8 ms·
Everyone loves e-bikes – except some who have to share roads with them
- rob_c 4y agoBe careful you can't speak bad of cyclists they're incapable of breaking the law endangering life or being a public nuisance so sayeth the great y forum... Yes I've had people argue things like this can't be true on here.
- 65536b 4y agoNo one is arguing that in good faith. There is a tendency for car drivers to be let off easy in accidents, because people immediately assumed that the cyclist “probably deserved it” and the cyclist is usually too dead to argue back. Which is why some people are wary of people trying to “victim blame” cyclists.
- rob_c 4y agoLet's reverse that to cyclists getting 2 years for killing pedestrians in the UK. I'm fed up of putting people who don't follow rules or wear helmets on a pedastle. And yes, I know 2 people who's lives were saved by a helmet in a collision. But that doesn't change that these are in the minority and actually are safe cyclists. Frankly why the stigma of public transport which I exclusively use exists astounds me but people probably "ass-ume" I drive a car daily.
- n4r9 4y agoCyclists aren't put on a pedestal; the sentence for causing death by careless or inconsiderate driving is rarely any longer: https://www.sentencingcouncil.org.uk/offences/magistrates-court/item/causing-death-by-careless-or-inconsiderate-driving/ https://www.sentencingcouncil.org.uk/offences/magistrates-co... There are several recent cases of drivers getting 15 months or less for killing pedestrians.
- capableweb 4y agoSeems the complaint is not actually against e-bikes, but people breaking the law on e-bikes, like going the wrong way in a one-way street ("the e-bike rider was going the wrong way on a one-way street") or riders using sidewalks instead of the actual street ("The idea of normalizing any vehicle zipping along any and all sidewalks"), then goes on to claim "In the grander catalogue of neighborhood dangers, getting hit by an e-bike is far from the deadliest" which is outright ridiculous, do these neighborhoods not have cars, that are way more dangerous? Instead of putting the blame on e-bikes, blame your local city government for not providing the right infrastructure for bikers in general, because they should not travel on the same "road" as pedestrians.
- Caligatio 4y agoI honestly don't even know what subset of automotive rules apply to e-bikes. Do they have to follow signs for one way streets? Do they go on sidewalks and co-exist with walkers? Do they follow traffic lights? I just moved to Germany and electric scooters are seemingly in the same regulatory grey space. There was a scooter in the bike lane, blew through a red light, and then went up the wrong way on a divided street. Personally, I would like bikes/e-bikes/scooters to just be predictable and predictability means laws and regulations.
- capableweb 4y ago> I honestly don't even know what subset of automotive rules apply to e-bikes Same as any other bike. Go in the bike-lane and if there is none, go on the road meant for vehicles. Yes, bikes need to follow signs for one way streets. If you have to travel on sidewalks, jump of your bike and lead it until you get to a proper road. Yes, if you're on a bike, you need to follow traffic lights.
- bilegeek 4y agoAt least in the US, they are to be treated as any other vehicle on the road, and are supposed to follow the same rules. Aside from restrictions on highways and freeways because of slowness, there is no "subset".
- elric 4y agoAs someone who lives in a part of the world where a lot of people cycle in general, I have mixed feelings about ebikes. When human-powered, speed correlates highly with proficiency and experience. With ebikes, that's no longer true, and many unskilled & inexperienced cyclists are now among the fastest on the streets. This is especially problematic with people using "speed pedelecs" at speeds up to 45kph. They're essentially mopeds with thinner wheels. I feel very uncomfortable cycling when they are around. They're mostly inaudible and it can be very scary when they suddenly overtake you, especially on narrow paths (which is pretty much every bike path in Belgium). On the other hand, ebikes are a lot better than cars, so I'm willing to be more tolerant of them than I'd like. I'd just feel a lot better about them if infrastructure would keep pace...
- bogomipz 4y ago>"When human-powered, speed correlates highly with proficiency and experience. With ebikes, that's no longer true, and many unskilled & inexperienced cyclists are now among the fastest on the streets." I completely agree. I also think the biggest contribution to this phenomenon is the proliferation of food and grocery delivery services. The business model seems to practically require this type of beahvior.
- alanfranz 4y agoAfaik in the US e-bikes can be much more powerful than in EU, they’re almost electric mopeds. In EU there’s no such problem, but there’re more E-bikes around because they appeal to elder or people that wouldn’t generally feel comfortable riding a normal bike, so yeah, numbers are increasing and some older people aren’t happy. About the “bikes need dedicated infrastructure”: every time a dedicated bike lane is proposed around my region in Italy, the project gets scrapped because it would remove parking lots, or make some car lane narrower. You can’t have bike infra without sacrificing car infra, and that’s the big deal.
- Someone 4y agoThe EU has electric bicycles that don’t provide any power when going over 25 km/hour and speed pedelecs (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_bicycle#S-Pedelecs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_bicycle#S-Pedelecs), which stop providing power at 45 km/hour. The former typically are treated as bicycles (can go everywhere bicycles are allowed), the latter as lightweight motor cycles (⇒ requires insurance, some driver’s license and helmet use, can’t go on regular bicycle lanes, may be restricted from using some separate bike paths)
- TomMasz 4y agoI ride my bike on the Erie Canal path, a restricted-access path intended for pedestrians and bicycles. Having vehicles capable of 30 mph on that same path is just asking for trouble. I hate them.
- crote 4y agoAnd that's why most of the EU classifies e-bikes capable of such speeds as mopeds or motorcycles, banning them from cycle paths.
- dvfjsdhgfv 4y ago
- jaclaz 4y agoFrom what I have seen around in my area e-bikers are not worse than "normal" bikers when it comes to respecting traffic laws, while there are more than a few transgressions, I haven't noticed any prevalence of them among e-bikers, they are simply going a bit faster than most bikers, but not (usually) dangerously. What is a problem are (rent) e-scooters, they are driven everywhere (roads/cycle paths/sidewalks) without respecting any traffic rule, and they go as fast as 25 km/h on those tiny wheels, with brakes that cannot be called efficient, they are a real danger to both pedestrians and bikers (besides to their drivers), particularly after sunset (they have no lights). They plan to put obligatory lights and to reduce speed (to either a lower speed everywhere or geofencing the center of the city) and a number of other safety provisions, but they will be effective, if I recall correctly, starting 2024.
- bannedbybros 4y agoCars are far deadlier for both individuals and the planet. That's why everybody travels on the sidewalk. If instead of subsidizing cars they built infrastructure for pedestrians, bikes, and light EVs, then there wouldn't be a problem.
- Balgair 4y agoWe have dedicated bike infrastructure where I am. Paths that only bikes and peds can use, okay, dogs too. Love the paths, love the scenery, hate the ebikes. It's bad enough when someone comes whizzing from behind on their road bike, but at least I can kinda hear their rear cassette idling and pull kids out of the way. The ebikes are just silent and I can't hear them coming up from behind for nothing. Just, whoom, all of a sudden they are cutting between me and the tykes and my inner momma-bear becomes an outer momma-bear before I even know it happened. I do not know what it is with me, but I just cannot stand it when they come out of nowhere near the rugrats at those speeds. Yeah, I know, I'm complaining about idiots, big surprise. But where I am, it's gotten pretty bad with the pandemic and seems that only the idiots bought ebikes. Maybe I'm just jealous and should buy one myself!
- cassianoleal 4y ago> We have dedicated bike infrastructure where I am. Paths that only bikes and peds can use, okay, dogs too. This is contradictory. Dedicated bike infrastructure is for bikes only. Pedestrians and dogs should have their own dedicated, also physically segregated (from the bikes!), paths. Mixed bike/pedestrian paths is horrible for everyone. The cyclists who cannot ride efficiently and are constantly worried someone or their dog are suddenly going to appear in front of them, and for the pedenstrian (and their dogs) who, as you aptly described, have to be constantly worried about getting run over by a bike. I do agree pretty much with everything else in your comment though.
- haspoken 4y agohttps://archive.ph/AGvtc https://archive.ph/AGvtc
- wilrnh 4y agoshameless plug to get some HN quality feedback on this related idea: https://mastodon.online/@wilrnh/108466609841665605 https://mastodon.online/@wilrnh/108466609841665605