18 ms·
Animal melting pot created by climate change could lead to new disease outbreaks
- admissionsguy 4y agoI am disturbed and worried by the infectious disease alarmism that the 21st century's safetyism has metastasized into.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoAgreed, Corona has made us hyper sensitive to fears of illness. I hope this blows over. For example monkeypox does not have the potential to have even close to an impact like Corona to the population and health system. Simply because most people are not promiscuous. Fears that it will involve to something spreading significantly beyond sexual encounters are unfounded at present. Edit: Like I said: significantly. I know it can spread in other ways but it's not doing so at levels which are harmful to society as a whole. And I'm not saying it's just an LGBTIQ+ thing either, like most of the media are doing now. But it does spread mostly through sex right now which eliminates it as a risk for most of the population (being monogamous) and thus as the possibility of completely stopping society like Covid did (and i'm saying that as a person who is not monogamous) I'm not saying it's harmless and yes we have to fight it but it's not another covid. Illness is a risk and one that we can't ban completely. We just have to deal with it, and it's not worth completely throwing our lives around to have a minor effect on that risk.
- h0l0cube 4y ago> Monkeypox can spread to anyone through close, personal, often skin-to-skin contact, including: > - Direct contact with monkeypox rash, scabs, or body fluids from a person with monkeypox. > - Touching objects, fabrics (clothing, bedding, or towels), and surfaces that have been used by someone with monkeypox. > - Contact with respiratory secretions. https://www.cdc.gov/poxvirus/monkeypox/transmission.html https://www.cdc.gov/poxvirus/monkeypox/transmission.html
- fzfaa 4y agoAnd yet if you look at the number of cases separated by sexes, it paints a whole different picture.
- hh3k0 4y agoThat might be skewed due to testing practices, lots of places will only test you if you're a homosexual or bisexual male. African monkeypox cases, for example, are not concentrated among gay men. 60% of the affected are men and 40% are women: https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/african-monkeypox-cases-not-concentrated-among-gay-men-experts-say-2022-08-04/ https://www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/...
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI doubt that it's a testing thing. Very few cases are asymptomatic and the disease gives a really painful rash. It is very unlikely to pass unnoticed. I do agree that it's not just gay men. I'm sure it will/has already spread to swinger clubs etc. But I do think it is related to promiscuity in general, meaning most of the population will not be affected. The cases originating from non-sexual interaction are a really small minority. I think the men/women disparity is not really due to homosexuality but because due to societal views. A man who is promiscuous is viewed a as a 'cool go-getter'. A promiscuous woman is viewed as a 'slut' (Note: I don't agree with that!!). So it's just more common in men at first.
- fzfaa 4y ago>I think the men/women disparity is not really due to homosexuality but because due to societal views. A man who is promiscuous is viewed a as a 'cool go-getter'. A promiscuous woman is viewed as a 'slut' (Note: I don't agree with that!!). So it's just more common in men at first. So women are immune? This theory makes no sense.
- GekkePrutser 4y ago
- andai 4y agoBit of a nitpick, but it was not Corona which conducted a psychological operation against the global population, it was people.
- tzs 4y agoUnless promiscuity has gone way way up in recent years, it seems like something else might be going on. There have been previous outbreaks of monkeypox outside of Africa, including in the US about 20 years ago. They all pretty rapidly petered out. Why is this one different?
- GekkePrutser 4y agoBecause this one spreads more though sexual contact. It's already been confirmed this is not the same variant that made it out of Africa before.
- gallow1956 4y ago
- andrewclunn 4y agoSo long as multinational corporate media controls the messaging, you can expect the fear porn to effectively control the masses. Hitler's Mein Kampf should be taught in school (or perhaps The Myth of the Twentieth Century), as the means by which "the people" can be influenced and their perception of reality guided are still used today.
- rapind 4y agoAgreed. What most people talking about corporate media and "fear porn" (eyeballs for advertising) fail the mention though is that there's also a ton of independent "fear porn" (fear of government, fear or corporate media, etc.) produced under the guise of anti-corporate or anti-government or anti-random-thing. Meanwhile they're all getting paid by our advertising overlords. Getting rid of corporate media doesn't suddenly solve this problem. The alarmist torch will continue to burn bright because of advertising.
- f6v 4y agoI dunno man, I’m doing medical research and I think it’s pretty serious.
- trash3 4y ago
- hackerlight 4y agoIt appears as alarmism until the evolutionary dice roll lands on "Ebola-like severity with Covid-like infectiousness". Some prudent concern and hard thinking being applied to unpredictable tail risks isn't alarmism.
- pumpkinhead 4y agoThis isn't a far-fetched as you might think. This damned virus seems to mutate at an alarmingly fast rate.
- hackerlight 4y agoWhich happened with the Spanish Flu. There was a mutation that made it more deadly for young people. Such concerns also apply in the abstract to some unknown future virus which may work via a different mechanism to Covid and be capable of something far worse in terms of mortality*infectiousness.
- tresqotheq 4y ago>Some prudent concern and hard thinking being applied to unpredictable tail risks isn't alarmism. That is fine as long as same is applied when it does not suit the $uits.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI think if that happened you'd see people actually taking it seriously.
- hackerlight 4y agoWe definitely would be, but there's also pandemic preparedness which can be worked on now.
- throw827474737 4y agoYou were likely similarly disturbed by the climate alarmism in the 90s, 00s, 10s, still right now? There is something between panic mode and ignore it..
- admissionsguy 4y agoYep. It all started with the ozone hole alarmism.
- batch12 4y agoI remember acid rain coming before the ozone hole problems.
- huetius 4y agoHonest question: what is worrying to you? Is it the idea that infectious disease being used as the pretext to create an environment of fear and compliance, such some unwanted social transformation which is actually predicated on ulterior motives can proceed over objections? Is it the idea that people overestimate the degree of control people can actually exert over these diseases, leading to hubristic reactions? Do you object to being alarmed about infectious disease as such?
- Proven 4y ago
- the_third_wave 4y agoWhen will this torrent of panic porn related to 'climate' let off? Probably only when there is a more immediate, more tangible, more real threat to write about - war, famine, pestilence and death come to mind and all seem to be champing at the bit to be let free. It is not as if the climate has been static during the evolution of Homo Sapiens and still we made it through, through the Roman and Viking warm periods, through the little ice age, through the volcanic winters of Tambora and Krakatoa, through the several plague epidemics, through the decimation of the population due to several famines, through the most recent glaciation and through the massive changes caused by the industrial revolution and - lo and behold - through the more intense warm period of the 1930's which (together with certain agricultural practices) gave rise to the Dust Bowl in the USA. Earth will abide. Mankind will abide. The climate will keep changing as it has always done. Some areas will become more amenable to agriculture, others will become less so. The planet will become greener due to the increased carbon dioxide content of the atmosphere and later it will become more barren when the carbon dioxide content goes down again as it has done countless times already.
- jiggywiggy 4y agoTo me it feels like a big grasp for meaning for many of the climate activists. Without religion or kids giving a reason to live, mostly living for oneself is very depressive. (I know also people with kids do this) Having a goal higher than yourself, especially that is of the highest moral purpose is very liberating. It comes at a cost though, reason goes out of the window. This doesn't mean there aren't real concern, but yeah the world is not ending.
- spicymaki 4y agoI question your premises: Why do you think all climate activists do not practice religion? Why do you think fighting for the environment is not part of a moral purpose? Why do you think climate activists lack a sense of meaning?
- jiggywiggy 4y agoBecause we all do.
- pvaldes 4y agocould? nope... will. This is not a new and unexpected idea
- jimmySixDOF 4y agoAnd don't forget to add the potential risk for long dormant Anthrax and other virus strains to reemerge due to the thawing tundras (along with methane pockets). https://phys.org/news/2020-08-climate-expose-epidemics.html https://phys.org/news/2020-08-climate-expose-epidemics.html
- hunglee2 4y agoIf Covid-19 was a trial run we are in very big trouble. Already it seems that we've given up trying to control the spread of it, and I think the damage done to public trust over the past 2-3 years will make it extremely difficult to try non-pharmaceutical preventions again. We may end up just not reporting on it, and adopt the Trumpian method of pandemic management
- _abox 4y agoPersonally I think the Covid-19 was handled much better by the western world. Look at how China is doing right now. Their population has almost no exposure to the virus, meaning every outbreak is still significant like it was for us in the early days. We've moved beyond that where it's now a fact of life and no longer hampering us or saturating the health system. We have enough natural defenses along with the vaccines to give us adequate protection and we can live our lives again. We do control but it's on the health system impact, not the spread of the virus as such. And letting our immune system do the job it evolved over hundreds of thousands of years to do, supplemented by vaccines when necessary is really working out well for us. Meanwhile China is stuck in a groundhog day loop of zero-covid policy that is really harming their society. I think in the western world we've handled it really well, we've accepted the inevitable and dealt with it in a way that had the least impact on society. Our focus on balancing freedom with prevention has really worked out well. I do think a zero-covid policy could have worked but it would have been in February/March 2020 when total containment was still on the cards. In April/May when it spread to the entire world we were already past that point. At that point 'living with it with the least impact' became the only possible option. I'm not a Trump follower at all but in Europe we have essentially adopted the same policy as the US did without the ridiculous misinformation of injecting bleach etc :P
- pumpkinhead 4y agoThat COVID-19 is new in humans, is incredibly fast spreading, evades both vaccines and tests worries me. Now it just needs to pick up some genes that can cause it to be more deadly and we are in a lot more trouble. Did a postgrad degree in Mol Bio a while back, and I cannot think of any reason why this virus has/will not pick up genes that would increase its pathogenicity.
- hh3k0 4y ago> Did a postgrad degree in Mol Bio a while back, and I cannot think of any reason why this virus has/will not pick up genes that would increase its pathogenicity. Yeah. We've been lucky so far, comparatively speaking. It's insanity to insist on unmitigated rolling of the dice, though.
- f6v 4y ago> evades both vaccines How so? Vaccines generate a good T cell response.
- pumpkinhead 4y agoSomething very important that I didn't mention in my post - the virus mutates very quickly and each of the major variants seems to evade the vaccine of the last major variant. Here in Australia I will be going to get my 4th shot in a few weeks. I only get one 'flu shot a year though in comparison, and I got MMR decades ago.
- f6v 4y ago> each of the major variants seems to evade the vaccine of the last major variant I think that COVID vaccines aren’t variant-specific.
- dzink 4y agoThere are a number of problems merging at the same time and the world needs to focus on re-engineering itself for resilience to weather pattern changes instead of trying to make more people subscribe to a religious belief (religion polarizes instead of uniting towards a common goal). Temperature extremes, droughts, flooding, eruptions, earthquakes, animal diseases, are all problems when they exceed the parameters infrastructure and human settlements are designed for. We need to first and foremost broaden those parameters, build accordingly, and create fallback plans to enable humans to survive failure. We need efficient quick housing and water supply solutions. We need proper communication and evacuation channels in case of emergencies. That’s an engineering, logistical, and political problem that is very real. Sustainability of food and energy sources is also hugely important. The part about carbon credits is financial engineering that inverts the incentives and the political resolve of most economically lagging regions of the world (the most polluting ones) to do anything about the above - because it is political and religious. Religious as in focused on redistributing resources based on beliefs - akin to buying away your sin in Catholicism, and political when it is ignoring the fact that a lot of climate regulation in developed world simply outsources the dirty work to the undeveloped/developing world for the lower cost of production, thus not actually helping the planet. Or that politicians of both camps are heavily backed by the two dominant energy production camps and reliably fund whoever is backing them with regulation instead of building engineering solutions to mitigate the wider range of risks for people. The world needs low cost ways to move housing, redirect water, feed people, provide energy, find and plan for regions at risk, identify and contain outbreaks, all engineering and social problems, as soon as physically possible. The religious and political fights that are happening instead make all of that less possible and even impossible when it shouldn’t be. The short term thinking is leading to politicians pulling the rug on a still not completely outlined problem in their own favor, instead of preparing 8 billion people for resilience and education to re-architect us into a better position for survival in the face of change. People with the technical understanding of what is needed need to run for office and communicate what is needed to the world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pumpkinhead 4y ago
- goodpoint 4y agoReminder: the biggest source of new diseases is animal farming. Especially in countries that allow massive use of antibiotics. (like the US)
- pvaldes 4y ago> Reminder: the biggest source of new diseases is animal farming. Especially in countries that allow massive use of antibiotics. Reminder, this is obviously false. Animal trade, human travel and commerce, alien species, exotic pets, exotic wildfood ... are much, much, much worse. The only animal diseases that we had studied seriously and extensively are: 1) Human diseases 2) Diseases of pets. Canine and feline diseases 3) Diseases of human food. Poultry and cattle, and some fishes. We farm since 3000 years or so and have spent huge resources into researching each disease of cattle. Anything hidden in cattle that could affect human has affected us since 1000 years ago and is definitely not new. A farm would be the last place to look for a lot of new diseases.
- f6v 4y ago> the biggest source of new diseases is animal farming. There was a study(I don’t have a link handy) on microbiota in Neanderthal dental plaque. You’d be surprised, but pathogens existed even before farming.
- goodpoint 4y ago> You’d be surprised, but pathogens existed even before farming. Yet if you look at recent papers from microbiologists and virologists you'll find that the field experts are very concerned at the rapid evolution of antibiotic resistant pathogens linked to the widespread use of antibiotics in animal farming. There is a whole field of research on the topic, not just a paper or two, and they've been sounding the alarm for almost a decade. But of course, leave it to the HNers to handwave the whole problem away. EDIT: the FDA is "well aware" and still has some of the most lax regulations amongst developed countries since decades...
- nradov 4y ago
- drno123 4y agoOr, perhaps, we should stop doing gain of function research in the same way like we are nit doing human cloning research?
- pumpkinhead 4y agoGain of function research is very important in that you get to see how a pathogen behaves. From this you can formulate a plan/vaccines/treatment etc. It is too difficult to infer from what is already known. You just gotta be careful.
- vt85 4y ago
- trash3 4y ago