6 ms·
Satoshi has demonstrated inhuman levels of restraint. The only explanation is that he is dead. The others are that he is not human, or that it's a committee de
by sph 4y ago
Satoshi has demonstrated inhuman levels of restraint. The only explanation is that he is dead.
The others are that he is not human, or that it's a committee defying Hanlon's razor: i.e. not governed by stupidity like most human affairs, but malice. Both are equally improbable.
- LatteLazy 4y agoOr he\she\they\it just burnt the keys and forever gave up those early bitcoin when they were worth a few 100 or 1000...
- MrPatan 4y agoYes! Plus Faketoshi most likely waited until the person/people he knew (or strongly suspected) were Satoshi were dead to launch his scams. Less chance of a forum post saying "I'm not Craig Wright".
- tim333 4y agoIt would be rather funny if Satoshi did that. Though having faketoshi out there probably increases the deniability.
- baby 4y agoThe most likely explanation to me is that it was hal finney, who is dead now (presumably).
- tim333 4y agoI think most people in the space have a pretty good idea who it is, quite likely the guy who made the predecessor. The important thing is it's ambiguous and unproven which stops this kind of legal stuff.
- chaosite 4y agoOr that he has lost the private keys.
- sph 4y agoAlthough Bitcoin is resistant to the "charismatic leader" problem, his second coming would give him incredible fame, following but also personal danger. Yet I do not think any human would resist a moment in the spotlight, if not to renounce its child and its current direction.
- sweetbitter 4y agoI'm sure there are plenty of humans who don't care for fame/money/power. You just don't hear about them because... well... Though in this case Satoshi could have just kept a smaller number of coins not tied to him.
- chaosite 4y agoOf course. Various people have claimed to be Satoshi over the years, but failed to provide any sort of proof. Satoshi could either actually be one of those people, or realize that without proof he would be subject to the same fate.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoI think someone who believes that it will bring certain death could resist. It wouldn't surprise me if he destroyed his private keys to prevent himself from ever succumbing to the temptation. Those coins are of little value when using any of them would kick off a race to track you down and kidnap you with the intention of rubber-hosing the key out of you before going short on bitcoin. Having a secret in your head that can be converted into billions of dollars is not a good position to be in if you are not already a highly powerful individual with tons of people looking out for you.
- sph 4y agoHe must have lost the keys very early, when Bitcoin was just a fun experiment, and that would still be dubious: how did he imagine his creation would be so big as to prompt destroying his keys right there and then? The common human response at that idealistic stage would be greed. And even if he had the foresight, it's probably harder to just stay silent for 15 years. I imagine one would just come out, say they've lost all their BTC, that the original project was a failure but they have an even better idea now, and starting a new cryptocurrency with his name attached. Overnight billionaire once again.
- m12k 4y agoHe could also very well have lost his wallet, no?
- Ekaros 4y agoNot liked the direction and not actually seen the future. It took some time for those coins to be worth something.
- biglearner1day 4y agoI doubt that would be the case given his history and method of working
- lottin 4y agoHe was a Windows programmer if I'm not mistaken.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoSubtle. But seriously, wouldn't you grab the most off the shelf stuff for your throwaway persona to use?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lysergia 4y agoCommittee? Like as in Satoshi was a team of people? That’s one possibility. As a side note the Nakamoto Institute website archived all of Satoshi’s emails and ‘his’ IP is Californian. Make of that what you will. For all we know it could’ve been one of Musk’s side projects that caught on and went viral.
- invalidname 4y agoIf there's one person he's not it's Elon Musk. That guy can't shut up... We'd all know.
- rdbell 4y agoMusk’s specialty is selling vaporware and big promises. Satoshi released working software without prior announcements and did hardly anything to promote it. I don’t know how anyone really thinks Elon could be Satoshi.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoDude created a company that built a reusable rocket and you accuse him of selling vaporware.
- sph 4y agoWe're talking about someone with inhuman self-control, and GP is talking about someone that just can't keep his mouth shut and loves being in the spotlight. If the genesis block did contain the image of a trollface (or any other 2008-era meme) instead of "The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on Brink of Second Bailout for Banks", I could entertain this theory.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoIt's easy to retain self control when you already want for literally nothing.
- 4y ago
- aqme28 4y agoMy pet theory is that he's just one of the myriad of early developers who made hundreds of millions from crypto and keep relatively private. At that point he'd have nothing to gain and a lot to lose by revealing himself.
- im3w1l 4y agoSatoshi owns a huge hoard of bitcoin that has never moved. He has a lot to gain (and a lot to lose) by making use of that money.
- aqme28 4y agoIf you have maybe 300MM from early investments, and are a private person who doesn't want fame, then what does Satoshi's hoard actually buy you?
- squeaky-clean 4y agoHis unsold hoard is currently worth about 20 billion dollars.
- arlcode 4y agoAssuming he had some later money (in the Blockchain) that's maybe "just" a few dozen / hundred million worth. That's plenty money for one person without the liability and the publicity. You can live a life in pure luxury and fulfill all your material wishes. Maybe he lost the keys or threw away the machine after a year or two. There's nothing to be gained from going public in this case but a massive threat to your life.
- owens99 4y agoSelling this may ruin the story and crash the price. It would probably go against his values and mission. He could easily have other early wallets and have $B's. Most likely explanation though is that it was Hal Finney who passed shortly after Satoshi disappeared.
- 111111101101 4y ago> The only explanation is that he is dead. He might be dead but someone has control of his keys & logins as they used his accounts to defend Dorian Nakamoto. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/03/06/bitcoin-creator-returns-to-internet-to-say-i-am-not-dorian-nakamoto/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/03/06/bitcoin-...
- nostrademons 4y agoThat message was sent about 6 months before Hal Finney died. (Who, incidentally, lived a couple blocks away from Dorian Nakamoto.) Personally my money is that Satoshi Nakamoto = Hal Finney, and he's cryopreserved and likely to come back in a couple centuries to sit on top of a few quadrillion-dollar Bitcoin hoard.
- clay-dreidels 4y agoI donated to Dorian's BTC address back in 2014 when he was falsely accused. https://blockchain.info/address/1Dorian4RoXcnBv9hnQ4Y2C1an6NJ4UrjX https://blockchain.info/address/1Dorian4RoXcnBv9hnQ4Y2C1an6N... https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1ztjmg/andreas_im_fundraising_for_dorian_nakamoto/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1ztjmg/andreas_im_...
- theonlyklas 4y agoAnd to advertise NFTs on December 24, 2021. http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topics/bitcoin-open-source?commentId=2003008%3AComment%3A169634 http://p2pfoundation.ning.com/forum/topics/bitcoin-open-sour...
- sph 4y agoLooks like that account on that website has been hacked.
- narrator 4y agoSome people have alleged that Paul Leroux, who is sitting in prison right now, is Satoshi. That would explain why Satoshi hasn't moved any coins or sought fame.
- 14 4y agoThat would be highly interesting. Not like you can get easy access to the internet inside a prison so he would have to either convince a guard to bring him a phone to access it or possible use his lawyer. Anyone who visits they would likely record his conversation with the exception of his lawyer. But what good will the money do him, he isn't set to be out until he is like 72 years old and looking at him he is not in prime shape and may not even last that long. Maybe he could wait until enough is at stake like other countries adopting bitcoin as a currency and when the time is right find a way to put all his coins on the table causing a crash in price. I can't imagine what end game he would choose if he truly is the creator and how he has had so much will power he has had up until now to not move any of his coins. One thing is for sure I really do hope I come to HN one day and see the top story with 2000 plus points saying Satoshi's coins have just been moved.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoFor anyone interested, his bio is a fascinating read in itself. I will admit that for me he is likely the top contender.
- izzytcp 4y agoI invested a lot of time on his identity, not for anything just because I was bored and curious. I highly suspect it’s Adam Back and he currently sits in a tax haven, Malta.
- owens99 4y agoVery unlikely. Hal Finney is the more likely candidate. Adam is/was not a good programmer like Satoshi was. Satoshi was in favor of alt coins in Adam is notoriously against them. "Adam put enough effort into proclaiming that Bitcoin was based on the concept of HashCash that, if he was Satoshi, Satoshi would have given HashCash more credit." - Another HN User. Satoshi had a positive attitude and Adam is notoriously unpleasant. Hal is a great programmer, worked for Phil Zimmerman on PGP. Hal is the first person Satoshi contacted, first person to mine outside Satoshi (op sec). Hal was aware of all the prior works that failed, b-money, bit gold, hashcash, etc. Linguistic analysis of the Bitcoin whitepaper and Satoshi's forum posts most closely match Hal's writings. Hal lived in the same town for 10 years as did Dorian Satoshi Nakamoto. Hal died of ALS shortly after Satoshi disappeared (he knew it was coming and that he couldn't continue).