17 ms·
Wet/Dry Vacuum Buying Guide (2019)
- Already__Taken 4y agoAnything to attach the blowers to for use as a compressor? Shop vac is really useful on a boat and the blower can do 90% of the inflatables to top-off with a compressor. Bolting something on the blower for the last 10% would be awesome.
- gruberjl 4y agoMore than I'll ever need to know about vacuums. Next time my wife has a question I may be able to answer.
- theseanz 4y agoThis site might be able to help also: https://www.vacuumland.org https://www.vacuumland.org
- turdnagel 4y agoImagine a world where every product category had someone dedicated enough to build a site like this and keep it up to date. I'd specifically love one for cameras, lenses, and for the analog shooters out there, film.
- alexb_ 4y agoThat's what Reddit is for.
- Ajedi32 4y agoYeah, just about every major hobby subreddit has a wiki which is basically that.
- trumpablehump 4y agoThere exist countless sites for any product category in any language. With zero quality assurance or heart but filled with nothing but useless text and affiliate links. Affiliate programs have destroyed this kind of web and Google happily suggests these sites as search results.
- somehnguy 4y agoOnly continues to get worse too. I get ads for AI copywriting services on my social media all the time. Out of curiosity I joined one of the groups for one specific software - just filled with people attempting to do affiliate marketing spam. Not even tech savvy people, just suckers who are following some stupid get rich thing. It honestly just makes me sad.
- tantalor 4y agoIt's hard to trust a site with nothing but Amazon affiliate links.
- shanecleveland 4y agoI would say true for most affiliate sites that are just aggregating the available options. However, there are certainly sites, and perhaps this is one, where there is considerable credibility (actual interest and knowledge), research and effort that I have no problem with the owner being compensated for providing the resource. Even if just providing a more intuitive and deeper method to narrow down options to fit a narrower use case (which vac has the longest cord!), then there is added value.
- elephanlemon 4y agoI think Ken Rockwell probably qualifies for that. https://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/recommended-cameras.htm https://www.kenrockwell.com/tech/recommended-cameras.htm
- buildbot 4y agoI would strongly recommend against ken rockwell, much of his info is incorrect and he has…strong niche opinions, like RAW files being useless.
- vanillax 4y agoyea Ken Rockwell is the my pillow ceo of the photography world.
- wpietri 4y agoAnd this is such a good example of why single-person review sites are not the answer to the problem. The site is in theory most useful to people who don't know much about the topic. But to know that the site isn't credible, you need to know a fair bit. One solution is things like Consumer Reports and Wirecutter, where you have an institution that does some quality control. But I wonder if there's something in the middle, like a few good reviewers clubbing together and certifying one another, such that there's a recognizable brand that they share, one with meaningfully high standards.
- turdnagel 4y agoI've actually found some of Ken Rockwell's info on analog cameras (especially Leica & lenses) to be super helpful, but I can't speak to his digital knowledge. Also, his photography itself isn't great.
- dockd 4y agoThere's value but you can't just read one article. He contradicts himself. One post will rant about how digital means you don't need a tripod then another will be a glowing review of...a tripod.
- Avamander 4y agoGSMArena exists and I really like it. The one I personally miss the most is one for monitors. It's way too difficult to wade trough all the models and not get tricked.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoHave you seen https://www.rtings.com/ https://www.rtings.com/ ?
- ciupicri 4y agohttps://tftcentral.co.uk/ https://tftcentral.co.uk/ used to be pretty good, but they don't test too many models.
- lastofthemojito 4y agoI'd prefer such a decentralized world, but heck, if Amazon provided such an accurate, detailed, garbage-free view into product categories I might start shopping with Amazon again.
- trabant00 4y agoI would recommend (not necessarily for your categories) https://www.rtings.com/ https://www.rtings.com/ I use it mostly for monitors, mouse, keyboards, TVs. It does have amazon affiliate links but the test are pretty good (and standardized to allow comparisons) as far as I am concerned.
- buildbot 4y agoForums are awesome for this, for example. https://www.photrio.com/forum/home/ https://www.photrio.com/forum/home/
- randerson 4y agohttps://www.the-digital-picture.com/ https://www.the-digital-picture.com/ seems like a good one for cameras/lenses, and https://cameradecision.com/ https://cameradecision.com/ is useful for just comparing quantitative data.
- pjlegato 4y agoThis is pretty much the world we live in now. True aficionados who devote time to discovering, analyzing, and sharing actual quality -- not because they expect to make money from doing so, but simply because they like that category. Untold amounts of time have been spent on this exact thing over the past twenty years. The problem is discoverability. Though there are more sites like this than ever before, it's hard to find any of them. Google has been thoroughly conquered by content marketing at this point -- if you search for any product category, the first dozens of pages are 100% long form commercial advertising now. They all have much larger budgets and way better SEO skills than the average aficionado.
- thestepafter 4y agoCheck out Fred Miranda for photography reviews and discussions on equipment.
- jrussino 4y agoI check this every time I or someone in my family needs a new bicycle helmet: https://helmets.org/ https://helmets.org/
- andrewksl 4y agoI've always liked the lens reviews on https://www.opticallimits.com/reviews https://www.opticallimits.com/reviews
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Alton Industries makes all Stanley and most Porter-Cable vacs, as well as most Dewalt wet/dry vacuums! Understanding these relationships can be important for your vacuum choice. You might love well Dewalt manufacturers its drills, but that would not be a reason to purchase a large Dewalt vac, since it's not manufactured by them—Dewalt licensed their brand name for vacuums to Alton Industries. We have gone from branding that consumers revognise to branding spesifically being used to mislead and confuse customers. Hwat went wrong in the market?
- adamsmith143 4y agoWhat went wrong? What do you mean. The market is operating as intended, it just found yet another way to extract profit from consumers. This time by misleading them about the quality of a product by leveraging a known brand.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoI believe the OP means what went wrong for consumers.
- adamsmith143 4y agoThe market is a system for profit maximization system not consumer benefit.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoI think the short answer is that brands as a legitimate thing (a method by which a given maker-of-things could distinguish its products) were a relatively recent invention in human commerce, and were exploitable on a way that only even more recently was discovered. Essentially turns out the approach has a fatal flaw and that flaw has been exposed.
- nerdponx 4y agoI suspect that this flaw has been exploited for a long time, and I also would assert that brands have been "a thing" for a long time. A brand is just a systematic attempt by a business to develop name recognition among customers and potential customers.
- post_break 4y agoI bought the cheap black friday rigid from home depot for $49 and have been pleased with it. I have a koi pond and purchased an expensive pond vacuum however. If you live in an area prone to flooding, it's pretty incredible. Instead of shutting off when full, it has a discharge hose. It can run continuously while vacuuming. Meaning it fills up and then empties itself while running. Would be a godsend if you ever experience flooding inside your home. I hope I never have to use it that way.
- sgt 4y agoI need a new dust filter for my Hoover Max Extract Pressure Pro model 60. Can perhaps anyone on HN assist? It's urgent.
- crmd 4y agoThis youtube video is an excellent shootout of wet dry vac price/performance. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSN7PXwn1yU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSN7PXwn1yU Summary: SHOP VACS TESTED: Ridgid, Craftsman, Shop Vac, Bauer, DeWalt, Hart, and Stanley tested for horsepower, air speed, suction and noise level. Testing also included speed of vacuuming 5 gallons of water and 50 pounds of sand. Total water holding capacity also measured for each brand. Finally, each brand participated in a "grudge" match when the suction hoses were joined together.
- nolan879 4y agoProject Farm really does some very helpful consumer research videos, he is quite active in reading the video comments for suggestions too.
- twblalock 4y agoI wonder where he gets the money to buy all the stuff he reviews. It can't all be coming from Patreon. He also seems to live on, and maintain, a fairly large plot of farmland.
- Blackthorn 4y agoThe reviews have gotten more in-depth and of more expensive items as he's gotten more popular over the years, which has likely given him the ability to do more frequent and expensive reviews. On the farm part, there's a pretty funny video he has called (iirc) "Does Project Farm actually farm?"
- therealdrag0 4y ago2.5m subscribers is nothing to sneeze at if they have ads enabled.
- CapitalistCartr 4y agoHe has stepped up to approximately one per week. That's the point at which a popular Youtube channel can be a primary income.
- toss1 4y agoLooks like a very useful tool - all searches should be on actual characteristics like this! Of course, there's always more to add, and the first items I notice are that there seems to be nothing from Fein (makes great vacs, I've used one in my workshop for years), and that we can't sort by CFM, Lift, or Air Watts. Please keep up the good work!
- photochemsyn 4y agoNice search engine, but the 'country of origin' information is often lacking from product descriptions or is highly ambiguous ('Made in China' vs. 'Assembled in USA' for example - 'Made in USA' gets zero results). I'd guess almost all the parts are manufactured in China these days, even if some assembly is done in the USA.
- dj_mc_merlin 4y agoIt never ceases to amaze me just how much complexity and story there is even in most random subjects. Wall mountable vacs. Volume levels. Power cord length. A family business that implodes after being the biggest player in the vac manufacturing market. Hose diameter. Washable filters (which should be called rinseable). Motor stages. Tank capacity.
- symlinkk 4y agoSame, I bought a house recently and wanted to get the walls painted white. Turns out there are hundreds of different whites that are ever so slightly different from one another, various sheens that determine how reflective and glossy the paint is, various levels of durability, various schools of thought on what color goes where (i.e. one theory is glossy plain white on trim and doors, beige ish off white on walls, flat white on ceiling). I ended up getting everything in a single shade of white, just varying levels of glossy depending on if it’s trim or ceiling. And I am not really that happy with the outcome to be honest.
- samstave 4y agoYou'd be surprised at how well all shades of grey, from super light to actualy black, can make a space. I had a GF who decided to paint a major wall in her house as pure pitch black. I thought it was a horrid idea, until it was finished. Grey is the way. Its neutral to all of your bad interior design decisions.
- yboris 4y agoThe best design for a (home) vacuum I think is the Rainbow: it uses water to filter out all the dust and debris. Water is the best filter - once a dust particle touches it, it will not be blown out with the air. The downside is how expensive and heavy the vacuum is, along with the extra time it takes to set up (add water & later discard water).
- bombcar 4y agoIt looks good but an actual filtered vacuum performs better. There's something entirely satisfying about dumping out that filthy water afterwards, however, that you don't quite get with a bagged vacuum. "Bagless" vacuums like the popular Dyson are a joke compared to either.
- hatware 4y ago> "Bagless" vacuums like the popular Dyson are a joke compared to either. The Dyson weighs considerably less. Turns out there's tradeoffs in different engineering solutions.
- Arrath 4y agoMy parents have always been quite happy with their central vac. It solves the problem by just exhausting anything that evades the filter to the outside.
- 4wsn 4y agoI got a Makita shop vac a couple of years ago for home use. It's huge, loud, and heavy. But it sure is the best vacuum I've ever owned.
- jrm4 4y agoTo pull back the camera a bit: Hey, HN type people: How can we build a network of people and sites like this to replace the inferior process of adding "reddit" to the Google searches to actually find useful information?
- InvaderFizz 4y agoI guess the question is how do you prevent astroturfing and how do you fund it? Wirecutter being a prime example, they tend to exclude products they can't get an affiliate link for. So their incentives are not always aligned with yours.
- 90minuteAPI 4y agoI knew something had to be up with them. It’s bad when I come across a round-up or comparison that fails to even mention my top options, and that seems to be the norm over there.
- bfors 4y agoIt's amazing how much more useful this site is than anything I've found on google recently
- ARussell 4y agoKagi (a search engine you pay for) has a feature called Lenses. One of the default lenses is for "Discussions". It's been quite helpful for me, personally, so far.
- StrictDabbler 4y agoThat part's easy. The hard part is that, as soon as it's a trusted source, somebody shows up with sacks of money. That whole mattress review scandal with Sleepopolis and HonestMattressReviews shows exactly what happens when sites like this get big. So they need to stay small and secret. Unfortunate.
- lastofthemojito 4y agoI wish Google would add an advanced search parameter, maybe called "Unpolished discussion" for this reason (but to include forums, etc - results beyond just Reddit). I was looking at vacation destinations recently, and considering taking a toddler, and Google searches for things like "Destination A vs Destination B" or "Destination A with toddlers" led to so much SEO junk. Ads for shiny e-books with regurgitated information, text that was clearly robot-generated, etc. Then adding "reddit" to the end of the searches does get you to helpful discussion from everyday people. Sure, you might have to read between the lines ("oh, this person seems unwilling to pay more than Motel 6 rates", "oh, this person seems like they might be afraid of black people", etc). Sure, the info might be out of date, or otherwise in need of verification. But you can quickly accumulate some useful ideas that the shinier SEO-optimized junk sites just don't seem to provide.
- LeSaucy 4y agoUncanny timing, I literally just bought a Numatic George yesterday!
- twic 4y agoWhen i bought my own place, i hired a cleaner to do a deep clean before moving in. I asked her what vacuum cleaner to buy, and she recommended a Henry with no hesitation. They're big and heavy, but they'll suck up anything and they're indestructible. I also got a George; i'll mention for the benefit of our American readers that Henry is a dry vacuum, Charles is a wet/dry, and George is a wet/dry with a tank and pump for spraying carpet cleaner. There seem to be no Numatics in this database: http://wet-dry-vac.com/?manu=Numatic% http://wet-dry-vac.com/?manu=Numatic%
- DrewADesign 4y agoGreat info, but man, making the background a bluish slate grey without changing the default blue link color was a bad decision. Illegible on my devices. This is a much more obvious problem than most "well X is my favorite color and it it looks fine on my monitor" developer design decisions, but the subtler ones can be as or more consequential. Design is more than decoration and really knowing how it works takes a lot more learning and practice than many developers realize.
- twobitshifter 4y agoI bought a cheaper rigid vacuum from home depot a while back so i’m not in the market for another. When I compared the rigid vacuum to our expensive miele on a floor, the rigid picks up much more. It seems to be that household vacuums give priority to noise, light weight, maneuvering, etc. and that comes at the sacrifice of power.
- LeSaucy 4y agomodern cannister vaccums will also contain multiple filters on the bag, motor, and exhaust. The ridgid might have more suction, but that is only part of the engineering that goes into canister vacs.
- hairofadog 4y agoI bought a rigid vacuum cleaner a few years back in part because it had "Lifetime Warranty!" emblazoned on the front of the box, and it died after about six months of light use. When I checked the terms of the warranty, it said that it was only covered if it failed on the first or second use out of the box. https://www.ridgid.com/us/en/wet-dry-vac-warranty https://www.ridgid.com/us/en/wet-dry-vac-warranty > It is our experience that a product that fails prematurely due to a manufacturing defect in materials or workmanship, will generally do so very early in the products life cycle, often the first or second time the product is used. When returned for inspection, these products are generally found to still be in like new condition and show very little signs of use. It is uncommon for a product that was manufactured with a defect, to survive under normal use for any extended period of time. Products that are returned for warranty inspection after months or years of continuous reliable service are rarely found to be defective. The most common demand for service is the result of normal wear and tear issues, which may not be considered a defect in materials or workmanship. No warranty is fine, but I don't understand how they can put that badge on the box in good conscience. It wasn't that big a deal, but it rubbed me the wrong way and I'll never buy Rigid again.
- bornfreddy 4y agoIs there no mandatory warranty period required by law where you live? Genuinly curious.
- Syzygies 4y agoWow, I learned that I could have a wet vac drain. My yard is absurd clay. I've used my wet/dry vac, along with an electric pressure washer, to dig holes and remove tree roots (easier to cut what you can see). A drain would increase my work time, at the expense of thicker sludge when I'd have to empty the vac manually. What I really want is to move the mud slurry, not store it. I suppose I should build an open frame to replace the vacuum body, and just use the pump lid.
- 1MachineElf 4y agoI love my Ridgid wet/dry vac. They're the only brand I can find in stores that sell a "HEPA" filter+bag combo for trapping fine drywall dust. Lots of accessories available, including a unique water pump attachment that hooks up to a garden hose.
- 120photo 4y agoDid some research and Ridgid is king. Also seen that HF Bauer vacs are also a strong competitor. Do love that I can wash the filter on my Redgid and install those bags.
- SoftTalker 4y agoHarbor Freight stuff seems to be getting better and better. Of course they still sell a lot of junk, but in my experience their toolboxes, power tools, and hand tools are generally much better today than they were 10 years ago.
- walterbell 4y agoThe portable corded Dewalt (Alton) DXV04T has an optional HEPA filter, https://www.protoolreviews.com/dewalt-4-gallon-wet-dry-vac-review/ https://www.protoolreviews.com/dewalt-4-gallon-wet-dry-vac-r...
- thrdbndndn 4y agoFantastic stuff! This kind of website (filter search list) often looks intimidating at the first glance but they're surprisingly very easy to use, from my experience using Digi-key as a non-EE professional. I do have a question about shop-vac in general: Under what situation you (as your household) need one comparing to just having a normal "dry" vacuum? I never owned one so don't see its applications.
- stew-j 4y agoYou can remove the paper filter and clean up liquid spills--plumbing overflows, accidents in the kitchen, etc.
- ericd 4y agoGreat site, but in my experience, the challenge with this kind of thing is designing a (preferably automated) process to keep the data up to date without more work than keeping it running is worth to you. I’d be curious to know if the original author has found ways to automate this, or if he’s somehow maintained a high level of motivation (or if it’s been abandoned).
- Night_Thastus 4y agoEDIT: I misunderstood the purpose of the site, my bad. Ignore this.
- lock-the-spock 4y agoWe have a super expensive Miele bagless and a cheap Kärcher and I always end up using the Kärcher as I don't need to be afraid to break anything... I like Miele products (we have dishwasher stove and dryer and are just waiting for our Samsung washer to fail to buy a Miele) but the price always makes me afraid that any damage will cost me dearly...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- matthewowen 4y agoMiele don't produce wet/dry vacuums, AFAIK? Just "regular" style.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoOh, I thought this for wet OR dry vacuums, not ones that could do both.
- Stratoscope 4y agoActually I will reply to a couple of your points anyway, since I have your original message open on a separate device. I hope this may be helpful. :-) Regarding the thin non-HEPA filters that come with the packs of bags, if your Miele is anything like mine, you're supposed to use one of those and the HEPA filter. There is a vertical tray behind the bag compartment that snaps open where you can insert one of these pre-filters. (You may need to cut it to size.) The air exiting the bag goes through the pre-filter first and then the HEPA filter, so the HEPA filter clogs more slowly. On the cord retrieval system, my vacuum came with instructions to hold the plug while the cord is pulled in, and only let it go when the slack has been all taken up. This prevents the whipping you mentioned.
- 4y ago
- yuan43 4y agoI don't get it. It seems that some context is missing. Is this parody? Why is this the top story on HN? Why do I see SQL at the bottom of the highly-touted wet/dry search page? > SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT vacid) FROM vac ; http://wet-dry-vac.com http://wet-dry-vac.com
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stew-j 4y agoFrom the guide: > The original, and most iconic manufacturer of wet-dry vacuums, the privately held Shop-Vac Company, imploded and went out of business. A disappointing sign of the times, but luckily (so far) I've been able to find 3rd party replacement bags and supplies for my 3 Shop-Vacs online.
- walterbell 4y agoThey were resuscitated in 2021, https://www.inquirer.com/business/shop-vac-vacuum-williamsport-lowes-china-20210919.html https://www.inquirer.com/business/shop-vac-vacuum-williamspo... > The bank indeed sold Shop-Vac’s assets to a Chinese company. But the new owner, through its subsidiary GreatStar Tools USA, decided to keep Shop-Vac’s operations in Williamsport, led by new American managers. More than 200 of the old workers -- about half of the previous Pennsylvania workforce -- were retained or rehired this year ... Shop-Vac will continue to produce motor assemblies for all of its vacuums in Asia, and it will also continue to produce small Shop-Vacs -- under four gallons -- in China or in Vietnam to reduce tariff costs. Those smaller household vacuums sell at a lower profit margin, and they can still be produced in Asia at a lower cost.
- londons_explore 4y agoIt's notable for all users in the EU that the EU versions of these products are very different because there are power and noise limits on EU products. Products made before the power and noise limits came into force now sell for a lot of money, because they work better!
- hancholo 4y agoSince I already had a ryobi drill, I bought a ryobi battery powered vacuum that uses the same batteries. It's not going to be stronger than the ridgid or shopvacs but it definitely gets the job done for cleaning my car.
- tegiddrone 4y agoWhen I read the description on HEPA filters, it is alarming advice to me: > "[A HEPA Filter] is particularly useful for very fine dust that can be harmful, like asbestos or mold spores [...]" It is a misconception that you can purchase a vacuum with a HEPA filter and safely pick up materials like asbestos, lead dust, mold. If the seals in the vacuum are not sufficient then you risk throwing around the hazardous materials when you suck them up. The professional vacuums (such as some manufactured Pullman Holt, Nikro) are tested and certified for these purposes. Please do comprehensive research when dealing with hazardous materials. Consider professional abatement services. Edit: formatting, disclaimer, typos, precision
- frognumber 4y agoThis is an important disclaimer. I'll mention, though, that a HEPA filter on the vacuum, together with an N95 on your face, is often adequate, even if the vacuum doesn't have a properly sealed full HEPA system. The upside of a HEPA filter on the vacuum which most of the air passes through is that it will catch most (not 99+%) of the fine dust. If you reduce fine, harmful dust by 80% every time (assuming 80% of the air passes through the filter and 20% goes around it), after three cleanings, you'll have removed >99% of the fine dust. A lot of this depends on the level of hazard. There's a scale from pollen allergies to nuclear/BSL-4 waste. For the pollen end, I've found that combined half-measures usually do better than the uber-over-engineered stuff.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWhile good advice in general, these sort of products are designed for professionals with 40 hours of exposure a week to hazardous materials. Vacuuming up small quantities on an infrequent basis isn't going to create an elevated risk.
- calsy 4y agoSomething is clearly wrong if you are being exposed to hazardous materials 40 hours a week.
- 4y ago
- water8 4y agoWhatever you do get a cyclone filter
- corytheboyd 4y agoThe best vacuum I own is a shop vac I got for $10 in an estate sale. It gives no fucks about me, and I give no fucks about it. When it dies I'll go spend $10 again. Perfection
- walterbell 4y agoUK manufacturer Numatic's "Henry", https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/jul/24/how-henry-vacuum-cleaner-became-accidental-design-icon https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2021/jul/24/how-hen... > Modesty permeates Numatic. The campus is more Wernham Hogg than Silicon Valley; the firm never advertises Henry and retains no PR agency. Yet it has a turnover of almost £160m and has now made more than 14m Henry vacuums ... Duncan beams with pride as he tells me almost all of the 75 parts that make up the latest model could be used to repair “Number one”, as he calls the 1981 original; Henrys are made to last – and to be easily repaired – in the landfill age of rapid obsolescence. https://numatic.com https://numatic.com https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32414066 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32414066 > I'll mention for the benefit of our American readers that Henry is a dry vacuum, Charles is a wet/dry, and George is a wet/dry with a tank and pump for spraying carpet cleaner.
- spfzero 4y agoToo bad there are no reviews of Fein and Festool vacs. I've had a Fein for over 20 years, still going strong, can still get parts. Nice and quiet too. Love that thing.
- samstave 4y agohttps://www.importyeti.com/supplier/suzhou-alton-electrical-mechanical-industrial https://www.importyeti.com/supplier/suzhou-alton-electrical-...