine of being environmentally friendlier than needed. Which isn't just "brand", but also staving off government intervention. So, given that Tim and co are presumably capable of thinking through the repercussions of how the company operates, are they truly making the call that causing people the kind of pain and frustration that makes posts like this rise to the top of hackernews is somehow 'worth it', or are they, at least in this highly specific regard, short-sighted morons / dangerously uninformed about how their own company's processes work? I just do not understand. Whatever it costs to stop pissing off and chasing away developers for your platform whilst arming the masses to demand regulatory intervention HAS to be worth it. And if Apple and co can't see that, I say; Heck yeah. Bring on the fucking regulators. I know and accept it'll suck and they'll make a hash of it, but odds are good it won't be such a shitshow as what app review is today, and examples need to be made.
- ezoe 4y agoSo the follower of Apple are living in literally a Paranoia TRPG world? "Good morning-cycle citizen. Your publication contains REDACTED which you have to remove because you are not allowed to mention it in your security clearance. Good day-cycle."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- raverbashing 4y agoI find it funny (no, not funny, tragic) how alledgedly the most efficient companies around can go down to Aristotzkian levels of bureaucratic gaslighting.
- DawnQFunk2 4y ago
- NotYourLawyer 4y ago
- saagarjha 4y ago“Fun fact”: mentioning pre-release software is actually very much allowed by the App Store guidelines, and has been for several years. The App Store reviewers themselves have failed to keep up with the developer program license agreement changing and removing the “you can’t talk about beta software” bit. As an app developer it’s hilarious that we have to keep better track of that agreement than they are willing to but sadly kind of expected at this point.
- CharlesW 4y ago> “Fun fact”: mentioning pre-release software is actually very much allowed by the App Store guidelines, and has been for several years. FWIW, I'm reading the App Store guidelines now and can't find anything to support this. I must be missing it. What section are you thinking of?
- saagarjha 4y agoIt’s not the guidelines specifically, beyond the fact that you must follow the developer program agreement, which is the actual thing they’ll ding you for. See this thread for sample rejection verbiage and why it is invalid: https://twitter.com/_saagarjha/status/1438603898999083028 https://twitter.com/_saagarjha/status/1438603898999083028
- ergocoder 4y ago> As an app developer it’s hilarious that we have to keep better track of that agreement For app developer, getting rejected is a huge deal. For the reviewer, it is just a normal Friday. Trust me they don't care that much.
- michelb 4y agoMaybe there are two teams at Apple both working on a different feature with the same name but they never know because they still can’t talk to eachother about it? ;)
- jeffparsons 4y agoI haven't had to deal with Apple's reviewers much personally, but I've watched in amazement as my colleagues wade through the process. Sometimes reviewers get stuck in loops, repeatedly flagging "issues" (misunderstandings) that were already resolved earlier in the conversation. It's like talking to a chat bot with no conversational memory; I guess maybe because it's actually a different person on the other end each time? The most successful strategy I've seen so far is to summarise the entire conversation so far in every single message you send. I've also found, like other commenters in this thread, that we are now much better versed in Apple's rules than their own reviewers. So it can help to include quotes from their rules in the conversation summary.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- borisgolovnev 4y agoRecently it took me 7 re-submissions to get an app through app review. The reason? I was using a third-party SDK! One reviewer figured that the SDK is contained in the app and this means it counts as content. And any third-party content requires a written and signed agreement with me personally which for an open source code from github I obviously didn't have. I was trying to explain the situation but each consecutive reviewer was just copying and pasting the same rejection. The process is just so broken.
- vogt 4y agoWhy is Apple so hard on small developers with incredible scrutiny on releases and sometimes seemingly arbitrary eval criteria, and Tik Tok can run rampant with a keylogger injected with JavaScript? Genuinely asking in good faith here as this is way out of my domain of expertise. I worked as a UI/UX designer for a company that shipped iOS and Android games exclusively and they (Apple App Store reviewers) were always hard on us for every little thing we published. But it seems like the major social apps have some seriously invasive tech bundled in and I have to imagine if JoeBlowApp LLC wanted to ship an app with the level of data collection that Tik Tok has, they'd get reamed by Apple, no?
- Fuzzwah 4y agoAs with most things, "because money"
- vogt 4y agoI had a hunch that may have been the case but I was hoping it wasn't that simple.
- aaronmcs 4y agoMoney
- Terretta 4y ago“It’s clear, Travis… Uber must go.” — TimC to TravisK on Super Pumped https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIiXPQkB-0M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IIiXPQkB-0M
- Apocryphon 4y agoUber bowed part way and they never even got close to getting their app banned. That in-person meeting was more than any rejected developer got.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoIs there a website that lists a collection of all the times people complain about having their face eaten like this by App Store Review? I’ve thought about this from time to time and thought it might be a fun pastime to create a collection of these.
- eckza 4y agoI'm about to release my first iOS app, and all of these posts of late are making me nervous. Does anyone have a good link to a guide for dealing with the App Store reviewers' capriciousness? Or is it simply a roll of the dice, no matter how closely one follows the Apple documentation?
- bquest2 4y agoDo you really wanna pay for the privilege of going through all of this? Do yourself a favor and just leave it at a web app. That way you can still keep your creative freedom.
- eckza 4y agoI've built the whole thing with web-first technology (Elm + Capacitor) and it's cross-platform already - but distributing it as a native mobile app is part of a larger branding strategy to cement my position in an underserved niche as a purveyor of fine software products. Future apps that I have plans for will need to take advantage of hardware-specific features; I see this as a foot in the door. But if I can't get it in, I'll just market the webapp and pivot my strategy for future products.
- tylerchurch 4y agoIn my experience they’ve been fine. Plan on getting dinged for something you forgot or for something minor. Make the tweak and resubmit. No biggie. It’s annoying, but it’s not a huge deal.