14 ms·
AMD passes Intel in market cap
- chazeon 4y agoUnsurprised to be honest. I have access to a few HPC resource in various HPC center, all the the newer clusters (from ~2yrs) are using AMD EPYC CPUs. These are traditionally the market for Intel. Landscape doesn't look good for Intel.
- duped 4y ago> AMD reports fiscal second-quarter earnings on Tuesday, when investors will be watching to see if it is facing the same macroeconomic challenges as Intel as PC sales drop around the world. Intel revenue fell 7% (YOY) in Q1 and 22% in Q2. AMD revenue grew 71% in Q1. Something tells me they aren't facing the same macroeconomic challenges.
- greggyb 4y agoThey are facing the same macroeconomic challenges (pretty much tautologically). AMD is and has been taking market share from Intel.
- duped 4y agoSarcasm doesn't translate well online, I meant that Intel's problems don't seem to be macroeconomic when AMD is seeing high growth (it's not just grabbing Intel's marketshare, they also saw big growth in custom silicon and embedded).
- hedora 4y agoSure it is. Intel's failure to deliver much in the last decade has become a macroeconomic drag, since demand has shifted to competitors with limited manufacturing capacity -- look at the impact on chip shortages on cars, for example. It's creating different challenges for AMD and Intel though.
- api 4y agoOne of the most destructive things you can do to a company is give them a near market monopoly for a while.
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoWhile also putting an MBA in charge.
- rapsey 4y agoAnd put bean counters in charge.
- iasay 4y agoAh yes HP 1999 calling there…
- BeetleB 4y agoThis trope needs to be put to rest. Brian Krzanich was a tech insider and Intel fared poorly under him. The current CEO is as much of an insider, and it's still doing poorly under him.
- Throwawayaerlei 4y agoAn exception to the trope doesn't "put it to rest," except of course for that exception. For Intel the interim CFO made CEO was actually executing a strategy that might have worked. I was pretty sure Gelsinger would be a catastrophic mistake because he wasn't a fabrication guy (but maybe they couldn't hire one?) and I'm sad to see this playing out. His strategy depends on one difficult to impossible, and one impossible thing: regain the ability to move to new nodes on a very fast time scale and change the corporate culture to accommodate foundry customers without buying such a company. By now without having heard of mass firings of incompetent managers but plenty of reports it's still a snake pit or clown show if you prefer, and the latest capex decrease of $4 billion says nothing good. Even if the latter is just that they can't buy the machines they need. While I'm at it, how well is their 10 nm now Intel 7 node at shipping parts? That was when Intel's decades of bad top level technical management snared their crown jewel.
- StevePerkins 4y agoI remember the first computer that I ever built (it was cheaper to do it yourself back at the dawn of globalization). I used an AMD 386 rather than an Intel 386. Simply for the youthful reasons that I liked AMD's logo better, and I've always tended to root for the underdog. I'm not much of a PC gamer, and so I haven't built a machine from scratch or thought much about individual components in decades. But there's a small flicker of my teenage self way down in there, pumping his fist and giving a cheer.
- neogodless 4y ago> root for the underdog This has been a lot of it for me. I didn't switch to AMD until the Athlon XP 1700+ came out. I've stuck with them for desktop builds, mostly, except a few budget "Intel Gxxx" cpus, while I stuck with Intel for laptop purchases until the Ryzen 4xxx chips came out. I've switched between Nvidia and ATI/AMD a lot over the years. If Intel becomes the underdog (against the AMD and Apple titans), I guess I'll have to hope they put out good products :)
- dragontamer 4y ago> I've always tended to root for the underdog. Time to start rooting for Intel now, lol. ------ I've been rooting for Intel's AVX512 instruction set for some time, because I really think its a great technology. But with Zen3/4 on the way with rumored AVX512, and with Intel's most recent decisions to cut AVX512 from 12th gen Core-i7 processors, its hard to find an advantage for Intel right now. Intel supports DDR5 a few months earlier than AMD, and Intel is doing some smart things with CXL and I/O space rather than CPU space. The new big.LITTLE design is interesting, but the loss of AVX512 is pretty big (and Intel really should fix that IMO).
- neogodless 4y agoJust to clarify, Zen 3 has been out since November 2020. (Zen 3+ earlier this year.) Zen 4 is not yet formally announced (at least not the full technical details), so presumably that's what you mean. Intel's biggest remaining advantage is if you want a laptop with Thunderbolt. It should theoretically be available on AMD laptops, but I don't know if any have become available yet. EDIT: See below, Zen 4 is announced but not yet available, so performance and final details are pending (including models, performance, etc.)
- nabla9 4y agoIntel is still much bigger company. Intel revenue 73.39B AMD revenue 18.88B TSMC revenue 58.43B
- frant-hartm 4y agoThanks! Intel is only 3.8x as much. AMD used to be tiny compared to Intel in both revenue and market cap. Is there an easy way to get this data over time?
- notemaker 4y agoKeep in mind their growth rates though. In 2019 AMD had 6.7B in revenue and Intel had 71.97B.
- riku_iki 4y agoShould cost of production be substracted from AMD revenue for apple to apples comparison? Intel has in house production, why AMD pays premium to TSMC.
- bagacrap 4y agoIntel also outsources certain components to TSMC. The only apples to apples comparison would be to isolate revenue for chip sales. Also TSMC has reportedly surpassed Intel in quarterly revenue, so all these numbers are changing quickly.
- willmadden 4y agoI'm curious how the crypto crash and general recession will impact AMD. When crypto prices come down, the demand for GPUs also crashes. AMD makes a lot of money from graphics cards.
- kolbe 4y agoAnd Intel just cut its 2023 revenue forecast to low 60's
- oumua_don17 4y ago
- huangc10 4y agoRemember the days when AMD was like $3/share and Intel was like crushing it. The world really has changed in the last decade.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI bought at $5 and sold at 15 thinking I was so clever. Then I bought at 80 and held through 160, now it's at 96. I'm a long term bull on AMD, but I think the rocket left the atmosphere already. To me it's a blue chip. Intel nor AMD will ever go out of business, unless and until x86 itself dies and neither can pivot. AMD has a lock on consoles, it is the only competitor to Intel in x86, it basically can't go out of business.
- manquer 4y agoWith increasing ARM both on servers and laptops(Macs) x86 itself may wane in marketshare .
- lelanthran 4y ago> With increasing ARM both on servers and laptops(Macs) x86 itself may wane in marketshare . Not a problem - they both (Intel and AMD) make ARM chips too, don't they?
- adam_arthur 4y agoCloud vendors have been increasingly pushing their own chips. It's hard to see AMD having any pricing power in the long run, unless their chips are significantly better than what big tech can create on their own
- unethical_ban 4y agoThe Gigacorps have done this, some of them. I have more interest in the ARM argument than in the "custom chip" argument, unless Amazon and co. decide to retail their processors. Consoles, most OEMs, and all non-gigacorps will be buying off-the-shelf processors.
- elromulous 4y agoSo I'm very much in camp AMD. But, market cap has proven over and over again to be kind of bogus. E.g. do we really think Tesla is actually worth more than the rest of the top 10 or so automakers?
- tiahura 4y agoThings are worth what others are actually willing to pay, there is no such thing as a metaphysical true worth. So yes, Tesla is actually worth whatever the market cap is.
- ido 4y agoThe less literal reading of OPs statements is that Tesla is overvalued & will at some point in the future face correction down to a value more in line with their sales/profit potential. I have no horse in the game (no Tesla nor any other automotive stocks) but we’ve definitely seen companies being massively overvalued in the past and then face fierce correction - AOL was once worth $222 billion and later (not even that much later) sold for less than 1% of that.
- tiahura 4y agoWe’ve been hearing that for at least 4 years at this point. Along with scenarios where Volkswagen or Ford is going to teach Tesla how things really work. I’m not persuaded. First, my understanding is that Tesla has a night and day lead in battery sourcing. Second, Tesla doesn’t have the legacy costs that the others do. Also, at this point, Tesla is still selling cars faster than they can build them. Even if demand weakens, they may still be at max output.
- tsimionescu 4y agoSure, but Tesla is selling high end cars, which are a rounding error in the car market.
- enragedcacti 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoThis could give Intel room to maneuver. I suspect they were going to have a quarterly loss, or close to, no matter what so jammed as much future/high potential loss into that single quarter as they could as well. Now that they appear not to have a dominant position (Samsung sells more chips! AMD is worth more!) this will blunt some opposition to the juicy handouts just passed by the US Congress and may cause some opposition to any attention the newly awake antitrust division might direct to them. Intel isn't in a near death position like Apple was, they are rather in a more extreme version of Microsoft's directionless drift and sag in the second half of the Balmer era. And like Microsoft, Intel has a lot of resources available to use to get back to the top of the dogpile. Like Microsoft they've been squandering those resources for years, but perhaps this symbolic milestone will cause them to finally feel the tang of fear. Otherwise they'll continue to float around on residual habits, like GE.
- georgeburdell 4y agoI wouldn’t ascribe this quarter’s woes to some grand machinations. Intel’s situation really does seem that bad and they’re years from recovering (if they do)
- gumby 4y agoStandard practice in a turnaround is that if a loss is unavoidable anyway, you might as well make it as bad as possible (i.e. jam future bad news into it). But as you point out I am not privy to Intel's actual practice here and haven't bothered to read the 10-Q.
- oumua_don17 4y ago>> as much future/high potential loss into that single quarter as they could as well But Pat mentioned in the earnings call that they expect the next quarter to be even worse and are expecting (but in reality `hoping`) that they see turnaround in the final quarter. So by this account, they need more than one quarter to jam the potential losses.
- compumike 4y agoLonger term (1980-present), it's been a very rough ride for public equity holders of either INTC or AMD: https://totalrealreturns.com/s/INTC,AMD https://totalrealreturns.com/s/INTC,AMD Intel is still below its year-2000 peak (even in inflation-adjusted, dividend-reinvested terms). AMD's growth since ~2015 all-time lows is incredibly impressive: https://totalrealreturns.com/s/INTC,AMD?start=2016-01-01 https://totalrealreturns.com/s/INTC,AMD?start=2016-01-01 Ryzen was launched in late 2016 -- was that the catalyst?
- SkyMarshal 4y agoDoes AMD outsource all their fabrication now, or do they still run any of their own fabs? If they outsource everything to TSMC then this market cap lead could quickly reverse if hostilities break out in Asia.
- kinghajj 4y agoAMD hasn't had their own fabs since they were spun off as a separate company, Global Foundries. They still use GF for some things, like the I/O dies on their recent chips.
- jongjong 4y agoI had invested in AMD when Lisa Su took over as CEO. I had been keeping tabs on the company for some time. Unfortunately I needed money to cover my basic living expenses and had to sell all my shares about a year later. Even at the time, it was painful because I had spent a lot of time researching AMD and I was very optimistic about Lisa Su based on her background and her tenacity. I could have made maybe 20x on my investment... Still, I don't feel regret. You can only regret things if you had a choice and I know that there's no way I could have avoided selling those shares.
- ant6n 4y agoI did make 20x, got in at 2$ — too bad I only put up 500 bucks. Lost more on intel tho… It’s gambling indeed, even if lightly informed.
- running101 4y agoI am still invested. I only got in like 1 or 2 years ago. Kind of think I should put more in.
- caycep 4y agoI probably missed the boat. But thinking now is the time to buy INTC and hold off on buying AMD...until the roles are reversed again?
- mywittyname 4y agoA new player could step in and take on Intel. Maybe the owners of ARM wise up and get into the manufacturing arena. People made it big on AMD and Nvidia because they got lucky by owning the players who profited from the shakeup that cloud computing and ML brought to the industry. If you told someone 15 years ago that companies would be buying clusters of Nvidia GPUs for $100s of thousands of bucks, I doubt many people would believe it. Intel certainly isn't a bad buy right now. Lots of things could happen and the industry will certainly look a lot different in 20 years. I can see a path where they manage to out-maneuver everyone else, but I think it's just as likely that they go the way of other major players.
- DethNinja 4y agoDoes anyone think that all that backlash about Intel IME had an impact on this? I think Intel lost lots of confidence from domestic users due to accusations against IME. Not that AMD is any different but they somehow managed to not draw public attention to PSP.
- philistine 4y agoIt is inconceivable to think that one criticized aspect of Intel's design that AMD has as well somehow tanked Intel. AMD's just got a much brighter future.
- twblalock 4y agoI don’t think the IME had anything to do with it. The people who complain about it online in tech forums are a small but vocal minority. Intel’s poor performance last quarter was mostly self-inflicted.
- NotZachari 4y agoWhile I'll admit that Intel's made several missteps recently and AMD has closed in, the reality is that they pad their numbers using pipeline and microarchitecture tricks to get higher raw stats that don't translate to real-world performance. Intel's tends to be a bit more expensive for the same "tier" with lower listed performance numbers but better performance. That's because AMD has consistently done shit like using shorter pipelines and rampant pipeline flushing. They have used sacrificing cycles to get the raw benchmark numbers to justify someone "saving money for more power". Intel's made a lot of mistakes recently, but I trust their chips to perform at the price point they're sold at. A quality AMD processor or GPU performance-wise is equal in price to their counterparts in Intel and Nvidia. I'm not anti-AMD at all. I want competition in the marketplace, but their historical approach to this where they cut costs and use tricks to generate raw numbers makes it really hard to support them. "Consoles and gaming computers featuring them are selling like hotcakes!" Yeah because companies are looking to sell units at the highest profit margin. I think the elite tier of this competition is a solid one, and I'm constantly watching to see what each company's pushing out. That being said, I think it's widely known that Intel's products in their low to mid-tier offerings are superior.
- dralley 4y agoI'm not a hardware engineer so I have to ask, how is using "shorter pipelines" supposed to be illegitimate? Just because Intel may do better at the workloads you have in mind, that doesn't mean that AMD's approach doesn't do better in other (legitimate) workloads. Pentium 4 and Bulldozer both had (very) long pipelines and look how they turned out. Long pipelines certainly doesn't fundamentally equal better real-world performance, short pipelines != better benchmarks. It depends on the combination of architectural decisions considered together, right? You're going to have to expand on this concept a bit to convince people that these design decisions are a deliberate attempt to cheat the benchmarks, throwing out lingo doesn't quite suffice.
- NotZachari 4y agoIt's not that I think that shorter pipelines are a bad thing when implemented properly, but historically, AMD used that as a way to match or beat Intel on raw benchmark numbers. A shorter pipeline and pipeline flushing when ops hang or whatever means you get more operations per cycle on paper. If there's an issue, they'd just say "fuck it" and flush the pipeline and run it back, and because it's shorter, the pipeline is full and progressing fairly quick. That leads to higher benchmark scores for inferior hardware or stats that the average casual gamer or enthusiast sees. That leads to sales. As I said, Intel's not perfect and I don't hate AMD. I want the best possible products. I just feel like market share isn't a great indicator of quality here. Threadripper and top tier AMD products are on the same level as Intel's products, but I personally tend to trust Intel's performance at the price point far more in real world situations. It was the worst kept secret in tech for years that AMD was gaming raw numbers at lower price points to sell units. Gonna be real. This is all just my take on it, and I could be wrong or biased. I know they're not the same as they were 10 years ago and produce legitimate contenders at the top level. I just don't trust their low to mid-tier products.
- bekantan 4y agoIntel was once known for its memory. Then it became known for its CPUs. I expect that they will pivot at least once more, this time to something which will supersede GPUs for ML workloads. This is, of course, very uncertain which is reflected in the size of my long position
- scrlk 4y ago>Intel was once known for its memory. Then it became known for its CPUs As Andy Grove once succinctly put it: "Only the paranoid survive"
- oumua_don17 4y ago>> they will pivot at least once more, They most likely won't be a third time lucky. They had to pivot after their first 10nm delay but their monopoly in server CPU allowed them to keep pumping money despite manufacturing delays. Meanwhile, that gave AMD a chance to catch up which they not only did but outperformed them. One can claim that it's easy to say in hindsight, but that's the hallmark of great leadership which they haven't had since Grove's retirement. Now Intel have lost that money making division so much so that all the fanfare of regaining manufacturing leadership has been defused with the announcement of reduction of 4bn in capex and still a focus on shareholder dividend. Intel will need some financial engineering and a split of manufacturing and design shouldn't be surprising. And this won't be some smart timely pivot, but a forced split.
- bhouston 4y agoI think this may be the top out for AMD at least in terms of market share and revenue. The next gen of ARM and RISC-V is the future, especially if they as well can apply chipsets to their CPUs as well.
- rsp1984 4y agoCall me crazy but I think long term (10 years +) the Intel strategy of fabricating chips domestically is the correct choice. There's a ton of geopolitical pressure in this direction. The US simply doesn't want to be dependent on Taiwan for chips, for obvious reasons. Intel knows this and is trying to become the TSMC of the west. And frankly they're the only ones that can pull it off. I'd be surprised if 10 years from now the majority of their revenue comes from selling processors rather than fabricating them for AMD, NVIDIA, etc. Why compete when there's plenty of steak for everyone?
- spaceman_2020 4y agoSpot on. Any large country that's NOT desperately building up fab facilities within the country right now is playing with fire. This stuff is the new oil. Insane how little of our modern life works without chips.
- noogle 4y agoIs this about CPUs or all electronics? Computer chips are in general a reliable hardware, and top-of-the-line CPUs are in general way more powerful than needed, so there is no need for cutting-edge manufacturing and also an embargo won't halt existing activities. Simpler/embedded processors seem to be a generic product that can be manufactured by many countries, hindering embargo efforts. Are chips more critical for a country than e.g. food? because many countries are not nutritionally self-sufficient.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoBoth - CPUs, electronics, military gear, etc. Strategic risks such as war, invasions, sanctions, etc. have to be dealt with on a decadal basis. You have to ask: what's the current reality, and what's the trend? The trend is pretty clear: our world is going to depend more on computers, not less. You have to prepare for a world where drones have replaced your fighter jets, where every citizen has a smartphone, and where your financial system will collapse without working computers and servers.
- smugma 4y ago“The original headline to this story mistakenly stated that it was the first time AMD had passed Intel in market cap. In fact, it happened before in Feb. 2022.” So not really newsworthy?
- bluSCALE4 4y agoMuch deserved. Let's see Airbus take over Boeing next.
- adamsmith143 4y agoFor comparison: AMD Q1 2022 Revenue: $5.89B, YoY Change +70.89% Intel Q1 2022 Revenue: $18.35B, YoY Change -6.71%