6 ms·
The conditions of the middle-class are actually too luxurious. Everybody in the world can't have a suburban lawn. What the middle-class (and the poor) don't ha
by pessimizer 4y ago
The conditions of the middle-class are actually too luxurious. Everybody in the world can't have a suburban lawn.
What the middle-class (and the poor) don't have is security. They live in a state of fear that the entire bottom will drop out of their lives if they get fired, or have a heart attack, or any of a million things. Supplying security to people is actually cheaper that what we do now, just as socialized health care is far cheaper than an ad hoc privatized patchwork.
We don't need more growth, we need more humanity.
edit: I'd trade most (though maybe not all) of the great meals I've ever had for the guarantee I'd never go hungry.
- newsclues 4y agoAnd yet the upper classes aren’t exactly leading the way.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> I'd trade most (though maybe not all) of the great meals I've ever had for the guarantee I'd never go hungry. I wouldn’t — and there’s been times I was quite hungry while homeless. Moreover, your fear doesn’t give you the right to impose that choice on me.
- pessimizer 4y ago> your fear doesn’t give you the right to impose that choice on me. That's entirely up for discussion. Civilization has imposed a lot of choices on you that you may not like.
- zmgsabst 4y agoIn the same sense any rights are “entirely up for discussion”. Is that your point? — that because we had slavery, slavery is “entirely up for discussion”?
- pessimizer 4y agoNo, in a different sense, because the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right. The rights you have were decided upon by people who aren't you, and imposed on you. I'm theoretically sympathetic to your wanting to opt out of public services, but it's too onerous to have to maintain lists of houses not to put out if they're on fire.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right You just said the right to not be a slave is a made-up right. > it's too onerous to have to maintain lists of houses not to put out if they're on fire So don’t? — but you’re losing me at the point you go from “I save money by not tracking exceptions” to “I have the right to make you participate because I want your money”.
- pessimizer 4y agoIf you consider obeying the law equivalent to slavery, then I absolutely am saying that. The law is other people's choices imposed upon you.
- zmgsabst 4y agoSure — as is slavery. Which is my point: you’re not differentiating between the two, while asserting that you don’t have the same rights in one case. Slavery was also the law.
- tremon 4y agoI'm less sympathetic: I wouldn't want to live next to a house that has opted out of sewage service.
- trashtester 4y ago> because the right to not have other people's choices imposed on you is a made-up right I agree with this statement. Actually, I consider this more of a principle than a right. Society should aim to minimize the degree to which it imposes the will of the government on the citizens, not fundamentally because freedom is an a priori right, but because it leads to a more peaceful society. A society where the citizens do not tolerate would be tyrants that want to excessively dictate how people live, tends to be (EDIT) more stable, innovative or economically competitive over time. Citizens of a freedom-loving society may not all understand this from first principles. Even if most believe they have such a right somewhat dogmatically, it may still have the same outcome. Dogmatism may come with the downside of seeing people with different opinions as evil, though, and may sometimes lead to needless conflict.
- imtringued 4y ago>Moreover, your fear doesn’t give you the right to impose that choice on me. You will have to explain how reducing growth dependence reduces agency. If anything, one could argue that there is no such thing as agency with growth dependence.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> You will have to explain how reducing growth dependence reduces agency. Your process of “reducing growth dependence” is fundamentally you stifling and regimenting growth. You don’t have a fundamental right to moderate my growth, against my wishes — but I do have a fundamental right to seek growth.
- sprucevoid 4y ago> You don’t have a fundamental right to moderate my growth, against my wishes — but I do have a fundamental right to seek growth. No, neither is a fundamental right. Because both growth and degrowth as a national policy (or global international policy) has immense consequences on the opportunities and outcomes in peoples lives. Both stifle and regiment the lives and actions of people in a myriad of ways (climate change is a massive externality for everyone!), so anti-stifling arguments have no traction. The only arguments that can do real work will have to concern policy consequences: which policy yields better life outcomes in terms of health, wellbeing, longevity and so on.
- jiriknesl 4y agoGrowth or degrowth are not national policies but individual ones. You cannot prevent someone with growth mindset from doing actions leading to growth. And at the same time, nobody is preventing people with degrowth mindset to practice what they preach.
- sprucevoid 4y ago> Growth or degrowth are not national policies but individual ones Degrowth as used in the OP article is about macro level policy. For example solar panel subsidies, taxing coal and investments in public transportation. Individual actions performed in the name of "growth mindset" (whatever that means) can like any other actions be stopped, and likely will be stopped if they cause harm to others.
- nickff 4y agoPeople seem to be willing to trade some level of security for some level of luxury. This is why people take out the largest mortgage they possibly can given their income, and spend money they don't have on cars (which they will take a long time to pay off). These revealed preferences are hard to deny, and it would be quite presumptuous to impose a different trade-off on a plurality/majority of the populace.
- juve1996 4y agoWhat choice do people have? It doesn't make sense to trade anything for security because that security is non-existent anyway. Losing your job & health benefits for much of the middle class would be a death sentence regardless if they bought a 35k car or a 10k beater.
- cudgy 4y ago25k saved (the difference in price between the cars) is more than most people have in savings. It would at least delay the fall of the guillotine long enough to find another job.
- pessimizer 4y agoOr it can be eaten up by one emergency room trip and three days of intensive care.
- jacquesm 4y agoQuite a few countries have solved this problem.
- AstralStorm 4y agoUnless you can't work, have to retrain, your work is dependent on not driving a beater, driving one of these is not banned due to environmental concerns... then it would delay nothing. Ultimately you will incur maintenance costs. The trade-off between non-existent luxury is most visible in Europe. We get small flats, mostly. The choice is between way too small inconvenient flat, inconvenient location that forces hours of commute or being already rich. The flats these days are much less luxurious than older post-war ones, and way smaller. Then again families were even twice as big and multigenerational, but flats were even 5 times bigger. The better furnishings these days slightly help but not enough. Then again, there tends to be public transport that works, except in USA. So maybe you could get away with a bicycle commute if your health allows it. Not quite yet in most cities though.
- steve76 4y ago
- TeeMassive 4y ago> The conditions of the middle-class are actually too luxurious. That's not for you to decide. The market can and does apply proper growth slowing pressure by itself. > Everybody in the world can't have a suburban lawn. That's just a different version of "think of the poor who can't eat". Countries and cultures aren't the same. Suburbia only exists due to improper distribution of business centers and housing bubbles. Overpopulated mega-cities don't have to exist with proper distribution of work and living space. Majority of countries are uninhabited and undeveloped. > What the middle-class (and the poor) don't have is security. Most developed countries are have welfare. Our poor live better and longer than kings from a century ago. > They live in a state of fear that the entire bottom will drop out of their lives if they get fired, or have a heart attack, or any of a million things. Firing is necessary to keep efficiency and competition. > Supplying security to people is actually cheaper that what we do now, just as socialized health care is far cheaper than an ad hoc privatized patchwork. Who will "supply security"? People who work and who are getting paid so they buy stuff. Who pays and produce their stuff? Other people who need to work. The demand for "security" will only keep increasing due to comfort. There's a reason Bill Clinton was elected on a platform to reform the welfare system. > We don't need more growth, we need more humanity. And flowers and unicorns too.
- DubiousPusher 4y ago> Most developed countries are have welfare. Our poor live better and longer than kings from a century ago. This is always a dubious comparison to me. Why are you poor people worried about the continued lack of atonomy you experience due to a lack of ownership in modern society? The state will give you penecilin. The duke of dorkingshire might have looked like he was doing well but he did have gout to contend with.
- WalterBright 4y agoFree market health care is far cheaper than socialized health care.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoI'm not sure there's an advanced "free market" bealthcare system in the world we can use to even make that comparison.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe free market produces goods and services at less cost for everything else, why would health care be any different?
- jacquesm 4y agoBecause health is quite literally priceless.
- WalterBright 4y agoSo is food. But every country that tried socialist food production reaped famine.
- jacquesm 4y agoYes, but food isn't magic and medicine to most people is. Here take this pill and boom life extension is on a different level than this is my carrot and even though I have 100's you can't have any. The first will lead to bankruptcy the second to riots.
- WalterBright 4y ago> Yes, but food isn't magic and medicine to most people is. The most bizarre argument I've encountered yet.
- impossiblefork 4y agoYes, you're completely right. However, I believe that their lack of security is due to their lack of power, and that their lack of power is due to their lack of wealth, their loans and that they do not own the companies in which they work. Consequently I see wealth and power as effectively the same and become moderately unhappy when I see policies that will in any way reduce the wealth or power of ordinary people. So, while I used the word 'conditions' I actually meant their state of subjugation.