8 ms·
I'd rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices, and cripple a bunch of critical applications if I d
by kelnos 4y ago
I'd rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices, and cripple a bunch of critical applications if I decide I want to, y'know, actually do whatever I want with the hardware I own.
I'm not unsympathetic to Apple's difficulties and goals here (assuming this spam problem is actually the reason, though I'm skeptical that there aren't also self-serving reasons that would be sufficient for Apple), but I'm so tired of society's slide toward "security at any cost, and to hell with freedom" since the 9/11 attacks over 20 years ago.
(It's possible and likely that slide has been going on much longer, but I was a teenager in the 90s and not really aware of such things. But I think it's undeniable that the aftermath of 9/11 was a big turning point for the surveillance state and for average citizens being so scared of everything that they'd be willing to give up essential freedoms just to quell that fright.)
- rootusrootus 4y ago> I'd rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices, and cripple a bunch of critical applications if I decide I want to, y'know, actually do whatever I want with the hardware I own. Egads, no. The abuse heaped on me by Apple pales in comparison to the spam phone calls and emails I get. If I start getting spam via iMessage, I'll be an extremely unhappy camper. It already happens with text messages and that's bad enough.
- kelnos 4y agoSounds like other people in this thread already get a lot of iMessage spam, so I guess you've just been lucky? And it shows that this attestation junk doesn't actually curb the spam problem, so it's just an analogue of security theater. Anyhow, sure, if you want to give away your freedom to actually own your devices, just so you don't get spam... I guess that's your choice. I just don't want to be locked into a system where that's the only choice. Regardless, iPhones also receive SMSes. If it's impossible to spam over iMessage, they'll just use SMS. If it becomes impossible to spam over SMS, then presumably Apple can implement similar measures for iMessage that don't require us all to have hermetically-sealed, locked-down devices.
- eek2121 4y agoiMessage users don't get spam from other iMessage users. Also, iMessage lets you filter out 'known' and 'unknown' senders. Apple also will automatically flag/block certain messages if they are clearly spam.
- phinnaeus 4y ago> iMessage lets you filter out 'known' and 'unknown' senders Nitpick, that's not an iMessage feature, but at "Messages" feature -- the app. The filtering applies to both iMessage and SMS.
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Sounds like other people in this thread already get a lot of iMessage spam Same folks who didn't realize that all messages show up in the same color, the blue bubbles only happen when you send. They're getting SMS spam. > I just don't want to be locked into a system where that's the only choice. Who's locked in? I can and have switched back and forth between iPhone and Android devices. My contacts are sync'd between them, calendar, mail, all of it just works either way. Only reason I'm back on iPhone right now is because the churn (and by extension, TCO) is significantly lower. If the calculus changes on that, I'll jump ship again, no big deal.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> Who's locked in? I can and have switched back and forth between iPhone and Android devices. The cost to switch is not trivial for most of the world. And the cost of iPhones is high compared to the alternatives.
- fastball 4y ago> The cost to switch is not trivial for most of the world. Why not? > And the cost of iPhones is high compared to the alternatives. Given that the discussion is about switching from Apple being hard, this seems like the opposite of the point you're trying to make.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoApparently PRISM has not been a wake up call. What do people need ? Apple coming and killing their cat ?
- fsflover 4y agoEven knowingly using child labor wasn't enough [0] - or people just don' know about it, so spread the word please. This is how Apple actually care about children unlike what their PR says [1]. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25607386 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25607386 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28309202 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28309202
- gumby 4y ago> I'd rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices, and cripple a bunch of critical applications if I decide I want to, y'know, actually do whatever I want with the hardware I own. It’s really oppressive that Apple doesn’t let you install WhatsApp, Secret, Telegram, FB Messenger or any other communications app beyond their own. While it’s all sweetness and light that Google got into bed with the phone carriers to develop this new “standard” tied to a phone number subscription that brings along all the retrograde privacy nightmares of Big Telecom since the bell system broke up. The points you want to raise are crucial, but this is far from the hill to die on.
- kelnos 4y agoDefaults matter. I too have WhatsApp, Signal, Google Chat and a few others on my phone, but the fragmentation is annoying to deal with, and getting social groups (or even individuals) to move to a single consolidating messaging platform turns out to be much more difficult than I expected. If the default chat app is featureful and universally supported, people tend not to stray toward non-default alternatives unless they offer meaningful benefits. Sure, this ship has in many ways already sailed, since those alternative apps have a lot of mindshare and network effects. But if Apple added RCS to its default messaging app (or if Google were permitted to add iMessage support to its default messaging app), I would ditch everything else and just message everyone (including groups) using the default Android Messages app, relying on it to select the best non-SMS/non-MMS contact method for everyone, regardless of platform. Sure, it would take a little more work to move messaging groups over, but the cool thing is that I could just do it myself, and not wait for my friends to download yet another messaging app. This is the problem I ran into when I wanted to get friends off of WhatsApp; I had to convince people to install something else, and not everyone felt like doing it. But everyone already has the default messaging app installed, so that problem just goes away. > While it’s all sweetness and light that Google got into bed with the phone carriers to develop this new “standard” tied to a phone number subscription that brings along all the retrograde privacy nightmares of Big Telecom since the bell system broke up. Just wanted to call this out as FUD. RCS existed as a standard long before Google was involved (nearly a decade?). I too don't love that it's tied to a phone number, but options for doing this well are limited, and building a second, parallel identity system has its own issues. RCS at least can be federated, and it'd be possible to allow phone users to choose their own provider. And in practice, phone number portability means you aren't stuck with the crappy choice of ditching your "identity", or sticking with a phone provider you hate. Not sure how iMessage or WhatsApp or Google Chat or Signal is any better, though, as they're all controlled by a single company that requires you to use their identity system.
- sergiotapia 4y agoI hear you believe me. But in the past five years, I have received so much call spam that I just don't answer my phone anymore. Imagine that, the primary use of a phone and it's all cocked up. Imagine what happens to imessages if they leave it open. Blame the cretins that spam people.
- kelnos 4y agoSounds like iMessage spam is already a problem (if another poster in this thread is to be believed). Since I'm on Android, I'm stuck using SMS a lot, since most people I know have iPhones. I do get some SMS spam, but not a ton, and most of it is auto-flagged and I never see it. > Blame the cretins that spam people. SMS and voice call spam is actually a solved problem, but carriers have been dragging their feet implementing the solutions (and have lobbied the US government to give them more time). Killing spam does not require our devices to be locked down. Carriers deserve some blame here too. But I don't really care about blame, I care about outcomes. Blaming spammers isn't going to fix anything. Forcing carriers to implement the required technical measures to stamp out spam... that could actually work.
- midoridensha 4y agoBlaming spammers is like blaming mosquitoes. What's the point?
- mschuster91 4y ago> Forcing carriers to implement the required technical measures to stamp out spam... that could actually work. Another desperately needed measure is enabling law enforcement to actually fight spam at the root: follow the money. When the spammers can't monetize their spam, they won't have any incentive to spam and scam. Uncooperative countries (e.g. India, just look Mark Rober's Youtube series where he and a bunch of associates track down and prank scam call centers or Turkey which is the German equivalent) should be sanctioned until they are compliant. Letting spammers, scammers and hackers operate in a foreign country unimpeded should be considered an act of war. Forcing carriers or anyone to implement technological measures (remember the idea to charge people .5 cents to send out emails?) is a worthwhile effort but it's at the core a band-aid at best and the only thing it achieves is to marginally drive up the cost and complexity of service for everyone else while the scammers simply find workarounds.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices So use Android! I have friends with Android. We use WhatsApp abroad and SMS at home. The messages are green and I can't tapback. That's it!
- GekkePrutser 4y agoBut group chats don't work over SMS. That's a big deal-breaker IMO.
- worthless-trash 4y agoI'm pretty sure ive had group chat work over SMS in australia, much to my dismay.
- thayne 4y agoIt was probably MMS, not SMS. SMS does not support group chat, but MMS does.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> group chats don't work over SMS I have multiple group chats running with mixtures of iPhone and Android users.
- kelnos 4y agoYou're using MMS for those group chats, not SMS.
- GekkePrutser 4y agoYes indeed, and some networks here in Europe don't support MMS anymore.
- kelnos 4y agoThis thread is about a hypothetical situation where Apple allows iMessage on other platforms (such as Android), but only on platforms that can securely attest that they have not been modified. Yes, I use Android, but would like to also be able to interoperate with iMessage. But I don't want to be stuck in a (for now hypothetical) state where I have to choose between using iMessage and being able to do what I want with my phone. > We use WhatsApp abroad and SMS at home. The messages are green and I can't tapback. That's it! SMS has ordering, latency, and delivery issues. You also cannot send media over SMS, and MMS has size limits for media that were set decades ago. Any video you send over MMS will be recompressed to the point where it'll be unwatchable. SMS also does not support group chats. MMS does, but delivery and message ordering issues are even worse there, and group chats are inflexible; for example you can't add new people to an existing group chat, or remove existing people. I do use WhatsApp, grudgingly, for some people who refuse to switch to something else, but I'd like to reduce my reliance on things owned by Meta/Facebook.
- renewiltord 4y agoAnd I'd rather the opposite and the current situation offers us both that choice.
- tempsy 4y agoSMS spam is real.
- deadbunny 4y agoI've not had a single SMS/messaging spam message in the last decade. In the UK if that makes a difference, maybe we have effective laws around it? Not looked into it.
- marrs 4y agoSame here and I've used and shared the same number for at least 20 years. I had no idea SMS spam was an issue until I read this thread
- purpleblue 4y agoIn the last 6 months SMS spam has increased a lot for me. A lot of it are random messages like "I'm sorry but please don't message me again!" or "Hey, I really had a great time last night, let's make plans for next weekend!" that basically is reply-bait.
- rprospero 4y agoI’m also in the UK and received two SMS spam messages last month, which wasn’t particularly out of the ordinary. Both were low effort fishing attempts along the lines of “You have been sent a package that requires the payment of customs fees. Please provide your account information at http://customs.uk.gov.scam.example.horse” http://customs.uk.gov.scam.example.xn--horse-sw3b I probably get more of those now than the “we’ve heard that you’ve been in an auto accident that wasn’t your fault” robocalls.
- lokedhs 4y agoI'm in Singapore and when I read this I realised that it's been a long time since I received an SMS spam message. It must be at least 2 years. And even then they were quite rare (one ever few months maybe?). I wonder what different telcos does differently, because I have heard about some countries where you're getting flooder by these things.
- shmoe 4y agoYou don't think Google can blacklist apps?
- _-david-_ 4y agoYou could compile AOSP (and remove any blocks in it) yourself or get a ROM that doesn't block an app. You can't do that with iOS.
- shmoe 4y agoTrue, but we're talking single digits if not less than 1% of the Android population there, regardless of the ability. And if you add Google services you're right back where you started.
- kelnos 4y agoSure, but I'm talking about simply having the capability. If Google started getting ridiculous, regularly censoring apps, deleting data off people's phones, stuff like that, I can easily believe that there'd be a push to make installing an alternative ROM or OS a simple thing to do. Regardless, the option is there. I think there's a ton of value in that, even if the vast majority of users don't avail themselves of it. With iOS, you live with what Apple lets you do, and that's that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- inkyoto 4y ago> I'd rather live in a world with spam […] That is a personal choice, and I choose to not have spam on my phone. Several months ago I was subjected to a floodgate of good ol' fashioned SMS spam that lasted several weeks. There was no way to stop the spam because the phone was receiving it through the legacy SMS channel coming specifically from Android devices infected with Flubot; the bulk of spam now comes from unpatched Android devices because hardware vendors stop releasing security updates after a short cycle, or due to loose default app permissions set on the device. I ended up creating a support ticket with my mobile telco and soon I received the following reply from a human being: What you have encountered is, as you may have guessed, not a legitimate SMS notification. This particular message is designed to entice you to click on a link, and doing so would potentially expose your device to malicious software. This malicious software is trying to target Android devices, so, if you are an Android user, you should take particular care with such messages. Note that you may receive this message even if you do not use Android devices - the website link is simply being sent to a number of random telephone numbers in the hopes that an Android user will receive it, and manually bypass the built-in security protections and install the malicious software presented by the website. In other words, if you use an iPhone, you can still receive these SMS messages (often claiming to be relating to a voicemail or parcel delivery), but there is no direct risk to your iPhone by simply receiving the SMS. Nor is there currently any risk to your iPhone if you happen to click on the link that is in these SMS messages. If you use Android, you should avoid permitting your device to install any software that did not come from the official Google Play store. > … where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices … Corporations, such as Google, make decisions for users without getting their consent nor without informing the users. If you sign into a Google account in a web browser on your phone, for instance, the sign-in will also silently and non-consentually sign you into your Google account across all Google apps installed on the device without informing you. The corporations, good or bad or anything in between, must be bound by the code of conduct they ought not to be allowed to get out from: must request the explicit user consent first.
- kelnos 4y ago> That is a personal choice, and I choose to not have spam on my phone. The problem here is that we are talking about a (possible, hypothetical) measure that blocks spam, but requires phones to be 100% locked down and unmodified from the factory. I categorically refuse to accept that sort of thing. If you will accept that, then you are a part of the problem. In reality, though, there are plenty of ways to combat spam that do not require us to have locked-down phones and move closer and closer to a corporate nanny state. Your shitty telco is actually fully capable of blocking spam like what you've received, but they have chosen not to. > Corporations, such as Google, make decisions for users without getting their consent nor without informing the users. Sure, but at present I can wipe my phone and install GrapheneOS or CalyxOS or whatever, and Google will not be able to make any decisions as to what I do on my phone. I get that they make other random decisions for us. Sure, that's inevitable. If I want to use Google Docs or whatever, they will make decisions about how my data is used, and what features are present in the product, etc. I accept that, and am ok with that. But if I'm sold a piece of general-purpose hardware, I expect to be able to do whatever I want with it. > If you sign into a Google account in a web browser on your phone, for instance, the sign-in will also silently and non-consentually sign you into your Google account across all Google apps installed on the device without informing you. Maybe if you use Chrome, but... I don't. So that doesn't happen to me.
- frogpelt 4y agoI agree in principle. But it depends on how much spam and what the corporations are allowing.
- quickthrower2 4y agoYes. Or let the user choose in settings: (i) Allow rich non-iPhone messages through for all people. (ii) As (i) but only for numbers in my contacts list, or who I have replied to. (iii) Don't allow rich non-iPhone messages. Use SMS.
- yalogin 4y agoYou don’t need the world to change for you. Simply use android and live in that ecosystem.
- sunderw 4y agoAnd what if you care about your privacy ? Because there is ONE alternative doesn't really mean I have the freedom to choose...
- marrs 4y agoUse a degoogled phone
- lern_too_spel 4y agoIf you care about privacy, you would use Android (or one of the newer open source mobile operating systems).
- jankyxenon 4y agoYou’d rather live in that world, many others would choose the low-spam one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gravytron 4y ago> I'd rather live in a world with spam than a world where corporations get to decide what I run on my devices, Why do you present this as a binary choice? Why do I need to suffer at the whims of your wants and needs? Why are you so hellbent on advertising your opinion in this binary manner? Don’t like iMessage? Use something else. Nobody is stopping you. Why do you feel compelled to bring the conversation back to this weirdly obsessed and diluted dilemma where you see a first party solution and start kicking and screaming incessantly
- unilynx 4y ago> actually do whatever I want with the hardware I own. But you don't own the hardware running iMessage.
- INGSOCIALITE 4y agoso live in your world with spam and green text bubbles and blurry images.
- lnxg33k1 4y agoBut to be honest you don’t really need to live in the whole world of spam, if that’s your preference then you can just avoid Apple stuff? You live in the best world of choice
- guidoism 4y agoI’m not sure this is either/or though. I have a secure/locked down device with iMessage and an open not-as-nice device for my playground as a programmer and hardware hacker.