15 ms·
Most Americans support using the popular vote to decide U.S. presidents, data
- hunglee2 4y agowe often talk about 'going back to first principles' but we're afraid to do it when it comes to politics. Lets have a try here - should we even choose leaders based on voting for them at all? Seems to me that popularity has zero correlation with competence
- sdf234f234fd 4y agoGeneral elections are largely a mechanism for resolving conflicts and not for finding competent leaders. Historically, people have fought to select leaders. Such a system puts the strongest and most brutal in power. Now we let people talk and then vote. It's a mechanism for resolving conflicts that has been extremely successful at its job. This is, btw, why freedom of speech is so important and why it's exactly whose we least want to hear, who must to be able to speak. We resolve conflicts with people we have conflicts with, not people we agree with. Talk about it or fight about it. Talking has led to, probably, the most peaceful period of human history.
- orzig 4y agoZero correlation is a strong claim. Would you actually predict that a randomly chosen American (whose opinion you distrust) would be all-around more competent than half our actual presidents? Not just the current or last one depending on your affiliation.
- rdl 4y agoI think sortition is superior to election for most offices, especially those which should be relatively proscribed in what they do, not requiring exceptional competence, etc. I'd almost certainly prefer a mechanically determined pool (say, all Walmart store general managers as of 2020 who are natural-born citizens, >35, not felons, etc), and then randomly pick the President from that pool. Maybe let people use negative voting to eliminate 10-50% of the pool first.
- orzig 4y agoI actually really love that idea. Thanks for expanding my mind about what is possible, maybe I can find a way to use it in human systems I do control
- dudul 4y agoA randomly chosen group of Americans, who would not take any campaign donation, who would be truly held accountable for their actions/decisions while in office would, according to me, make better decisions than half of the past presidents.
- adrian_b 4y agoThere have been a few US presidents that have been much better than it is likely for a randomly chosen American to be. Unfortunately, among recent US presidents, there have also been many who have been much worse than it can be expected for a randomly chosen American to be. I do not believe that it is possible to make with any certainty an estimate of which president selection system would have been superior, i.e. how the better and worse presidents would have been compensated in the 2 systems. So judging from the US historical experience, it is impossible to reject the system of a random selection of the president, like for jury members, as clearly inferior to a president voted by the people. Maybe a combined system would be better, with a set of presidential candidates chosen randomly from all citizens, one of which is elected by popular vote. This would exclude the people addicted to power who have progressed inside their party through dubious means, becoming the party candidates.
- tech2 4y agoI've occasionally toyed with the thought that political duty should be managed in a similar manner as jury duty. (One of) The problems with political representatives is that they _want_ to be politicians. Either as a means to an end, or as a mechanism to better serve themselves or others like them. On more rare occasions you find the occasional altruist. Since there's a selection bias going on, how can the current crop act as representatives of their populace when they aren't _like_ those they claim to represent?
- shlurpy 4y agoI think the jury thing is onto something... a small group rather then an individual can work wonders to cover for the failings and corruptability of the others.
- hunglee2 4y agoi think randomised leadership might well work just as well. Certainly we can say it would be more efficient - no campaigning, no pandering to the crowd, no making decisions just to be elected again. More I think on it, the better it sounds!
- choko 4y agoA better contrast would be whether or not you trust a random to do a better job than half the presidents elected after the social media explosion post 2000. Social media and the internet have changed politics to a very large degree.
- dudul 4y agoAs a long time supporter of sortition since i studied the functioning of the Athenian Republic, I am pleasantly surprised by the positive comments under this thread. It is an idea that is usually so quickly dismissed with "what if we pick a total idiot!?" - as if people optimizing for campaigning as opposed to governing couldn't end up being total idiots as well.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoThe alternative to choosing leaders by voting isn’t choosing them some other way – it’s not getting to choose at all.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI think its the leader part that is the problem, not the democratic vote. Why do we have one absolute ruler? You could make up reasons about deciding votes and stuff, but clearly it's a throwback to the good old days when one person killed anough people to become King.
- giantrobot 4y agoThe President is not meant to be a ruler. They are the executive, their job is to enact federal policies and enforce laws written by Congress. Over the past several decades Congress has abrogated their responsibilities which has increased the workload of the executive. But even with that increased power the President is not a ruler an is nominally subject to the same laws as anyone else.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI'm not saying they are literally a king, I'm saying there's no logical reason why we need to vote for one person, rather than say 3. They could work shifts and always have someone awake, while still being able to go on holiday. Similar applies to CEOs, why does it have to be one person representing the will of many.
- adrian_b 4y agoThe main principle of all political institutions of the Roman Republic, applied during several centuries, was that in any executive function 2 or more people must be elected and a single one can be accepted only temporarily, during emergencies like wars or other calamities. There are a lot of modern countries who claim to be republics and even USA has a "Republican" party, but all these modern uses of the word "republic" are wrong, because none of them uses this principle of filling all executive positions with multiple people, so that none of them will have all the power of those positions. The modern states which use the word "republic" justify their claim by having elected leaders, but that was not something specific to the Roman Republic. There were plenty of ancient states with elected leaders and with various other lesser public functions filled by elections. What distinguished the Roman Republic from all others was the requirement of electing multiple people for all positions, including for the supreme executive function, for which they had 2 consuls, and not 1 president.
- hef19898 4y agoSee, that is why I don't like first principle. It is just arrogant and ignores complete fields of study. In your example, hundreds of years of political studies and actual experience. Democracy is the owrst political system, except for all the others. It is also the only system that has the slightest chance of protecting civil rights, human rights and to considering a tad more than just the interesst of a powerful majority.
- adrian_b 4y agoDemocracy, means that the political power is not restricted to a subset of the citizens, but all citizens have equal political power. This principle does not specify anything about the mechanism that determines how certain executive or legislative positions are filled. Any such position could be filled for example based on the result of a majority voting by all citizens, or by representatives of all citizens, or based on a random choice between all citizens. These and also many other possible mechanisms are all equally democratic, because any citizen can fill those positions and all citizens have equal influence on who will fill the position.
- hunglee2 4y agogreat nuance, we need more of this understanding of democracy. It is much more (or less for that matter) than just electioneering
- canjobear 4y ago> Democracy, means that the political power is not restricted to a subset of the citizens, but all citizens have equal political power. On what basis do you claim it means that?
- hunglee2 4y ago> Democracy is the owrst political system, except for all the others not only objectively impossible to measure but there is no evidence for this. It's Churchillian cliche which has now become a thought-destroying mantra.
- shlurpy 4y agoGo one further, why do we need to have leaders at all? Assigning specific jobs to make decisions for specific domains makes sense, but trying to have one person be in charge of everything seems like it's been proven too big a task. Politicians are terrible because anyone with that much centralized power is going to be bad at any individual task.
- hunglee2 4y agoyeah...acephalous organisation. Theoretically possible but perhaps maybe in future practically possible through technology
- t-3 4y agoAs long as we're sticking with a representative system, I'd rather be more federated than less, but president is the least important federal position and it probably wouldn't change much if it became a popular vote. There's so many more important and actually impactful areas to reform though - the fixation on the presidential election feels like a distraction from the horrible mess of a fixed-size House that causes so many problems.
- skinnymuch 4y agoFixed sized house is super silly, but the 2 senators per state is far worse. DC not having proper representation is also appalling when that’s a founding principle. The founding fathers didn’t want the masses to be given proper voting. There were 2 million land owners. 7-9 million non land owners. So founding fathers like John Adams did not want a real democracy. They wanted their power. Their 2 senator decision was done without info about the future and well, they aren’t amazing people anyway.
- feet 4y agoRight, I'm not sure we should really take into consideration the opinions of people who thought black people weren't actually people and didn't want women to vote. Those are some pretty bad founding principles.
- benf76 4y agoThose people are all dead.
- feet 4y agoYes and they wrote the founding documents. Do you think those opinions weren't included? They definitely were and we had to remove some of them. The concept of the Federalist society is primarily originalist, is it not? They attempt to ascertain exactly what the founders meant when drafting the original documents and interpret our current law based on that. I'm saying we probably shouldn't do that.
- norwalkbear 4y agoThe same polls that showed trump losing 2016? Even Alzheimer's and ssri research is faked these days. I don't trust the expert class these days.
- orzig 4y agoCould you be more specific about who you don’t trust, and how you determine truth?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spywaregorilla 4y agoThe polls were very clear that 2016 could go either way. Clinton was favored but it was close. This is equivalent to saying "You're gonna roll the same die that just rolled a six?"
- norwalkbear 4y agoNo it isn't I'm suggesting that the expert class is using manipulated dice for gaming social dynamics to get money,power, and influence. Aka it's not about truth. I think the replication crisis is one and the 2016 election. Manny many polls absolutely said Trump has no chance. I remember everyone I knew truly being shocked Trump won.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI'm not sure anyone was saying "literally no chance" in regards to the data rather than "odds are very low" — even with low odds there's always a chance. Of course people were shocked; the odds were low! If the odds were always right no one would care about sports.
- 4y ago
- Overtonwindow 4y agoIf you’re running for president and you have a limited money, it’s best to focus on the major population centers in your bases. Forget the rest of the country. If all you’re going for is raw numbers then it becomes a system that can be manipulated, which will leave half the country completely ignored.
- frosted-flakes 4y agoIs that true though? You don't need to visit a place to appeal to voters there.
- pauldenton 4y agoWell presidents typically do speeches and rallies in person
- sokoloff 4y agoMy concern is that if I don't trust the vote counting mechanisms in <pick a state that isn't mine>, I can at least take comfort that the worst-case outcome is that the citizens of that state do not get their votes accurately counted, but that the damage is limited to those (fixed amount of) votes being cast not in accordance with those citizens. If we define the amount of election discrepancy as being the difference between the election totals and the count of actual ballots properly cast by legally eligible voters, an electoral college system confines discrepancies to within the given state. Illinois voters might have their votes improperly represented, but that's of much less concern to Arizona voters than if any election discrepancy not only misrepresented voters' wishes in Illinois but could manufacture additional voting power to that discrepancy.
- gadflyinyoureye 4y agoThe majority of Americans are morons who would vote for anything they want without regard for cost. Look at California's ballot initiatives. Fact of the matter is that the president and senate should not be elected by the masses. The masses need to vote for local control up through their state legislature. After that, the States should vote for their representatives: the senate and the president. At the same time some small group of self-starters should act as citizen journalists to actually keep these people accountable. For too long the powers that be have the media running cover for them. New organizations and individuals on YouTube and other media sites are showing how corrupt the government is. We need to take them seriously, still confirming their validity. Finally, reform the US House so that it has the appropriate size for equal population representation. California needs more seats in the House. So do other States.
- mdorazio 4y agoI agree except for the journalism part. The last decade has shown that even when faced with proof of corruption, a large percentage of people will happily rationalize away bad things to maintain support of their favored party/representative. I think a better alternative would be publicly funded campaigns + term limits.
- throwayyy479087 4y agoAs a Republican i support this. I think that being required to broadly appeal to voters in a all states instead of focusing on winning tons of low population, overrepresented rural states would bring a bit of sanity.
- idontknowifican 4y agoi wish discourse allowed us to feel safe sharing our political views with eachother
- Izkata 4y agoThe result would be the opposite, due to how lopsided the urban/rural divide is in the US. All politicians would have to care about are a handful of large cities, ignoring the rest of the states.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- shlurpy 4y agoThe better solution would be something like separate elected offices for different interests, with representation based on how much an area is affected by that legislation, instead of a single position for everything.
- timemct 4y agoOne of the troubles with this argument is that it fundamentally assumes that people who live in cities don't care about people who live in rural areas. People are capable of having empathy and understanding of people who are not like themselves. We don't need to Other/make outsiders out of fellow citizens who have different lifestyles than us.
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoQuestion: which non-US democracy has the best system? Bicameral vs unicameral, presidential vs prime-ministerial, etc -- what has gotten the best results?
- throw0101a 4y agoOne analysis seems to show constitutional monarchies rank pretty high (i.e., the head of state is mostly ceremonial): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Index (2020/1 seem to have been a bad batch of years, as a lot of scores seems to have dropped) See also: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-Dem_Institute https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-Dem_Institute
- Taikonerd 4y agoThat's a tricky question... like, if you think Germany (for example) is a really well-run country, is it because of their parliamentary system? Or is it because of German culture, and they would do equally well under a presidential system? I do think it's revealing that when the US helps a country set up a new government (for example, in Iraq), they set them up with a parliamentary system, and not an American-style presidential one. I once asked a politically-minded friend why that was, and he said it was because parliamentary systems are friendlier to small factions in countries with lots of different ethnic groups.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoGermany also had their new government set up by the US (and others): > The authors of the Basic Law sought to ensure that a potential dictator would never again be able to come to power in the country. Although some of the Basic Law is based on the Weimar Republic's constitution, the first article is a protection of the human dignity ("Menschenwürde") and human rights; they are core values protected by the Basic Law. The principles of democracy, republicanism, social responsibility, federalism and rule of law are key components of the Basic Law (Article 20). Articles 1 and 20 are protected by the so-called eternity clause ("Ewigkeitsklausel") Article 79 (3) that prohibits any sort of change or removal of the principles laid down in Articles 1 and 20.
- pie_flavor 4y agoSo what's this poll look like, in terms of majorities, if you adjust it for electoral college representation? Because if you don't do that, then what is meant to be implied by stating this stat, is assuming the conclusion.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThere's already a multi-state compact that will switch to this method if enough states endorse it. So you don't actually need a party with this as a policy, to be elected via the old system. Still somewhat similar issues to getting enough states on board, but not quite the same. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta...
- hgs3 4y agoYou know what’s a better idea? Sortition [1]. Seriously, just randomly select people willing to do the job, maybe 10 or 15 people and then vote for one amongst that group. If this sounds radical, then consider this is already how primary votes work today except the “group” is only well connected folks approved by the donor and political class. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition
- mtgx 4y ago
- jhbadger 4y agoAn obvious problem is how do you stop these randomly chosen people from being influenced from the same sort of well-connected folks? An obvious strategy for these folks would be to present themselves as "advisors" to the randomly chosen people and just be rulers in proxy.
- hgs3 4y agoThat’s no different than “special interest groups” and lobbyist today. It’s a separate issue that needs addressing.
- jmclnx 4y agoThe issue is not with the Electoral College, but with the artificial limit on the House of Representatives. The limit of 435 Reps skews the numbers. House of Representatives is suppose to be 1 Rep per a fixed number of people. But Congress put a hard limit of 435, that means Small States have more people per Rep than Large States. For example, Wyoming has 1 Rep for 480900 people. California has 1 rep per 736000 people. To be fair and agree with the original intent of the US Constitution, California should have about 82 Reps instead of 53. Texas for that matter should really have 52 Reps instead of 36 has it as now. The way it is now it has one rep per 700279 people. Fixing that limit should solve a lot of problems
- google234123 4y agoIs this really a big deal? There are just a few states with a few reps that have a slightly lower ratio than average. Seems like a nothing burger to me. Fixing this would solve 0 problems anyway from what I see. Please name a single issue that would be solved if there were, idk, 470 reps instead of 435?
- taylodl 4y agoYes. It really is a big deal. Each representative now represents differing amounts of people. If you're a resident of California or Texas your amount of representation is diminished. Conservatives love to point out that America isn't a democracy but is a Representative Republic - but even that is skewed because not everybody has equal amounts of representation. Your demand for a single issue that would be resolved if everybody had equal representation is simply a red herring.
- google234123 4y agoI don't worry about wether my representative has +/- 3% representation compared to some other random state. Again, there are just a few small states with small population that have increased representation. Overall, I bet adding more people to the house would actually make the political process much worse. If you actually cared about this, getting a better census estimate would be the first step since that's currently helping democrats quite a bit.
- benf76 4y agoMany in this thread are saying things like “if LA county has more population than 40 states why should we listen to those states?” At the surface level this makes sense. But dig deeper. It’s reciprocal- if you take that approach why should those states listen to you? If you throw out their interests wholesale, then you have no right to govern them and they should secede and make their own laws. This is how we got the senate and electoral college. Why should someone in Florida have a say over the people of Kenya, New Zealand or Idaho? In a sense people should self govern unless they come together in some kind of mutual pact where both sides get a benefit. Otherwise you are speaking of literal tyranny.
- emptyparadise 4y agoIf California and Idaho don't want to listen to each other, why even remain in the same country?
- divided 4y ago> Many in this thread are saying things like “if LA county has more population than 40 states why should we listen to those states?” I think this is a highly uncharitable rephrasing of what's being said. This sort of hyper-partisan lens I think can ruin one's ability to reason through what's actually being said. It's strawman-ing, in other words. What's _actually_ being said is "LA county's population should be listened to as much as Michigan state" (for example). No one is saying don't listen to 40 states. They're saying each person should have an equal say in how our nation is governed. Without that hyper-partisan lens, your argument sorta just looks silly and falls apart, doesn't it? I mean, "it's reciprocal" we value your state's population equally to our own. Those states should listen to us because we listen to them. No one is throwing out anyone's interests wholesale, so we do have a right to govern together and no one should secede? Being clear here, no one is talking about disenfranchising people of their representation. They're talking about equalizing representation. When your interests are overrepresented this might _feel_ like an attack on you, but it's the same way some subset of men felt women earning the right to vote lessened theirs or some subset of white people felt black people achieving the right to vote lessened their control. It's true in a way, but only in the sense that some portion of the population unjustly and unfairly held more power than they were entitled to. You don't want to look at your voting power that way, do you?
- yieldcrv 4y agoBut what does an Electoral College distribution of Americans support?
- tstrimple 4y ago> Most Americans ... > popular vote So you're telling me most people prefer the system which gives them some control over their government rather than the system which enshrines a minority party due to archaic and outdated laws. The majority of the population have had their will overridden in every single Republican presidential win since Reagan if we acknowledge the incumbent advantage especially after 9/11 for Bush Jr. The senate is also deeply flawed. Republican senators represent 41 million fewer voters than Democratic senators, yet they control half of the chamber and get to stymie everything done outside of budget reconciliation. The House is supposed to represent the people, but has the same bias (to a lessor degree) thanks to the frozen size of the House and rampant gerrymandering. For example, in Wisconsin Democrats won roughly half of the popular vote for house seats in 2020, but only gained 1/3rd of the representatives. Half the population votes Democrat, half votes Republican and Republicans get strong majorities in representation. If California house members had the same proportional representation as Wyoming house, we'd need an additional California house members so even our alleged "proportional representation" system is fundamentally broken. The majority are getting tired of the minority dictating how politics work in our country.
- sokoloff 4y ago> the system which enshrines a minority party due to archaic and outdated laws Both major parties are minority parties.
- myapp 4y ago"Most Americans"... I guess that means "the popular vote" wants "popular vote".
- jhkiehna 4y agoMost Americans can't even find the US on a map of the earth.
- NoblePublius 4y agoIt’s funny to me that proponents of this idea are generally Left leaning, because they believe in some kind of “demographic inevitability” of their success, while never once considering that the Right could adapt its messaging towards the center and win popular elections. Biden’s margin of victory over Trump was basically the same as Obama’s margin of victory over Romney adjusted for population growth.
- Ekaros 4y agoAnd do to the abysmal winner takes all used in most states, the might be change in voting habits brining either side to actually vote as their votes wouldn't be stolen by other side.
- culi 4y agoI wish the Popular Vote Interstate Compact didn't lose steam. It's currently at 195EV worth of states, 72% of the 270 needed to go into effect. If a few more states signed it into law it would trigger and all of those states would pledge all of their EVs to the winner of the popular vote Essentially using the Constitution's (anti-democratic) clauses that allow state officials to pledge their votes however they want regardless of vote outcomes in order to assert a more democratic and representative popular vote system
- homeland221 4y agoAgain another unverifiable and non audit-able "most Americans". I have heard so many "most American" votes/polls in my 50+ adult years life. You will be surprise how some of this poll conducted....there was once I recalled a polled "done" by a staffer in toilet cubicle several years back. It is like Bitcoin is actually worth 250K usd now. Just dont trust the current selling price and buy it now at cheap!
- divided 4y agoI think it’s very worthwhile to want to find a methodology behind this, but I think it’s naive to believe most Americans wouldn’t support this. The popular vote is 7-1 in the previous 8 elections for one party, although the electoral college went 5-3 during that time. Your statement implies this popular majority favors their side losing? They walk away from those 2 elections feeling this is how things should work? That’s a little silly of a belief.
- stuckinhell 4y agohttps://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/11/polling-catastrophe/616986/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/11/polling-ca... Yea the polling crisis shows polls are fake.