10 ms·
IPv4 Address Auctions
- e63f67dd-065b 4y ago$50/ip is surprisingly cheap. 1,000 IPs will cost 50k, less than the cost for hiring a dev for half a year. An entire /16 block is still in the single digit millions. I don’t know what’s a price that I feel would actually be too high. Doubling it to $100 still seems reasonable, but 200? $1000? 10 years ago they were worth $10 each, I wonder how much they’re worth in another decade. For the more knowledgeable amongst us, how is this not an investment opportunity? What’s stopping a hedge fund from buying up a /12 block and renting it out?
- smileybarry 4y agoFor $50 I kinda wish I could buy my own (/32) IP. I realize it’s horrible for privacy, DDOS-ing, etc. but there’s something neat about owning a specific address. Last place I worked at had extensive subnets and memorized IPs so that might be why.
- Bluecobra 4y ago> What’s stopping a hedge fund from buying up a /12 block and renting it out? This is basically what Amazon does. I don’t see an easy way for a hedge fund to rent out the IP space unless they are a cloud provider. The problem is that to participate in BGP/the Internet, the smallest allocation that can advertised is a /24. You need to own the space you advertise before an ISP would allow this. The hedge fund would need to transfer the a minimum of a /24 to you and I guess you would have a contact to pay the hedge fund a monthly fee and give the space back when you’re done? Seems a bit messy to me.
- tomklein 4y agoActually, you can assign (not transfer) IP ranges and the one advertising it does not need to own it, but would need a Letter of Authorization (LoA) or similar.
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoWhat causes the restriction of /24, rather than being able to route individual addresses?
- casylum 4y agoRouting tables need to be limited in size in order for hardware to decide where to route packets fast enough. In the past hardware was more cpu and memory bound than the present.
- Dylan16807 4y agoBut also at present, dealing with millions of routes at the packet-switching level gets difficult. Especially because the speed of links has increased so much.
- ikiris 4y agoPhysics. Routers can only handle so many routes, so their operators set floor values for size of route they'll generally accept.
- netr0ute 4y agoThen it's time for operators to get with the times, because routers today don't have those same limitations as before.
- betaby 4y agoNothing to do with with operators. Again, physics, notably tcam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content-addressable_memory#Ternary_CAMs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Content-addressable_memory#Ter... very expensive.
- wmf 4y agoRecent routers can handle 1M routes while the Internet routing table currently has... 928K routes. Allowing people to disaggregate further would blow out routers. I'm not counting gold-plated routers because I see no reason to force ISPs to buy those.
- phil21 4y ago> I don’t see an easy way for a hedge fund to rent out the IP space unless they are a cloud provider. This is a solved problem these days. I personally know of IPXO[0] and can vouch for them as being legitimate and well ran. If you have an idle /20 laying around or whatever, I highly suggest getting it on their market and making some relatively easy money leasing out your blocks. The total interaction (short of initial setup) these days is clicking a few buttons in your favorite interface to publish ROA records every so often when an IP block sees churn. A hedge fund could hire a junior neteng to handle those requests, the very rare abuse complaint, and any hijacked routes you need to track down. Overall this is becoming a mature market with a number of players emerging for a public market. In private it's been going on for some time on a much more informal basis. [0] ipxo.com
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wmf 4y agoRIRs won't approve transfers that are purely speculative. Also, IP leasing seems to mostly be used by spammers or other bad actors who trash the reputation of any IPs they use.
- kloch 4y ago> What’s stopping a hedge fund from buying up a /12 block and renting it out? These marketplaces are open to all and operate with the knowledge and blessing of the RIR's. However, the recipient does still need to justify the allocation they are buying just like when RIR's were handing out addresses directly. While anyone with existing IP allocations are allowed to lease them out to anyone, even customers you are not directly providing connectivity to, IP's leased out to non-connected customers do not count towards justification for new allocations/transfers. This is different from Amazon or an ISP leasing IP's to their directly connected customers, which do qualify as justification towards further allocation/transfer justifications. So a transfer would be denied by the RIR unless the recipient claimed they were going to directly use the /12 to provide internet service to themselves or customers. If they lied on the RIR application that would constitute fraud, which is one of the very few reasons RIR's will actively go and revoke a registration for. RIR's are aware that businesses and use cases can change over time and they explicitly do not revoke for simply not needing addresses anymore, to encourage a liquid and efficient resale market. So the question comes down to whether the application was in good faith at the time it was made. RIR's know what's up and it would be very unlikely for a hedge fund to pull this off without actually investing significant capital and effort to deploy an operational network that would justify a /12. There have been proposals in ARIN to explicitly allow the leasing use case to count towards future justifications, or even for original allocations/transfers but these proposals have not gone anywhere.
- kortilla 4y ago> For the more knowledgeable amongst us, how is this not an investment opportunity? What’s stopping a hedge fund from buying up a /12 block and renting it out? The numbering authorities (APNIC, ARIN) will block the transfer if your justification for purchasing isn’t to actually use them yourself. It’s not an open market that anyone can purchase on.
- zokier 4y ago> 10 years ago they were worth $10 each, I wonder how much they’re worth in another decade. Maybe not that much more. At some point the demand for ipv4 addresses is going to wither as ipv6 adaptation grows. 10 years ago we were at <1% ipv6 adaptation, now we're at 40%. Give it another decade and I can imagine someone like google or apple sunsetting ipv4 support completely and after that ipv4 addresses aren't going to be worth much anymore.
- Bluecobra 4y agoI have been following the price history for some time now. It makes me really wish that I bought a subnet when it was $10 per IP as some kind of alternative investment. The ARIN maintenance fees seemed pretty high though.
- icedchai 4y agoI have a /24 I registered back in the 90's. There's no maintenance fee because it's a legacy block.
- greyface- 4y agoIIRC there's no way to use RPKI with legacy blocks; ARIN has been using this as a lever to get people to sign an LRSA. Has that been a problem for you? Do you expect it to become one?
- icedchai 4y agoIt hasn't been a problem so far. The majority of Internet routes still don't use RPKI. I'd sign an LRSA if I really need to, but until that time...
- lysergia 4y ago
- pkrumins 4y agoAs the Internet is moving to IPv6 (https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html https://www.google.com/intl/en/ipv6/statistics.html), soon these IPv4 addresses will be worthless.
- zeristor 4y agoWith that in mind the value of ipv4s would be worth tracking
- bombcar 4y agoThe way to make IPv6 take off is to make IPv4 addresses astronomically expensive.
- derefr 4y agoIt's kind of funny that doing so would have been easy years ago; but the easier it is to just transition to IPv6, the harder it is to drive up the price of IPv4, as decreasing supply of IPv4 at this point will just drive down demand. Yes, you're "making IPv6 take off" in some sense by doing so, but not in a positive-feedback loop; more in a negative feedback-loop, where the market ends up in a new equilibrium state where nobody is switching.
- octoberfranklin 4y agoWhich is exactly why IPv6 never should have required transitioning off of anything. There were IPng proposals in which zero-padding an IPv4 address gave you a valid, interroutable IPng address. One network is a strict superset of the other.
- bombcar 4y agoGreenfield redesign was a great idea, until the ipv4 fire NATion attacked ...
- kloch 4y ago> As the Internet is moving to IPv6 It's been 22 years since the first Global Unicast IPv6 allocations were made and progress has been very slow. This will not be complete until long after I am retired.
- Prolixium 4y agoI always figured that 4-digit and 5-digit ASNs were "cool" to a certain crowd but seeing them at the bottom of this auction page just seems like lunacy. Sure, IPv4 blocks have reputation but I've never heard of the equivalent for ASNs, especially ones that have a small number of digits. 32-bit ASNs are very easy to come by from all registries and there are lots of them. Most all BGP implementations have supported them for a long time so there shouldn't be a reachability issue. Am I missing something? Is this just plain vanity?
- mrweasel 4y ago> Sure, IPv4 blocks have reputation IPv4 blocks are actually useful. If you run a datacenter it makes sense that you'd try to get something bigger than a /24. Why you'd care about having a 4 digit ASN I don't understand... easier to remember?
- Sesse__ 4y agoBecause BGP doesn't support ASN numbers larger than 16 bits; the 32-bit support is a pretty nasty hack, and for a long time, lots of equipment would not support it.
- kloch 4y agoRunning BGP with 4-byte ASN's is well supported by all major vendors by now. The issue is policies that use ASN:XXXXX communities which is 2-byte:2-byte. There is an RFC to extend this to 4-byte for the ASN part but that is not widely supported yet. https://community.cisco.com/t5/routing/how-to-set-up-in-the-route-map-community-4-byte-asn/td-p/2979861 https://community.cisco.com/t5/routing/how-to-set-up-in-the-... https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc5668/ https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/rfc5668/ For small enterprises/end users (that might not define their own communities at all) this is usually not a problem but for larger networks or ISP's you end up with a compromise where you are truncating the 6-digit ASN or using a private ASN, neither of which are desirable. Arin let's you request a 2-byte ASN and if they have one in inventory (they usually do) you can get it.
- 4y ago
- derefr 4y agoAs the CTO of an API SaaS who sees a lot of promotion fraud on our service (i.e. bots attempting to sign up for thousands of free-tier accounts, because enough free-tier API-keys lashed together ≡ the capabilities of one paid-tier account), I see fraudulent sign-ups coming from IP addresses reallocated by these auction providers all the time. Addresses sold on IPXO (https://www.ipxo.com/ https://www.ipxo.com/) are seemingly especially bad for this. If there was a big list of all reallocatable / not-permanently-allocated IP ranges, I'd willingly — gleefully! — just dump it into Cloudflare as an IP blocklist for our website / registration flow. And there'd be zero fear in my mind of getting any false positives or user complaints by doing so. After all, none of these reallocatable ranges are ever purchased by residential/commercial broadband ISPs; those customers would much rather solve their IPv4 problems permanently, by doing either IPv6 enablement or CGNAT, than solve them for only the next 1024 customers, by buying a piddly /22 — especially at an unpredictable, un-budget-able price! And for registrations, any IP other than ISP IPs doesn't matter. IaaS IP? Bot. VPS IP? Bot. Colo IP? Bot. "Internal-use" IP? Bot. if someone's traffic isn't coming from an IP address owned by an ISP, then for purposes of registration, it's not good traffic, 99.999% of the time†. Those IPs are perfectly fine when it comes to actual requests — obviously, your application backend using our API is a "bot" in some sense — but your application backend shouldn't be going to our website and filling out a sign-up form. :) († The other 0.0001% are people using "workstation in the cloud" services. But people using those are used to being treated as second-class Internet citizens when trying to do web browsing from their cloud workstation; and they already know the solution is always to switch back to their real computer's web browser for anything requiring IP reputation.)
- leshenka 4y ago> solution is always to switch back to their real computer's web browser for anything requiring IP reputation … only to find out that you’re through no fault of your own blocked by region because we suddenly have a splinternet in the great year of 2022
- hnov 4y agoSo much for running a personal VPN in the cloud.
- rkagerer 4y agoWhere's the best place to buy IPv4 blocks that are "clean"? (Not likely to have been previously used for spambots etc)
- toast0 4y agoAPNIC, but you gotta be in the region and you can only get two /24s.
- throw0101a 4y agoNANOG had a panel on this a few months ago, "Buying and Selling IPv4 Addresses": * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FlTJEct9_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FlTJEct9_s