15 ms·
Illegally placed concrete blocks have taken over public parking in Seattle
- diogenescynic 4y agoLocal governments are clearly failing protecting their own citizens if they are having to resort to this. I blame the government and its lack of accountability.
- codefreeordie 4y agoYep, it's a sad state of affairs that if one lives in these neighborhoods, ones choices are to put out these blocks or to have one's street become unlivable
- slater 4y ago
- chrsig 4y agoObviously there's a lot of potential options to solving the problem at large, not so much on a small scale. honestly, having been a resident of Seattle, I understand where the people are coming from placing the concrete blocks. I don't think it's the right solution, but given what control residents actually have, it's understandable. Instead of snarking about a false dichotomy, can you provide any productive suggestions for residents (i.e., not city policy makers) to improve the situation?
- slater 4y ago[flagged]
- vorpalhex 4y agoWhen your home becomes awash in dirty needles and fist fights, you can lecture the rest of us about "punching down". It's not crazy or entitled to want your home to be safe and not an open air sewage pit. Go actually stay in or near one of these encampments for a bit. When my city was tired of them, the encampments moved to the mayors office as a form of protest. The mayor went from being pro-encampments to demanding extra security details.
- slater 4y agoNot lecturing anyone. I was asked a question, I answered. Also, I live in San Francisco. Depending on who you ask, I can barely close my front door due to all the feces and needles!
- forrestthewoods 4y ago> Vote in folks that plan to solve underlying problems, not vague "i'm gonna crack down on crime!" band-aids Seattle did that. Repeatedly. For years. After endless failure and things getting worse people got fed up and voted the other way. Check back in 3 years to see if they’re happy with the outcome or if the pendulum will swing back.
- thr0wawayf00 4y ago> Vote in folks that plan to solve underlying problems, not vague "i'm gonna crack down on crime!" band-aids. That's what the vast majority of people who run for local office try to do, the problem is that the issues like this tend to be far more complex than a soundbite can solve. There are two problems here: legislative and enforcement. RVs park illegally overnight in neighborhoods,which leads to public health issues like how to deal with their wastewater, etc. The city fails to enforce the law, and residents respond by illegally putting up concrete barriers. Nobody wins reelection by spending lots of money and causing the city budget to increase, which would realistically be necessary in order to take enforcement seriously. So I guess that's a long-winded way of asking: what should a problem-solver local candidate do in this situation?
- 4y ago
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoWhat do you propose for the individual to do?
- fargle 4y agoAgreed. One look at the pictures should tell you why people and businesses are resorting to this. And guess where the sewage goes when you can't or won't drive your RV to the dump site?
- collegeburner 4y agoi agree we gotta go back to enforcing laws. problem is then ppl just move they RVs. like, we can't rly make them stop unless we take they RV, now we got 1 more homeless. or we could take them to prison, now we got 1 more prisoner. none of this fixes the problem bc it's rly hard to punish ppl who got nothing to lose.
- fargle 4y agoWell, if they have to keep moving their RVs, then at least there'd be a good incentive to get them and keep them running. Talk about incentives - perhaps prioritizing enforcement of RVs with drugs, trash, and sewer issues first would do a world of good. "They won't hassle you if you keep to yourself and don't leak fluids and leave trash on the street". These guys do have something to lose - their RV and all their stuff in it. You can't ask them to magically with money they don't have, but you can effect behavior and priorities. Now if you lose your RV and start squatting in a park, get warned for trespass and then stay anyway, while doing drugs in the open and shoplifting, etc. I'd love to see an escalation that eventually lands you in jail (not prison) and a 1/2 way house and treatment. Rules need to be enforced. They can and should be enforced extremely compassionately and incrementally. But they need to be enforced. And if they are not, this is a perfect example of what happens. The city has now de-facto abdicated a lot of it's authority and here we go, back to vigilance committees and self-help of 150 years ago. As shown, the self-help mechanisms lead to sub-optimal solutions for everyone. Now no one can park on those streets at all and the homeless are still homeless. Society just isn't going to just sit back and let shit-heads ruin it for everyone because the current city governance is too ineffective to take care of business in an optimal way.
- munificent 4y ago
- AlexandrB 4y agoI agree. It's terrible that citizens have to resort to living in their cars/RVs. Governments should be protecting their citizens from this fate.
- thepasswordis 4y ago
- munificent 4y ago> Governments should be protecting their citizens from this fate. This framing does a disservice to the homeless because it takes away any of their agency. What about the people who choose to live this way? Or does the government take that choice away from them too?
- colinmhayes 4y agoThe thing is it only takes one person to in stall the blocks. There might be 100 people on the block who are ok with the RVs, but if one person isn't the blocks show up.
- dontcare007 4y agoBut they aren't failing - this is the result of liberal policies being voted in by citizens. Unintended consequences maybe, but not a failure.
- nkrisc 4y agoWhich policies?
- josephcsible 4y ago
- balderdash 4y agoI’m not sure guilty until proven innocent is the most useful tact to take here.
- josephcsible 4y agoI don't want guilty until proven innocent either. I'm saying I want those to be the penalties if we can prove the blocks are yours somehow.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoThe problem in many cases is that it's hard to prove who actually owns the blocks. Who do you fine when you don't know who put them there? They're so cheap to setup that they can easily be replaced if they're removed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LegitShady 4y agoIt's super simple. Get the police to investigate - go to the nearby business owners and ask them if they placed them or know who did, and remind them that lying to the police is a crime much worse than placing the blocks.
- tomschlick 4y agoIf only they didn't reduce the funding to their police department which is now in the middle of a recruitment crisis...
- ct0 4y agoIf someone specifically placed these blocks, they also know the right they have to remain silent and not self incriminate.
- fargle 4y agohttps://archive.ph/aCih1 https://archive.ph/aCih1
- 8note 4y agoI think of public parking spaces as having a ~3hour limit. If they're actually camping spots, why limit them to RVs?
- jeffbee 4y agoHey, you're pretty close to a breakthrough here. The real question is why American cities provide little free or near-free storage for private property, if and only if that private property is in the form of cars.
- Swizec 4y agoYep there shouldn’t be free parking anywhere. Make drivers bear the full cost of their habits. Of course if a business/person wants to provide free parking on their property, that’s fine. But they shouldn’t be required to by zoning. edit: disabled parking should be free, that’s different
- forrestthewoods 4y ago> Make drivers bear the full cost of their habits. I don’t think public transit riders should be forced to pay the full price of their habit. Nor do I think cities shouldn’t charge taxes and spend the revenue on both roads and yes even curb side parking. It’s quite reasonable for cities to fund numerous modes of transit.
- Spooky23 4y agoNYC is experimenting with this now. The NYPD is pissed off and not enforcing turnstile jumping.
- Swizec 4y agoI agree in theory. The issue is that some of those modes of transport are more efficient (when done right) and should be encouraged. The funny thing is that you wouldn’t even need to make parking super expensive to act as a huge disincentive. $1/h is enough to change behavior.
- pkdpic 4y agoThis is crazy but cities really are putting neighborhood residents and businesses in a position where they can either break the law by taking enforcement into their own hands with actions like this or let their neighborhoods descend into anarchy. There are descent people that are pushed into homelessness, but one camper can turn to a dozen in less than a week and only one of them has to start threatening to hurt your family, breaking into vehicles or set a fire to turn a benign situation into one that can threaten your life or livelihood. Speaking from personal experience, we turned a blind eye to a middle aged man living out of his car next to our garage for a few months. Then we woke up one night to find the van had erupted into a two story fireball that almost burned down our entire block. I go out and talk to people now when they start forming an encampment in our neighborhood. Its incredibly difficult work and I have never had both more and less sympathy for their situations and the real threats encampments pose. This is a complex issue but it is an issue that is the city's responsibility to address. Shame on them for putting people on both sides of this issue in impossible positions. New York figured this out in 1979. Cities have a constitutional obligation to build shelters for everyone that needs them. They did. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Callahan_v._Carey https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Callahan_v._Carey
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pclmulqdq 4y agoNew York in the 80s also got the other part of the puzzle: they enforced the laws. The people who are breaking the law - all of them, not just the politically convenient ones to go after - need to be fined and/or arrested. Those blocks will come down really quickly if business owners started getting fined for putting them up and van-dwellers started finding their houses getting towed. However, the city likely can't do one without the other.
- gweinberg 4y agoIf the van dwellers were being towed nobody would have put up the eco-blocks in the first place.
- AlexandrB 4y ago“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.”
- vorpalhex 4y agoIt's a great quote. It's meaningless when your wife gets assaulted by some drugged out homeless person in a place that she should be safe in. Or when you literally get harassed just walking downtown.
- ahelwer 4y ago
- chrsig 4y agoseattle tried that... https://www.seattlemet.com/news-and-city-life/2019/03/licton-springs-village-is-closing-but-it-was-a-tiny-house-success-story https://www.seattlemet.com/news-and-city-life/2019/03/licton...
- collegeburner 4y agoi'm not gonna pay a bum to quit living on my street. that's a glorified protection racket.
- ahelwer 4y ago
- collegeburner 4y ago
- ahelwer 4y agoYeah, if you want a system with private property then it needs men with guns who can kick peoples' doors down. And if you want that system to not be utterly horrible there's gonna be taxes that are enforced by men with guns kicking your doors down. I didn't introduce the men with guns here, that came with the private property. You can't have one without the other. > some article obfuscating everything with relative instead of absolute numbers give me a break.
- thepasswordis 4y agoThe people parking these RVs aren't following the rules, why should the people they're dumping their sewage and trash onto follow them? It's really frustrating to be expected to follow the laws when the homeless aren't. I get cited for parking an RV in my own driveway because it is unsightly. 2 blocks away there is a full blown homeless encampment.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xpe 4y ago> The people parking these RVs aren't following the rules, why should the people they're dumping their sewage and trash onto follow them? If you embrace only a purely strategic point of view, sure, choose from the palatable tools available to achieve your ends. But most people have some kind of moral and ethical code, imperfect as it may be. The golden rule is nearly universal across various moral belief systems. Be careful: if you only consider the purely strategic point of view you may find yourself as the primary casualty. Living without a moral code is perhaps the most self-defeating decision you can make.
- sershe 4y agoThe alternative is simply that it's ethical to not follow laws against someone who isn't following laws, in proportion at the very least. Direct self defense is the simplest example, this is another - both are placing illegal objects in the parking area...
- xpe 4y agoUnderstood. The ideas you mention overlap considerably with the notion of the moral sphere as explained by Robert Kane at the University of Texas at Austin. His books and audiobooks are very accessible and well done. To summarize, when acting within the moral sphere (which Kane defines as the situation where people are acting in a way that respects other people's rights), we should act to maintain it. But when it breaks down, we do the best we can to restore it, which might mean acting less ideally toward the people causing breakdown.
- Scoundreller 4y ago> While ecology blocks are typically made with excess concrete and cost around $20 each Wow, when Toronto put up concrete blocks (wtf is “ecology” in the name), they spent $100k for about 100 blocks to be bought and placed in front of various unregulated marijuana dispensaries. Then another $250k in bureaucratic/engineering/legal expenses. https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2020/01/20/blocking-off-illegal-pot-stores-with-concrete-slabs-cost-more-than-350000-city-says.html https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2020/01/20/blocking-off-ill...
- doodlebugging 4y agoSomeone made a killing on that deal if the blocks they used look anything like the ones in the article. Blocks similar to those in the article (2 ft tall, 2 ft wide, 3 ft long) can be bought for $50. Add a foot of length to that and they are $75. Someone there spent $1000/block and since those appear to be about 4 feet long they would likely cost about $100 each so the labor cost to install each block plus profit to the installer eats up $900. Probably a kickback in there somewhere. Of course with lawyers involved there was probably a round of blowjobs to buy for the team and the final cost of that would depend on which corner they visited for that service.
- nkrisc 4y agoWell if it was $100k to purchase and place them, then you're paying $1000 for the block itself, and for each one to be transported and placed. Not saying it wasn't grift, but it's not as simple as $1000 - $75 = $925 in the bank.
- doodlebugging 4y agoRemember that $925 is a per block rate. There is no way that transport, delivery, and installation is gonna eat up $900 per block. They will be transported on floats that can handle multiple blocks. A single block weighs approximately a ton so a loaded float can haul up to a couple dozen at a time. It will have the equipment to unload and place the blocks on the trailer so if you bought 100 blocks you have at most 5 loads. It takes one man less than 5 minutes to unload and place a block and if he has a swamper it is less time than that since the swamper can manage grabbing the blocks or setting them, either one. Your labor and fuel costs are gonna be low too since these will be procured locally. Any way you slice it you don't get to $900/block unless someone really pads the invoice. It was a giant rip-off from what I see.
- andrew_ 4y agoI had never heard of this very unique PNW problem until I became friends with people from PNW. Has anyone seen this phenomenon anywhere else?
- Tempest1981 4y agoSilicon Valley has quite a few RV-lined streets, if that's what you're asking. PNW = Pacific NorthWest?
- munificent 4y agoMany large California cities have similar problems too.
- diogenescynic 4y agoIn San Francisco, residents were placing boulders for the same purpose: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/02/san-francisco-boulder-homeless-crisis https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/oct/02/san-francisc...
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoJust build some subsidised trailer/rv parks? Then they wont have to park on the street
- rasz 4y agoDo you mean Slab City?
- joecot 4y agoNo, because you see that would reduce property values. The line is only supposed to go up. You can't create affordable housing, or allow multifamily housing, or do anything that would stop the people who own homes there from having their property value raise 50k every 6 months. But you also can't have homeless people around, that would be unsafe. Also they still expect people to live there and do service jobs for them, even though there is no place affordable to live.
- wmil 4y agoThey want to live downtown in major cities. They won't accept a trailer park in the boonies.
- blamazon 4y ago
- zmgsabst 4y agoUh… what free market? Seattle heavily restricts development of housing, from zoning to committees that can veto buildings for the wrong facade to regulations that drive up expense like mandatory unit size and parking. You’re witnessing the failure of “feel good” government regulation.
- daenz 4y agoWhat does "free market" mean to you that this meets that definition?
- sva_ 4y agoIts sad to imagine that people who turned to live in RVs probably aren't your average imagined homeless guy, who can't hold up any kind of job, but rather lower to middle class people who work a job but can't afford to live in an apartment in the area anymore.
- seattle_spring 4y ago
- Grimburger 4y ago> I 100% support people doing everything in their power to push these people out. Where do you advocate for them to go?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoSoylent Green, apparently. Edit: I just realized this after writing this comment, but Soylent Green is supposed to take place in 2022. Life imitating art I suppose...
- Fatnino 4y agoBuild a new city somewhere just for homeless people to sleep on the sidewalks in. Maybe name it New Detroit
- collegeburner 4y agolol i've heard a few ppl pitching a "city for the homeless". build a government subsidized city in the most cheap ass land we can find in the country. away from everything else. free housing free food, nothing fancy. have them do jobs processing food or building weapons or whatever else the government needs. there's cops everywhere, you step out of line there's somebody there to taze your ass. imports and exports is controlled so they can't relapse on drugs. oh wait, we got something like that... prison. it does a shit job at fixing homeless ppl.
- TrevorFSmith 4y agoI live on one of the Seattle streets mentioned in the article where there was a cluster of RVs, they were forced to move, and now there are ecoblocks. The RVs arrived a little over six years ago after they were forced to move from a lot underneath a nearby overpass. There were around a dozen vehicles and some tents. There was a lot of violent crime, including several shootings toward the end of the encampment. There was a lot of trash and sewage. When they were moved the city hauled away several tons of trash and "shopping bag toilets". There was a lot of obvious mental health problems and the deep fear and desperation that goes along with it. I've worked in enough urban service jobs to recognize people who don't have access to the mental health support they need. There were single people, couples, and two families with children. The people I spoke with are mostly from Seattle and a few grew up in this neighborhood. They are homeless but not from some far away place. This is their neighborhood. They stay here because they know people and because they can sometimes find work here. We failed as a city to provide a safety net when these people fell. My street is more safe and has less trash and it's true that I like it but to get that we didn't solve a single problem. We just moved it along.
- poulsbohemian 4y agoThank you for stating all of the above. I speak to a lot of people in my area who say "we don't want to become Seattle" but without understanding or seeking to understand how things in Seattle came to be. I think you hint at this above - it wasn't about Seattle providing handouts to "attract" homelessness (like I hear many conservative types arguing), rather it was a series of unfortunate events - housing got crazy expensive, there wasn't enough mental health and similar resources, incomes and opportunities don't align with expenses (health care being a major one!) and before you know it totally normal people are slipping through the cracks all over the place.
- diogenescynic 4y agoLet them camp in front of the mayor, governor, and state senators houses. They conveniently always seems to allow camping in the lower socio-economic areas and protect the richer ones.
- paulpauper 4y agoThis makes no sense Homeless advocates say it is not fair that the city expects vehicle dwellers to obey parking laws.. It does not matter if it's to run errands or improvised RV housing, why should some obey the parking laws and others are allowed not to? The defeats the point of having parking spaces. Parking spaces were never intended to be dwellings. This seems really unfair. It's a difficult problem...everyone says that housing affordability/availability is the answer yet nothing get done.
- lukas099 4y agoThe rest of the quote is, "...when it allows businesses to prevent those living in cars from following them by taking up public parking." To me, a permanent concrete block is an even worse violation of parking laws than a semi-permanent RV.
- solardev 4y agoThis isn't a problem Seattle can solve on its own -- whether resident, business owner, police, mayor, or otherwise. Hyperfocusing on RV vs concrete blocks is missing the forest for the trees. This is the new face of urban America, where rampant wealth inequality makes it so that many people have no viable alternative to living on the streets. Instead of depression-era tenements, we have luxury apartments next to tent cities. There is a lot more money these days, but it's so concentrated in the hands of so few that everyone else is left fighting over scraps. Seattle is dying. San Francisco is dying. Portland is dying. All victims of their own successes, that perfect storm of a gilded, top-heavy society crushing those beneath them, combined with public policy that has turned a blind eye to decreasing real purchasing power for decades, all veneered over by a thin layer of new money and bravado. Blame drugs, blame political opponents, blame the government, blame developers, blame tech bros, blame whatever or whoever you want... but at the end of the day, still no solution is in sight. There is no widespread push for affordable housing or a pathway out of poverty, no real long-term care for people fighting addictions or mental illness. There is only the relentless push for profit for a few as society crumbles around them and more and more Americans get displaced. It's going to get a lot worse before it gets better. We're circling the drain with no end in sight.
- ceeplusplus 4y agoSan Francisco spends $61k/year/tent [1] on homeless tents, which is more than median income in the US. The problem is not funding. The problem is that the local population would rather spin performative activism instead of taking real action (i.e. institutionalizing mentally ill people and forcing people off the streets and to stop using heroin and meth). [1] https://sfist.com/2021/03/04/insanely-it-is-costing-san-francisco/ https://sfist.com/2021/03/04/insanely-it-is-costing-san-fran...
- woodruffw 4y agoForced institutionalization is plainly unconstitutional, and there's no particular evidence that you can disappear whichever group of undesirables you see fit and guarantee that more won't appear. The homeless don't spontaneously generate from other homeless; they come from the same households that you and I do. The solution is what it's always been: a universal housing mandate, and adequate social services (including harm reduction). The things stopping that aren't "performative activism"; it's Seattle's pathological disdain for housing and a polite-society liberal ethos that values property values over human lives.
- justapassenger 4y ago
- poulsbohemian 4y agoI don't disagree with what you are saying here - but it also takes money, time, resources, and political capital to do the things to get people off the streets. Seattle is so clearly overwhelmed by the problem that it could pretty clearly take years to unravel the problem even if there is an agreed path forward.
- justapassenger 4y agoI’d agree if homelessness was a new thing. Homeless people living on the street was an issue in USA for decades, and it’s as American as McDonald, obesity and gun violence. Most of people coming to visit USA from other developed country was shocked by it for a really long time. There are no excuses left. We’ve been trying for decades to solve the problem by helping people just a little. That’s only leads to issue getting much worse.
- xracy 4y agoThis is definitely one of those "it's going to get worse before it gets better" kind of things, because the increasing price of everything means that people are not going to have better upward mobility (out of homelessness) anytime soon. If we wanted that, we should've invested in low-income housing, and public transit infrastructure so that people could live elsewhere, and commute. Also, healthcare for folks who struggle with mental health. Lacking investment in those things, I imagine we can't start the clock on when this might get fixed.
- xpe 4y ago> If we wanted [better upward mobility (out of homelessness)], we should've invested in low-income housing, and public transit infrastructure so that people could live elsewhere, and commute. Also, healthcare for folks who struggle with mental health. I want to focus on the "If we wanted that," part. The "we" part is notable and problematic. I'll mention two senses here: * desire (measured by preference aggregation): what do "we" want, based on aggregating (somehow) individual preferences * action (collective action): what can we agree to do? My point is this: Just because _action_ hasn't happened does not mean that _desire_ is not there. There is big gap between the two. One recipe is: 1. define the group with the desire 2. find and organize them 3. identify the common preferences 4. accumulate political capital 5. wield the power I'm not a naive optimist; this is hard. But don't assume the _desire_ is not there! It takes effort to align a previously scattered group of people into something with cohesion and identity.
- xracy 4y agooh, yeah, I mean, clearly people want the symptoms fixed. And I think a reasonable number of people want to live in a city with low-income housing, public transit, and mental healthcare for all who need it. I'd be surprised if anyone didn't want that. But I think the specific things when suggested, are things people oppose. "I want public transit, but I don't want them to put it on my street". Also, full agreement that I'm not able to comment that people don't actually want this, only that the elected officials (and other powerful people) don't appear to want this (in Seattle). That is definitely who I'm referring to.
- 4y ago
- stevage 4y agoNothing screams "ecology" like a giant 2 ton block of concrete on the side of a read... If placing them is illegal, but requires specialised equipment to do it, couldn't the city go after the operators of that equipment?
- diogenescynic 4y agoHow about solving the issue that is pushing random citizens to resort to this?
- Pakdef 4y agoWow... is that one of the worst cities in the USA?