5 ms·
Logistics, How Did They Do It, Part III: On the Move
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- loufe 4y agoThis has been one of my favourite of his series. I've been thinking about making a game with some of my friends to model the complexity of moving an army around.
- h2odragon 4y agounits pushed too hard take a few days of, or go ravage the countryside, or decide to assisnate the general... like Rimworld but the units you're trying to control hate you a lot more and are willing to do something about it. Let the user decimate units for indiscipline and stuff too. or hang cheating officers to win troop loyalty. Could be a real favorite of sadists and masochist.
- watwut 4y agoHow would you deal with foraging amd looting in that game? Based on the previous parts, army can not survive without looting surrounding area every few days or without extorting them for food (and valuables).
- shakezula 4y agothe first two parts of this blog post series absolutely blew my mind and changed how I think about an army in the real world. Can't wait to read this post.
- ReactiveJelly 4y agoI'm gonna go back and read the first part after finding out this is the "Dothraki Horde" blogger. Loved that one.
- 7373737373 4y agoI'd love to read something similar about how taxation and the management and securement of (moving or fixed) gold/money reserves worked back then in practice.
- shakezula 4y agoAgreed. The author makes a few comments in the second part of the series about how ships of gold were the main way to ferry money around and how if that went wrong it had sweeping consequences, too. Would be a really interesting series fro this author.
- cwillu 4y agoI believe his fall of rome series has more on this; specifically about how there are multiple stable attractors in the economic capacity space. There's also the series on the defense of cities, the series on bread and the one on clothing. Oh, and the series on steel production. You know what? Just read everything he's written.
- danielheath 4y agoRecommend Scott’s “Against The Grain” for that! Chapter four specifically.
- 78124781 4y agoAmazing work from Bret as usual, but very sad that this kind of popular/actually useful history is completely unrewarded in academia. This is far more valuable than whatever top university press book most historians write.
- wjnc 4y agoIt’s entertainment. Academia shouldn’t be entertainment, at least that is my opinion. I’ve seen more than a few erstwhile respected professors turn into talking heads without much substance by sudden media fame. One of the better stories was the one that started bringing in his own newspaper clippings to the universities media department in order to rank higher on the yearly media ranking. After that he rented an apartment near Harvard and bought Harvard professors lunch to publish the photos. I think Bret rightfully treats it as a secondary career and that his patrons are very right to support him.
- trebbble 4y ago> It’s entertainment. Complete disagreement here. Informative writing may serve as entertainment, but if it's done well, that's not all it is. It helps people understand the world, which can provide all kinds of benefits beyond keeping them from being bored for a few minutes. In fact, this type of work is precisely how people learn almost everything, right up to grad school, which means it's the way the overwhelming majority of education is conducted. Most people going through that aren't doing it for entertainment. Hell, Spivak's Calculus is more on this level—presenting findings to non-experts—than it is an academic endeavor, and no one dismisses that as just being entertainment. It may not be valuable to people who are already experts in a field, so may not be properly "academic", but this categorization of acoup (and anything like this work) as simply entertainment is going way too far.
- jcranmer 4y agoBret actually has an entire thread on this in Twitter (https://twitter.com/BretDevereaux/status/1513255197597966341 https://twitter.com/BretDevereaux/status/1513255197597966341), responding to someone calling him "the orc logistics guy". The tl;dr is basically that part of an academic's job is to educate not just the professionals but also the lay public. By using fantasy and other pop culture works, he's introducing pretty important military history and theory concepts to those who wouldn't otherwise attempt to wade into it--and if they enjoy it, they might come back for some more pressing and serious can't-sugarcoat-this topics such as the implications of Russia's invasion of Ukraine. In general, I would say that academics all too commonly forget the need to engage with people outside of their narrow disciplines, and in doing so, you can cede the field to engaging writers who are way out of their depths and horribly wrong about what they are writing (e.g., Jared Diamond).
- jalino23 4y agothis is such a good find! I've been playing age of empires 4 and got really interested in the military before gunpowder
- antonymy 4y agoHave enjoyed this series a lot. His whole blog is great and you can easily spend hours reading through his lengthy, well-researched posts if you have an interest in premodern military history or topics that brush up against it (i.e. strategy video games, fantasy literature, etc).
- ju-st 4y agoAbsolutely, I was so proud of my Google skills for finding this blog three weeks ago, and now it's on top of Hackernews. The series about the decline of the Roman empire is amazing.
- littlestymaar 4y agoFunny you've never seen it on HN before, his weekly post show up on the front page almost once a month in average for the past few years. (From here[1] I've counted 8 appearance in the front page in the past 5 months) [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=acoup.blog https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=acoup.blog
- ttr2021 4y agoMind blown. So many variables to consider, so many options. Excellent read.
- mastax 4y ago> What will not work is overland external supply with more wagons; as discussed the animals eat food and so adding more wagons just slows the army down more and increases its food demands; that’s the tyranny of the wagon equation at work – the army cannot wagon its way out of a foraging pit. The "tyranny of the wagon equation" is so good.
- Heyso 4y agoInteresting, although having most stuff in miles is not helping me. I don't understand why he keep making "what if we double the size of the army" explorations. Isn't his 20k+ army already big enough ? And if it is just to say we double everything (food, etc), well I can do the maths myself. It is also repetitive.
- watwut 4y agoI think he is doubling it, because armies could be of that double or even bigger size. So, the goal is to show how it would affect everything.
- inglor_cz 4y agoThe fact that there seems to be a hard cap on size of an overland army in pre-railway times is important. After all, various empires of the ancient world had hugely different population sizes; and in modern times, say, 1900, all other being equal, an empire with more people could have sent a much larger army to conquer its neighbors. That is what we expect. But from Devereaux's studies on logistics, it seems that the premodern empires, after reaching a certain size, were "almost equal" when it came to military capability, and a lot of the (dis)advantages were on the quality side, such as good maneuvering and an ability to join two armies at precisely the same time. It surely explains why the Romans never managed to crush the Persians, even though the Roman empire had a lot more resources to draw from. The logistics of running a really massive campaign against the East were too daunting.
- Raziarazzi 4y agoBret relies on literature you might not think are important and has conducted similar study on his own. This is significantly more valuable than any top academic press book that most historians produce.
- testing654321 4y agounreal!