4 ms·
> 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD It's not intellectually fine, only fine in the sense
by kazinator 4y ago
> 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD
It's not intellectually fine, only fine in the sense that it's well within the bounds of free speech.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoNo; it's really fine - same with tube amps etc. It's OK to have a subjective preference for some kinds of distortion. It's not OK to say it's "truer to the original sound", which is where this usually comes off the rails.
- kazinator 4y agoSure, if the artifact you prefer actually exists and you can confirm it in a double blind test.
- cwillu 4y ago“I prefer bit of oregano on my pasta.” “Not without a double-blind test you don't!”
- pessimizer 4y ago"The pasta you just said was the best pasta you ever had didn't have any oregano on it."
- cwillu 4y agoThere was no cilantro in the dish you just said was delicious: we substituted dove-brand soap shavings.
- wolrah 4y agoYou're not wrong in the general "audiophile" world where fools and their money are parted over snake oil magical cables claiming benefits only those with the most golden of ears can enjoy. Where you're getting pushback is that this thread is talking about vinyl records and tube amps, things where the noise and distortions introduced by their operation are well known, well documented, audible to anyone with normally functional ears, and regularly utilized artistically. These are not the inventions of grifters with a product to sell, it's just an older technology that is less precise in a certain predictable way which some people find pleasant.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt's relevant to the article, where a digital source made from a tape should sound the same as the tape.
- wolrah 4y agoRight, but this subthread is about it being fine for people to prefer the sound of less accurate systems, just not to claim those systems are objectively superior. The poster I'm replying to is then acting like it's some weird audiophile belief that records sound different from other media. On the topic of the overall article, of course the people who believe a digital processing step makes things inherently worse are absolutely off their rockers.
- kazinator 4y agoA quality tube amp for audio reproduction (not guitar playing) has very low distortion.
- kstrauser 4y agoI subjectively prefer to add sriracha to my burrito. That's intellectually fine. It doesn't make it an objectively better burrito.
- kazinator 4y agoYes, because the sriracha can be confirmed to exist. If you say that waving your hand over the shriracha while murmuring a magic incantation makes it taste better, then that may not be so intellectually fine any more.
- Edman274 4y agoA digital recording has to be mastered with the understanding that it could end up getting played on a car stereo, on a bluetooth boombox, on cell phone speakers, in bluetooth earbuds, at a dance party with a DJ or on a hi-fi stereo setup that looks like the one from the old Maxell "blown away" ad. A recording on a vinyl record doesn't. The person mastering a record doesn't need to care about bluetooth earbuds, car stereos, cell phone speakers, boomboxes, and only marginally about DJs at dance parties. They can tune their mixing and mastering decisions to just the case of a hi-fi stereo setup with an enthusiast listening. They have to make fewer compromises because there are fewer cases to handle. The format enforces those constraints. You can't just ignore that.
- mrandish 4y ago> They can tune their mixing and mastering decisions to just the case of a hi-fi stereo setup with an enthusiast listening. This is what audio purists should be asking for. Let's pay the creative production team to create and release a high-fidelity digital mix optimized for us. No concerns about radio play, boomboxes or loudness wars. Just their original creative intent.
- jamiek88 4y agoIf tidal offered that it would be good value and a real differentiator.
- Syonyk 4y agoIf there's a "high bitrate" (24-bit, 96kHz FLAC or something like that) master, often enough that will be the case. You can reasonably assume that someone who's buying that version of the track has something capable of playing it back sanely. Same with the "high def audio" formats (SACD, there was another one...) - they often did, in fact, sound better. Not because of the high resolution, so much as because they were mastered to be listened to on a competent system, not on the subway on earbuds.
- kazinator 4y agoNobody who is mastering records gives a damn about bluetooth boomboxes or phone speakers; and there is no way to optimize for a phone speaker and the "Maxell blown away" stereo setup.