5 ms·
In this space, if you have WPA3 then there's no benefit to having a "password" for WiFi which actually is public knowledge. In WPA and WPA2 the password means
by tialaramex 4y ago
In this space, if you have WPA3 then there's no benefit to having a "password" for WiFi which actually is public knowledge.
In WPA and WPA2 the password means network use is encrypted, which means a completely passive adversary can't just snoop the network so long as there's a password.
But in WPA3 even without a password everything is encrypted anyway, your station says "Hey, I'm joining this network here's a number" and the AP says "Welcome aboard, here's a different number" and now you've got encrypted networking. Obviously with no password the AP could be an imposter, but passive snooping is impossible.
On the other hand, if you're dead set on identifying users, there's no substitute for the Enterprise WiFi behaviour all the way from WPA onwards where users have a username and password, doing this locally for your home WiFi is very annoying, but at scale it's convenient yet able to be responsible. The entire world's academic community have a single such network EduROAM, if you're an MIT student and you happen to be in the library of a Polish university, your WiFi just works, or if you're a Cambridge professor giving a talk at the University of Sydney in Australia, same deal. The institution where you're a guest knows your identity (often email address), but doesn't see your credentials (password in most cases), it's trusting your home institution to validate that identity.
- thenthenthen 4y agoFunny, when teaching networking we would be able to visit each others local webservers across multiple campuses and subnets (!) on EduRoam. Fun times.
- NoahKAndrews 4y agoSmall correction: with WPA2, a passive observer can decrypt the traffic between a device and the access point if they know the password and capture the initial connection of that device. Wireshark has built-in support for this.
- tsm 4y agoI worked in IT support as an undergrad ten years ago and am now going to grad school and using eduroam. It is such a night-and-day difference; I'm so incredibly pleased that there was enough international and inter-institutional cooperation to make it work. I especially like it when I open up my laptop at a new coffee shop and discover it's already connected to eduroam—in the city I live in (Edinburgh) there are enough university buildings scattered around that a surprising percentage of the city center is covered. The National Library also uses eduroam.
- solarkraft 4y agoSame deal in my city. Very cool! ... it also raises questions about what would be so hard to just distribute WiFi access to all citizens.
- sillystuff 4y ago> The institution where you're a guest knows your identity (often email address), The identity in the outer EAP does not have to be your real identity, just the realm (@domain.dom) must be correct so the radius proxying can be routed appropriately. E.g., anonymous@example.edu in the outer EAP will work fine for the user, jdoe@example.edu.
- _8j50 4y agoEven for wpa3 if it is public wifi you should use a VPN and restrict LAN traffic because of other hostile clients on the WLAN.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://eduroam.org/ https://eduroam.org/
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoI always don’t understand the name, looks like someone made a type when was writing “eurodam”. Because it’s a EU thing, and could a dam to break to silence/Incommunicability, so with EDUROAM and not EURODAM?! I’m going crazy every time. I use a lot this network.
- Toboe 4y agoEducation + Roaming [0] = Edu + roam = Eduroam [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roaming https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roaming
- giuliomagnifico 4y agoOh… thank you! I have never thought about this. So it makes sense!