9 ms·
Venetians fear ‘museum relic’ status as population drops below 50k
- superchroma 4y agoI wondered if you could reclaim some land near the city but off to one side and put some low office buildings and modern apartments or something, and get some natural traffic in the area there for the food and atmosphere. This is a city that was living and constantly renewed to the state of the art that is now halted and frozen in time. That's an expensive proposition to maintain, plus the environmental situation there is worsening[1] which will be very difficult to rectify. [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/venice-floods-pictures-tourists-wade-through-cafes-saint-marks-square-2021-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/venice-floods-pictures-touri...
- dfadsadsf 4y agoThey did and that place is called Mestre - right next to Venice on mainland. Lots of space and reasonable housing. I think the main problem with living in Venice is that the only jobs available are in services and those do not pay enough to compete in housing with tourists. So attracting remote workers and retirees is the only reasonable play. One note on population drop - you would expect it even without tourists. 50 years ago Italy was poor and families had many kids crammed into small apts. No one lives like that now - anything less than 1bdrm/kid is cruelty. Considering virtually no new housing in Venice in last 100 years (no land), drop in population is expected.
- amrocha 4y agoidk where you got the idea that having kids share a bedroom is cruelty
- superchroma 4y agoI think he's commenting on public perception rather than making factual assertions.
- nickff 4y agoThe newly reclaimed land would by definition not be part of the Historic City of Venice. The commune contains a significant amount of land on the Italian peninsula, and many people who work in the Historic City live there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venice#Local_and_regional_government https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venice#Local_and_regional_gove...
- seydor 4y agoBut they are sidekicks in an open air museum. If they wanted people to stay there, they would have made the city livable, but given the amount of tourism, lack of transportation and very unique conditions, why would someone stay in venice? Maybe it's possible to lure some digital nomads there to create a sense of community, it s probably an interesting place for that, but otherwise why would someone move to venice?
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>digital nomads there to create a sense of community How can they create a community if they're nomads? Communities are created over years or decades by people who stick around together (for the good times and for the bad times as well) to plant roots and build homes, lives, and businesses locally, sometimes for more than one generation, not by yuppie remote tech bros with MacBooks who come over to spend some money, have their fun, and once they're bored or life gets a bit unpleasant, leave.
- seydor 4y agodigital nomadism does have a culture though, and they tend to create hubs, even if those are revolving doors.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>they tend to create hubs Hubs and communities are two vey different things in my book. And major tech hubs with top paying jobs or a concentration of rich tech workers tend to score poorly at anything related to the sense of "community" as you have major gentrification issues from the giant wealth disparity and a caste system of those with tech jobs and money and those without. And the modern, compensation oriented tech workers, have rarely been great at forming any kind of community together, let alone with others, being more individualistic and preferring always to do things each their own way. Just ask them to unionize and see what happens. >even if those are revolving doors And "revolving door" communities are the worst. S-E Asia and Latin America are full of these gated communities of western remote workers and digital nomads and it kinda sucks, as everyone treats the place like a holiday amusement park. Not learning the local language, not integrating with the locals, not adapting to local laws, customs and traditions, they're just there to have their fun of being the top 1% earners there, consume, party, Tinder around, and once the novelty wears off, move on. That's the worst kind of community I can think of. For me, community, is what I see in small european villages/cities with small family businesses going back generations and everyone investing back into the local community and in the local environment for the future generations in the long run.
- adamsmith143 4y agoMost people don't want to live inside Disneyland or the Bellagio either.
- seydor 4y agoI don't know about the bellagio ...
- mysterydip 4y agoI was just there on a short holiday, and it was definitely swarming with tourists. The city itself was difficult to navigate if you just wanted to get from point A to B; finding the right bridges definitely added time. Nice to visit, but I couldn't imagine being a resident there.
- ZanyProgrammer 4y agoI had to look this up to verify, but the actual population of the city is about a quarter of a million, the 50k refers to the historic part of it.
- occamrazor 4y agoThe rest of the city is called Mestre. It’s a separate town on the mainland, which belongs to the sane administrative “city”. Nobody considers them as _the same_ city.
- MattGaiser 4y agoIsn't Italy in general facing massive demographic decline? Is this all that unique to Venice?
- potiuper 4y agoAs the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_in_Italy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_in_Italy shows some are better off; venice is unique: https://www.businessinsider.com/the-economic-history-of-venice-2012-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/the-economic-history-of-veni...
- TylerE 4y agoItaly itself is a rather recent concept, surprisingly. The modern country of Italy didn't form until 1866, after a rather long series of civil wars. Venice was it's own Republic until 1798, when it fell to Napoleon.
- butokai 4y agoThat makes the country of Italy rather recent (just like most European countries), not the concept of Italy. The concept of Italy is much older than the country (for example, “Italian” was used as a language in the Venetian republic, and by that it was meant Florentine)
- LtWorf 4y agoAnd by venice itself we forget to mention all the coast in jugoslavia
- jeffbee 4y agoIt is less known than I would have expected that Italy has a program under which you can move there if you have any kind of skills and are an EU or US citizen, and they give you a massive tax break of between 50% and 90%. I'm considering doing it myself, just to take a break from America. You can be self-employed and you get more tax breaks for having dependent children!
- notorandit 4y agoVenezia is not a real city where you can actually live. Poor infrastructure and troublesome environment. A world marvel, indeed. But still unfeasible for real life.
- crooked-v 4y agoPlenty of people "actually live" there. They're outnumbered by the tourists, but they exist.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> Poor infrastructure and troublesome environment. That would describe most remote area cities. Would you also say they’re not real cities where people actually live ?
- LatteLazy 4y agoAnd that fat a 1 bed apartment there will cost you millions to buy and millions more to maintain. This looks to me like ultra wealthy tourists who want to cosplay as locals objecting to tourists in spoiling their fun...
- thepasswordis 4y ago
- dougmwne 4y agoCome to any city in Europe sometime and be proven absolutely wrong. Venice is depopulating because it’s not a livable walkable city, not because it’s walkable.
- thepasswordis 4y agoAre you going to tell me that European cities don’t have suburbs? Is it just infinite French cafes and attractive people on bicycles as far as the eye can see? Because no it isn’t.
- dougmwne 4y agoClearly you don’t know what you are talking about. I live on the very edge of the city limits of a city of a half million. These are dense 5 story apartment blocks. The next street over are 40 brand new apartment block buildings going up, serious density you would only see in the city center of a US city. The very next street is farms and villages. There are no suburbs, at least none that would be recognizable in the US. There are a few single family home neighborhoods, but not that many and their yards tend to be small and the developments limited to 5 to 10 houses. I have a trolly line that goes right to our house and a bike path that will take me right down the to local cafe or the city center. Urbanization in the EU is absolutely nothing like the US. There are some countries that have more unchecked development than others, but absolutely nothing like the US. Many people have cars, but the car culture is nothing like the US either.
- whatatita 4y ago> The reality is that most people want to live in suburbs Maybe. But there's plenty of people (literally billions) that would prefer to live in a dense, walkabe city. The atmosphere, culture, and freedom that brings is beloved by many, including myself. Venice is having trouble because the city is ful of tourists, who don't buy "normal every-day things", don't use/need residential infrasturcture, and don't work in the city. Coupled with the thousands of AirBnB's that take revenue away from the city, the poorly developed local economic sectors, and the lack of modern residential infrastucture, you have a city in rapid decline.
- bookofjoe 4y agoMany years ago William Gibson called Paris a theme park.
- spoonjim 4y ago"Venice’s main island has lost more than 120,000 residents since the early 1950s, driven away by myriad issues but mainly a focus on mass tourism"... surely it's the tourists driving away the residents and not the fact that the city is fucking underwater
- LtWorf 4y agoThey have a plan to block the rising waters… balloons or something… they sank millions into that thing, probably for nothing.
- LtWorf 4y agoThere are huge amounts of tourists in many other cities in Italy, but not all of them get flooded with basically sewage water constantly.
- jimbob45 4y agoTourism is a double-edged sword because you take money but at the same time you expel all the activities and space for [the residents] I see no reason why cities don’t have caps on tourists. We have visas for entire nations, no reason not to have them on more granular levels as well.
- thfuran 4y agoWell, except for the fact that there's usually no border control at municipal boundaries and probably no legal mechanism by which the cities could change that.
- ggm 4y agoIt started decades ago. It was predicted decades ago. We're living a predictable outcome. It's in the second paragraph: since 1950. So 70 years of structural planning failure to manage this problem. Across the same interval of time Italy had multiple financial and political crises, the red brigades, the resurgence of the northern league, Mussolini's daughter becoming a political reality, Berlusconi and bunga-bunga.. And the amazing saga of the seawall and how it turned into yet another giant tax dodge crime related boondoggle. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/15/venice-controversial-barriers-prevent-flooding-for-second-time https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/15/venice-controv... Really, each decade there was a significant decision they could have made, and didn't: limit access and provide structural support to residents. They just decided not to decide. There were half-arsed attempts, but pretty much none of them worked. If they did rent controls and financial aide to locals at scale, they'd see a return of the venetian diaspora and probably make the problem worse. Here's one nobody wants: move a significant amount of the relocatable artwork to Mastre, and make people want to go there. The impact of tourism spreading more widely will boost the Mastre economy, and relieve pressure inside Venice proper. That would mean construction investment, in an economy which is notoriously corrupt especially in sectors like construction. Here's a second one which they already tried: tell the cruise ships to fuck off, and really make it happen. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/13/italy-bans-cruise-ships-from-venice-lagoon-after-unesco-threat https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/13/italy-bans-cru...
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoIt's like the resource curse except the resource is tourists.
- ggm 4y agoIf they sold cheap tickets at the railway station at 3am, and charged anyone else 100x the door cost they could limit the burden, alienate lots of middle class people, and create an industry for the unemployed touting the tickets. Local restauranteurs are already doing their part, charging EUR300 for speciality fish dishes and one cocktail. Everyone I know who has been to Venice enjoyed it somewhere between a bit, and immensely and none of them want to go back! Meanwhile, there is a woman's prison farm on Giudecca which I think is pretty amazing. It's like somebody took Rykers Island, and converted it to hipster organic food produce. Maybe NY state could learn a trick. The resource curse and the success overload failure are interesting problems to have. A lot of eco tourism has gone directly to gated entry. Yosemite has entry limits, so maybe we have to treat Venetians like Bison.
- labrador 4y agoI thought Venice was a museum city. You mean people actually live in a flooded city and get around by boat?
- donw 4y agoUnfounded fear. They'll be a littoral marine habit well before they become a museum.