10 ms·
Gen Z have 86% less purchasing power compared to baby boomers in their twenties
- throwayyy479087 4y agoThis doesnt pass the sniff test.
- Sakos 4y agoIt does for me.
- ggm 4y agoAbsolutely agree. This is a piece about relative poverty in disposible income against current inflation and % of post-tax income which has to go to rent/power &c against truly disposable income. I'm not in the cohort, but I still believe the model. Look to UK power bills, and Australian rents, and rates of home ownership since the 1960s.
- dm319 4y agoI'm an older millenial, should be earning a good wage (doctor/consultant etc..) in the UK. Correction, I am earning a good wage. My parents can't understand how so much of my money goes towards mortgage, commuting costs, bills, childcare. Some things are a lot cheaper. A midi controller, DAC converter, HDMI splitter - these are all cheap imports from china these days. Toys for kids are cheaper, but also cheaply made. But labour is so expensive - building work, window cleaning, childcare, carpentry etc.. Lots of things grossly expensive now - houses, disneyland, centreparcs, football and sports tickets. It's only going to get worse. Hundreds of pounds more leave my bank account this year for energy costs, nearly a thousand more may leave my bank account next year for mortgage costs. I might just sell up and go somewhere else.
- Sakos 4y agoPeople sometimes point out how cheap things like TVs or computers are now, but they're such different scales of cost. In the 90s, a decent computer might run you a few thousand $. A house now costs hundreds of thousands more than it did back then. The savings in commodities isn't making up for rising costs in housing, education, energy, etc.
- ggm 4y agoI think its odd a cohort (me basically) had the golden years, between the one before which had to live through postwar rebuild and industrial conflict, and the ones we leave our somewhat blasted legacy to, refusing to die, spending the inheritance. I don't entirely feel good about this outcome. I am pretty sure higher taxation may be necessary, a return to the state, not the free market. But in the UK and Australia, older voters are holding this back. It's impossible absent revolution to change without waiting for my cohort and older.. to die.
- fallingfrog 4y agoWell I think it’s partly true and partly not- which is dangerous because it muddies the water and makes people less likely to believe what they read in the future.
- Panzer04 4y agoI don't know why you're downvoted - You're correct, even some basic common sense should show that we aren't buying 86% less stuff today than in the 70s. And that conclusion is born through when you actually read the article, they completely misrepresent reality with that title. It's kind of astounding how many people are just taking it as face value.
- xqcgrek2 4y agoThis is the stuff that can cause or facilitate revolutions.
- seydor 4y agoor just resignations
- nine_zeros 4y agoSo much this. A lot of people are just checked out. Their plan if they get laid off? Take a flight to Mexico and live a better life while the storm passes.
- tintor 4y agoThat is the plan for Texas frost storms.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoMedian age is too high for revolutions. Most people are tired and chugging along.
- bilegeek 4y agoIt bears repeating[1]: the mob doesn't replace the king; the court does, using the mob to do it. Nothing will get better under a revolution unless we're EXTREMELY, infinitessimally small chance lucky. [1]https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs?t=878 https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs?t=878
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jleyank 4y agoWell, I spent my twenties (in the 80's) in school, or working for 30K or 36K/year. You can work out what inflation does to those salaries vs. what purchasing power gets you today. Anecdotal, yeah, but it's all I got. And albums cost $4-5 in the mid-70's and I did ok on $20/week for food and stuff in school. And there was no internet and the only computers filled rooms (but were still fun). One did social interactions F2F, which might actually have been a little more expensive.
- msbarnett 4y ago> Well, I spent my twenties (in the 80's) in school, or working for 30K or 36K/year. Ballpark the 80's as 1985 and that works out to 82,604.83 to 99,125.80, for the curious. What most people would consider an excellent salary in their 20s, probably (software engineers in the current market excepted, perhaps).
- m00x 4y agoThere's always a golden job in the era. Back in the 2000s in Canada, you could make 350k/y driving a truck in the oil fields with 0 education. Software engineers are just the new golden job of this era. Even then, it's still considerably harder and has a higher bar of entry than driving a truck.
- elzbardico 4y agoBoomers in their twenties were mostly working. Gen Z in their twenties is finishing college, working towards a master's or even a PhD. EDIT: No value judgments here. This is just a fact, people entered the active workforce earlier.
- battery_glasses 4y agoMakes sense, a Boomer in their twenties could buy a house and support a family of 4 with a high school education.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThey also weren't competing with a bunch of people with college degrees so except at the highest end a college degree was less of a necessity therefore they could get away without wasting 4yr on it.
- elzbardico 4y agoThe joys of an industrial economy without too much automation.
- gruez 4y agoand the fact that US is the only major economy isn't in ruins from ww2
- colinmhayes 4y agoan industrial economy without too much competition there’s plenty of cheap labor to be had in the world. The us was prosperous because there was the right combination of labor and capital.
- falcolas 4y agoMy mother, a baby boomer ('48), worked as a waitress part time to pay her way through college in her 20's. My dad worked for ma'bell, and earned somewhere around $150k in today's dollars as an high-school-educated lineman when he retired (and was then hired back on to train). And that's with a fully funded pension plan. So, even if they were in the workforce earlier (they weren't, I (as a genX) was working part time in college at 18, my wife full time), the workforce was very different. The times, they've changed.
- shrubble 4y agoI really feel for the younger than Gen X (which I am) groups. My older brothers who are boomers did have it easier (than me) and I had it easier than the younger groups. Purchasing power and a general decline in society's support along multiple axes for what most would call a 'normal' life really does make me think that some form of strife or revolution is coming.
- bamboozled 4y agoIt does feel inevitable because at some stage, young people aren't going to care about supporting rich older people and check out of the boomers preferred systems of politics and taxes.
- elzbardico 4y agoYou're probably an early cohort of Gen X. Late Xers, that started their professional lives in the late 90s or early 2000s already got a bad deal.
- falcolas 4y agoAs someone who was saddled with around $150k in college loans in a major I couldn't use (flying; that career was aborted in September of 2001), yeah... Bad deal sums it up nicely. Took me into my 40's to buy a house, and for my area I got a steal at under $200k. At which point my dad (born '38) chewed me out for not saving money and building it myself like he did for only $10k (~$100 in today's dollars for 5 acres of land and 3,000 sqft).
- it_citizen 4y agoIsn't it a natural consequence of capital growing faster than wage?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> a natural consequence of capital growing faster than wage? No. It’s the result of our real estate and housing system. (Stocks and Bitcoin can go up faster than wages without spiking CoL.)
- KennyBlanken 4y agoIt's a result of skyrocketing corporate profit margins and plunging corporate tax share leading to a massive consolidation of wealth among a very, very small number of people.
- morninglight 4y agoDon't discount the change in population. The US population has doubled during this period. Everyone has an opinion on how that change would have affected the economy, but it would be foolish to assume that it did nothing.
- stolenmerch 4y agoIt seems the annual income vs. CPI is the core chart here. Something happened in the decade of 2000-2010 to throw things out of whack. I'm not informed enough to know if that was the result of policy decisions or what, but I'd like to know how wage growth declined so dramatically during this time while prices seemed to maintain its projected linear growth.
- mlcrypto 4y agoQuantitative easing
- okwubodu 4y agoUnsubstantiated guess: insane P/E ratios became the norm and maintaining them is harder when you’re raising salaries.
- DamnYuppie 4y agoHow do large P/E ratios impact salaries?
- Enginerrrd 4y agoI don't think this would pass much scrutiny, but I suppose you could have a situation where a small number of people that own a large number of shares in a variety of companies could become a monopolistic unified force that could put downward wage pressures on entire industries.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> insane P/E ratios became the norm and maintaining them is harder when you’re raising salaries P/E is the inverse of earnings yield. It varies with rates. So 2% -> 1% equity yield means a doubling of P/E. But framed as a yield shift it looks less dramatic (and more familiar).
- davesque 4y agoOne thing jumps out in my mind. I think of the 2000s as being the decade in which tech companies that survived the dot com bust turned into tech giants. And these companies would go on to rack up market caps that broke historical records. I remember everyone was sort of in awe of the numbers and generally had a pretty positive sentiment towards the success. However, I'm not sure I can craft a really clear narrative that connects this back to stagnant wages. But it seems related. Perhaps in the sense that large corporations like the tech giants seemed to be free to monopolize and suck up all the money without allowing it to circulate in the economy. The tech giants may have just been a particular touch stone in a long trend of increased, unchecked corporatization of US business. Perhaps that culminated in a kind of phase transition that took place in the 2000s. But there's another interesting detail to that chart which is that wages appear to be back on track since 2010 and have trended upward pretty sharply since then compared to the 2000s. If the slope of the wage line is to be believed (and were to continue), we'd be in pretty good shape in another decade or so. So, to play devil's advocate, perhaps it's wrong to look sideways at some of the big players in the space right now. I don't know. Not an economist.
- hot_gril 4y agoHome prices are misleading because real estate has become an inflation-proof place to store wealth, like stocks but with nuanced subsidies. Even homeowners who live in the house are partially buying with the expectation to sell it for more later. Call it a bubble that never fully pops. In some less countries with higher inflation and less developed markets, this is so extreme that nobody really buys a house, only buys a piece or inherits. Better to look at rent, which isolates the utility part.
- ctoth 4y agoAt least they can buy cheap TVs, right? I wonder if we can finally accept that just because things like phones and TVs got better faster than purchasing power got worse, doesn't mean that it hasn't been getting worse for a while. I'd even go so far to say that technical progress in a couple areas has hidden some pretty stark declines. Or at least allowed some people to point at shiny things getting better when complaints surfaced.
- Swizec 4y agoWhat good is cheaper tech if we just use that to add more features and keep the same price? You could get a TV for less than $50 if it had the same features and processing power as it did in 2002. Same for computers. Imagine how cheap we could make a car that only has the features we had in the 90’s? Even if you include the mandatory passive safety upgrades.
- i_am_proteus 4y agoI'd be first in line for a new car that only has the features of cars from the 1990s.
- hot_gril 4y agoFord Crown Victoria was sorta that until 2010.
- 4y ago
- vt85 4y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoHow does one compare the purchasing power for a phone, which would be like a million dollars back in the day (if it was built to do a fraction of the things it can do now)?
- ceejayoz 4y agoYou don't, because that's not a sensible way of looking at things.
- Zenst 4y agoLandlines, which were not cheap going by UK prices compared to operating a mobile today. Don't have figures but then couldn't afford one when I grew up in the 70's. Then colour TV's. Much technology has got cheaper. Now real-estate and travel costs (well apart from plan flights I'd say) have got more expensive. But when rent and travel is a big chunk of life, and you measure things from owning a home. Well, those do skew things. Then you also have aspects of population growth, post-war, kinda fewer people, that soon grow to hit that real-estate boom. Also interest rates, was mentality of saving for things in 70s and shifted towards low interest rates and buy now, pay later. This also changed the landscape and again made those on the property ladder grow and push the access to that property ladder higher and higher. But rental and travel, those really are the skew factors at play. Need to compare quality of life really to get a bigger picture of everything, as that has increased in more aspects than people appreciate. Heck I grew up with no central heating, single pain windows which had ice on the inside in winter and an outdoor toilet. This was in the uk in the 70s. Today, that would be called homeless. So much improved, so can't distract from that difference either.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThis doesn't make sense at all to me. They're comparing income in constant 2022 dollars with the CPI. That's saying "if we adjusted historical salaries for inflation, then assumed that the constant 2022 dollar numbers were actually nominal numbers for each point in history, then people would've been able to buy much more stuff back then". Which is true, but not very meaningful. The whole point of the constant 2022 dollar adjustment is to back out the effect of inflation. If 2020 average salaries in 2022 dollars were $44.2K, and 1970 average salaries in 2022 dollars were $24.6K then 2020 workers have 80% higher purchasing power for whatever basket is used for the deflator.
- readams 4y agoThey've specifically pulled out only the categories that have risen faster than inflation, and didn't include any categories that have fallen relative to inflation. So it's guaranteed to get this result.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Skunkleton 4y agoMaybe they are arguing that GenZ should commute to the past? That way they can spend their 2022 dollars on good value 1970s products?
- andrew_ 4y agoMy parents are boomers and frequently talk about the 2020s being 70s dejavu. My father entered his 20s in in 1968, and the tail end of his 20s in a deep recession and purchased a modest home in 1976 at a blistering 14% on 30 year fixed. His experience in the Midwest did not match with the assertions in the article.
- Pxtl 4y agoHow much was the total price of that modest home? 14% of cheap is still cheap.
- nemo44x 4y agoIt’s pretty much the same as today when you consider inflation and interest rates. People love to believe homes were basically free back then but they weren’t. Interest rates were super high and people still paid the same percentage of their monthly income line today. There has been sone warping to be sure in and around metro areas people want to live in. Those areas were being abandon back then. Most places in the country are really cheap. But overall it’s about the same.
- fallingfrog 4y agoRents really are higher though.
- andrew_ 4y agovery true. in my area it's related to Zillow and the iBuyers swallowing property and inflating rent artificially.
- juanani 4y ago
- kbrannigan 4y agoThe proliferation of payment plans. Everyone can "afford" a flagship smartphone. Only 36$ per month Everyone can afford a car only : 340$ a month. numbers add up fast digging themselves into a hole
- gruez 4y ago>Everyone can "afford" a flagship smartphone. Only 36$ per month Everyone can afford a car only : 340$ a month. But auto loans were around since the 20s. What changed? https://lendedu.com/blog/history-of-auto-lending-industry https://lendedu.com/blog/history-of-auto-lending-industry
- mattrick 4y agoIt seems like everywhere is pushing financing as an alternative to payment upfront. Even small (<$50 purchases) are being offered financing through services like Klarna. It really feels like it's become an option for almost any purchase now.
- nomel 4y agoFinancial responsibility, it would appear: https://www.businessinsider.com/credit-card-debt-record-2017-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/credit-card-debt-record-2017...
- rvz 4y agoGiven the banks know these people can't afford it anyway they will still allow them to continue borrowing despite knowing that it is already getting expensive for average people to do so quickly. If some are rejected directly by the banks for getting these loans, then the banks can still get them by setting up a BNPL (Buy-Now-Pay-Later) competitor / service with even higher interest rates. Either way, the banks still win. So you will own nothing, and you will be very happy. Even if you can't afford it, the banks will be very happy to charge you interest and you will still be happy. The scam of the century.
- m00x 4y agoThat's incorrect. If anything, banking and lending regulation have only increased since the boomer era. We made it more convenient, but we also made it harder for businesses to trap people in bad loans.
- lettergram 4y agoTo be fair, most (the vast majority) of people I know in gen z I know works significantly less hard than my parents did, I did, etc. Those who do work hard are fairly well off. They work two jobs, didn’t go to college, but own their homes and have a steady income. There’s definitely systemic issues, but work ethic is the major issue. And that’s a cultural issue. Would you want the gen z you know building your house? I know some that I would, but not many.
- hot_gril 4y agoI know gen Z as working harder, especially in school. The bar gets higher every year.
- kurupt213 4y agokids left highschool knowing more math in the 70's than college graduates do now
- hot_gril 4y agoI doubt it. Kids leave elementary school today knowing more programming languages than college graduates did in 2010. If you want actual data, compare SAT scores or something. I'm willing to bet that by any metric, school was lax back then.
- eganist 4y agoIf anything, if that was actually true, it'd be a colossal indictment of prior generations of administrators and leaders demolishing the quality of education for those who followed. So for GP's sake, I hope they're actually wrong about math skills being weaker among the current gen.
- kurupt213 4y agoSAT scores have a trend of being inflated over time because they are dropping. There is no way the average college bound student from the 70’s doesn’t score higher on every standard subject than a contemporary one.
- FightingSpirit 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- endisneigh 4y agoI don't understand why people compare now to before (Boomer adolescence) in the United States. The USA basically had no competition when Boomers were in their 20s. All of the major powers destroyed themselves and their economy. I'd be interested to see this analysis done per country.
- nemo44x 4y agoAgreed. Compare to previous eras. Post WW2 America was an anomaly.
- smt88 4y agoThis isn't a chart of declining GDP. It's a chart of declining purchasing power. The US economy is thriving. The profits just aren't getting to actual workers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- colinmhayes 4y agoRight, all we have to do to return to a post ww2 era of middle class success is destroy the rest of the worlds industry.
- kurupt213 4y agoaren't taxes lower now, though?
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoAt the federal level nominal rates are lower. Effective rates are a lateral move or slight change depending on your bracket. Unless you're rich enough that progressive taxes (e.g. income and property) dominate your tax burden (most 20yos are not this wealthy) overall tax burden in most places is way up due to the proliferation of regressive consumer taxes and government fees that are basically taxes in the past 70yr. The above paragraph is a broad brush statement and does not apply to all jurisdictions and situations. The prior sentence shouldn't be needed but is.
- telchior 4y agoOne of the items this article doesn't cover is healthcare spending, which has increased between 2 and 8 times since 1980 (depending on whether you're looking at individual spending or share of GDP). Here's a decent collection of charts: https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/u-s-spending-healthcare-changed-time/ https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/chart-collection/u-s-spe... It has been shocking to me to see how cheap and effective healthcare can be in other countries, from an emergency visit to the hospital (in the US: I got a $50k bill for one emergency surgery) to an eye test and new pair of glasses (US costs running $500-$1000, although startups have chipped away at this). In the US, healthcare is effectively a collection of cartels -- an enormous parasite that will be nearly impossible to rip off our soft underbelly.
- hot_gril 4y agoI always see the healthcare cost to consumer compared to other countries, but that isn't the true cost to society if the govt is subsidizing the rest. AFAIK the US healthcare is still truly more costly. Monopolies or something, idk.
- willcipriano 4y agoThe US government spends more on healthcare per capita than any other OECD nation. We are just being robbed.
- hot_gril 4y agoThat still mixes a lot of factors in, including how often people need care and what kind of care is provided. Better to compare the same procedure/drug/etc in the US vs elsewhere. I think in the US it's usually more costly that way, especially when it comes to drugs.
- ekianjo 4y ago> healthcare per capita than any other OECD nation. You also need to mention that the US is not like any other OECD nation. It also happens to he the nation with the largest innovation in Healthcare, and not just by a little. By Far.
- elzbardico 4y agoThings have been bad for the young for quite some time. It all started way back in the dawn of neo-liberalism. Since then, productivity has been raising without salaries growing as much. And worse than income concentration, we've seen an absurd level of wealth concentration since the late 80s and early 90s. Late Gen-Xers were already pretty much fucked.
- fallingfrog 4y agoAh not to be a spoilsport but I don’t the title is accurate. Actual quote is: “Gen Z dollars today have 86% less purchasing power than those from when baby boomers were in their twenties.” Quite a different claim.
- koboll 4y agoSome of these charts are atrocious chart crimes. This one is particularly bad: https://i.imgur.com/hfHmvhP.png https://i.imgur.com/hfHmvhP.png
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoJesus Christ, the person who made this chart needs to accept Tufte into their life.
- phonon 4y agoThe author apparently has no idea how to do CPI calculations. She somehow seems to be calculating inflation adjusted wage increases to CPI changes. Rather-- Median Family income in 1970 was $9,870 [0] Median Family income in 2021 was $79,900 [1] CPI in 1970 was 38.8 [2] CPI in 2021 was 271.0 Ratio of incomes = 8.1 Ratio of CPI = 6.98 So household income has increased more than inflation. Median household income might not be the best comparison--family sizes have changed, there are more women in the workforce, etc. But "86% less purchasing power" makes no sense. [0] https://www.census.gov/library/publications/1971/demo/p60-80.html https://www.census.gov/library/publications/1971/demo/p60-80... [1] https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il21/Medians2021.pdf https://www.huduser.gov/portal/datasets/il/il21/Medians2021.... [2] https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/inflation-calculator/consumer-price-index-1913- https://www.minneapolisfed.org/about-us/monetary-policy/infl...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- titzer 4y agoThis one's a whopper. The annual salary in the first graph is adjusted for inflation, while the CPI is not adjusted for inflation. Rather the CPI is how inflation is calculated. Wildly misleading.
- 88913527 4y agoThere have been methodology changes between 1970 and today.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThat doesn't make any difference; any methodological differences are just swamped by the erroneous double application of the price deflator in the comparison.
- gruez 4y agoOkay but two wrongs don't make a right. If there were actually methodology changes that caused CPI to be not representative of purchasing power then accounting for CPI twice doesn't really fix anything, it just adds more noise into the result. To do it properly you need to explain what the methodology changes were, estimate their impact on the "real" CPI, and use your revised CPI to account for inflation. The author hasn't done that, so it's far more likely she has no idea what she's doing.
- topynate 4y agoThis article is complete bullshit because it effectively corrects for inflation twice. The CPI is a measure of the nominal change in cost of a basket of goods. This should be compared, like for like, to nominal income, not inflation-adjusted income. The CPI was already used to adjust the income to which it's compared in this article!
- modeless 4y agoThe fact that this got upvoted to the top despite being complete bullshit just shows how desperately people want this to be true. 170+ people clearly upvoted the headline and didn't understand the article. And everyone in the comments is knee-jerk posting their own personal rants about finance with only a tangential connection to the article. What a dumpster fire of a post.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 4y agoThank you for summing this up so succinctly. I knew they comparing these two numbers was wrong, but I couldn't quite articulate it.
- shard 4y agoOther ways to say this: Baby boomers have 86% less purchasing power than the greatest generation had in their seventies. Gen-X have 86% less purchasing power than the silent generation had in their fifties.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amelius 4y agoOn top of that, boomers use the money they have against the people who don't have the money (e.g. by buying real estate, and also by speculating with it). So the problem is compounded.
- jscipione 4y agoIt seems obvious that the cost of living is much higher today than it was in the 1970s when a family could be supported by a single income while today given the cost of house, car, and commodities even two incomes does not compare to the buying power of a single income then. The dollar has inflated to the point that it will soon be worthless. I wondered how the fed planned to pay its massive multi-trillion dollar debt once the dollar crashes but the Inflation Reduction Act has answered that question. Democrats are planning to extract the wealth of the American people at gunpoint held by 87k new militarized IRS agents.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fleddr 4y agoIt's a simplified conclusion, but the era in which a mail man could support an entire family with ease was a historical anomaly. You can pinpoint the timeline exactly, where the above wealth stagnates or declines whilst the rest of the world is rapidly catching up, industrializing. You can locally optimize but not even taxing the rich for 90% will fix this. My other simplified conclusion is that everything that you need seems to be getting ever more expensive whilst everything that you do not necessarily need becomes dirt cheap. We should probably spend some more time thinking about that. Everything becomes cheaper due to spectacular advances, but not housing, healthcare, energy, education, tax levels. I mean, it's almost as if some invisible force blocks this progress, benefiting from artificial scarcity. Almost as if we're not supposed to have it good.
- Panzer04 4y agoWhat's with the title? The article itself does not make this claim (even if it has some outlandish presentations of information) - it claims that dollars have 86% less purchasing power, not that we have 86% less purchasing power. The article does everything it can to make you think this without actually saying it, but it doesn't say it. It's a terrible article, but that title is somehow worse. (Honestly, I don't think this really deserves a submission, it's just wrong..)
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoYou should compare things that didn't change between then and now. BigMac, for example, cost 65c in 1970, and $5 today. Average income (from the first graph) was $3.68k vs $44.2k today. So you had to work x1.5 more time for a bigmac in 1970 than today. A return flight from NY to London cost $550 in 1970, about the same today. So you had to work 10 times more for that flight in 1970 than today.