10 ms·
Sweet sanity: 75% of Americans say infringement fines should be under $100
- anigbrowl 15y agoThose darn social science majors and their worthless degrees. If only they would get real jobs! http://piracy.ssrc.org/the-copy-culture-survey-infringement-and-enforcement-in-the-us/ http://piracy.ssrc.org/the-copy-culture-survey-infringement-...
- ugh 15y ago?
- anigbrowl 15y agoI am lampooning a widespread bias that exists on HN against 'soft' sciences.
- nazgulnarsil 15y agobias implies people are unfairly disparaging the soft sciences. most of what I see seems pretty fair.
- dasil003 15y agomaybe you're biased?
- nazgulnarsil 15y agoI think you're just saying I'm biased because you're biased against people who disagree with your biases.
- dasil003 15y agohey, it was just a question.
- nazgulnarsil 15y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Response_bias http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Response_bias
- anigbrowl 15y agoYeah, I think you need to quantify a statement like that if you want me to take it seriously.
- pagekalisedown 15y agoIn other news, bank robbers say bank robberies should be punished by fines under $100.
- MaxGabriel 15y agoFirst, it does indicate a problem with the copyright system when such a large number of people (+50%, per Free Culture) are 'felons' under US law and liable for hundreds of thousands in damages. Second, wouldn't it be reasonable for the bank robbers to request that they're not sentenced to death for robbing banks? Can't they argue the punishment doesn't match the crime?
- masterzora 15y agoFirst, it does indicate a problem with the copyright system when such a large number of people (+50%, per Free Culture) are 'felons' under US law and liable for hundreds of thousands in damages. While I agree with your conclusions, the logic here is flawed. If everyone started shoplifting, for example, it wouldn't indicate a problem with the laws that people are now criminals. (Sidenote: Only a small number of people are felons on account of copyright. Under US law, to be a felon you have to have been convicted of a felony.)
- nextparadigms 15y agoCopyright infringement is not shoplifting.
- pyre 15y agoHe's arguing that "everyone is doing it" isn't proof that something is good.
- masterzora 15y agoGoddammit, I knew someone was going to trot that line out. You see, I never said copyright infringement was shoplifting, or related to shoplifting, in any way. Just because someone uses the words "copyright" and "shoplifting" in the same post doesn't mean that they are saying copyright infringement is shoplifting. In my above post shoplifting was only an example. My post makes just as much as sense if I replace shoplifting with murder and copyright infringement with cannabis possession. Or shoplifting with arson and copyright infringement with being left handed. The underlying logic I quoted is what was wrong, not the categorisation, so stop jerking your knee.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoEven better than the statistic quoted in the title, 48% of Americans don't believe any fine or other punishment should exist at all. The quoted statistic actually refers to 75% of the remaining 52%.
- chaz 15y agoThis is actually the larger issue -- that piracy isn't viewed as something that should be illegal. The fines are just a detail of applicable punishment, and exorbitantly high fines are a distraction.
- Egregore 15y agoIs in US possible a referendum on this matter?
- krschultz 15y agoUnfortunately the US federal government does not have a mechanism for a referendum. Some states do, but this would be a federal matter.
- joshAg 15y agopersonally, i think that anyone caught infringing should pay a fine equal to the cheapest retail price (over say, the past year) of the thing infringed(like for like, if you pirated the hd version of a movie, you have to buy the blu ray or hd dvd version. if you took a cam'ed version, you have to buy a movie ticket), iff they do not already own it. yeah, there's a whole bunch of issues that would have to be ironed out and yes, there's no proof you would have even bought whatever you infringed on in the first place, but i feel like its a much saner starting point than what we have now.
- PotatoEngineer 15y agoThat would encourage piracy. If you pirate a movie right when it comes out, that's $20 or so, but after a year, it gets closer to $10. So: pirate it now, pay next year's price in the worst case!
- joshAg 15y agono, past year based on the time of infringement, not time of conviction, so if you pirate it June 25, 2011, you pay the cheapest price between June 26th, 2010 and June 25th 2011.
- sliverstorm 15y agoEither way, you're still left with the choice: 1) Pay $20 to see movie 2) Pirate movie and maybe have to pay $20 sometime later. Maybe.
- wmf 15y agoWhile that is just plain common sense, there are still problems. If the fine is no great hardship and your chance of getting caught is less than 1%, it's rational to always infringe rather than pay. Raising the rate of enforcement would be hard since $100 doesn't cover the court costs and thus the industry would be losing money on every case — even ones they win.
- joshAg 15y agoso then why not go after the people producing the infringing copies instad of the people using/buying them? weren't the original copyright laws created to prevent book publishers from printing a book that they didn't have a copyright to print and then selling them? producing infringing content, be it physical or digital, is a completely separate matter from using infringing content.
- wmf 15y agoI was thinking of P2P file sharing, where regular people are the ones making the infringing copies. In P2P I think downloaders should have some responsibility since they request that copies be made. But it goes without saying that professional infringers should also be punished.
- joshAg 15y agoI would argue that distributing is a different issue from producing. In the p2P case you used, I see the producer as the person who prepares the data and/or originally seeds it. Everyone else is just a distributor. "In P2P I think downloaders should have some responsibility since they request that copies be made." why do you just limit it to P2P? Are people who buy pirated movies or pirated books guilty of the same crime?
- 18pfsmt 15y agoAre people who buy pirated movies or pirated books guilty of the same crime? I think it's important to remember that non-commercial distribution is a civil matter, _not_ criminal. That is no small distinction as it determines who will bare the cost of enforcing these rights. Criminal matters are funded by the tax payer.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- qjz 15y agoOnly 52 precent of American adults support punishment at all It seems the real story is that 48 percent support no penalty at all. Why the misleading (and inaccurate) headline?
- sophacles 15y agoBecause no penalty is functionally the same as a $0 fine, which is well under $100. (if there are nth-time offender bumps to the fine price, then they become different, but that is not studied here).
- div 15y agoNo penalty implies a moral / ethical stance that is different from even a $1 penalty. The underlying argument being that the majority of the population finds the current laws to be unjust not in measure, but on principle.
- duairc 15y agoOh come on, where are there so many copyright apologists here? Even if you're a capitalist the concept of intellectual property doesn't make any sense.
- dasil003 15y agoDon't be blinded by the abuse of copyright by megacorps. The idea that if someone works hard on something, they ought to have some commercial control over it is sound. Imagine you wrote a 1000-page novel. Isn't it reasonable for the government to grant you exclusive publishing rights for 14 years? It certainly seems like a sensible incentive for you as a creator. It's hard to make the case that you deserve nothing simply because copying bits is easy.
- thehotdon 15y agoIf you intend to make money from your novel, it's your responsibility to find a way to capitalize on it. Obvious approaches include collecting funding/reservations in advance or asking for donations after the fact. If you release a digital copy of your novel online, it's quite likely that at least a few people will copy it. However, there's also a pretty good chance it will attract more future customers.
- danssig 15y ago>or asking for donations after the fact. Right, so if you provide a service you can charge what the market will bear but if you provide an art that happens to be convertible to digital form you need to get on your knees with your hat outstretched and beg for your income. Do you people actually think about what you're saying?
- vidarh 15y agoSociety has no obligation to make your preferred business model profitable. You don't have a right to make profit, only to try. In this case copyright only exists as an explicit tradeoff by society in order to gain other benefits. If those benefits can be obtained cheaper and/or without the limits imposed by copyright through other means, or if society decides the tradeoff is not worth it, then tough.
- eli 15y agoErr, I wonder what percent of people think parking tickets should be under $5. Not sure that means it's a good policy.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoIf people are more annoyed by parking tickets than by people parked in the places where they prevent traffic and provoke accidents, then we should consider toning those down and/or making rules less strict. But I guess that if the problem really exists, people would be pro big parking ticket fines, because a minority who get those also annoys the whole population.
- Confusion 15y agoThe trouble is that the parking tickets may have caused the decline of the number of people parked in places where they prevent traffic or provoke accidents. In that case, the major annoyance is gone and the parking tickets is only the new minor annoyance, but now the biggest, that took it's place. Reversing the amount or height of parking tickets will not cause a decline in annoyance then.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoYou actually get a negative feedback loop there which would circle around an optimal parking ticket fee.
- yardie 15y agoDepends on the infraction. Overrun a meter? just pay the difference. Double parking on a one-lane or major artery? Hang them by the big toe.
- jemfinch 15y agoYou don't seem to understand that as long as enforcement isn't 100%, the cost of punishment must exceed the cost of compliance if it's going to deter violation. If the only cost of overrunning a meter were paying the amount of the overrun, any economically rational actor would simply never pay meters. If he doesn't get caught, he's parked for free; if he does get caught, he pays only what he otherwise would have. The civil penalty for laws like unpaid parking meters and illegal downloading of copyright works should be slightly greater than the original cost times the inverse enforcement rate. If we catch 1% of parking meter cheaters, they should pay at least a hundred times their overrun to ensure that it's economically rational to pay meters. Since we need only deter humans, not "economically rational actors", we can take risk aversion and incomplete knowledge into account and probably decrease that fine somewhat. The same principle that applies to parking meters applies to copyright infringement.
- brc 15y agoSurveying people on what fines anything should be is ridiculous. I once made the mistake of surveying people what software product prices should be. Surprise surprise the average was about $15, which I suspect was just as much as they could say without actually asking for free.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoAnd guess what? Apple proved that cheap and abundant software is really the way to go. People were right but the industry took a while to catch up.
- yardie 15y agoUnless I actually need it for business (in which case it makes me money) I wouldn't pay more than $15 for most applications or games. Photoshop, MS Office, AutoCAD, Maya, Quickbooks yes. Quicken, Toast, and games >$20, no.
- forensic 15y agodifference between corporate policy and government policy. Government policy is supposed to be democratic.
- christiangenco 15y agoLet's figure out what the fine should be with math! :D (10+0)/2*0.32 + (100+11)/2*0.43 + (1000+101)/2*0.14 + (5000 + 1001)/2 * 0.03 + (100000+5001)/2*0.01 + (250000+100001)/2*0.01 = $2467.56
- Natsu 15y agoYou're not properly representing the large fraction of people who think the fine should be zero. It's kind of confusing unless you read it carefully, but 49% of people do not support fines at all. That pie chart you're copying only represents the other 51% of the population. I mention that not to quibble with your formula, but because people seem to be seeing that chart and missing that part of the explanation.
- christiangenco 15y agoIn that case, it would be: 0.51 * ((10+0)/2*0.32 + (100+11)/2*0.43 + (1000+101)/2*0.14 + (5000 + 1001)/2 * 0.03 + (100000+5001)/2*0.01 + (250000+100001)/2*0.01) = $1,258.46
- Tsagadai 15y agoIn a real democracy the majority would actually make the laws. A fine of $100 sounds fair, it is still a punishment and would be much more acceptable to police heavily (and with less lawyers involved). I would be fine with automated fines of $100 being handed out to people downloading a file illegally and I think that would be a more effective deterrent than the present lawsuit madness that rules copyright.
- cynest 15y ago> I would be fine with automated fines of $100 being handed out to people downloading a file illegally and I think that would be a more effective deterrent than the present lawsuit madness that rules copyright. And then enough people challenge the fines to break the system. You still have to guarantee some form of trial.
- barrkel 15y agoThere's plenty of precedents for fines that become much more expensive if you challenge them in court, because being found guilty by a court indicates a higher degree of confidence in the finding.
- nitrogen 15y agoThat seems (in the US) to violate one's constitutional right to a trial. That is, exercising one's right to a trial should not increase the potential punishment, as doing so is a deterrent against exercising that fundamental right.
- lurchpop 15y agoHere's a place where tort reform could be applied sanely.