26 ms·
Edible insects role in transmission of parasitic diseases to humans (2019)
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI’ve wondered about this for a few years so this is extremely gratifying to read. I’ll have to go in deeper later to really understand the implications of each parasite, but my main takeaway is that my intuition here was way off. I expected insects to pose far fewer risks from parasites to humans. I wouldn’t have taken a chance based on that assumption, and cooking bugs seems like it would eliminate most of these pathogens, but still. I figured it would be safer. I’d need to read a lot more to draw some kind of comparison between insects and animal agriculture (both seem to carry plenty of baggage), but it’s great to see research like this so it’s possible to begin doing so.
- Traubenfuchs 4y ago> both seem to carry plenty of baggage Salads can literally kill you via the listeria they bring.
- RC_ITR 4y agoThe majority of foodborne illness and death in the US is due to animal products. [1] [1]https://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/attribution-image.html#foodborne-illnesses https://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/attribution-image.html#f...
- steve_adams_86 4y agoIsn’t it also the case that a lot of these contaminations in produce (like leafy greens) are caused by animal manure being used to fertilize the produce? Without manure being used the risk is diminished by orders of magnitude.
- markdown 4y agoOnly little backyard operations use animal manure. No large food chain will carry greens grown in animal manure.
- tompccs 4y agoHave you heard of a small movement called organic farming? https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.morningagclips.com%2Fwp-content%2Fuploads%2F2017%2F09%2Fcertified-organics-20170920-02.jpg&f=1&nofb=1 https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F...
- wyre 4y agoMaybe so, but how does that explain how E. coli outbreaks on lettuce? From what I understand the waste from animal farms run off into waterways that feed the vegetable farms.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoField workers who don't get bathroom breaks.
- scythe 4y agoRabbits? It's not exactly easy ensure there are no animals across thousands of square miles of farmland.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoLooking into this, it's hard to say since there are contamination issues at every point between preharvest and the moment you put it into your mouth: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6899298/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6899298/ It doesn't seem to rank the causes it lists, but googling it suggests widespread contamination caused by fecal matter runoff from animal ag finding its way into irrigation water.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoHere in Canada we have pretty heavy application of manure, primarily in spring and fall. It's part of how we replenish soils at small and large scales. I suspect we rarely grow greens immediately after applications, but to say only backyard operations use animal manure isn't true. Evidently this is a common and well-researched practice in the USA as well: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286297896_Animal_Manure_Production_and_Utilization_in_the_US https://www.researchgate.net/publication/286297896_Animal_Ma...
- aeternum 4y agoFrom that link it looks like about half of illnesses are from animal products and half is from produce. Deaths from animal products is higher. The data is also from 2008. Things have likely changed since US households and food prep has been heavily focused on cleanliness around animal products but nowhere near as much focus is on produce. The 'pre-washed' pre-packaged produce is especially risky.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI’ll pick the salad over the steak any day, though. Above all I’d love to see better technology and attention for food safety, though. It’s stunning to see how many people suffer from food born illness today — something I’d thought was far more under control up until my mid 30s. It’s better under many circumstances and I’m not going to pretend it’s anything like it has been in the past. However, we could do much, much better than we do now and it would literally save lives.
- thelittleone 4y agoWhy, for example over say grass fed, organic steak?
- frankzander 4y agobecause it's salad is a hell lot better in terms of environmental friendliness
- steve_adams_86 4y agoHealth concerns around animal products are not dramatically reduced between organic and non-organic agriculture. It's better, but it's still not good. I don't drink organic alcohol, either; it's harmful to your health no matter how you slice it.
- throwaway09223 4y ago"I’ll pick the salad over the steak any day, though." In terms of food safety and risk of pathogens, salad is far, far more dangerous than steak.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoIt is also not recommended to feed certain types of salad to small pets like birds because it is loaded with pollutants from farming.
- orangepurple 4y agoNot if you flash deep fry 'em
- weberer 4y ago>my intuition here was way off. I expected insects to pose far fewer risks from parasites to humans. Weird, my intuition was the exact opposite. The thought of eating bugs triggers a disgust reaction, similar to the thought of eating crap. Humans developed those reactions over hundreds of generations for a reason.
- orlp 4y agoA disgust of eating insects is not universal in all cultures.
- weberer 4y agoIts instinctual, not cultural. I'm going to guess you're referring to hunter-gatherer societies that frequently have to overcome famine and eat bugs out of desperation.
- sidkshatriya 4y agoThere will always be some cultures that are different from the norm. 100% uniformity in human culture is very rare. But look across the globe: I would posit that a large percentage of humans have a taboo against insect consumption. If there are any counter examples that you can state from the world one must analyze how numerically large that community is within that country and the world. In other words, don't count the number of cultures/communities that are OK with insect consumption, count the population of the cultures/communities that are OK with insect consumption.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoI don't think taboos are in anyway useful in determining health implications. For example, are dogs or horses in any way materially worse than cows or sheep for people to eat? Why are the French happy to eat frogs and snails? I'm reasonably certain the idea of certain food being taboo is almost completely due to cultural norms.
- 4y ago
- slfnflctd 4y ago> cooking bugs seems like it would eliminate most of these pathogens I prefer everything I eat to be properly cooked. I even usually avoid raw vegetables. I can't imagine eating a raw bug on purpose unless it was for a lot of money and I could chase it with a shot of hard liquor afterward.
- shaburn 4y ago"Parasitic developmental forms were detected in 244 (81.33%) out of 300 (100%) examined insect farms. In 206 (68.67%) of the cases, the identified parasites were pathogenic for insects only; in 106 (35.33%) cases, parasites were potentially parasitic for animals; and in 91 (30.33%) cases, parasites were potentially pathogenic for humans. " Sounds horrific. How does this compare to other food sources?
- ars 4y agoWe've been eating other foods for a very long time, and we've developed methods to handle, and prevent, the parasites. Cook meat, make sure fruits and vegetables are not blighted, ferment dairy, various preservation methods from pickling to canning to smoking. The list of methods is enormous. We haven't been eating insects except in times of famine. We have not yet developed methods of dealing with it.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoHumans have been eating insects for a long time. In south africa they eat ants, china they eat scorpio, thailand they eat crickets... The ants and the scorpio are quite tasty IMO. On the other hand, I know of places where their casual vegetables are dangerous because their hold traces of animals feces with pathogens but you couldn't tell when buying them. And finally, I remember eating the best eggs ever from my mother old neighbourg for years. One day friends from the city come, and eating them, get sick. So there is a strong habit component. The study on insects is interesting but more informations is needed to draw conclusions.
- shaburn 4y agoThese are trivial quantities that are unreasonable to reference.
- asien 4y agoThat’s correct. The startup Ynsect at the moment is targeting Fish Farming not human. What would be the impact over many generations of that type of food ? I’m scared of the “SuperBug” type of disease that would be resistant to antibiotics because it’s been dormant in us for too long...
- instagraham 4y agoPossibly like any other food source, then? Boils down to how they're grown, handled, prepared. Arguably, the wet markets in Wuhan wouldn't have been such a disease nightmare if the cages of live animals weren't kept one atop the other, dripping feces and other fluids between species and breaking the inter-species barrier.
- nfhshy68 4y agoWhere do you get your information from? Have you seen that wetmarket? It looked pretty clean to me. Wetmarkets are diverse.
- MisterMower 4y ago
- SapporoChris 4y agoAgreed, there's been substantial clean up of wet markets at least in China. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_markets_in_China#Modernization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wet_markets_in_China#Moderniza...
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoBig fan of Black Soldier Fly farming and there are efforts with grasshoppers. Not sure the featured article (TFA) issue extends beyond the few people working in production (increasingly automated [1]) because the output is a dry meal flour. This, Seaweeds, and directed precise fermentation are a big part of the 10B+ people solution. [1] https://www.rebelnews.com/worlds_largest_cricket_farm_finishes_construction_in_london_ontario https://www.rebelnews.com/worlds_largest_cricket_farm_finish...
- h0l0cube 4y ago> a big part of the 10B+ people solution A better solution is not to have the problem in the first place
- baxtr 4y ago
- chucktingle 4y ago
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoAlternatively, one of you could move to an underpopulated area, and we can all stop consuming beyond our wildest needs.
- marliechiller 4y agoplease respect the mod rules of this site
- dang 4y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments? It doesn't matter how bad another comment is—you're still breaking the rules. You've unfortunately been doing this repeatedly, and we ban such accounts. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
- midislack 4y agoIt's good that we don't have to eat the bugs. Pods are still on the menu though.
- buryat 4y agowe already eat water bugs
- midislack 4y agoNo we don't.
- Gigachad 4y agoEating the bugs never really made sense when they are less efficient and more expensive than plants.
- adrianN 4y agoPeople like variety in their diet, insects are good sources of protein and they eat stuff that we can't eat.
- mrguyorama 4y agoWhat's the solution to the "an antenna/leg is stuck in my teeth" problem that I experienced when I ate crickets? The actual bug part was inoffensive, lightly dusted with salt, and had a satisfying crunch, but the legs and antenna stick to your mouth like a hair and make it hard to eat. As others have stated, 2 billion people eat insects, surely not all of them eat legged insects, but I wonder how the ones that do deal with it. Do they just suffer through it? It's not exactly going to stop you if you're hungry
- adrianN 4y agoI assume the same strategy that works for popcorn parts stuck between your teeth also works for insect parts.
- neodypsis 4y agoHaving eating crickets in Mexico in the past, now I'm concerned.
- neodypsis 4y agoBTW, is there a way to test for these parasites (the rest-of-body kind mentioned in Table 1 [0])? [0] https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0219303 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- kseistrup 4y agoWeren't the crickets prepared? E.g., roasted?
- wonderbore 4y agoChapulines are not eaten raw, like most bugs they're fried or toasted in a pan or comal, but the study shows that parasites may survive that. - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chapulines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chapulines
- BrainsPachanga 4y agoThe study clearly says that cooking them significantly improves the safety, what’s your source?
- wonderbore 4y agoIt’s right there in the document, assuming that the comma here was a typo: > Despite, food preparation processes parasite allergens may still be detected.
- baby 4y agoI’m happy I refused to try when I was there. My SO tried a scorpion though
- MintDice 4y ago
- 0x20cowboy 4y agoI don’t get why it’s so hard for people to just stop eating animals.
- NL807 4y agoBecause the answer is not as simplistic as the question itself.
- tuatoru 4y agoOver the years I've seen several female friends try to stay vegan. One managed a decade before she couldn't put up with the anemia any more. The others quit sooner, because of weight loss, malnutrition, and other issues. It seems humans were evolved to scavenge animals as well as eating plants. It's not just protein, it's iron and fats, and a few other things.
- washbrain 4y agoMaybe it was challenging before, but honestly, getting enough iron and protein in a vegan diet today is pretty trivial. There are plant based alternatives to more or less everything these days. I'm vegetarian,, and only for 3 or 4 years, but honestly there's nothing really missing at all for me.
- tommit 4y agoOn every HN thread about meat there are people claiming they know dozens of people that nearly died because they stopped eating meat, completely neglecting that there are entire cultures that eat pretty much no meat[0]. Or the fact that there are numerous studies about how we eat too much meat and how it affects our health[1]. Sorry, I just don't believe it. Or my experience is just vastly different, because nobody I know that went vegan had side-effects as described by these comments. It's like you said, getting your nutrients on a vegan diet is trivial nowadays, especially if you live in a developed country. The only explanation I have is that people are scared to lose their burgers. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegetarianism_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vegetarianism_by_country [1]: https://www.ndph.ox.ac.uk/news/new-study-finds-links-between-regular-meat-consumption-and-a-wide-range-of-common-diseases https://www.ndph.ox.ac.uk/news/new-study-finds-links-between...
- dukeofdoom 4y agoThey probably contain toxins that can't be cooked away either. Ask yourself why humans refrained from eating them unless near starvation and death for the recorded history of humanity.
- codekansas 4y agoCould just be because they're hard to catch in bulk compared to other prey
- vintermann 4y agoThey didn't. Many insects are even literally kosher. It's just that farming them didn't make much sense until recently. Plants and mushrooms, having far more different biology from us than insects, are probably a worse concern when it comes to toxins that can't be cooked away. And yet humans managed to cultivate food with plenty of those, like cassava.
- jart 4y agoIf by many you mean just locusts. When a bunch of bugs eat all you food and the only thing left to eat is those bugs, then I think locusts being kosher has more to do with survival than actually being kosher.
- vintermann 4y agoAt least several types of locusts as I recall. It's been widely speculated that the dietary restrictions were really about parasites and other food safety concerns, but what's also famous is that they were quite legalistic about it. So if it was only permissible as desperation food, they would have said so... at length. Either way, Jews and other middle eastern groups with picky dietary rules, do have a long tradition for eating it in non-desperate times too. It's icky for us not used to it, but there's no reason to think parasites is a bigger issue with insects than with animals far more similar to us, which we do eat. Remember this article is about pet food insects, often fed to pets raw (if not alive), and it notes some extremely unsanitary practices in pet shops that farm them, such as feeding them on the excrement of the type of creature they're fed to. It's not particularly relevant for insects considered for human consumption.
- pb060 4y agoInsects are the food of the future. So glad to live in the present.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PostOnce 4y agoWe'll all live in megacorp apartments eating crickets and own nothing but subscribe to everything.
- redox99 4y agoAnd you'll be happy
- AvocadoPanic 4y agoor else...
- Oarch 4y agoThis terrifies me. The build to rent sector is absolutely exploding here in the UK. Feudalism here we come!
- 1001101 4y agoI will eat crickets when the rentiers do, which is to say, never.
- prometheus76 4y agoNeom in Saudi Arabia is the vision for the future. I don't want to live in that future.
- cuteboy19 4y agoYou will own the NFT of the apartment don't worry
- smiddereens 4y ago
- Linda703 4y ago[dead]
- noduerme 4y agoMy modest goal these days is to set myself and my descendants up so that none of us ever has to eat bugs. I don't care what it costs. Life isn't worth living if you can't happily chomp a steak, suck down a martini and light a cigarette at the table. It's not to piss people off. It's for enjoyment. Fuck people who can't enjoy life and want to make everything a disgusting misery for other people. If eating cockroaches is what someone believes it takes to save the environment, then let them be a crazy saint. The world will recover after humans wipe ourselves out, if we do, but it's not really worth living if you spend all your time hating yourself for existing and desiring what comes naturally, is it? I'm just dead tired of the neo-religious bullshit around the idea that what I eat or drink is some kind of sin. This is the reason to get rich. Let everyone around scream and faint into their bowl of mealworms. fuck'em all.
- sacrosancty 4y agoThere is a lot of puritanicalishism in current western culture. I miss the 1990's when people were excited for the future and the upward course of human history.
- easytiger 4y agoHow is eating bugs to satisfy the scalability and reporducibility goals of a software developer who spends hundreds of billions lobbying governments to change what i eat because it meets both his pseudo moral and investment portfolio agendas "the upward course of human history."?
- sacrosancty 4y agoI was referring to the general complaint of the parent poster about how people feel enjoying pleasures is wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- ilitirit 4y agoWhat do the latest studies of farm animals indicate?
- elzbardico 4y agoYeah, I always said that for me, a south American for which the Churrascos/Assados (barbecue) is part of my cultural identity, I prefer to become a vegan than eat insects. Pass the lentils, shall you?
- nivertech 4y agoLarger animals can be inspected individually to find pathogens or diseases. Insects are so small that it's practically impossible to inspect each individual organism. You can do sampling of the batch, but the odds of missing bad ones are still high. Same with the fruits and vegetables, some are easy to inspect, others are almost impossible, or impossible to clean. There are kosher (insect-free) versions of lettuce and some berries which are much more expensive than non-kosher ones. Lastly, disgust is a part of the human immune system. Religious dietary laws and cultural taboos are probably partly developed from disgust, and partly from trial-and-error.
- sigmoid10 4y agoIt's still not economical to test e.g. every single pig for roundworms, especially since they do not create clinical symptoms in these hosts and a direct test is rather expensive. But they can pose a significant risk to humans who eat undercooked pork and in the past about 5 percent of Americans were estimated to be infected at any given time. This has only gone down thanks to modern production standards that eliminate or drastically reduce exposure to wild animals that may transmit the disease. Compared to farm animals it's actually pretty easy to contain insects in an environment where they can't get infected with foreign pathogens, since people don't really care about freely roaming larvae.
- nivertech 4y agoI've read a medical research paper about the resurgence of some nasty parasitic disease in Israel with the breakdown by religious community[1]. Turns what? The stricter the dietary laws for the community were - the less infections occurred. And we're talking about sheep here, which is similar in size to pig. There are might be a confounding variables here though, i.e. some communities are mostly urban, others are more rural ones. Or maybe sheep meat is less popular among less infected. Or maybe the animals were smuggled from the "West Bank" which is endemic, and veterinary control services are not strict there if existing at all. -- [1] they used 4 different religions there, but I won't name them in order to not offend anyone.
- 4y ago
- christmm 4y agoWhy is WEF in coordination with Bill Gates owned companies, lobbying so hard for insect consumption?
- dirtyid 4y ago>Conducted parasitological examination suggests that edible insects may be the most important parasite vector for domestic insectivorous animals Bummer. I was aquainted with some folks in insect farming who tried to get novel food regulations moving years ago that for whatever reason gave up and fell back to insect based flours/protein powders and animal feed. Some of them had pretty interesting proposals integrating insect farming with recycling urban bio waste that then gets turned into animal feed which looked good on paper but I always wondered if that was recipe for disease. That said, crickets taste pretty good fried, but for some reason I don't like the idea of the meat I eat being fed on crickets.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> > edible insects may be the most important parasite vector for domestic insectivorous animals > Bummer. You quote this as a bummer, but even if we change the 'may be' to 'definately is' I don't see how this is unexpected? 'Domestic animals' avoid a lot of parasite vectors that wild animals face, and if you have a pet reptile that eats insects, then there's not that many other places for it to get parasites from.
- justthinkhn 4y agoDon’t eat the bugs. You have an innate disgust reaction to bugs and to the idea of eating them. It evolved over millions of years. Heed nature’s warning. They only eat bugs in places where it was historically necessary due to extreme famine. These activists trying to get you to eat bugs don’t have your best interests at heart. Eat meat. It is one of the great liberties man enjoys.
- throwaway41423 4y agoOnly the human species is able to surviva in all climate zones. Cultural evolution allows us to utilize everything around us, including certain insects. You are making a sweeping statement by saying, "eating [all] the bugs" is dangerous and _contrary to our nature_. Also, you should be careful with the word "idiot".
- epgui 4y agoJust decades ago people in the West had the same reaction to lobster, crab and other seafood. Modern society needs to go beyond animal instinct.
- chucktingle 4y ago> Modern society needs to go beyond animal instinct. Yes, especially when it's a certain minority of "modern" society that determines those needs for the society as a whole. I can assure you billionaires won't be eating bugs.
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> Just decades ago people in the West had the same reaction to lobster, Aversion to lobster was an American phenomenon, lobsters have been considered a delicacy in coastal communities around Europe since the Roman era, possibly earlier than that. In the American north-east, people were initially averse to eating lobster because they were originally from inland parts of Europe and didn't know much about seafood. But they did figure it out as they developed their own coastal palates. We've all been living alongside bugs this whole time. If they were good to eat, they'd be popular by now.
- jongjong 4y agoIt's not surprising... I mean look at them. There is an evolutionary reason why insects look disgusting to us. Same reason why feces look disgusting - We're not supposed to eat that.
- hnbad 4y agoThey're spooky because they move erratically and their bodies are so different from ours that we can't intuit where they are looking or what they are about to do. Disgust is largely a learned response, i.e. cultural. Many people find crutaceans disgusting to look at. Rodents are also extremely polarizing. Personally I find dogs mildly disgusting because they often drool, roll in dirt and residue of urine and fecal matter can cling to their coat since they don't clean themselves like cats do. On the other hand some people find cats disgusting exactly because they clean their butts with the same tongues they use to clean their coat and maybe you. The reason most people find insects digusting isn't the insects themselves but that insects are a signal of decay. Spoiled and rotting food attracts flies and other insects, so food with insects on it is unappealing. Countries that don't have a tradition of dairy consumption often find cheese disgusting because it is practically rotten milk.
- marliechiller 4y agoFaeces look disgusting as you learned that it was disgusting from your parents when you were young. Its unrelated to your own evolution but is instead a memetic idea passed on from one generation to the next
- jongjong 4y agoI don't think it can all be reduced down to memetics because there are things which I find disgusting which my parents don't find disgusting. Like oysters for example. Though I think obviously some people are more influenced by memetics than others.
- aeternum 4y agoInsects being disgusting could also be a learned response, kids are pretty willing to pick up and touch things they haven't seen before including insects. However they look to their parents when doing it, or about to do it and are generally quite good at picking up on even subtle facial clues. Since kids can easily be 1 or 2-shot learners about stuff like this it's very difficult to separate innate from learned.
- shaburn 4y ago1. Number of people eating bug(driven by mimesis pushed through a media narative and thus typically viral(aka Exponential by default). 2. Number of variety of bugs being eaten(regionality and entrepreneurialism((often referred to as Cambrian explosions in perfectly competitive markets)) . 3. Number of geographies bugs for consumption being grown in((any including Antarctica and space with a new profit motive...look at the impact of disease due to invasive species)). 4. Number of production methods and processes. 5. New combinations of genetics of peoples and insects/infectious organisms being consumed. Think Montezuma's revenge or lactose intolerance in certain regions of the world except possibly contagious and deadly Multiply all that by orders of magnitude faster gestation cycle and thus the chance for mutation, aside from technology developed to support existing food chain, Number of mutations per lifecycle, increasing the chances of deadly DNA combination by 12x, so order of magnitude. Average lifespan of... A. Bacteria: 12 hours B. Insect: 12 months C. Mammal: 12 years (shortest being the primary disease harbinger, the rat).
- ferruck 4y ago
- tommit 4y agoYeah, I have noticed that with a lot of HN threads that resolve around eating meat. It gets to a level of tinfoil-hat that I'm absolutely not used to on this website, but maybe I've simply not been here long enough. The other day someone unironically said they feel there is "a war on protein" going on, because apparently it's more likely to have an "elite intellectual class" in the background, scheming to deprive us from nutrients, rather than the fact that raising and killing billions of animals each year could simply have adverse side-effects for our planet. I have no explanation for this, and it makes me a bit sad to be honest. It really seems like a whole bunch of people here simply do not want their worldview challenged when it comes to eating animals, and will continue to do so no matter what. With the recent uptick in doomsday-news regarding our climate and all the effects we can feel *right now*, it's also possible that I'm overly sensitive. But it's really depressing to see the community that I've been very impressed with regarding their discussions take such a weird, head-in-the-sand stance on this.
- hnbad 4y agoHN has always been tolerant of this kind of fringe, it comes with the territory of its (right) libertarian bent. The fringe just didn't have as much political potential until a few years ago and has been emboldened to be more open about its views. They've also had years to test out ways to be open about their beliefs while hiding behind a guise of "civility" or "curiosity" and spreading blatant lies only to discard them and move on to the next talking point when caught. HN is incapable of fixing this "problem" because doing so would go against its supposed neutrality and impartiality while the people in question are usually lucid enough not to resort to outright slurs or insults that would allow them to be banned for a breach of civility. As a German I have heard many stories about the nice neighbor or uncle who just happened to actively go on to do war crimes despite otherwise being such a nice person. Civility is not a basis for productive debate, it's a shield for reprehensible views you wouldn't dare to spell out in polite company.
- Trouble_007 4y agoFYI: Food Contamination - harmful Chemicals and Microorganisms in food : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_contamination https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_contamination Foodborne Illness / Food Poisoning : https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foodborne_illness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foodborne_illness
- uwagar 4y agowho is eating them right now?
- hnbad 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entomophagy_in_humans#Insect_consumption_in_human_cultures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entomophagy_in_humans#Insect_c... > Up to 2,086 species are eaten by 3,071 ethnic groups in 130 countries.
- ramblerman 4y agoIf insects were such a valuable and risk free source of nutrition wouldn't we see a lot more human cultures eating them? They've been around forever, but somehow we share a mostly common disgust for eating bugs. Is it farfetched to assume that perhaps that disgust allowed us to survive.
- blablablerg 4y agoA lot of animals do eat insects however, so it is not that they are dangerous a priori. Our evolutionary ancestors, small mammals/primates, most likely did eat insects. We somehow evolved them out of our diet. Strange actually, since they are quite abundant.
- pessimizer 4y agoPlenty of cultures currently eat insects.
- trinachi 4y agoThat's simply not true. The UN FAO estimates that 2B people worldwide consume terrestrial insects regularly in their diets. Add in aquatic insects like shrimp or lobster and that number increases drastically.
- mmmpop 4y agoNo doubt, but I'd be interested to see this figure broken down by country and sorted by GDP.
- cwkoss 4y ago2B people intentionally consume terrestrial insects. 99+% of humans incidentally consume terrestrial insects. Food processing is imperfect and insect contaminants are common. "But the FDA allows up to 225 insect fragments per 225 grams of macaroni (yes, that's one piece of bug per gram) and 4.5 rodent hairs per 225 grams. Per 100 grams, the FDA allows either 10 fly eggs, five fly eggs and one maggot, or two maggots in most tomato products." https://www.fatherly.com/health-science/fda-data-food-contamination-family https://www.fatherly.com/health-science/fda-data-food-contam...
- sumo89 4y agoAs an owner of a reptile this study has another angle for me. The insects tested are all classic reptile food and aside from some creatures being illegal to import or breed the production and selling of edible insects for animals seems pretty unregulated. Every producer claims their bugs are all parasite free so seeing ~80% actually do have parasites is alarming.
- iLemming 4y agoI wonder why Dubia Roaches weren't included. Arguably, one of the most popular feeders for pet reptiles and arachnids.
- helpfulmandrill 4y agoI went through a phase of getting "Eat Grub" edible cricket snacks. Feeling somewhat regretful. Stupid trendy bugs.
- cnity 4y agoIt's wild to me to see such an anti-insect eating tirade on HN. Just observe the comments here: almost every highly upvoted comment is anti-insect, and the comments that express any positive sentiment towards eating insect is flooded with angry responses. Bizarre.
- teknopaul 4y agohttps://montanadailygazette.com/2022/07/27/bugs-the-real-reasons-they-want-us-ingesting-insects-petition-within/ https://montanadailygazette.com/2022/07/27/bugs-the-real-rea... The linked article sounds scientific, but the same author wrote this: "they" are trying to poison "us" rant.
- cnity 4y agoIt seems that if anybody is trying to change anyone else's eating habits, it's the anti-bug folk in here.
- weberer 4y agoThe parent commenter is spreading misinformation. The authors are not the same. They don't even have similar names.
- ergl 4y ago"the same author wrote this" That's not true though, the link you posted is authored by a completely different person.
- slothtrop 4y ago
- prometheus76 4y agoDon't you want to "follow the science"? Science says insects are a major vector for parasitic disease in humans. So should we ignore the science now because other science?
- eth0up 4y agoThe importance of this subject is underestimated and applies as well quite independently of whether humans eat the insects directly or not. Consider the cuban tree frog for example, which has long since initiated its campaign in Florida to host and spread throughout the food chain the rat lungworm nematode. Rat lungworm (angiostrongylus) holds its own in the burgeoning presence of hideous and hostile parasites. It is highly infectious to many species and no picky eater, as it favors the entire body of the host, the brain and all. Burmese pythons are another up and coming host in Florida, and while they might prefer a provincial life in the everglades, many other species will meander north and onward. There are other nasties from nematodes to cestodes and more, gaining new ground. Baylisascaris procyonis is another terrible nematode found almost anywhere in the US, mostly in racoons, but in other species (humans included) with more varying and less frequency and it's often incurable. A study showed that, if I remember correctly, 40 out of 250 wildlife rehabilitation personnel had been exposed, but symptoms varied by exposure load. Both rat lungworm and baylis ascaris are resistant to environmental elements that normally break things down, with baylis even surviving UV light, formaldehyde and extreme cold. Rat lungworm can be deposited on surfaces (eg vegetables), and snails are common vectors. Lungworm is very difficult to remove by washing while baylis is so adhesive that wildlife control authorities advise disposing of rather than washing shovels or tools exposed to racoon latrines. The list goes merrily along with other nasties, but it would require time to refresh my memory and accurately describe more.
- justcookitright 4y ago
- Shindi 4y agoI'm sorry to be direct, I know your post has a ton of interesting knowledge, but it was impossible to read. Have you considered using newlines or breaks? You probably have amazing ideas and more people would read them if it was easier to read (my 2c)
- yubiox 4y agoit is not clear(I hit return here) how to put newlines(and here) on HN
- andix 4y agoIs this still a threat, if you properly cook the insects before eating? AFAIK they are usually roasted or fried.
- keepquestioning 4y agoWe need to stop eating animals. Full stop.
- steve76 4y ago
- cloudkilla 4y agoI was thinking of raising insects for my cat to hunt in the apartment, and had the idea that maybe an indoor farm could become parasite-free after a generation or two of treatment with ivermectin. I searched the article (didn't read) for the words "ivermectin" and "treatment". Nothing specific, but it did have this to say: > The high prevalence of selected developmental forms of parasites in the evaluated insect farms could be attributed to low hygiene standards and the absence of preventive treatments. I kind of assumed that bugs raised for reptiles, etc. would be treated, but maybe not. What do you think?
- shaburn 4y agoSo YC has a few dogs in this fight(Entocycle, Ovipost)?
- CatWChainsaw 4y ago