10 ms·
> So Google Duo is being rebranded to Google Meet, and the existing Google Meet app is sticking around for a bit. That means there are now two apps called "Goog
by yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago
> So Google Duo is being rebranded to Google Meet, and the existing Google Meet app is sticking around for a bit. That means there are now two apps called "Google Meet." Google has a help article detailing this extremely confusing situation, calling the two Meet apps "Google Meet (original): The updated Meet app" and "Google Meet: The updated Duo app." The "Google Meet (original)" app will someday be put out to pasture; it's just sticking around while Google rebuilds the meeting functionality on top of Google Duo. Did everyone follow that?
I'm in stitches; dying of laughter over here. Folding together apps to reduce the number of chat apps if probably a good thing, but renaming them to an existing name while the old app is still around? Even Microsoft had the decency to tack on "for business" when they were butchering Skype's branding!
On a more serious note, I'll be interested to see how this affects the business side of things; will Google Workspace keep Meet, and what Meet will it be?
EDIT: Reading through the linked help article, they talk about Google Workspace under the section for the new "Meet" nee Duo and not under the section for "Google Meet (original)", so I guess they have or will transition it. Probably.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nextos 4y agoIt's sad because Google Talk was good. Jabber/XMPP on a web, for the masses. It had good federation, as it followed the standard. And Google even contributed JINGLE, a XEP (standard extension) for videocalls. I was making videocalls from Google Talk using a Nokia 770 in 2007. It feels we've gone backward once Google became dominant and Nokia got taken over.
- acdha 4y agoThere’s a certain dark humor in the way that Google Talk/Reader kind of marks the apex of their reputation - they sacrificed so much trying to beat Facebook at its own game, and all they got for that devil’s bargain was G+.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoExcuse me, there was Wave.
- nerdjon 4y agoReader really was the turning point for me personally. Before that I was a strong advocate for Google, I used any of their products that made sense and I would jump in and try anything new. Then reader was shut down and I had to start re-evaluating the services I used. Slowly that meant distancing myself from anything google.
- acdha 4y agoSame. One of the big things I don't think their management appreciated was how Reader's users skewed towards people who influenced others — journalists, libraries, the family “tech expert”, etc. — and how forcing them out of something which worked into something which simply wasn't ready to launch ensured that, unlike almost every previous Google launch, the coverage was predominantly negative. They'd had flops before (e.g. Buzz) but since nobody was forced to stop using something they liked to use the flop those didn't damage the brand anywhere near as much.
- MrPatan 4y agoYes, Reader was Google's Twitter, in the way that maybe it doesn't make money but it can be used to put the right info in front of the right people. Throwing away that capability is demented. We were lucky, really.
- nerdjon 4y agoYeah I do think that was seriously under calculated. It seems like reader comes up on nearly every article about google screwing up something like this. What I never understood though, why did they cancel it in the first place. I always figured that the crawler likely used RSS for discovery. I mean why wouldn't it? I constantly find that RSS has articles before I see them on the website. So how much extra data were they really storing for supporting Reader? I mean they had to support the UI but it just seemed like an odd removal.
- mtgx 4y agoThey've gone backward and the "spirit" of the old Google was literally killed when Sundar Pichai took over. The only reason he's still CEO is that he's milked the Google brand for all its worth and has made everyone a shit ton of money. Other than that, the direction he's been giving Google, as a brand, has been terrible.
- HeyItsMatt 4y agoTo replace Pichai the two largest Google shareholders would have to give a shit about the direction of the company. But they've been absent for longer than Pichai has been CEO.
- leoc 4y agoYes. Normally people are too quick to attribute power and fault to individuals, or so everyone says, but here's a case where two individuals really seem to have something close to full power and ability to fix at least the more obvious and readily fixable problems—they simply choose not to—and yet people usually diffuse the blame among "Google" or "the incentives".
- tmpz22 4y agoOne of those individuals also solicited sexual favors from his subordinates in the Google offices during work hours [1]. I don't know if we should put them on a pedastal. [1]: https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees-masseuse-room-2018-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/google-sergey-brin-employees...
- Dylan16807 4y ago> and yet people usually diffuse the blame among "Google" or "the incentives". People are not wrong to do so. Those two are not causing the problems. They can carry some blame for inaction, sure, but not that much of the blame.
- hot_gril 4y agoWhat has he milked, though? I thought Google's money just comes from preexisting businesses like search, ads, YT, etc. None of the new stuff introduced under Sundar went anywhere, but all boats rose over the years for tech, especially in 2020.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoI was a happy Google Talk user who had written a useful App Engine chatbot. It was really easy because App Engine had built-in XMPP support and each one had its own built-in address, so handling chat messages was even simpler than handling HTTP requests. But then Google stopped supporting XMPP from other domains (including their own domains) in their chat apps, which meant that I could only use my Google App Engine chat bot from non-Google chat programs, and that was a ridiculous situation.
- sneak 4y agoAccording to Google, approximately nobody used the federation capabilities of Google Talk except inbound spammers. It was absolutely not "for the masses". The masses all stay entirely within the censored and pruned walled gardens, then and now. It was all maintenance and antispam burden for no product benefit to users. Hackers vastly overestimate the desire of users to use federated systems.
- axus 4y agoHow is Google's share of the chat market doing these days?
- hot_gril 4y agoThis is how I feel when I get an SMS from an email address. There are 0 legitimate people who would message me that way. I have an entire rant on XMPP in some other HN thread, but basically I agree, chat federation is for nerds. And if XMPP wanted its federation dream to come true, the core standard (not including extensions) needed to be more rigid and keep up with the times. Instead, every sever ended up supporting a very different feature set, usually lacking things you'd take for granted in other chat apps.
- NPtzH9DW9Ejxxa9 4y agoApproximately nobody used the federation capabilities because approximately nobody used Google Talk... LOL In more seriousness, I know of quite a lot of people who chose to use Google Talk specifically because they could use it with their client of choice. (It also had a very wide reach for a while, thanks to its Gmail integration edit: and federation) I honestly don't know anyone else who used Google Talk (other than whenever they checked their Gmail they'd also see any messages in it). In other words, Google killed off the two reasons why people used it (edit: reach and choice of client). Since then they've "replaced" pieces of it with multiple different apps (Hangouts, Chat, Allo, Duo, Meet), some of which they're finally deciding to merge back together, and in the process all they've ever done (and all anyone expects them to do with this merger) is remove features. Usually exactly those features which were the only differentiation those services had from the competitors. Which means there's no difference from a competitor with a wider reach (Zoom, 100 different IM apps, iMessage/FaceTime, etc.). Which means it's doomed to be terminated (and probably reincarnated) by Google again in a few years. (Maybe there was even a third reason to use Talk: it was the IM with Google accounts. I don't think there's been One IM To Rule Them All from Google at any point since then.)
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago> It feels we've gone backward once Google became dominant and Nokia got taken over It feels Capitalist.
- aceazzameen 4y agoAnd it was simple and everyone had it in their Gmail. I used to use it with friends all the time! Then Hangouts and every rebranded disaster took its place. Since then we all migrated to Facetime, Zoom, Discord, etc. There was too much friction to follow Google's video chat decisions. This current headline just makes it easier for me to decide to never try their new products.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- UncleMeat 4y agoThis one is particularly insane. Google appears to want the branding from one app (old Meet) but the install base of the new app (Duo) and the best they've come up with is to call them both "Meet"? Is branding so critical that Duo can't be used? Or that it cannot at least do so until all of "old Meet's" functionality has been brought over? This should be in the fucking interviews. It is such a predictable scenario. When you hire some PM or brand manager who will be responsible for things like this ask them precisely how they will navigate this situation.
- rurp 4y ago> When you hire some PM or brand manager who will be responsible for things like this ask them precisely how they will navigate this situation. This is good advice for most companies, but for Google itself who could be trusted to evaluate these answers? From what I can see, their current product management is inept.
- game-of-throws 4y agoThe problem is brand management doesn't come up on leetcode, so they can't test for it in interviews
- gundmc 4y agoThis doesn't even make sense. Why would a brand manager role interview have leetcode questions? That being said, who the heck greenlit this change? This is parody level mismanagement.
- saghm 4y agoIt's definitely hilarious that they literally have made so many different chat apps that they ran out of names they like! On the other hand, it's a bit confusing that upon realizing this, they've decided not only to just prune the number of chat apps but somehow end up duplicating names while doing this anyhow.
- wnevets 4y agoThe Microsoft-acation of Google continues.
- wlesieutre 4y agoYou mention butchering the Skype branding, but I also uninstalled one of the Teams apps so I would stop opening the wrong by accident. The one I still have is called "Microsoft Teams (work or school)," I forget what the other was. "Microsoft Teams (friends and family)" or something.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoOkay, in my defense I escaped that ecosystem just as the thing I knew as Teams was replacing SfB, and I was unaware that they'd pulled that... fascinating little twist.
- wlesieutre 4y agoI was wrong, the other one doesn't specify anything at all. So you have "Microsoft Teams" or "Microsoft Teams (work or school)". And then the icons are barely different too. https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-id/315015i31D0A1060770F7E2/image-size/large?v=v2&px=999 https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/image/serverpage/imag... What a stupid branding mess.
- koyote 4y agoThere's also the two OneNotes. I got quite confused the other day when the OneNote on my personal machine did not look like the one on my work machine. Turns out there's OneNote for Windows 10 and OneNote (which also runs on Windows 10...)
- wlesieutre 4y agoOneNote for Windows 10 is also for Windows 11, but why plan ahead with version naming? (see also: Xbox)
- _ea1k 4y agoThis is very typical for Google. I still have no idea if I'm using Google Pay, GPay, Android Pay, Android Wallet, or Google Wallet. Maybe some of those old names didn't exist or even still exist? And good luck finding all those reward barcode cards that you added over the years. I'm sure someone got a bonus for saving the company money by improving their focus, though.
- deepdriver 4y agoI've told the "two different apps named Google Wallet" story for years to illustrate G's internal dysfunction, but didn't know there were so many brands/apps in addition to the two Wallets. Incredible.
- cpeterso 4y agoDon't forget Google Pay Send and the Tez mobile payments app in India.
- hbn 4y agoGoogle released this totally not confusing graphic to help you understand https://i.imgur.com/liaNvzz.jpg https://i.imgur.com/liaNvzz.jpg If you're in Singapore or US, Wallet & GPay. Everywhere else Google Pay (not to be confused with GPay) points to Wallet. And in India, you will continue to "enjoy" the current Google Pay app. See? So simple!
- frameset 4y agoI'm in the UK, so it doesn't affect me, but is there a reason the USA and Singapore are different?
- tobyjsullivan 4y agoI'd be very curious to hear the true story as well. As an outsider, it looks like a classic process followed by many tech companies. GPay was probably the first attempt and the assignment was to build anything that works and just make it work in the US - we'll expand to other markets later. And then, because it's payments, they immediately learned that every assumption they made in the model fails to work in any other jurisdiction. No idea why Singapore - maybe that was the first attempt at expansion where they learned supporting other regions wasn't going to scale. From there, maybe they built Google Pay based on better assumptions that apply globally. But, of course, nobody bothered to tell the GPay team who kept cranking out new features in the meantime. Lo and behold, Google Pay could never reach feature parity with GPay so they perpetually have to support GPay in the US, while deploying Google Pay to the rest of the world. But now we have to manage two apps. We'd better just build a brand new app to replace both. Enter: Wallet. It supports every region with all the critical features. Oh, except Wallet's model can't ever support those 20-year old legacy APIs that are still used by tons of products nobody owns. So actually people who use GPay now get both GPay and Wallet. That's my guess, at least...
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoThey've recently shoehorned "Chat" tab into Gmail, of all places! So no, folding together apps is not always a good thing.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoWorse, I prefer to chat in a separate app on the phone, so I can more easily multitask between chat and email, but the separate Chat app has less functionality than Chat in the Gmail app.
- ericbarrett 4y agoGoogle's chat products have been integrated with gmail since the start, though: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Talk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Talk
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoNo, it was different. It was never in the same app. Merging chat history into it was the best thing about it, and you could use it with any xmpp client (disclosure: I was developing one such client). But it never wasted valuable screen estate in a mail app to make you know that you can also chat. There was a separate app for that.
- munificent 4y ago> It was never in the same app. Yes it was. Look at the last screenshot in this article from 2008: https://techcrunch.com/2008/06/06/the-evolution-of-pre-launch-gmail-in-screenshots/ https://techcrunch.com/2008/06/06/the-evolution-of-pre-launc...
- matthewdgreen 4y agoMaybe I’m looking at the wrong screenshot, but they’re all web desktops. I assumed the previous poster was talking about mobile apps, where screen real estate is really at a premium.
- Macha 4y agoOld Meet has a history of this. It's first iteration was called Hangouts - no relation or connection to the more well known Google Hangouts, the consumer messaging app. One was hosted at hangouts.google.com and the other at hangouts.google.com/_/ - hence why g.co/hangouts redirects to old Meet and not Google Chat which was the anointed consumer successor
- brokenmachine 4y agoThis hurts my brain.
- yieldcrv 4y agoAnd this is after Hangouts was used as a replacement for Google Voice for years, and then they kicked out Google Voice from Hangouts forcing people to use the Google Voice app again, for Google Voice
- dwheeler 4y agoThe long-term plan makes sense, but it's absurd that they'll have 2 different apps with the same name at the same time. At first I thought this was an Onion article. I hope this is just some misunderstanding. If not, this will be a great example of how to confuse everyone.
- Rackedup 4y ago> Even Microsoft had the decency to tack on "for business" when they were butchering Skype's branding! 1 Xbox (2001) 2 Xbox 360 (2005) 2.1 Xbox 360 S (2010) 2.2 Xbox 360 E (2013) 3 Xbox One (2013) 3.1 Xbox One S (2016) 3.2 Xbox One X (2017) 4 Xbox Series X | S (2020) On a tangent, MS really screwed up Skype when they bought it (by removing p2p supernodes).
- Dylan16807 4y agoThose names are far from good, but they're still different names for each generation. And you can skip the letter at the end for this comparison.
- fomine3 4y ago"Series" as a generation identifier (like 4 or 5 on PlayStation) is weird for me (but not English native). Is it natural for natives?
- Dylan16807 4y agoNo.
- ploxiln 4y agoNope. It sounds like it refers to the "franchise" "lineage" of xboxes. It's really like that old Abbott and Costello skit "Who's on first" (especially the "Xbox One" and the "X" suffix. Which Xbox? the X one.)
- ClassyJacket 4y agoNope, it's a very strange and awkward sounding name.
- sireat 4y agoOld pre MS Skype was pretty amazing for its day. In mid 2000s Skype was dominant. Pretty much all chat/talk flowed through Skype with corresponding interest in monitoring from pretty much any government. There is a plausible conspiracy theory that part of why Microsoft bought Skype was to have everything centralized on US servers. Sort of devil's bargain. I remember reading Microsoft's defense of centralization here on HN some years ago and it was extremely unconvincing.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI don't know why they bother. I have never once used Google Meet, or Google Duo, or Google Hangouts. I have never heard of anyone else using them. I have never been asked to contact someone or join a meeting using one of these apps. Google: just change the name, change the code, do whatever. Nobody will notice.
- scrollaway 4y agoYour bubble is not representative of reality. Google Meet may not be as popular as Zoom but it’s a strong second. It’s very popular in the business space especially, so it’s mostly used for work. I also sometimes use it with friends when I want a reliable, easy video call with screen share.
- nl 4y agoAgree. Google Meet (the current one) is a pretty decent app. Not as good as Zoom but much better than Teams or any other alternative. And the number of meeting requests mirrors that. First Zoom, then Meet, then Teams, and then random other things which basically barely work long enough for us to switch to Zoom.
- alephxyz 4y agoIt's so unintuitive to use for personal calls that I don't think I could ever convince one of my friends or relatives to use it. Having to create a meeting, send the link to someone, then hope they read it while I join the meeting and wait for them is so much more akward than just pressing a video call button like every other app does it.
- Sunspark 4y agoGoogle Meet (original) has an excellent accessibility feature, it supports real-time computer generated captions. Duo never had that, or if it does, only recently. The only other big app that could do that back then was MS Teams which was not at all as accessible or pleasant to use as Meet.
- dheera 4y agoHangouts is disappearing, but Hangouts Dialer is still around? And then there's Hangouts Meet, and now two Google Meet, Google Chat, ...