10 ms·
The strength of the strong force
- RandomWorker 4y agoThis baffles me, both gravity and electromagnetic forces drop off with increasing distance. Anyone familiar with the theoretical basis for this? I assume this has really weird consequences for unification of all forces. I believe when I was studying physics they said that strong and electromagnetic were very similar (at short distances).
- dilivion 4y agoTo understand the strong force coupling look up the concept of asymptotic freedom. This running of the coupling constant would in principle allow unification with the electroweak force in most theories e.g. supersymmetry - we just have not worked out the exact framework.
- pc128 4y agoSimply put, the biggest difference is that gluons, the interaction particles of the strong force can in contrast to photos, which mediate the electromagnetic force, interact with each other. That gives rise to a lot of strange phenomena, such as the long-distance behaviour of the strong force.
- cjfd 4y agoIt is mostly to do with color. If something is not a color singlet, gluons attach to it. Trying to separate the two quarks of a meson it is thought that a tube of gluons forms between them of which the energy is linear in the length of the tube. Since force is the derivative of energy, this leads to a constant force.
- Iolaum 4y agoIt's been more than a decade since I 've been out of High Energy Physics. The mediator of the strong force, the gluon, is a different beast compared to photons. It can directly interact with itself and create more of it. Add in the math that describe it and you get an emerging behavior vastly different from the one you get for photons.
- meltyness 4y agoI'm brushing up. One tidbid is that "coupling" has a specific non-intuitive meaning which differs from "action-reaction pair." Since a couple acts on the system, and the action need-not be always-centering, it produces a torque, but exerts no force. The article also mentions mass-growing at a distance, I wonder if - they really mean "with displacement, mediated by speed" - there's some interaction under which two gluons can enter a binary, uniform rotation about one-another The introduction to the full text identifies a subset of the theories under comparison, and hints at the techniques the theories deployed to arrive at their predictions, for example by "light-front quantized QCD" [1] [1] https://www.mdpi.com/2571-712X/5/2/15 https://www.mdpi.com/2571-712X/5/2/15
- adrian_b 4y agoThis work has provided improved experimental confirmation, but that the force remains constant with distance was assumed already many decades ago. The fact that the force between hadrons does not decrease with distance like the electromagnetic or gravitational forces explains why it is impossible to obtain free quarks. When you have a system of particles which is bound by electromagnetic forces, e.g. the electrons bound to a nucleus, and you come with an external force and you pull the electron away from the opposite charge, the force retaining the electron becomes weaker and weaker while the distance increases, until the electron becomes free when the work of the pulling force exceeds the binding energy. On the other hand, when you have a system of bound quarks, e.g. 3 quarks that compose a proton, and you come with an external force and you pull away one quark, the force remains constant while the distance increases, keeping the quark bound, until the work of the pulling force exceeds the energy of generation of a quark-antiquark pair. At that threshold, a quark-antiquark pair is generated and the antiquark sticks to the quark that is pulled away, while the quark sticks to the other 2 remaining quarks. Thus the effect of pulling one quark away is not the appearance of a free quark, but the appearance of a free quark-antiquark pair, which is named pion, a.k.a. pi meson, while the original proton may either transform into a neutron or remain a proton, depending on what kind of quark-antiquark pair happened to be generated. To prevent the existence of free quarks, it would be enough for the force to decrease very slowly with the distance, but a model where the force is actually constant is the simplest and the most elegant, so it is good that the experimental data match this. The reason why the interaction through electromagnetic or gravitational forces has a force decreasing with distance is that the force is the same in all directions and it is constant per solid angle, so the ratio of force per area decreases proportional to the area of the sphere centered on the source of the field. This can be visualized with the Faraday's lines of force as equidistant radii going from the center of the sphere, and the density of lines of force per area decreases for greater spheres. On the other hand the force between quarks can be visualized with the Faraday's lines of force not being towards all directions but being confined inside a tube that connects 2 quarks. When the distance between 2 quarks increases, the tube of lines of force becomes longer, but its cross-section remains constant, so the density of lines of force per area, i.e. the intensity of the force, remains constant. When the distance increases over the threshold for generating a quark-antiquark pair, the tube of lines of force breaks into 2 tubes, with the 2 new ends of tubes being terminated on the newly generated antiquark and quark. So visualizing a force that is constant with distance is not difficult and there are many materials that have the same behavior when they are extended over their elastic limit, i.e. their elongation increases continuously while the force is constant, until the material breaks.
- boxed 4y agoI believe you're confusing the strong with the weak force. Elecromagnetism does indeed join with the weak force and form electroweak at high energies. The strong force is a very different beast.
- pavelboyko 4y agoThe fundamental equations for QED (electromagnetic force) and QCD (strong force) are similar, but the solutions are radically different as gluons interact with themselves in a peculiar way. And we only know how to solve QCD equations at short distances where the force is small. Solving QCD at large distances is one of the unsolved "Millenium problems" [1]. [1] https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/yang%E2%80%93mills-and-mass-gap https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/yang%E2%80%93mi...
- raverbashing 4y ago> both gravity and electromagnetic forces drop off with increasing distance. Anyone familiar with the theoretical basis for this? Gauss's law (which is purely mathematical). Or basically, the area the force "sees" as it gets farther or closer.
- prof-dr-ir 4y agoYes it is quite surprising. There is actually a simple way to obtain a force between two objects that does not decrease with distance: simply connect them with an (idealized) string. And it is indeed not entirely inaccurate to say that the strong force produces some kind of quantum mechanical string between two quarks. Historically the study of exactly these strings for the strong force led to the idea of string theory. Only later was it realized that it can be useful as a theory of quantum gravity as well.
- TurboHaskal 4y agoWhat my boxing coach said.
- las_balas_tres 4y agoAt what distance does the strong force start to level off and become constant ?
- ginko 4y agoYeah, I was kinda hoping for a plot distance vs force.
- dguest 4y agoUnfortunately this is usually plotted as momentum vs coupling, which, if you wave your hands around the uncertainty principle enough, is sort of the reciprocal of the same thing. You can find a plot in the preprint: https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.01169 https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.01169
- LordHeini 4y agoFrom what i could gather at about 10^(−15) m. Roughly the size of a Hadron.
- lettergram 4y agoI do wonder if this has more to do with measuring, than reality. Many of times our inability to measure accurately or precisely enough causes failures in our understanding.
- isolli 4y agoIt reminds of the alternative to dark matter that is MOND, stating that the law of gravity behaves as 1/r at large distances (as opposed to 1/r2 at our scale) [0]. I personally like it because it seems less ad hoc than to posit the existence of invisible matter, and similar in my mind to the special relativity adjustment. (Do not take this endorsement too seriously, of course.) However: "The most serious problem facing Milgrom's law is that it cannot eliminate the need for dark matter in all astrophysical systems: galaxy clusters show a residual mass discrepancy even when analyzed using MOND. The fact that some form of unseen mass must exist in these systems detracts from the adequacy of MOND as a solution to the missing mass problem, although the amount of extra mass required is a fifth that of a Newtonian analysis, and there is no requirement that the missing mass be non-baryonic." [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Modified_Newtonian_dynamics
- entrep 4y agoAs gravity is a signed integer it overflows when it gets big enough and turns into a negative number.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoWhat is NaN+1?
- Drakim 4y agoNaN1
- bitcharmer 4y agohow would NaN apply to signed integers?
- withinboredom 4y agoThen you have a signed NaN and instead of eating them at your local indian food restaurant, you put it in a collection.
- orwin 4y agoIt is fascinating. I'm not imagining scifi application or anything, this discovery in itself is fascinating.
- dan_mctree 4y agoIf it's the maximum value and constant at all distances, wouldn't the strong force be dominated by all other objects everywhere else? Or does this force only apply to particles matched up together? If so, how does this matching occur?
- sethjr5rtfgh 4y agoThis statement is only for the hypothetical quarks alone in the universe. In practice, they shield each other.
- martincmartin 4y agoQuestion for physics types: in a hydrogen atom, each quark feels a force from the other two quarks. But if the force really is constant over all distances, would it not feel an equal, or even greater force, from all the other quarks in the entire universe? If there was any imbalance, even one more quark on one side of the Hydrogen atom than the other, wouldn't the quark be pulled toward that? Or does the strong force go back to zero at distances say larger than an atom?
- sethjr5rtfgh 4y agoNo. Because the farther away hydrogen's quarks force is shielded because they are closer to their quarks than to the close up hydrogen's quarks.
- martincmartin 4y agoBut that's my point. If the strength of the force is constant, independent of distance, then the farther away quarks contribute the same as the nearer quarks. In other words, distance doesn't matter, whether something's farther away or closer has no bearing on the strength of the force.
- sethjr5rtfgh 4y ago
- machina_ex_deus 4y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_confinement https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_confinement The charge of the strong force is called color, and outside particles like protons the total color charge seen from the outside is zero. It stays zero because of color confinement - at some point, it's less energetic to create color-anticolor pair instead of allowing color imbalance.
- femto 4y agoI had the same thought. Perhaps the bound quarks are never far enough apart for the strong force to be constant? My understanding is that if you do manage to pull two quarks apart the energy of separation is eventually enough to form two new quarks, thus pairing them up again. My question is whether this pair production happens before or after the strong force reaches the region where it is constant?
- dguest 4y agoLink to preprint: https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.01169 https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.01169
- jeroenvlek 4y agoSo we're on the road to creating "droplets"? (Dark Forest reference) Offtopic: Can we please bury the phrase "only time will tell" already?
- AndrewDucker 4y agoIt's possible that it will be dropped. Only time will tell.
- dvh 4y agoCould this be what causes weird galactic rotational curves?
- kloch 4y agoNo, the strong force does not have any effects at galactic scales. It is effectively neutralized at sub-atomic scales.
- amelius 4y agoNot being differentiable is going to break a lot of physics texts, I suppose (though the article was not specific about it).
- max51 4y ago>Figure-Eight on a Bight >Easy to untie after it has held a load. I completely disagree with that description, Out of every knot you can use for an anchor or your climbing harness, the figure eight is the most difficult to untie. If you ask any rock climbing why they use [insert figure-eight alternative], the reason is always because it's a pain to remove after it's been loaded.
- ascar 4y agoBelongs to this topic https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32408393 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32408393
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 4y agoWhat is the difference between a Force and Coupling? I think of force in terms of F=MA, but it feels like this "coupling" is something different.
- photochemsyn 4y agoWikipedia's discussion seems pretty good. Fundamentally, force calculations in classical physics tend to be replaced by perturbation calculations in quantum mechanics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coupling_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coupling_constant > "A coupling plays an important role in dynamics. For example, one often sets up hierarchies of approximation based on the importance of various coupling constants. In the motion of a large lump of magnetized iron, the magnetic forces may be more important than the gravitational forces because of the relative magnitudes of the coupling constants. However, in classical mechanics, one usually makes these decisions directly by comparing forces. Another important example of the central role played by coupling constants is that they are the expansion parameters for first-principle calculations based on perturbation theory, which is the main method of calculation in many branches of physics." Perturbation theory and calculations depend heavily on the coupling constant. If I recall correctly, in quantum electrodynamics (Feynman diagrams) the coupling constant is ~ 1/137. If you raise this number to higher powers (adding terms in the pertubation process) it quickly falls off towards zero, so you can get very accurate calculations using this approach in QED. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perturbation_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perturbation_theory With the strong force, this coupling constant is much larger and so the higher powers in the perturbative calculation are significant, meaning it's much harder to calculate accurately with QCD compared to QED. From the paper, this reference: * Improving our knowledge of αS is crucial, among other things, to reduce the theoretical “parametric” uncertainties in the calculations of all perturbative QCD (pQCD) processes whose cross sections or decay rates depend on powers of αS , as is the case for virtually all those measured at the LHC. * (2021) "The strong coupling constant: State of the art and the decade ahead" https://arxiv.org/pdf/2203.08271.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2203.08271.pdf
- QuadmasterXLII 4y agoFellow hackers who are good at physics but not formally educated in geopolitics or economics: do not succumb to Hacker News Gell-Mann Amnesia! Remember these comments when you're reading HN's response to the next inflation numbers or housing bill.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dataflow 4y agoI just can't wrap my head around how non-inverse-square-laws are supposed to work for forces. Why doesn't this (and MOND) violate a fundamental law? I thought the point of inverse square laws was that we have a point source, area increases with r^2, energy is radiated symmetrically in space, and thus energy at any given point has to drop off with 1/r^2 in order for total energy to remain constant. So how is a non inverse square law supposed to work? How can we not be violating something fundamental like conservation of energy, number of dimensions in space, spherical symmetry, causality, etc.?
- dotancohen 4y agoMaybe things in _our_ perceivable universe follow the inverse-square-law because they exist in the 3 dimensions familiar to us, as you succinctly explain. But maybe the Strong force propagates in less, or more, or different, dimensions? Does the Strong force propagate at C? Can we test that? It might give some hint.
- joe__f 4y agoIf you have an electric dipole with a positive and negative electric charge near to each other then the force drops off like 1/r^3, faster than 1/r^2. This result is for a single quark in isolation; in reality quarks come in pairs or triplets, and they each have different colour charges which cancel out the long distance behaviour of the strong force
- dataflow 4y ago> If you have an electric dipole [...] the force drops off like 1/r^3 > This result is for a single quark in isolation Sorry, I'm confused. Doesn't this confirm what I'm saying? For multiple particles I get how it could be different from 1/r^2 (though only less than 1/r^2, not more!), but as you say, this is about a single quark in isolation, which is neither multiple particles nor less than 1/r^2, so the problem is still there right? (The fact that quarks aren't ever found in isolation in practice seems irrelevant to me, unless the claim is "quarks absolutely cannot be found in isolation due to conservation of energy", which I've never read.) And what about something like MOND? I see the same problem, and it's about gravity!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago"They found that as distance increases between affected bodies, strong force coupling grows quickly before leveling off and becoming constant."
- raylad 4y agoWhat was missing from that article was how the strong force actually is responsible for mass. This blog post explains it fairly well: https://axelmaas.blogspot.com/2011/10/mass-from-strong-force.html https://axelmaas.blogspot.com/2011/10/mass-from-strong-force...