24 ms·
Tor is fighting and beating Russian censorship
- colordrops 4y agoHow about Chinese censorship? That's the real challenge.
- drewcoo 4y agoA bigger challenge is our own because we are largely oblivious to it.
- AzzieElbab 4y agoOn the bright side 3 years ago I would have laughed out loud if someone told me to check out an obscure Jewish magazine, a falun-gong associated newspaper, and a Christian jokes site. Strange times
- pessimizer 4y agoThere are three OTA Falun Gong TV channels in Chicago, but Chinese state (or designated affiliated) media was banned from Google News.
- ChadNauseam 4y agocan you elaborate on that? as far as I know, my government (the USA’s) does little to limit my access to information beyond copyright issues. There is of course censorship on social networks, which is no doubt real, but it’s a much trickier problem to solve.
- pessimizer 4y agoThere is censorship on every network, not just social ones, and it's naive to think that's not connected to government policy. What I'm not aware of are any DNS level blocks (even at individual ISPs), but I'm afraid someone will correct me.
- kruuuder 4y agoBeating any state censorship is a success and we should appreciate that.
- nirui 4y agoTor does not work in China. I was once tried to setup my own Tor Bridge on a VPS, the VPS ended up got blocked after just few days of use (actual time of use is more like 30 minutes). If Putin really wants to, he can just buy the tech from China, and Xi is more than happy to sell since it gives him a grip on Russia. Tor is not an anti-censorship tool all by itself, it's just a privacy protection tool. An anti-censorship program will have features that obscures it's traffic pattern, not 512-bytes fix-sized frames (cells). Also I want to point out that, even through the firewall might allow the traffic through, it does not mean that the user is undetected. As the firewall might record the behavior and notify law enforcement to manually investigate the usage.
- jacooper 4y agoI think they are already do, using meek-azure bridges.
- dopa42365 4y agoMy Weibo feed is full of Chinese people reposting Instagram content (blocked in China) that's posted by Russians (where Instagram is banned as well). People in both countries just use a random free or dirt cheap VPN. The feasibility of a "big firewall" is kinda low if you're not willing to go full North Korea.
- Sean-Der 4y agoThis has been really fascinating to watch. A patch just landed in Pion DTLS[0] yesterday to make the fingerprinting harder. I don't remember all the commits, but the Tor devs are absolutely amazing to work with and submit patches that are pretty much perfect :) If you haven't had a chance to investigate WebRTC I really think it is worth it. WebRTC gives up P2P Data/Media everywhere and it is really hard to block (because so many companies depend on it). To me it really feels like the best path forward to circumventing control. It also is a great career move. You can help people build conferencing tools during the day, and Censorship Circumvention at night. [0] https://github.com/pion/dtls/commit/de299f573c3e44fece16f09c7f62b76881640db7 https://github.com/pion/dtls/commit/de299f573c3e44fece16f09c...
- survirtual 4y agoAgreed on WebRTC. It is the only transport that meets all my own requirements for true p2p. It has a lot of issues, but once you write enough code to iron those edges away it is the only option for all-platform, high-speed universal p2p. A tor-like protocol baked on top of webrtc could do some amazing things :)
- marcodiego 4y agoThe network where I work breaks all the time. The cascade of firewalls often leaves us in a state that even DNS does not work. Tor and tor-browser usually work when this happens. I'm mostly using tor nowadays as a free proxy when network breaks.
- radiator 4y agoHow about European censorship? Is is possible to read russian news portals in Tor?
- dimitrios1 4y agoMy immediate thought here too. Is it possible to defeat US and European citizenship with Tor, as well? Looking for solutions once the "Disinformation Governance Board" gets rolling again.
- cowtools 4y ago>Is it possible to defeat US and European citizenship with Tor, as well? Rhetorical question? Serve your web page as an onion service (preferably without javascript). >Looking for solutions once the "Disinformation Governance Board" gets rolling again. I doubt it. It would be highly unpopular and supreme court will strike it down.
- trasz 4y ago>I doubt it. It would be highly unpopular and supreme court will strike it down. Last time it happened it took a decade to end it, and of course nobody got punished: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism
- knowaveragejoe 4y agoWhat if you're actually just looking at disinformation?
- MichaelCollins 4y agoAmericans have the right to read disinformation. I am and should be allowed to read propaganda from any idiot organization I please.
- xdennis 4y ago
- vogre 4y agoActually the Russian internet censorship is mostly bypassed by simple VPN app/extension. We have problems paying for them because VISA/Mastercard payments don't work, but there are plenty of free ones. Tor is mostly used for darknet/drugs/weapon selling. Nobody is using it to read some new Navalny's post.
- anonporridge 4y agoMullvad, http://mullvad.net/ http://mullvad.net/, accepts bitcoin and monero, which are currently uncensorable payment mechanisms, especially monero because it's base chain is truly anonymous. Of course, if you're in a state that's already started censoring information as Russia has, they also start censoring on-ramps to crypto, as Russia has begun, https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/07/15/vladimir-putin-bans-digital-payments-in-russia/ https://www.coindesk.com/policy/2022/07/15/vladimir-putin-ba... Owning monero and bitcoin in self custody is a "rather have it and not need it than need it and not have it" kind of thing. If you wait until you need it, it's too late.
- vbezhenar 4y agoUsing any kind of centralized VPN service is dangerous, they're first to be put on ban lists. Best kind of VPN is tiny personal VPS. You can run simple unobfuscated wireguard and it'll work, nobody cares as long as it stays tiny.
- ranger_danger 4y agoI don't think bitcoin is "uncensorable"... it is certainly traceable while monero not so much.
- AzzieElbab 4y agoMakes sense. Tor is too umm specialised and obscure. Although in brave you can simply open a private tab with Tor
- cowtools 4y agoSpecialized? Obscure? It exposes a SOCKS5 proxy at localhost:9050. If you can figure out how to use a VPN, you can figure out how to use Tor. In a way it is easier than a VPN if you are just using something like Tor Browser or Orbot.
- defanor 4y ago> It has found ways to avoid Russian blocking efforts, and this month, it was removed from Russia’s list of blocked websites following a legal challenge. (Although this doesn’t mean blocking efforts will instantly end.) The website is blocked again. [1] > However, people are able to connect to its services using volunteer-run bridges—entry points to the network that can’t easily be blocked, as their details aren’t public—and Tor’s anti-censorship tool Snowflake. It seems that plenty of bridges (the ones you obtain via the website) are blocked, refuse connections, or otherwise don't function properly. I've checked yet again now, with a bunch of hand-picked bridges to which connections at least succeeded at some point in the past, and connections over Tor just time out. It is still helpful though, but unfortunately "beating" looks like an overly optimistic way to describe this. [1] https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/28/07/2022/62e28fc39a7947c38f822c66 https://www.rbc.ru/technology_and_media/28/07/2022/62e28fc39...
- gonehome 4y agoPublic bridges often get blocked (the CCP does this too). Tor then spreads them privately through social media with people they trust in the country. Those are harder to find, but that’s also why they’re harder to block.
- everyone 4y agoI have a russian friend living near Moscow, and he can fully use discord, chat to whoever he wants, view any region free video on youtube (be it extremely anti-Putin or anti-russian) etc. etc. without any effort on his part, just using normal programs, no tor or vpn. It seems that there are just so many avenues for information on the net, anyone in Russia who cares to know about something can find out immediately with minimum effort and zero technical knowhow. It's just the majority of Russians dont want to know anything. Just like US citizens during the invasion of Iraq, most of them barely knew what was happening and simply didnt care to know. They were just comfortable in their assurance that USA was #1.
- vogre 4y agoTelegram channels are big deal in Russia. They are the best source of information about war, from first hands, Russian and Ukrainian. Don't forget that Ukraine and Russia are very tihtly related, with tons of friends and relatives on each side of a border. You don't need some Western media to get news about rumble on your backyard.
- int_19h 4y agoIt turns out that friends and even relatives often stop listening if you repeatedly tell them something they don't like to hear, as many Ukrainians have found out.
- vogre 4y agoThis works perfectly in two ways. Donetsk is shelled for 8 years bu Ukrainian Army, nobody was interested enough to stop it. "naah those separs are shooting themselves"
- mopsi 4y agoThe "8 years of shelling" talking point is one of the dumbest, I have trouble imaging who would believe it. We both know that Russia doesn't care even about its own people, let alone anyone else, with the sinking of Kursk and sieges of Nord-Ost and Beslan being shining examples of that. The indiscriminate destruction of large cities in Eastern Ukraine full of ethnic Russians is just another datapoint. According to the UN, civilian deaths in Russian war on Donbas were 25 in 2021, lowest since the war began in 2014. How many have died in 2022? If Russia wanted to stop needless bloodshed, all it had to do was to pull its armed forces out of Ukraine and leave rest of the world alone. Nobody wants to be a part of your pathethic "Russian world" of poverty and hopelessness, and now that everyone's seen the true "might" of Russian army, you've become a laughing stock of the world. Nobody even pays attention to the threats you make in regard to Finland and Sweden joining NATO.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoRussian here. Roskomnadzor's capabilities for blocking TOR are quite sufficient to cripple TOR's capabilities to the point of making it unusable as a VPN service, unless you set up your own private TOR ramp, which in this case is essentially the same as personal VPN, but much more slow. The algorithm is quite simple: 1. Attempt to connect to TOR 2. If it connects, blacklist the IP, goto 1. 3. TOR is unavailable (If an anonymous TOR user can obtain bridge address, shared by any means, email, Signal, messenger pigeons or whatever, RKN operative can obtain it as well)
- cowtools 4y agoA solution that Tor has been using with china is to host bridges on something like AWS. In order for china to block the bridges, they must also block all of AWS IP space. https://media.ccc.de/v/26c3-3554-de-tor_and_censorship_lessons_learned https://media.ccc.de/v/26c3-3554-de-tor_and_censorship_lesso...
- dilyevsky 4y agoThat’s exactly what telegram did when they had their famous battle against rkn
- cowtools 4y agoTor is not really comparable to telegram. check out that link I posted, that talk goes over a lot of details that I am currently at a loss of words for.
- defanor 4y agoAnd large subnets were blocked back then, blocking many unrelated websites/services at once. IIRC even some of RKN's own services were temporarily disrupted by that, but generally they don't shy away from inflicting collateral damage. There's no shortage of cases of blocking large websites for humorous or silly pictures and texts (not even political), too.
- 4y ago
- jerheinze 4y agoYou can help by running a Snowflake proxy (which merely functions as a gateway to the Tor Network, so you don't need to worry as no traffic exits from your IP) if you're in a country that doesn't censor Tor. You can either run the standalone Snowflake proxy: https://community.torproject.org/relay/setup/snowflake/standalone/ https://community.torproject.org/relay/setup/snowflake/stand... Or by installing the browser addon: https://snowflake.torproject.org https://snowflake.torproject.org
- Qworg 4y agoOr just using the embed at the bottom of the last link! You don't need to install anything at all - just keep a tab open.
- pessimizer 4y agoIt's a strange dictatorship where the government's decision to ban anonymous communication is held off by repeated court judgments.
- jacooper 4y agoThat's one of the most surprising things in the article. I was like, whaaat, the courts can actually top the government from doing things ? This is already much better than most dictatorships.
- kgeist 4y agoAlthough Russia is basically a dictatorship at this point, and courts aren't fully impartial, there's still place for maneuvers with good lawyers finding loopholes in the law - judges can't simply ignore the law outright, hence some limited success in courts. Usually it's about appealing to procedural mistakes which overturns cases. For example, a week ago a political case against a popular Youtuber was closed because of the statute of limitations - his "crime" happened a long time ago and so the government can't prosecute him anymore. However, if a case is initiated by Kremlin itself (not one of the less powerful agencies) then you'll get jailed no matter what (they can leverage FSB to fabricate evidence).
- cabirum 4y agoTor was developed by US military and is funded by dept of state. It should not be trusted. Better set up your own tunnel/vpn on a host you control.
- doublerabbit 4y agoUnless you own colocation, with your own netblock, the VPN still cannot be trusted.
- system33- 4y agoNow the other end of that tunnel still uniquely identifies you. It helps in some adversary models, but not many or all. I work for the Navy. The Naval Research Lab where Tor and onion routing was started. I wrote a FAQ to respond to these concerns on Reddit here[0]. AMA if you want. [0]: https://old.reddit.com/r/onions/comments/kdjrxa/tor_was_started_and_funded_by_us_navy_how_can_you/gfxd72i/ https://old.reddit.com/r/onions/comments/kdjrxa/tor_was_star...
- cabirum 4y agoThanks for an interesting read! Now, time for a thought experiment. Imagine Tor was instead developed by Russian researchers working for Russian ministry of defense at the time. Would you use it to visit rt.com blocked in your country?
- system33- 4y agoSure. The funding was secured to protect $military comms. Allegedly the $military actively uses it, so it better be actually secure, especially when malicious foreign enemy actors have had two decades to study it. Academics have studied it to death, and some of their discovered attacks have actually resulted in transitioned improvements. I myself have the benefit of (1) being extremely familiar with how it works on the lowest level and what its weaknesses are, and (2) not considering myself a target worth my $govt's close monitoring.
- 4y ago
- sacrosancty 4y agoIt's always other governments who are authoritarian and for whom censorship circumvention is a good thing. Of course they surely are relatively more authoritarian but everywhere has censorship that the locals want because it's their country with their culture and their rules. New Zealand imprisons people for sharing the video of the Chirstchurch mosque shootings. I'll bet Tor is doing a good job helping circumvent that censorship too.
- bennysomething 4y agoI'm not sure what your point is here.
- knowaveragejoe 4y agoThere isn't a point, it's contrarianism for the sake of being contrarian.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoSo if you run a site, why not help? If you run a service on Cloudflare stop blocking Tor users please.
- H8crilA 4y agoFWIW the Russian internet censorship is pretty weak because their propaganda machine relies on more traditional techniques for keeping things in check (domestic terror, lies about external danger, distortion of significant founding myths such as the victory over Nazism, exploiting native nationalism, and even just the basic need to feel sane via denial of reality). They missed the opportunity window to build a great firewall, but it seems it isn't needed after all.
- midislack 4y agoDoes Tor Browser still use the same relay for months at a time or have they fixed that?
- system33- 4y agoYes it is. This is by design, and better than using a random first relay for every circuit, new random one every day, etc. https://blog.torproject.org/improving-tors-anonymity-changing-guard-parameters/ https://blog.torproject.org/improving-tors-anonymity-changin... https://www-users.cse.umn.edu/~hoppernj/single_guard.pdf https://www-users.cse.umn.edu/~hoppernj/single_guard.pdf
- pie_flavor 4y agohttps://archive.ph/HYjJl https://archive.ph/HYjJl
- adam-p 4y agoPsiphon is helping almost 2.5 million Russians per day access the rest of the internet. (Which is just what we do.) https://psix.ca/d/nyi8gE6Zk/regional-overview?orgId=2&var-region=BY&var-region=RU&var-region=UA https://psix.ca/d/nyi8gE6Zk/regional-overview?orgId=2&var-re...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kgeist 4y agoAs a Russian, as soon as the whole thing started back in February, I installed my own OpenVPN server on a OVH instance in Singapore linked to a bank card issued to a friend in Germany (he's nice enough to pay 5 euros/month for me at no cost), and so far it's worked well - public VPN's the government knows about can be banned, if a VPN service is foreign it can be difficult to pay because of sanctions on my Russian bank, and my setup has been pretty stable, although some sites recognize it's a cheap OVH istance and block it. So far, in my experience, the problem has been not as much about Russia's censorship as about Western sites blocking access to Russian users just because - on a good day I can bump into a dozen of such sites (by default I surf with VPN disabled).
- speedgoose 4y agoIt’s not always without reasons. Russian and Chinese traffic represents most other automated attacks when you operate a western server.
- kgeist 4y agoSure, I'm aware of spam and alike, but it used to be much rarer before the invasion, so I concluded it must be part of the broader protest against the invasion (which includes companies leaving Russia). Now even some obscure technical blogs often return 403's. Some sites, upon detecting you are from Russia, also show the Ukrainian flag with some political message instead of the usual content, which go away if you switch to VPN.
- 0x38B 4y agoAnother option is to set up a couple WireGuard peers on a VPS and send the config(s) over Signal or other secure means to Russian friends and or acquaintances. Pluses: much faster than TOR.
- thorw73m 4y agoI just dont get it. Why would any one use vpn instead of tor if all you want is to circumvent the censorship? Tor provides access to restricted site for free the same vpn charges .
- pulketo 4y agoI hope it works against American misinformation too
- ThinkBeat 4y agoThe question is if it is worth the extra investment to try to stop -everything- or if blocking 95% if good enough and let some nerds have their fun on the side. FBI broke / infiltrated TOR, I am sure the Russians can do much more. But does it need to achieve the goal they have set? The US blocked Russia Today US on cable and YouTube. You can still get it. But for the vast majority they dont have to. "" RT, the English-language news network funded by the Kremlin and based in Moscow, was dropped from YouTube and American cable in early March, but still appears on an assortment of alternative video-hosting platforms, "" (Yes you can say that it was American companies not the government that banned RT. The distinction in reality is little. ) https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/11/07/how-did-law-enforcement-break-tor/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2014/11/07/how-did-... where reporting on the war is described as a “special operation chronicle