6 ms·
Apple held up Telegram’s latest update over emoji
- janandonly 4y agoNo, they held up the update over Copyright. Specifically, Apple's copyright on the Emoji's. As is their right.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 88840-8855 4y ago
- rustqt6 4y ago
- jjcon 4y agoAt what point does it become telegrams IP? The smiley face predates Apple by decades
- agsnu 4y agoAt the point that they design their emoji from scratch? Emojipedia shows you what they look like on a variety of platforms, the blog post shows they look a lot like they started with Apple's (although in fairness WhatsApp's look very similar as well).
- threeseed 4y ago> The smiley face predates Apple by decades And a circle, line and dot predates everything by centuries. So I guess all copyright is pointless. Or maybe that's not the system works at all and it's based on infringing a specific design.
- mschuster91 4y ago> Or maybe that's not the system works at all and it's based on infringing a specific design. There are also jurisdictions which have a concept of "it must have a good enough quality to be worth of protection", in Germany we call it "Schöpfungshöhe" [1]. However, even a work (e.g. a logo) that doesn't fall under copyright protection due to that floor still may fall under trademark protection... but that's definitely not applicable for Unicode-standardized emoji. [1] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6pfungsh%C3%B6he https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sch%C3%B6pfungsh%C3%B6he
- hnfong 4y agoIf it's good enough that Telegram wants to make unlicensed copies of specifically a set of emojis among other comparable designs, it would be hard for Telegram to argue that it's not original enough...
- dmitriid 4y agoUnicode-standardized emojis are not what Apple ships. Apple (and Microsoft, and Android, and Samsung, and...) ship designs based on standardized Unicode descriptions of emojis. There's a reason Emojipedia lists multiple designs for each emoji. See e.g. https://emojipedia.org/grinning-face/ https://emojipedia.org/grinning-face/ Edit: Gun is a better example, https://emojipedia.org/pistol/ https://emojipedia.org/pistol/
- jjcon 4y agoCan you show precedent that emojis are even copyrightable? Maybe you have no idea what you’re talking about
- threeseed 4y ago> House styles represent standard design choices implemented across an emoji set, such as the Google blob shape or a uniform non-yellow color for face emojis. A house style could provide the basis of compilation copyrights in emoji sets, and applying the style to individual emojis might help make those emojis copyrightable (or qualify as a derivative work, if they are a variation of the Unicode standard). House styles also could be part of a platform’s trade dress. https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2018/03/article_0006.html https://www.wipo.int/wipo_magazine/en/2018/03/article_0006.h...
- sneak 4y agoThat was speculation by the article's author.
- aaomidi 4y agoTheir right should be determined in court, if it gets to that point. Not by apple using its monopoly on the Apple Store to decide and judge whether something breaks copyright laws.
- baby 4y agoSo this article contains no information besides “update was held up” which must happen all the time. On the other hand these new emojis look really cool. This almost feel like an ads.
- Hamuko 4y ago>On the other hand these new emojis look really cool. I disagree. It feels like a painful return to early 2000s animated phpBB forum emoticons.
- dmitriid 4y agoWho wouldn't want a return of those emojis! :crazy-lopsided-grin: :head-banging-against-the-wall: :chasing-another-smiley-with-an-axe:
- emptyparadise 4y agophpBB aesthetics hurt so good.
- baby 4y agoAs a phpbb contributor I feel like it was an awesome era
- mschuster91 4y ago
- sneak 4y agoIt would be very silly indeed if the anticompetitive bundling of memoji (apple's competing high res emoji for messaging) is the hill they chose to die on, after finally letting Netflix link to their own subscription payments on the web.
- unyttigfjelltol 4y agoYes, in the current enforcement environment refusing to let a chat client render :) the same way across platforms, because you want to lock users into your integrated hardware/software ecosystem. Let's hold a Congressional hearing about it.
- weikju 4y agoIn previous articles, it was said the update was held up and prevented Telegram from releasing a feature that would revolutionize chat... > He claims that the update is “about to revolutionize how people express themselves in messaging” https://www.theverge.com/2022/8/11/23301864/telegram-founder-pavel-durov-blames-apple-holding-back-major-update https://www.theverge.com/2022/8/11/23301864/telegram-founder... Not so revolutionary in my opinion. Good way to spin an update delay to get some articles written about themselves though.
- threeseed 4y agoa) Idea is copied from KakaoTalk stickers which was released a decade ago. b) Emoji are copied from Apple emojis. c) PR strategy is copied from the dozens of startups who also played this victim game.
- drclau 4y agoRegarding a), I seem to remember that Yahoo Messenger had animated stickers _with audio_. I recall they had a pack with Madonna's (the artist) voice/songs. I just don't recall when exactly that was, but I think it was ~2005. Edit: I just found this: https://www.madonna.com/news/title/madonna-audibles-now-available-on-yahoo-messenger https://www.madonna.com/news/title/madonna-audibles-now-avai...
- Spooky23 4y agoThe audible “buzz” in Yahoo Messenger remains my favorite feature to this day.
- jbverschoor 4y agoThe tweakers.net forum has had animated emojis since early 2000s
- Handytinge 4y agoI ran multiple phpBB2 forums in that time with them. They weren't "emojis" though, they were emoticons. :)
- Groxx 4y agoNot sure why they'd take issue with Telegram doing this, when Slack and Discord and probably others have been supporting animated emoji for years. But that kinda is Apple's modus operandi. The left app store gatekeeper doesn't know what the right one approved or disapproved of last week, so you get smacked down seemingly randomly.
- Gigachad 4y agoDoesn't seem like its animated emoji thats the issue, its that they animated the default emoji design. Other apps like MS teams have their own designs which are animated rather than using the default set.
- chunkyguy 4y agoNothing new here. If you've ever published apps on AppStore you would know how random Apple is with app reviews. It's like there's no consistent guideline handed out to the reviewers and they just nitpick on whatever they feel like.
- ninth_ant 4y agoIn your rush to blindly condemn Apple, you may have missed that in this case TG deliberately copied unlicensed Apple assets as the basis for their new emojis. This is unambiguously copyright infringement, it is not at all “random” for Apple to enforce it in this case but to also allow animated emojis in other apps that do not steal their IP to include those features.
- m-p-3 4y agoTechnically, aren't emojis considered a glyph-based typeface? In the US https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_protection_of_typefaces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_protecti... > Typefaces cannot be protected by copyright in the United States (Code of Federal Regulations, Ch 37, Sec. 202.1(e); Eltra Corp. vs. Ringer). The idea that typefaces cannot be copyrighted in the United States is black letter law since the introduction of 37 C.F.R. § 202.1(e) in 1992. Under U.S. law, typefaces and their letter forms or glyphs are considered utilitarian objects whose public utility outweighs any private interest in protecting their creative elements.
- kome 4y agoI guess a solution for Telegram could be to design their own, standard, emoji set. So far they were using the apple one across platforms, just to avoid "emoji misunderstandings" (when the emoji design is different, also the meaning can be interpreted differently - that's why is better for a common chat to use the same set). Given the quality of Telegram UI and designers, I am sure they will do a very very good job.
- sippeangelo 4y agoIt was always really nice that the Telegram emojis were consistent but since they added the animated emojis I always find myself sending one and having the animation depict a whole other emotion because whoever made it lives under a rock.
- 6510 4y agoThey looked so happy and energetic before apple murdered them all. And we thought apple was so big and powerful but now that we see how frightened they are by these insignificant animations....
- threeseed 4y ago> If you don't take adequate or sufficient, reasonable means to protect and enforce your IP, then you run the risk of losing your IP rights. https://www.natlawreview.com/article/enforce-your-intellectual-property-or-risk-losing-it https://www.natlawreview.com/article/enforce-your-intellectu...
- rpdillon 4y agoThat article seems to be offering legal advice, but from a technical perspective is awful: it throws multiple types of IP law into a blender and then discusses IP like it's one thing, incorrectly. Of the types mentioned, only trademark must be enforced to preserve one's rights. Both patents and copyright have no such requirement, and Apple's claim here would be copyright-based. In any case, Apple is within their rights to assert that telemoji are an unlicensed derivative work of Apple's emoji, but they aren't compelled to enforce that to keep their copyright.
- oefrha 4y agoQuite simply, Apple Color Emoji isn’t licensed. They could have chosen one of the free emoji fonts like Noto Emoji, or if they don’t like any of the existing free ones, commission their own. Instead they chose to adapt an unlicensed proprietary font. > This is a puzzling move on Apple’s behalf… Hardly puzzling. What’s puzzling is their developers and designers seem to have never heard of licenses on artwork. And no, “your emojis are boring and we’re making them awesome” is not a valid copyright infringement defense.
- GlitchMr 4y agoTechnically it may not be a copyright infringement - whether emojis can be copyrighted is quite complicated. However, this is irrelevant as App Store Review guidelines say the following. > Apps may use Unicode characters that render as Apple emoji in their app and app metadata. Apple emoji may not be used on other platforms or embedded directly in your app binary.
- oefrha 4y agoSaying Apple Color Emoji the font, basically a collection of images, can’t be copyrighted is like saying Helvetica can’t be copyrighted.
- GlitchMr 4y agoHelvetica typeface cannot be copyrighted in United States, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_protection_of_typefaces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_property_protecti...
- tragictrash 4y agoSo... Correct?
- Someone 4y agoI don’t see why they would have to embed Apple’s font in their app. What’s at stake, IMO, more likely is that they created a derived work from Apple’s emoji, while Apple doesn’t approve of that. (I won’t make any claim here w.r.t. whether that is or should be forbidden)
- JimDabell 4y ago> “This is a puzzling move on Apple’s behalf, because Telemoji would have brought an entire new dimension to its static low-resolution emoji and would have significantly enriched their ecosystem.” This guy talks like a press release. > The update is loaded with other new emoji improvements, though. Users who subscribe to Telegram’s recently-launched $4.99 Premium service will be able to upload and use custom emoji in chats with friends, and Telegram is offering 10 custom packs with more than 500 emoji to start. Actually, this whole article sounds like an advert. Has The Verge stooped so low they are now doing undisclosed advertorials?
- throwawa-y123 4y agoit sounds like they’re performing the age-old excremental journalistic ritual of barely rewriting a press release
- egberts1 4y agoIt is all about the tracking of cookies^H^H^H^H^H^H^Hemojis.
- egberts1 4y agono, really. Tracking by Telegram.
- egberts1 4y agoTo the downvoters, May karma bite you. DEFCON presentation https://xn--fda.fr/defcon/DEF%20CON%2030%20-%20Hadrien%20Barral%20-%20Emoji%20Shellcoding:%20%F0%9F%9B%A0%EF%B8%8F,%20%F0%9F%A7%8C,%20and%20%F0%9F%A4%AF%20-%20Presentation.pdf https://xn--fda.fr/defcon/DEF%20CON%2030%20-%20Hadrien%20Bar...
- davelondon 4y agoI'm really surprised that Apple let this through. Clearly the Apple emojis are copyright by Apple, and shouldn't be modified by third party apps. I get annoyed when web apps mess with emojis instead of leaving them as the OS default (e.g. Facebook Messenger).
- sschueller 4y agoClearly the clock that Apple put on iOS6 was copyrighted by the Swiss Railway but Apple didn't bother to check, their artist plantenly copied it. Only after later outrage they were forced to pay to license it [1] [1] https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/time-is-money-apple-pays-21m-for-clock-design-says-report/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/tech-industry/time-is-money-apple-...
- simonw 4y agoI've always found the copyright status of specific emoji designs to be really confusing. Under what basis can an individual or company use emoji images outside of text-based messsges? I frequently see ads that include large scaled up copies of Apple's emoji. Is that allowed? On TikTok I see people illustrate their videos with huge emoji stickers. What's the copyright situation there? People seem to treat Apple emoji like clip art. Can you do that? Does Apple offer any clarity anywhere on licensing terms?
- tokinonagare 4y agoI don't see what's confusing here: emoji visible "images" are implemented in fonts, and thus covered by the exact same laws that cover fonts already.
- d0mine 4y agoCan you copyright a font in US?