4 ms·
Please, Lego, let this engineer bring your computer brick to life
- ada1981 4y agoFiling a provisional patent would have been nice before publishing this.
- amelius 4y agoIt costs money. Also, I think they would need a design-patent instead, as there is nothing technologically new about it (except perhaps the battery contact).
- j-bos 4y agoProvisional patents in the US are a couple hundered bucks, maybe 1000 tops if you make an llc to own them.
- zulban 4y agoMaybe he just enjoys creating and sharing. Why do people often turn to capitalism as the ultimate end goal?
- mensetmanusman 4y agoPatents happen to increase the likelihood that technology scales up, because it is a risk mitigation instrument for spending money on designing/building capital equipment necessary to service global demand. In a strange way, game theory with no patents dictates a first mover disadvantage, because the first mover has to waste all the money figuring out how to build these things quickly before they are copied by a fast follower who puts the first mover out of business. So the likelihood that these things stay craft projects is a bit higher with no patents.
- systemvoltage 4y agoYep, I hate Patents, but not because of their core value, but because of their expiration length. They need to have a variable length based on the type of technology, ease of manufacturing or scaling, as well as industry sector. Designed a novel ordnance for the military? 30 year patent grant. Designed a new ziptie with RFID? 5 years. Patented a rounded corner button on the iPhone? Outright reject with no refunds and a penalty for wasting time. I do see value of a patent-free society that can produce things fast and cheap, i.e. Shenzhen/Guangdong. I don't know if there is a way to have both systems co-exist in some form of a hybrid society without eliminating free markets. I also don't get the hate packaged in the form of the term "Capitalism". Usually, they mean "Crony capitalism".
- LesZedCB 4y agomarkets misallocating resources in the name of profit instead of public good aside -- capital, or property, often has a dubious history of ownership. nearly all of the land that factories are built on or resources are extracted from was stolen. that's not even touching surplus value. I recommend reading the first chapter or two of Capital if you want more info.
- pdntspa 4y agoSomeone else will?
- hiccuphippo 4y agoNot doing it marks this as prior art and prevents other people from patenting it.
- afandian 4y agoI’m not sure it’s that simple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_to_file_and_first_to_invent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_to_file_and_first_to_i...
- mesebrec 4y ago"First to file" only describes what happens when two conflicting patent applications get discovered for something that is patentable. Inventions that are already publicly known are not patentable because they're copies of existing ideas; not inventions. The only exception is that in some jurisdictions, the creator of an invention can wait up to a year between making their own invention public and filing a patent for it.
- dtx1 4y agoIf you know anything about lego you know they'd rather sue the author into oblivion than work with him. He should contact other brick manufactures instead.
- ezconnect 4y agoTheir patent is expired. You can make your own lego now.
- codetrotter 4y agoThe following Wikipedia article has a list of companies producing Lego compatible clone blocks. (See the “Brands” section of the linked article.) Maybe he can work with one of those companies. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lego_clone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lego_clone
- armadsen 4y agoThere is some precedent for Lego bringing outside ideas in. Adam Reed Tucker started doing architectural models outside Lego before they brought him on to create the still-running Lego Architecture line. Earlier sets even had his name on them. Chris McVeigh (aka Powerpig) had a website selling custom sets he designed, including retro computer sets, and a line of “brick sketches”. He’s now a designer at Lego. His Brick Sketches are official sets, and he’s designed retro computing adjacent sets too (including the new Atari 2600 set). There’s also the very successful Lego Ideas program.
- makeitdouble 4y agoWould any other manufacturer be able to stand the heat ? To note, it's really a plea for Lego to not kill them. The author's quote: > There’s a difference between doing something that is acceptable and being able to actually fight if they decide to throw their weight around.
- remram 4y agoThis is cool but useless. It's an impressive build but I don't see a single reason why Lego might want to sell that. I can see real value in more interactive builds, teaching kids about machinery and logic. However this display that can only show simple animations and is too small to use as output for any sort of machine is not that. Replacing batteries all over the place is already annoying enough as a parent, I don't think anyone is looking forward to buying Lego©® Mini Batteries ™ so that the fake computer screens keep showing a fake computer screen.
- lostgame 4y agoLEGO has - for decades - has had a standard, very basic and awesome system of delivering electricity from a ‘power brick’ that contains standard AA or 9V batteries. It’s very cool, they’ve got little metal clips under these special conductive bricks. If you’ve ever played with MindStorms, you’ll know how bloody cool it is. So you don’t have to worry about ‘Lego(c)(r) Mini Batteries’ - if you’d read the article; you’d see, that brilliantly - this is actually already the way the pieces are powered! They have no batteries in them. If you can’t see the value of working displays in especially a collector’s (adult) edition of, say, the X-Wing with that Death Star trench thing, then it’s not a product for you - but I assure you there are thousands of us who will happily say ‘shut up and take my money’ for such a thing.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 4y agoAnd they could probably upgrade the system to transmit both power and a modulated signal to let the bricks communicate.
- remram 4y agoQuoting from the article: > He tells The Verge he probably won't sell them — at least not without legal consultation and a small enough battery! I know the 9V batteries exist but this is not the author's goal.
- turtlebits 4y agoPretty sure it’s the author of the article wanting Lego to produce and sell it, not the actual engineer who built it.
- wofhdiiow10101 4y ago
- bastawhiz 4y agoAs the article says, yes
- max-m 4y agoSee also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31672704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31672704 from a couple of weeks ago.
- shreyshnaccount 4y ago>It’s absolutely insane how cheap and easy this stuff is, you know, to custom-design a new computer. I've always wondered how they do this. what software di they use to design it? is there a course that would teach me how to? is there a youtube playlist? i don't know what to even search for.
- Jtsummers 4y agohttps://www.kicad.org https://www.kicad.org - It seems to be pretty popular for doing this kind of design. As for learning resources, maybe someone else can answer. I studied CMPE 20 years ago before switching to CS, I'm sure there are better resources out there now for learning (and, in particular, for self-study) than what I could possibly recommend (even if I could remember book titles).
- yummypaint 4y agoKiCAD is excellent. You can use it to simulate circuits and play around consequence free as you learn. It has tools to go smoothly from schematic to simulation to PCB design including autorouting and checking netlists, which can be tedious and error prone to do by hand. As far as general resources "the art of electronics" by horrowitz and hill is still a gold standard for all-around electronics knowledge, and is written with good pedagogy.
- jsjohnst 4y ago> I've always wondered how they do this Here’s two beginner friendly options: - https://wokwi.com/ https://wokwi.com/ - https://www.flux.ai/ https://www.flux.ai/
- shreyshnaccount 4y agoknow any resources that teach you how to build a fairly complicated circuit?
- ezconnect 4y ago
- dfee 4y agoWho’s idea was it? The problem is that there’s no credit given to a product manager at Lego for original thinking and delivery. So it’s DOA. I’ve seen this as a bit over my career doing engineering. The decision maker for product innovation is not an engineer. Not to say engineers aren’t generally innovative, but a company is not set up for an engineer to take an idea and execute it, but rather to take a vision and build it. When engineers, hungry to build, realize this, they end up building outside company boundaries - sometimes creating new companies. To take these bricks to market, independent distribution (and a patent) would be worthwhile. I don’t generally believe in patents for software, but for hardware, it provides a counterbalance to the aforementioned culture of modern work. (The same holds true for marketing, distribution, etc.)
- thematrixturtle 4y agoI hate to interrupt a good rant, but Lego has a site literally called https://ideas.lego.com/ https://ideas.lego.com/ where they crowdsource new designs, and the most popular ones actually get turned into real Lego sets. Of course custom hardware goes well beyond the average set, but Lego is definitely not as myopic/Not Invented Here as your average megacorp.
- dtx1 4y agoAnd they take all the rights to your ideas if you upload stuff there so you get 0 if it's produced.
- dfee 4y agoYou lose all leverage until you have market power. E.g. https://brickset.com/article/47293/the-lego-group-acquires-bricklink https://brickset.com/article/47293/the-lego-group-acquires-b...
- dymk 4y agoDo you actually work at Lego or are you just cynically ranting into the void?
- 4y ago
- AndyMcConachie 4y agoThis is neat, but I don't see why anyone would want this. Lego is about building things from lots of interchangable bricks. This just puts a display on one of those bricks. It's neat, but it's not something that will change a kid's Lego experience much. It's just eye candy.
- zulban 4y ago"Lego is about building things from lots of interchangable bricks." Did you really just try to define how millions of children enjoy a toy? You need to relax a bit. Kids (and adults) like toys for all kinds of different reasons that don't necessarily match your own.
- dymk 4y ago> I don't see why anyone would want this > It's just eye candy. I think you do see why somebody would want this
- setr 4y ago… until you put a sticker on it. Lego structures are largely composed of general-purpose blocks, but many kits also includes some special-purpose ones as well (or specialization through stickers)
- crthpl 4y agoEye candy is one of the main reasons people build Lego bulids.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoPlease, no more electric crap in Lego sets. Let today's kids use their imagination like we did.
- Jtsummers 4y agoElectric "crap" has been in Lego kits since the 1970s through the Technic line. Hell, as a kid I didn't have the electronic components, but I did have some non-Lego electric motors so I extended my own Technic kits to be motorized. Sadly, I forgot to add a stopping mechanism. So many shattered cars.
- agumonkey 4y agoOne day I remembered that the first electric circuit I ever assembled was with Lego << Lights and Sounds >> kit that had batteries, connectors and mini light bulbs (with colored head caps).
- krisoft 4y ago> Let today's kids use their imagination like we did. I played with mindstorms and turned out fine. There were plenty of imagination involved all around.
- cianmm 4y agoMindstorms and the RCX put me on the path to software engineering. Probably the single best “toy” my parents ever gave me.
- galleywest200 4y agoThis is from back then: >Incredibly, the whole thing is powered by actual Lego bricks, too — the vintage 9V battery box and bricks with electrical contacts that Lego discontinued back in the ‘90s
- iforgotpassword 4y agoWait, that 9V system doesn't exist anymore, including the conducting bricks? That system was pretty clever. You couldn't really create a short accidentally, no matter how you rotated the next block on top it would always conduct further. You needed to actually use one of those cords that hat a conducting brick on both ends to short it. What are they using today, if this was discontinued (according to TFA)?
- codys 4y agoThey use a custom plug system that doesn't use the standard brick shape as contacts. https://www.lego.com/en-us/themes/powered-up https://www.lego.com/en-us/themes/powered-up shows some examples of the connector and socket. There's also the discontinued "Powered Functions" connection scheme, which can be seen on this model: https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/power-functions-motor-set-8293 https://www.lego.com/en-us/product/power-functions-motor-set... . It appears to be post-brick contacts and pre-"powered up" connectors. There have been many electrical connection schemes over the course of lego's history.